The nation who whose very name means Borderland has been home to nomads for millenia. As a pawn in the games of larger European powers, how did Ukraine become the complex geopolitical entity it is today? Cossacks, Tatars, Mongols and Vikings only scratch the surface of this ancient land
The Samurai Limited Edition Pin is available now.
Hurry and order yours now before they run out.
Or get one for free by signing up at Patreon like all of these nice people.
This episode is supported by Raycon, a wireless earbud company co-founded by Ray J and many
other titans of the music industry, at about half the price of the leading premium brands.
Head to buyraycon.com slash suibhne to get a further 15% off your order, which will also
help support this channel.
Ukrainian identity long precedes the formation of any nation-state on this soil.
The modern geopolitical entity and the current Ukrainian crisis can all trace their roots
back to the land's unique geography, and some of Europe's most fascinating cultures.
An identity that has its foundations in no less than three geographic features, the Eurasian
Steppes, the Dnieper River, and of course, the Black Sea.
These three very important parts of Ukraine not only shape its culture and identity, but
have also made Ukraine a pawn in the strategic and economic games of larger powers, especially
between Russia and the West.
During the centuries of Russian hegemony, this was less of a problem.
Monarchs and autocrats don't really care much for identity politics after all.
But post-independence, the centuries of influence from outside powers have started to show.
But Ukraine has its own nationhood and a story that goes all the way back to the migration
Well, it's been a long time coming, the remake of my old Ukraine video.
Let's see if I can get it right this time.
Now I know what you're thinking, doesn't Ukraine's history begin with the Slavic migrations?
And the answer is kind of yes, but the nomadic cultures of the Eurasian Steppes are inseparable
from Ukraine's early development.
A steppe in geographic terms, if you're not aware, lends itself almost exclusively to
the development of nomadic societies.
They lack geographic boundaries for defense, materials for building, and the grazing patterns
of animals mean that, well, you go where the food goes.
This is one of the reasons why the horse was domesticated in the steppes.
It made travel and hunting easier, and facilitated the raiding of rival tribes.
And if a horde got big enough, it might start raiding, say, the crumbling Roman Empire?
Hordes of Alans, Huns, Avars, Bulgars and Khazars had passed through this area on their
way to the rich lands of Rome, and each had left a massive influence on the Slavs and
directly caused their migrations in the first place.
If you think about it, the only place being worse than Rome would have been, like, anything
on the way to Rome.
Next is our second geographic feature, the Dnieper River, which means we get to talk
about Vikings.
Now the lands of the Slavs, you see, were pretty irresistible to the Swedish Vikings.
No centralized control, tons of wealth to raid and trade for, and hundreds of miles
of long navigable rivers through it all.
At the end of which lies the jackpot itself, Constantinople.
It wasn't long before these Norsemen, who the Slavs called Rus, had built a huge trade
empire centred on the Dnieper River, an old Khazar trading post called Kiev.
Now of course the Slavs did eventually expel the Vikings from their land, but then quite
ironically politely asked them to return and rule them, which began the medieval state
known as the Kievan Rus.
To try and create some unity through religion, Prince Vladimir the Great sent envoys to all
the neighbouring lands to study their various faiths, who reported that the Jews had lost
Israel and therefore couldn't possibly be a blessed people, the Muslim Bulgars were
sad and stinky, their words not mine, and also prohibited drinking, to which old Vlad
here laughed saying, drinking is the joy of the Rus, before finally settling on Christianity,
to be specific Eastern Orthodox Christianity, ostensibly because of how impressed his envoys
were with the Hagia Sophia, but between you and me I think they were just trying to suck
it up to the Byzantines.
His son, who would become known as Yaroslav the Wise, greatly expanded the prosperity
of the Rus state with Ukraine's oldest body of codified laws.
Although the Rus were pretty prosperous, they soon fragmented into regional rival city-states
for two main reasons.
One was the arrival of the Cumans, who took control of Crimea and severely handicapped
their trade routes, and two was the decline of its most wealthy ally, Constantinople,
thanks to a little event called the Fourth Crusade.
You really can trace a lot of Europe's history to this event, huh?
Due to increased infighting, the Rus cities were at their weakest point in decades and
so probably wouldn't deal very well with, say, oh I don't know, a horde of more than
30,000 mounted archers from Mongolia?
Ooh, just their rotten luck.
The part I want to focus on here, during an era called the Mongol Tatar Yoke, is not so
much the rapid rise of the Golden Horde, which made the Rus its glorified cash cow through
extortion, but rather its inevitable and arguably more important collapse.
Because in what was the medieval Rus state, three regional powers would come to fill the
Mongol vacuum, forever driving a wedge between the northeast and the southwest.
Moscow would consolidate in the north, becoming the genesis of the Russian state, but for
Ukraine, that genesis was in Lithuania.
It's hard to conceptualise this today, but the Lithuanian state once stretched from the
Baltic to the Black Sea, later forming a union with Poland, absorbing swathes of those
old Mongol Rus lands, which in Latin they called Ruthenia.
