New & Definitive Thunderbird Documentary

Ancient Legends Around the World
22 followers
Hi, I'm Bob Gimlin.
Thunderbird is a broad term used to describe oversized birds in North America.
Their most notable and consistent feature is their size.
Any bird in North America with an abnormally large wingspan,
compared to commonly seen birds, can be described as a thunderbird.
They are typically described as black and having comparatively rectangular wings.
Sometimes their wingspans are described as technically possible in the ballpark of 10-14 feet in length,
and sometimes they stray far from known standards of feasibility
and are likened to small aircraft with a 25-30 foot wingspan.
Such accounts persist to the very recent and go back well beyond written history in the Americas.
Much is said about this topic, but rarely is it all put together.
And though size estimations are always difficult, especially with no frame of reference,
some of the reports, sightings, and historical bouts are actually quite compelling,
and certainly denote some intriguing assertions.
This video will discuss the pre-European notion of the thunderbird,
historical sightings, modern sightings and encounters,
a few contested video clips,
what large really means for a bird,
and finally, a range of explanations.
The thunderbird was a predominant character, deity, or entity
in the traditions of North America's tribes.
And it's important to keep in mind that the culture of pre-European civilization in the Americas
was an oral culture.
There was no writing, so everything we know about their culture
is totally dependent on languages that are still debated.
So we'll never know with certainty the degree of belief in such matters,
but its role in native lore is consistent throughout the entire continent.
It is a giant bird that has a strong correlation with thunderstorms.
It is powerful, and generally considered virtuous or moral in its human attributes,
which all animals were endowed with.
The thunderbird is distinct in native culture, as it is often portrayed alongside eagles,
and in the folk stories, often interacts with falcons and ravens and other birds.
And thunderbirds play a particularly important role in native traditions.
They were in constant combat with the various less-kind deities,
such as the great-horned serpent and underwater or underworld panther.
Thunderbirds were called upon to combat these evil spirits.
Often lightning was perceived to coincide with these fights.
The language of the mythos is unclear.
Whether or not these deities fought with lightning,
if the fights caused storms, or if they fought during storms,
is culturally open to interpretation.
Totems held great significance to the North American tribes.
Totems are animals or objects used to depict certain attributes or features
that a group or individual wants to embody.
A totem pole is a physical representation of these totems, along with their symbolism.
Virtually all of the tribes of North America had a totem representation of the thunderbird.
Or a large bird that is related to lightning,
that holds particular merit within their belief structure.
The Kwakiutl tribe in the Pacific Northwest and the Ho-Chunk tribe of Wisconsin
used the thunderbird as their predominant totem animal.
Totem animals important to the Haida in British Columbia are
raven, eagle, killer whale, bear, loon, woodpecker, thunderbird,
hawk, wolf, dogfish, owl, otter, sea lion, mountain goat, and inaqua,
depending on who you ask.
And it is interesting how if you look up types of rabbit on Google,
the Easter bunny will not appear on the list.
And though obviously theological or mythological aspects were given to thunderbirds,
all animals were given such attributes,
because animals were pivotal to their belief structure,
especially in regard to creation.
And though the First Nation concept of thunderbirds is enshrined with mythos,
so is the rest of their world.
An animal being enshrined in mythology does not necessarily make that animal mythological.
But of course, the legend doesn't stop with native cultures.
Historical newspaper reports of thunderbirds are relatively rare.
Cryptids were actually quite topical in the past few centuries,
and the lack of giant bird reports almost leads me to believe
that it wasn't newsworthy or captivating enough to report,
or more importantly, captivating enough to merit valuable column space.
Author Loren Coleman compiled some sightings from Alton, Illinois,
that took place in the 1940s.
Numerous unrelated people reported seeing a large, jet-black bird.
Most of these sightings were at great distances.
One witness said that in 1948, he thought he was watching a small aircraft,
until its wings started to flap.
He said it was flying very high in the air.
Another witness the previous year described a similar black bird,
with an estimated wingspan of some 20 feet, that cast a shadow like an airplane.
Alois Kaufman, the mayor of nearby St. Louis,
was so inundated with giant bird sightings
that he endeavored to find whatever people were seeing.
