Buy and Sell A Home With Confidence | NerdWallet

Channeldo Credit
5 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 1, 2025
Smart Money hosts and Finance Nerds Sean Pyles and Sara Rathner are joined by Home Nerd Kate Wood who explains the home buying process to empower viewers to navigate buying a home with confidence.
Hi, I'm Sean, host of NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast.
Today, we're taking on three of your housing questions
in a lightning round.
We'll be answering questions
about how to shop for title agents,
whether it's a good idea to pull funds
from an IRA for a remodel,
and how to tap your home's equity.
I'm joined in this conversation by my co-host, Sarah Rathner
and mortgage expert, Kate Wood.
Kate, welcome to Smart Money.
We talk a lot at NerdWallet
about the importance of shopping around
when making a financial decision,
but the home buying process is so lengthy
and can be so exhausting
that many might not wanna shop around
for yet another person
to do this relatively small part of the process.
Do you think it's worth shopping around
for a different title agency?
What do people really stand to gain?
So basically, saving some small amount of money,
having some small amount of peace of mind,
but very few people are shopping for the title agency
for all of the reasons that you mentioned.
So, when you are looking at your loan estimate,
you will see all the estimated title costs
listed under the section
that says services you can shop for.
So it is like, yes, you can go out
and see who you wanna work with,
but again, hardly anyone is shopping for these
because once you've had an offer accepted,
your mortgage application's been submitted,
all of your incentive,
all that energy is really going toward closing the deal,
just like get to closing.
And so taking the time to suddenly step back
and research a title company
or research something like a home inspector,
these different providers
that kind of show up during the closing process,
you just don't have the time,
and you often don't have the energy.
So if this is something that you really wanna do,
you are actually much better off doing it
well before you've reached this stage
so that you're not holding things up
so that you can research,
in the case of a title company,
you're researching a company that's going to do research.
So while you're kind of still in that daydreaming phase
where you're just spending a lot of time
scrolling through houses online,
spend some of that time going through
these different companies,
look into different title companies,
look into home inspectors,
look into these different service providers
so that when it does show up,
you kind of know what you're looking for
or what you're not looking for.
You can have some kind of preference
when the different things are being suggested.
The one other thing that I would mention
that the listener brought up
was their example of the real estate agency
and the title company having some kinds of financial ties,
anything like that,
where there is that kind of conflict of interest.
If that's coming up during any part
of the home buying process,
that could possibly raise some red flags for you.
It is okay to step back and be like,
oh, hold on, maybe let's not go there.
Let's hit pause.
Well, now let's turn to the main part of Amy's question,
how to tap the equity in their home.
What options does Amy have?
Pretty much the standard options for accessing equity.
So one is to do a cash out refinance.
So that's where you refinance your original mortgage
for a larger sum,
and then you get the difference
between what you owe on the original mortgage
and that larger mortgage in cash.
The other option would be to take out a second mortgage.
And so second mortgage wise,
we'd be talking about a home equity line of credit,
commonly called a HELOC or a home equity loan.
The biggest difference between doing a cash out refi
and doing a second mortgage,
whether it's a home equity loan or a HELOC,
is that with a cash out refi,
you only have one loan.
But interest rates have gone up a lot since 2020,
and Amy's gonna lose that 3.75% mortgage rate
since prevailing rates are higher now.
Cash out refi rates also tend to be higher
than purchase mortgage rates
since cash out carries more risk for the lender.
So it's going to be a higher interest rate
on a larger loan amount.
With a cash out refi,
you are going to have refinance closing costs as well.
That's usually 2% to 6% of the amount that you're borrowing.
So that's that total larger amount.
Again, closing costs with a second mortgage,
with a home equity loan or a HELOC are usually lower.
They're about the same percentage wise,
but because you're borrowing a smaller amount of money,
since the cost of your original mortgage isn't included,
so 2% to 6% of say $50,000 is usually a lower sum.
So how else does a cash out refinance
compare with a second mortgage?
Well, with a second mortgage,
as the name implies, you now have a second loan.
So in this case,
Amy would be keeping that original mortgage
that has the low interest rate,
but would now also have another loan on that property.
