Cash-Out Refinance vs HELOC: Which Is Right For You? | NerdWallet

Act Funding
1 follower
Dec 30, 2024
With home values increasing over the years homeowners might be sitting on a nice amount of home equity. But how do you get that equity? Home Nerd Kate breaks down two options: a cash out refinance and a home equity line of credit, or HELOC.
Home values have increased tremendously over the past few years, so if you own your home,
you might be sitting on a pretty nice nest egg of equity. That equity could be used to fund
a major project, like maybe that renovation that you've always put off, because how would
you possibly pay for it? So your home is worth money, but how do you get to that money? Well,
that's where I come in. I write about mortgages and home ownership for NerdWallet, and my colleagues
and I spend all our time researching the ins and outs of this stuff so that you don't have to.
Today, let's talk about the differences between two of the most common ways of accessing home
equity, cash-out refinances and home equity lines of credit, or HELOCs.
With a cash-out refinance or a HELOC, you're borrowing against your home equity. Your home
equity is more or less the part of your home that you actually own. So to figure it out,
you take your home's value in today's market, and you subtract the amount that you still owe on
your mortgage. Now, with either a HELOC or a cash-out refi, a lender will potentially let
borrow 80% or more of that equity. But this isn't fun money. With cash-out refis and HELOCs,
you are borrowing against your home. That means your home is the collateral for the loan,
and if something happens that you can't repay it, your home is potentially in jeopardy. Because of
this, it's usually best to use these for something that could help you build your wealth. So for
example, consolidating high-interest debt or doing a renovation that could potentially add value to
your home. Let's talk a little bit more about each of these options. So with a cash-out refinance,
you are completely replacing your existing mortgage with a whole new mortgage. That means a
new everything, including a new interest rate. And it's also going to be a really big mortgage.
You're going to take out a loan for more than you owe on the current mortgage, and then the cash-out
that you get at closing comes from the difference between that new loan amount and the amount that
you actually still owe the mortgage lender. Cash-out refinances tend to have higher closing
costs than HELOCs, but you might be able to get a lower interest rate and you can always do a fixed
rate. With a HELOC on the other hand, you are taking out a second mortgage. So this is a completely
separate loan from your primary home loan. A HELOC functions a little bit like a credit card in that
you can borrow flexibly and just take money out as you need it. This can be convenient because you
don't have to pay interest on money that you haven't actually used for anything. You're usually
drawing from the HELOC for a period of 10 years, and then you're in repayment for another 20 years
after that. HELOCs generally have low closing costs, and in some cases, no closing costs at all.
But the interest rate is probably going to be a bit higher than with a cash-out refi.
Also, HELOCs virtually always have adjustable interest rates, so that means your rate will go
up and down with the market. How do you decide which one is right for you? Well, for a lot of
folks, this is going to come down to interest rates. If you could lower your mortgage interest
rate by refinancing, then yeah, a cash-out refi might make sense. But if your mortgage has a
significantly lower rate than today's prevailing rates, why would you take out an even bigger loan
with a higher interest rate? In that case, a HELOC probably makes more sense. Another time that a
HELOC might work is if you aren't sure exactly how much money you need to borrow. Since you're only
taking it out on an as-needed basis, you're never borrowing more than you actually need at any one
time, and that means that you aren't stuck paying interest on it later either. Whichever one you end
up choosing, do proceed with caution because again, you're borrowing against your home. But
if that home equity borrowing makes sense for you, it could be a huge step toward fulfilling
your financial goals. I'm Kate Wood, and I write about mortgages and home buying for NerdWallet.
Head to our website to use our home equity tools and see how much you might be able to borrow.
But while you're here, like and subscribe for more.