He sent an employee to trap a giant bird,
but considered the mystery solved when the employee returned
with photographs of tracks of a great blue heron.
The mayor was likely just after a bit of publicity,
but even the greatest of great blue herons
did not fit the profile of the reported giant birds.
And these reports from some 70 years ago
become more interesting when taking into account
that similar reports occurred in the same area again some 30 years later.
1978, Danville, Illinois.
A 17-year-old named John Walker was hunting doves with a friend.
It was noon and a bright day.
He claims to have seen a giant black bird that made a series of shrill shrieks.
He said the wings seemed more square than birds he was used to seeing.
He estimated the body, from neck to where the tail starts,
to be between 5 or 6 feet in length.
He said it was unsettling enough to end he and his companion's adventure.
But a decidedly more dramatic encounter occurred a year prior, in 1977.
It was in Lawndale, Illinois.
Marlon Lowe was 10 years old.
He was playing with some friends in a field beside his house.
He claims that a giant bird swooped down on him
and had contact with him for some 40 feet.
To be clear, he does not claim that it was carrying him up into the sky.
He weighed 60 pounds.
He asserts that it lifted him so that he was being dragged across the ground
as his legs tried to keep up, or else the talons would dig in.
His mother saw this happen from the house.
She ran outside and the bird retreated.
Another bird circled overhead while this occurred.
Marlon Lowe saw nothing immediately before the attack.
It was completely unexpected.
His mother, Ruth Lowe, filed a report with the county conservation officer
and the sheriff's deputy office.
Both mother and son described it as black, with a white ring around its neck.
The conservation officers put out an alert that there was an aggressive turkey vulture.
But the Lowe's disagreed.
They believed it was bigger than any turkey vulture.
After a visit to the library, Ruth Lowe concluded that it was an Andean condor.
The boy did have lacerations below his armpits,
but nothing requiring urgent medical attention.
Vultures and condors have gray-siled talons.
They mostly scavenge and do not have the same grasping power
as the more predatory eagles, hawks, and falcons.
It isn't impossible, of course,
but trying to fly off with a large prey item is uncharacteristic of turkey vultures and condors.
That same year, about 70 miles south of Lawndale, at Lake Shelbyville, Illinois,
A.J. Huffer was a freelance photographer for the local CBS station.
So many people had called the news station regarding giant bird sightings on Lake Shelbyville
that he was dispatched to film them.
And he did. At least, so he says.
This is what he filmed on that day, from his canoe.
There were two birds. He said they were much bigger than any bird he had ever seen before.
He said they were entirely black.
Their necks were long. Their heads were bald, black, and leathery.
Now, I know that size comparison is impossible, but it does seem rather large.
If it is something typical, then the likely candidate would be a turkey vulture.
If the photographer really wanted to get the facts,
he should have stayed put and waited for a heron or like bird to land nearby, for a frame of reference.
The show MonsterQuest had three biologists look into this clip.
Mike Wallace, an ornithologist with the Zoological Society of San Diego,
has no doubt that they are turkey vultures.
David Hancock is a biologist, and he said that it is a pair of turkey vultures.
And Patrick Reddick, the director of the Raptor Center at the University of Minnesota,
said it looks too broad to be a turkey vulture, and too long to be an eagle.
He said that it seems to be more alike to a condor.
He said that assuming the footage was taken in Illinois,
then the identification of these birds are in question.
In my opinion, the photographer's description is more useful than the footage.
All black, long neck, leathery black face.
At first, that sounds like a black vulture.
Their range barely makes it into Illinois, so they would not have been a common sight.
However, with a wingspan of only five and a half feet,
they are even smaller than turkey vultures,
and difficult to distinguish between an adolescent turkey vulture.
A wingspan of less than six feet is really nothing to write home about,
and likely wouldn't have turned any heads.
The fact that these two birds had caused such a buzz in the community
makes it seem unlikely that they were anything typical.
Two turkey vultures simply wouldn't have caused a buzz in the first place,
as they are extremely common.
Some say he saw two California condors.
Two adolescents.
Only the adolescents are uniformly dark,
so their wingspan could have been some nine feet long,
compared to a large bald eagle at seven feet long.