This was the turning point for the lands of the Rus controlled by the West, diverging
from those controlled by Moscow.
Through the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, what would become Ukraine had a direct line
to Western philosophy and liturgy, with the Greek Catholic, or Uniate Church, flourishing
in this period, whereas Moscow was isolated and inherited its autocratic rule from the
Mongols.
Even more so, symbolically, Moscow saw itself as the Third Rome, the defender of the Orthodox
faith, which further alienated it from the West.
Then we have our third regional power, the Crimean Khanate, a rump state of the Mongol-influenced
Cumans, whom the Slavs simply called Tatars.
And here we get to talk about one of the most fascinating aspects of Ukrainian history.
With the introduction of serfdom, a more severe form of feudalism, thousands of peasants fled
to the vast, open, sparsely populated frontiers to escape subjugation.
Embracing their nomadic roots, living off the land, free and fairly, they constructed
a whole society with refugees, peasants, escaped serfs and slaves, Tatars, Ruthenians, Catholics,
Orthodox, and Muslims alike.
They would become perhaps the most important piece of Ukraine's identity.
The Cossacks.
It's hard for me to overstate just how powerful the Cossacks became.
Not only were they instrumental in leveraging their autonomy and powerful armies in service
of the Polish crown, but they became inseparable from the idea of self-determination.
The roots of Ukrainian ideas of independence were the Cossacks.
And if they weren't treated the way they wanted to be, as equal autonomous partners,
then they would be more than happy to fight on behalf of someone else, an opportunity
they soon took during the Second Northern War.
The Northern Wars were a long series of not altogether related events, but basically amounted
to these four powers butting heads for more territory, especially over the Baltic Sea.
But the part we're going to focus on is the Khmelnytsky Uprising, and for this we
have Joe from the channel Jabzy.
Although the Cossacks had formed a close bond with the Commonwealth and had participated
in numerous wars against the Turks and Tatars, the spirit of independence within their homeland,
the Zaporozhian Siege, lived on.
Tensions had reached a boiling point when King of Poland, John Kashimir II, treated
the siege with contempt, and made efforts to curtail their autonomy spurred by many
local Cossack uprisings.
When wars broke out between the empires of Russia, Sweden, and Poland-Lithuania, the
Cossacks took the opportunity to assert their independence and revolted under the leadership
of Hetman Bohdan Khmelnytsky, aligning themselves with Moscow.
To this day it is still unclear whether the treaty between the Tsar and the Cossacks aimed
for further integration within the Russian Empire or simply as a temporary military cooperation,
but the Russian Empire's growth in the 18th century would ensure that Russia's interests
would soon dominate.
However, right-bank Ukraine still remained loyal to the Commonwealth, and when the left-bank
Cossacks invaded Poland on the side of Russia, it set off a series of brutal atrocities remembered
in Poland as the Deluge, and in right-bank Ukraine it is known as the Ruin.
This pivotal event would not only weaken the Commonwealth as a regional power, but also
result in the creation of a Cossack Hetmanate within the ironically far more heavy-handed
rule of the Russian Tsars.
And if you would like to learn more about this period, come check out my video on the
Khmelnytsky Uprising over on my channel Jabsi.
Now basically from the onset of the uprising, the Cossacks were treated with a certain degree
of suspicion by the Russians.
They were all too happy to use them to defend against Tatar raids and even to aid them in
their conquest of Siberia, but the Tsars knew all too well that a Cossack revolt could spell
absolute disaster if they ever lost the Hetmanate's favour.
All the Cossacks wanted was independence, and Russia simply couldn't allow that to
happen.
Their fears were pretty well-founded as it turns out, since the Cossacks again switched
sides in support of Sweden during the Great Northern War, but this time at the disastrous
Battle of Poltava.
The Cossack host was defeated, and from this point on, the seeds of malicious distrust
in Ukraine had been sown.
Russian control over the Cossacks, and Ruthenians in general, would slowly increase over time,
accelerated by the partitions of Poland where all of Ukraine, save for Galicia, found itself
under Russian rule.
There was of course an added benefit to increased control over the Ruthenians, and that was
because they stood between them and something the Russians deeply coveted, the Black Sea.
From the 15th century onward, it was clear to the Russians that the only way to truly
become a world power like those of Western Europe was through a large powerful navy,
but they lacked much in the way of seaports.
This was one of the motivations behind the Northern Wars after all, gaining control of
the Baltic Sea, and it wasn't long before Russia started eyeing the Black Sea as well,
inconveniently controlled by the Ottomans and the Tatars.
One Russo-Turkish war later, Crimea was now easy pickings, and annexed in 1783, just in
case you thought Russia annexing Crimea was a new phenomenon.
As with most of the territories acquired by the Russian Empire, Ukraine was heavily suppressed.
Its Cossack hosts lost more and more of their autonomy, the Ruthenian language we now call
Ukrainian was banned, and rebellions were violently put down.
