What is the RISKIEST Region in the US as the Climate Changes?

Protecting The Environment
106 followers
In 2021, just one year, nearly 1 in 10 homes in the U.S. were impacted by natural hazards.
And many places with the highest climate risk in the U.S. are also seeing some of the highest growth.
When we ask homebuyers and sellers directly, is climate change impacting your decision
to buy a home, to move to a particular location, it's yes. The answer is yes.
But then when you look at the macro trends of where people are actually moving,
Here's the thing. A quick search for weather hazards in just about any geographic location
will bring up news of disasters and dire predictions of worse to come.
So how can we make informed decisions about where to live and how to manage risk?
It turns out that even though some places will face far more hazards as the climate warms,
identifying the riskiest places in the future is really hard.
Take Alexander Pichlars as an example. In 2020, he was living in Portland, Oregon,
and the wildfires and smoke of that summer got so bad that he decided to move to Florida.
But when his car nearly flooded while driving through Miami Beach during heavy rain,
he realized he hadn't escaped his weather woes.
So we worked with some of the best minds in this space to help us sift through the data,
find where hazards overlap, and map out the riskiest places in the U.S.
And stay with us to find out where we think the single riskiest place might be.
As extreme weather increases all over the country, how do we figure out the riskiest places?
First, let's look at the safest places. These are the safest 10% of counties in the U.S. based
on projections of how climate will change by the middle of the century.
As the humid climate niche characterized by mean annual temperatures around 55 degrees Fahrenheit
moves north, some places that are particularly cold now might actually get safer because,
as we know from previous episodes, the most deadly weather in the U.S. is extreme cold.
This ProPublica study also lists the most dangerous U.S. counties, and we'll get to
that in a bit, but first let's add to our map mid-century projections for flood,
storm, fire, drought, and heat risk. Starting with one of the most local hazards, flooding.
This map shows the number of properties impacted by future floods due to rain, overflowing rivers,
high tides, and storm surge. Many coastal towns will be impacted by rising sea levels,
and places like West Virginia will be slammed with heavy rain as the climate warms.
According to Redfin, by 2050, 84% of properties in Cape Coral, Florida, and 98% of properties
in New Orleans will be at risk for flooding. Houston is also an outlier on this list due to
the sheer number of properties at risk as we saw when Hurricane Harvey submerged the city
under its record-shattering rains in 2017. But what about storms? It seems like these
extreme precipitation events are causing more and more damage as the climate warms.
The top 10 cities impacted by storms are mostly in the northeast, but Portland and Seattle,
both infamously rainy cities, also appear here. Now let's look at fire. Here the map shifts
dramatically to the west and southeast. This map shows the annual likelihood of wildfire in 2050.
The places most at risk of devastating wildfires aren't cities, but instead,
houses and developments on the edge of wildlands and places with lots of fire.
And it's not just forested areas that are at risk, but also the grass and shrub lands of
regions like the Great Basin, particularly places that are getting drier. Which brings us to drought.
This map shows decreases in precipitation over the last 30 years compared to the 20th century.
But what about the future? Well, here are the top five cities projected to be impacted by drought in
2050. Four of them rely on water from the Colorado River, which is already in a decades-long drought,
and large water use cuts in the basin are inevitable. Lastly, let's look at the second
most common cause of weather-related deaths in the U.S. heat. This map shows projected days over
100 degrees in 2053. Oh man, Florida, Texas, and Arizona are looking pretty toasty. Phoenix is hotter
than anywhere else, but in Florida, temperatures don't need to be as high for it to become dangerous
because it's also humid there. That makes it harder for the body to cool itself by sweating.
If we take a look at the combined risk of all these climate impacts, we start to see how different
regions will fare. And the southeast will pretty clearly bear the brunt of climate change.
And now let's add back in the data we looked at earlier, but this time for the riskiest 10%
of counties. At this point, we're beginning to get a clearer picture of some places you might want to
think twice about before moving. But are we really any closer to determining the single riskiest
place in the country? Perhaps we need to take a look at this issue from a different angle. We
reached out to Hannah Hess from the Rhodium Group's Climate Impact Lab where they study how
climate change will affect humans across a variety of categories, including death rates and the amount
of time someone can spend on the job working due to temperature. So what we're looking at on this
map is how workers in high-risk industries like construction or agriculture or manufacturing,
being exposed to higher temperatures during the workday causes them to have to shift their time.
This might mean starting their workday later or ending it earlier or taking more frequent
breaks to cool off and protect themselves from the heat. One thing their research shows is that
certain places that already see these temperature extremes more frequently are better adapted and
more equipped to deal with elevated temperatures in the future. In a place like, for instance,
Florida is a good example. Workers are already relatively well adapted to this heat. A lot of
people have air conditioning. A lot of people have figured out ways to cope with extreme heat.