I think that's likely large enough to be strikingly distinct enough
for multiple people to scratch their heads.
In fact, the only other bird you could see with that type of wingspan in Illinois
would be a trumpeter swan.
The closest California condors are known to be to Illinois would be Arizona,
so it certainly is out of place.
However, if we are to take the Danville boy and his mother's account into consideration,
then there may be another candidate.
She was very clear that the creature that attacked her son
had a white ring around its neck,
and she decided herself that it could only have been an Andean condor.
However, Andean condor live in the Andes,
along the Pacific side of South America.
Andean condor are kind of in a league of their own.
It is arguably the largest bird of flight,
with a wingspan of about 11 feet.
Perhaps its only equals are the albatross and some particular types of pelican.
And it is interesting how the photographer did not mention a white ring,
and the footage doesn't seem to depict it.
Andean condors live for over 50 years in the wild.
It is unlikely that the birds would gain or lose the white ring in a single year,
meaning that these two birds filmed in 78
were different specimens than the birds that accosted the boy in Danville.
But if two Andean condors were reported in Danville,
and then giant birds were spotted and filmed on Lake Shelbyville,
reason holds that they were one and the same.
I think it is more likely that they escaped from somewhere,
rather than simply traveling so far out of their range.
Perhaps the best evidence to support the Andean condor hypothesis,
in my opinion, is the fact that someone was motivated enough to try and film them.
Turkey vultures are extremely common in southern Illinois,
and I just can't imagine people getting worked up
unless they were seeing something truly unusual.
And in my opinion, an Andean condor probably is what it would take to do that.
I'm not really sure just exactly what this is.
There's no way to be certain,
but those who saw it are adamant that it was not a common sight,
and I see no reason to discount them.
More recently than the 1970s, and in a more suiting place,
giant birds have been reported in Alaska
by pilots flying between Juneau and Anchorage.
There have been dozens of these reports in the past 20 years or so.
Again, the reports likened the creature to a small aircraft in size.
Biologists are quick to point out that the stellar sea eagle,
usually found in Asia, are known to wander into Alaska,
and that they are likely to blame for the giant bird sightings.
But witnesses remain adamant that even the largest stellar sea eagle,
with an 8-foot wingspan, cannot account for the birds that they saw,
which they claim well over doubles even the largest sea eagle.
Of course, others have different suggestions
than mere misidentification of known species.
Some people claim that there are remnant populations of birds,
thought to be extinct.
One of the largest birds of flight ever is called Argentavis.
Argentavis weighed some 160 pounds, with a wingspan of over 20 feet.
In flight, the tip of its bill to the end of its tail feathers
would have surpassed 11 feet in length.
It is believed that Argentavis patrolled massive areas
in search of animal remains,
or even used its sheer mass to intimidate predators away from meals.
It has also been speculated that it had the capability
of taking down mid-range prey, such as calves.
Oftentimes, Argentavis is portrayed as a scaled-up condor,
but that doesn't seem to be the case.
Argentavis had robust bones, even relative to its size.
Therefore, Argentavis was very large-bodied,
so an albatross may be a better analog.
It is extremely unlikely that a human in South America
ever encountered Argentavis,
as Argentavis is thought to have gone extinct some 6 million years ago.
And with a wingspan exceeding 20 feet in length
and an active range of some estimated 200 square miles,
this thing would have a lot of trouble being cryptic.
But there is another contender that certainly encountered humans.
Pterotornithids, sometimes called pterotorns or pterotornis,
have been retrieved from the La Brea Tar Pits
and date back to a mere 10,000 years ago,
meaning humans certainly saw them in North America.
With slightly over half the wingspan of Argentavis,
but with a far slighter build,
pterotorns had a wingspan of some 13 feet
and weighed between 30 and 35 pounds.
To put that in perspective,
some bald eagle in Alaska
have been known to have a wingspan of 7.5 feet.
Though typically individuals found in the lower 48
are significantly smaller,
a large bald eagle maxes out at around 10 pounds.
With over 5 feet on the bald eagle's wingspan
and 20 pounds heavier,
pterotornis would have been a sight to behold.