This was all part of a process known as Russification, and one of its largest proponents was Catherine
the Great.
Jews were especially affected by these policies, restricted to stay in an area known as the
Pale, in small, economically disadvantaged communities called the Shtetl, which greatly
contributed to the suppression of Jewish culture.
Now although 19th century Russia was succeeding in the spreading of its internal power, the
same cannot be said for its place on the world stage, and their intellectual control
over Ruthenia would weaken due to several reasons.
Firstly, was the spreading of the Enlightenment ideas of self-determination during the French
Revolution.
Secondly, the Revolutions of 1848.
And thirdly, the very overt demonstration that Russia was not the invincible power it
fancied itself.
Losing major world conflicts in the disastrous campaigns of the Crimean War and the Russo-Japanese
War had exposed a weakness in the Tsarist regime that had stubbornly lacked reform and
industrialisation on the scale of other nations.
It's not surprising then to see that Ukraine was at the ready to go its own way during
the worst conflict Europe was to know at the time, at the outbreak of the First World War,
the effects of which would lead to the Russian Civil War.
It's worthwhile to remember that the Russian Civil War was by no means a monolith.
It was a complicated network of ever-changing alliances, and this is no more evident than
in Ukraine, where it is remembered as the Ukrainian War for Independence, an independence
they ultimately did not achieve.
The anti-Bolshevik White Army allied with some of the Ukrainian nationalists, who in
turn had allied with the Second Polish Republic.
The Black Army had initially seethed swathes of territory to form an anarcho-socialist
society before eventually allying with the Bolshevik Reds, and the Bolsheviks even used
Ukraine as a bargaining chip to seal a peace with Germany in 1918, but also with Poland
in 1921, which is where the borders were ultimately settled on again, splitting Ukraine in two.
It was not until the Second World War that West Ukraine would be reunited.
By force.
I've covered the history of the Soviet Union in a separate video, so I won't go into
too much detail about this era here, but I do want to go over some important details
in Ukraine's more contemporary development.
The first was that of exploitation.
Ukraine became a massive centre of industrialisation and natural resources in the Soviet era, making
it a huge target for two of humanity's worst dictators, not only Hitler during the invasion
of the Soviet Union, but also the Soviet's own premier, Joseph Stalin, whose land reforms
would cause the Great Soviet Famine, known as the Holodomor, which led to the deaths
of between 3 and 12 million Ukrainian peasants.
A majority of the more than 2 million Soviet Jews who perished in the Holocaust were also
from Ukraine, which erased almost all of its historical Jewish community.
In Kiev alone, the SS killed more than 30,000 Jews in just two days during the infamous
Babyn Yar Massacre.
The second is more to do with Ukraine's current geopolitical standpoint, which I think is
vital to understanding post-independence Ukraine, which has been in a push and pull in two directions
The vast open steppes are still envied by the Kremlin, who has lost one of its great
buffer zones to NATO.
Pro-Western leadership in this young nation has been hamstrung by Russian influence on
more than one occasion.
Russia wants Ukraine to be a quiet and stable ally, and they've actively supported pro-Russian
separatists since 2014.
The Dnieper river still forms the nucleus of the nation, and a divide that has gone
The inhabitants on the east of this river are still more likely to identify as and to
speak Russian, thanks to centuries of oppression under the Tsars and the Soviet Union.
And of course, the Black Sea is still as hotly contested as ever.
Fearing Ukraine moving to closer ties with the European Union, and the rampant instability
of the Ukrainian crisis, Russia illegally annexed the Crimean peninsula to protect its
Black Sea ports.
The current Ukrainian crisis may feel new, but it's worth remembering that we're not
at the end of Ukraine's story, nor are we ever.
We're in the middle of its most recent chapter, and conceptualising its past may help with
its future going forward.
Thank you to today's sponsor, Raycon.
Sorry, no clever segues this time, all I want to let you know is that I hate buying earbuds.
They're always way too expensive these days, and audiophiles talk endlessly with words
I don't understand, and at the end of the day, they're probably going to get lost or
eaten by my dog anyway, so Raycon is the perfect solution to all my problems.
A good pair of earbuds should be comfortable, affordable, and also sound great, and these
everyday E25 models tick all three of those boxes.
If you, like the co-founder Ray J, were just sick of good audio being too expensive, then
these will be perfect for you too.
I run in these, I sleep in them, you barely notice them there, and they sound just like
other great premium brands, and they start at about half the price.
Don't put off good earbuds any longer, head to buyraycon.com slash suibh any for a huge
15% off your already super affordable order, and you'll be supporting the channel when
you do.
Thank you everyone for watching, I know this remake has been a long time coming, I must
admit I was a little gun shy about tackling this topic again, since the first one I made
I'm pretty sure I was way under 100,000 subscribers, so I hope I managed to get it right this time.
Hope everyone is keeping safe, follow me on twitter or join my subreddit if you'd like
to discuss the episode, and are so inclined.
Until next time.