And even though Florida tops the list for hurricanes, these disastrous storms are actually
pretty rare in any given location. So maybe we can find an even riskier place. In contrast,
Southern California, Southern Arizona, Texas, a lot of those areas get really, really hot.
And one of the highest risk places in this data set is Phoenix, Arizona. And you might be
surprised by just how much the heat there is projected to impact people's ability to work,
damaging the city's economy. An individual worker by the end of the century is projected to spend
78 hours less on the job each year. So if you put that in the context of a company with,
say, 200 full-time workers, that would mean 15,600 lost hours each year. But working hours
lost isn't the only important metric for Phoenix to consider. According to the UNDP website,
under a moderate greenhouse gas scenario, Phoenix would see an increased death rate of 79
mortalities per 100,000 people from climate change by the end of the century. And to put
this into perspective, traffic accidents cause 15 deaths per 100,000 people. So we're talking
about one-fifth the number of deaths. And under a high emission scenario, the number of deaths
that Phoenix would see is projected to be nearly twice that number, at 148. And the ProPublica
study from earlier also projects that under that same high emission scenario by mid-century,
Phoenix could see temperatures in excess of 95 degrees for around half the year. So when you
add up all of Phoenix's different vulnerabilities to extreme heat that we've discussed so far,
it begins to sound like it might just be the most hazardous place to live in the United States due
to climate change, or at least near the top of the list. And another interesting thing about Phoenix
and the surrounding county of Maricopa is that it's also one of the fastest growing places in
the country. And this means even more people in harm's way and more difficulty adapting to the
growing challenges of climate change. But as we mentioned back in the beginning of this episode,
when you look at moving trends across the U.S., the weird thing is, Phoenix isn't that weird.
Among the 20 fastest growing U.S. metropolitan areas, you'll recognize many of the places we've
already discussed because of their climate risks. And almost none of them are in the least risky
regions. But to figure out why people are moving to the most hazardous locations, let's start by
taking a closer look at why they're choosing to leave the safest ones. People are leaving
these climate-resilient areas for economic reasons. On the one hand, you have people
leaving because of affordability. They're leaving the West Coast or the East Coast, these coastal
markets where home prices have gone up very dramatically. People would love to live in the
most climate-resilient areas. Like San Francisco, for example, has a very moderate temperature,
doesn't really have risks from hurricanes or drought or anything like that. But people are
being forced out of that area into more wildfire risky areas in inland California because of the
lack of housing. So, yeah, people care about it, but money ultimately is the number one motivator,
just being able to afford a home in the first place. In fact, the top five cities in population
outflow are all extremely expensive coastal towns. Another especially safe region is the
Midwest or Rust Belt. But people are leaving there for a totally different reason. It's not because
housing isn't affordable there. People in the Midwest are leaving due to a lack of economic
opportunity because they can't find jobs that pay enough for them to have the standard of living
that they want. So they go to places with more economic prosperity. And what does it say about
our country that people are having to move to riskier and riskier places instead of away from
them? Jesse Keenan focuses on finding answers to problems like these, and his research shows that
a big part of the solution comes down to information. Our brains are there to run out
of the way when a bus is heading our direction or a tiger is running to eat us, right? We're not
physiologically oriented for slow violence and incremental notions of risk. So we're just from
the get-go impaired in our ability to understand the accumulation of risk. The more information
that consumers have access to, the greater likelihood it is going to have that they are
going to shift their behavior accordingly. The availability of this kind of long-term hazard
information is crucial. And according to Redfin's data, it is making a difference. We did find an
effect that people who were previously viewing extremely risky homes in terms of flood risk
went on to make offers on homes with half the risk once they saw that information. So it seems
like it is having a tangible impact on customers. The most important thing we can tell people is
just to prepare. And by preparing, we may be able to avoid a lot of the damage because if a lot of
homeowners see that they have really high flood risk, maybe they'll start to mitigate ahead of
time, or they'll even band together and ask their local government to do something about preparing
for climate change. So now that we've really dug into the data on different climate risks across
the country, what can we say about the riskiest place of all? Well, when you factor in all of the
risks that we've talked about, Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and the California-Arizona border look like
places you should think twice about before moving to. But according to the ProPublica study,
there is one county that comes out on top. Buford County, South Carolina. This county is at risk of
nearly all of the natural hazards, including a couple that we didn't talk about. Impacts to crops
and wet bulb temperatures. Wet bulb is a big topic to explain here. But for now, I can tell you that
it refers to the dangerous combination of heat and humidity where the human body becomes essentially
unable to cool itself down. But that's a topic for a future episode. For now, we'd like to hear
what you think. Are you planning on moving? Or have you made a move recently? Has this episode
changed the way you think about your decision? Let us know in the comments.