Just as another reference,
one of the heaviest birds alive today that is capable of flight
is the trumpeter swan.
And it has a wingspan that maxes out around 10 feet in length.
And at just under 30 pounds,
it is still slightly smaller-bodied than pterotornis.
Understanding the significance of size variation in birds
is crucial in understanding just what it takes
for a specimen to truly stand out.
The largest native raptor
anyone should see cruising the skies of Illinois
should be a bald eagle
with a charitable wingspan of 7.5 feet.
Then would be the turkey vulture
with a 6 foot wingspan.
The California condor is at 10 feet
with the Andean condor, only slightly larger,
at 10.5 feet.
And the large-bodied trumpeter swan's wingspan
can get up to 10 feet.
Compare that with pterotornis
with a wingspan somewhere between 12 and 13 feet in length.
And then long-extinct Argentavis
with a conservative wingspan estimation of 22 feet in length.
And then in terms of weight,
a bald eagle is unlikely to exceed 10 pounds.
A turkey vulture, 5 pounds.
A California condor may weigh as much as 22 pounds.
And an Andean condor may weigh as much as 33 pounds.
A trumpeter swan is at 28.
And pterotornis was somewhere between 30 and 35 pounds.
And then Argentavis shows everyone up at 160.
And though humans never saw a living Argentavis,
we certainly saw pterotornis.
Pterotornis would have been a frequent
and certainly stunning feature
in prehistoric North American skies.
With more than 5 feet on a bald eagle's wingspan
and 3 times its weight,
the pterotorns would have been quite the spectacle.
So at their core,
I think it is safe to assert that initially,
early inhabitants of North America
were seeing pterotorns.
And they called them various names,
which were then passed down through oral traditions
from tribe to tribe and from culture to culture
until we roughly translated them into thunderbirds.
I think pterotorns were catalogued
with all other known animals.
And even though the pterotorns died out,
the mythology behind them didn't.
Think about it.
We'll be talking about tigers
long after the last one is gone.
One more contemporary sighting
comes from Pennsylvania in 2002.
It was archived by Stan Gordon's
paranormal investigation team.
It was late June in a mountainous part of Pennsylvania
in Wyoming County.
A man was on his porch
when he saw what he at first thought
were two huge herons,
but it quickly became apparent that they were not.
The man said, quote,
they were huge,
much larger than any bird I have ever seen.
He called some other family members
to confirm that he was seeing something anomalous.
He said that they landed on a coniferous tree
some ways away.
He said their wingspans were as wide
as the base of the tree.
Their weight bent the trunks,
and they had to stabilize themselves
by keeping their wings raised.
The witness said the diameter of the base of the pine
was 12 feet,
and the wingspan matched,
if not exceeded that.
He looked at a bird identification guide
and said that there was nothing remotely close
to the size of what he saw,
but he was absolutely convinced
that its pose and neck
was very much like a cormorant or anhinga,
and their iconic pose as they dry their wings.
I thought that was an interesting descriptor.
It reminds me of the petroglyphs
from Three Rivers National Parks in New Mexico.
They were made somewhere between 0 and 500 AD.
Thunderbird petroglyphs are distinct
from the eagle depictions
because the eagle was always depicted
with that iconic hooked beak
and rounded profile.
Thunderbirds were often portrayed
in a boxy or folded shape.
This is a sketch
of an almost entirely disintegrated totem
of a thunderbird
from what is now New Hampshire.
The piece is housed
at the Fruitlands Museum at Harvard.
It was fashioned out of copper,
likely from a kettle,
that could be dated back to somewhere around 1580.
The eyes were painted red.
Their vibrancy, lost to the centuries.
This obviously was not meant to be
an anatomical representation of the thunderbird.
Rather, fashioned like some curiously shaped,
red-eyed winged entity
on America's east coast.
The term thunderbird
may be a result of tall tales,
misidentifications,
fable,
ancestral or historic memory,
theology,
cryptids,
or something else.
And I've never seen any reason
to believe that those options
must be mutually exclusive.
Anyway,
like this video,
subscribe for soon to come content,
and as always,
thanks an awful lot for listening.