And that loan would probably have a higher interest rate,
both because prevailing rates are higher
and because lenders consider second mortgages
inherently riskier.
So again, they tend to have higher rates too.
Like I said before,
that interest is on a smaller sum of money.
So there's some math to consider here.
In terms of if we're looking within second mortgages,
the differences between a home equity loan and a HELOC.
A home equity loan is like a one-time lump sum payment
that usually has a fixed interest rate.
It's a pretty much a straightforward loan.
The biggest difference is that it's secured by your house.
A HELOC is a revolving line of credit.
And so that's usually more meant to be used over time.
You have a credit limit, you borrow money as you need it,
you repay it over time.
And HELOCs usually have variable interest rates.
So that can kind of fluctuate as the market goes up and down
because of the sort of like,
oh, pay as you go or take money as you need it.
People most often use HELOCs for like big renovations
or like a lengthy home repair where it's like,
oh, you know, something else comes up
and now we have to pay for that too.
You know, that kind of thing.
Whereas home equity loan, you're saying upfront,
okay, this is how much I know I want to borrow
and I'm borrowing all of it right now.
So what sort of return on investment
can people really expect
from different kinds of home improvements?
Okay, so please do not get me started
on home improvement shows
and especially all the kind of cosmetic things
that you just mentioned.
We're gonna set that aside for another day.
But for now, home improvement is,
if I can tell you one thing, let me emphasize,
home improvement is not something where you can think,
okay, for every dollar I'm putting in,
I'm gonna get a dollar out,
let alone get more than a dollar out.
That is simply not how this works.
You know, if you're really looking at like,
okay, what's the ROI?
What's the return on investment
I'm gonna get on this project?
That varies dramatically.
But it's something also that you can research,
you can look up remodeling.com.
It does an annual cost versus value report
that you can find online.
It's super interesting.
You can look at national numbers,
you can break it down by region
and see average cost and the return
on all these different projects.
And usually what they find is that the projects
that have the best ROI are almost always like
the least sexy and not really things
that you would think of as like adding a lot of value.
So replacement garage door,
almost always at or near the top of their list.
And even that is like, you know, yeah, right?
And even that's like, it's so boring, right?
New garage door.
But that even though it usually is like very close,
it's not the top item this year, but it's near the top.
You make the money back, right?
The projects that tend to have the worst ROI on their list
are a lot of ones that you might think
would be a lot higher.
So things like an upscale kitchen remodel.
Like on one hand, yeah, like these are things
that are going to lose value because of wear and tear.
So appliances aren't appreciating over time,
even if they're like Miele or Sub-Zero.
But also, you know, these are rooms,
like your kitchen, your bathroom,
these are spaces that are really personal.
And so one person's lovely, tasteful kitchen
is another person's like hard pass.
I don't want to buy this house.
And that said, these remodels are also extremely expensive.
Like we remodeled our bathroom here.
It costs like $20,000.
Don't think we're going to see that back dollar for dollar
when we eventually sell this house, if we ever do.
I don't want to promise you,
but like I can almost promise you, yeah, you won't.
And I know I did say like at length
that I don't want to talk about them,
but really the aesthetic stuff
that tends to be the focus on TV is like your lowest ROI.
People are going to rip that shiplap
straight off of your walls.
If you really want to make like a cost-effective improvement,
upgrade your HVAC, right?
So energy efficient upgrades that will increase your comfort
and will eventually save money are a win-win
if you're thinking about resale value.
It's something that shoppers tend to be looking for.
The other thing that you want to consider,
which this listener does mention,
is what is going to fit in with your living room.
So if you are like putting in marble counters
and you're on like a linoleum street,
when it's time to sell, right?
You know, people always say,
oh, don't buy the most expensive house on the block.
You don't want that to be your home.
You want to be relatively comparable,
relatively in line with your area.
Thanks for watching.
I'm Sean Piles, host of NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast.
If you learned something new today,
hit like and subscribe and share with your friends.
Also, listen to NerdWallet's Smart Money Podcast
wherever you get your podcasts.
