Are we rethinking the Big Bang? On this explainer, Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice break down Big Bang skepticism and what’s going on at the frontier of astrophysics.
What are the core tenets of the Big Bang Theory? We explore the frontier of scientific research and what ideas are being contested. We also walk through the scientific process and experimentations. Could the Big Bang just be a small piece of a bigger theory? Learn about Vulcan, the hypothetical planet pulling on Mercury that was invented to save Newton’s Laws. When Einstein’s relativity came along, why didn’t Newtonian physics go away?
0:00 - Introduction 1:19 - War of Ideas 3:55 - Search Results for “Big Bang Theory” 4:37 - Evidence for the Big Bang 5:23 - How the Big Bang Fits Into New Ideas 8:03 - Newtonian Conceptions of the Universe 8:57 - Theories of Relativity 10:20 - Closing Notes
Chuck, I got another explainer for you.
Oh, well I'm here to get it.
Yeah, yeah. There's no end to these, I don't think.
That's...
I will run out. At one point, my brain will be empty.
And I'll just be this vessel that used to have stuff in it.
A hollow shell.
A hollow shell. And it's all online at that point.
I'll need to do one of these consciousness uploads.
Nice.
To get my brain back from everything I put online.
But I have to address something.
That I think we've seen in the news.
You know, every six months goes by, and then you see a headline.
Oh, astrophysicists have to rethink the Big Bang.
Or Big Bang debunked.
Or... Did you see any of these at any time?
Oh my God.
Well, recently the James Webb Space Telescope, supposedly.
The headline is...
Did the James Webb Space Telescope make scientists think the Big Bang?
Or has the James Webb Space Telescope debunked the Big Bang?
Yeah, it makes excellent clickbait.
There it is. It's clickbait headlines.
So let me just explain a few things that's going on here.
Okay?
On the frontier of scientific research.
It is a bloody place.
Ideas are slain.
Two scientists enter.
One scientist leaves.
It's the octagon.
Welcome to Science Dome.
On the frontier, ideas are contested daily.
Right.
And most ideas turn out to be wrong.
All right.
So what you are as a scientist working on the frontier,
you're in this idea factory.
That's what you are.
And the successful idea is not the one that's argued most strenuously
or argued by the most articulate.
Yeah, that's called politics.
That's called politics. Exactly. Exactly.
It has nothing to do with either of those.
It has to do with evidence.
All right.
Which idea is supported by evidence?
So typically what happens is you contest your ideas.
And here's where you have to be convincing.
You have to say, I think my idea is better than your idea.
And here's a way to test it.
Right.
So I have an idea.
So if you don't like me,
the way you show it is you design an experiment to show I'm wrong.
Okay.
That's some cutthroat nasty stuff right there.
Oh, it's nasty.
All right.
That's some real housewives stuff.
Real housewives.
Let me tell you something, Phaedra.
Your hypothesis is trash.
Trash.
So scientists contest their ideas.
So you, you don't like me and you're going to show me that I'm wrong.
And so you go home and you invent an experiment.
You invent an experiment to test my idea.
With the objective of showing that I'm wrong.
And it turns out, hey, wait a minute.
I'm getting what the dude says.
You got to publish that.
And then someone else performs another kind of experiment
aimed at testing the same hypothesis.
And they get kind of the same result.
And then someone from a different country with a different wall current,
240 volts maybe,
and they plug their stuff in and they're getting the same result.
When you have repeated experiments verifying an idea,
we have a new objective truth that has emerged in those sciences.
And what I'm telling you is that the Big Bang Theory,
by the way, if you type that into Google, you get the TV show.
My personal jury is still out on whether that's a good or bad thing.
It doesn't mean like science is so popular, it's a TV show.
That's the first thing you hit.
Because you got to get through that.
Then there's the Big Bang is a K-pop group.
You got to get through that.
Then you get to the origin of the universe.
In the Google search.
Just thought I'd point that out.
Well, it's good to know that we Google in order of importance.
There it is.
Just saying.
Here's the point.
The tenets of the Big Bang,
that the universe started out small, hot, dense,
where matter and energy were a primordial soup,
where the forces of nature had merged,
all of that is thoroughly supported by observations of this universe.
Thoroughly supported.
Now, there's some things that, well, did this really cause that?
Or might it be something that we don't know about yet?
And who ordered up the dark matter?
We don't know where that came from.
And where's this expansion?
We don't know where that came from.
But we can describe it.
And we can measure it.
Here's the point.
If tomorrow you have a new idea about how the universe works,
it's going to enclose everything we've been talking about up to that moment
that has been experimentally and observationally verified.
You can enclose it in something deeper.
Okay?
You can say, well, I have an idea.
Our universe is just one in a multiverse.
Fine.
Okay?
But our universe would have started with a Big Bang.
Okay?
And our universe would have expanded from a dense, hot state.
And it's been cooling ever since.
That's observed.
And that's real.
And that's not going away.
That's my point.
So what you have are journalists trying to make clickbait.
And if there's some little thing in the early universe that is still on the frontier,
still being contested in the octagon, in the fight dome,
and some new idea is emerging over another idea,
people say, oh, Big Bang is in trouble.
Scientists go back to the drawing.
But Big Bang is not in trouble.
Right.
I'm just saying it's not in trouble.
It is a whole thing that could conceivably fit in a deeper, bigger idea.
Right.
But it's not going to be swapped out tomorrow.
We're not going to find out tomorrow, gee, the early universe was cold instead of hot.
That is not going to happen.
That's not how science works.
So if you're going to come up with something new,
you're not coming up with something that will change the old.
The old that has been experimentally verified.
That's done.
Right.
If you're going to come up with something new about the earth and the sun,
it's not going to be, well, it's really earth is stationary and the sun moves around the earth,
and the sun is cold, and earth is hot, and earth is what's illuminating the moon.
That is not going to happen.
Right.
Okay?
You can't just pull an idea out of your orifice and ignore experimental verification of what's going on.
Right.
So you might come up with the Big Thang, but you're not changing the Big Bang.
Well, what's the Big Thang?
I get a C-plus on that one.
It's what came before the Big Bang.
We call it the Big Thang.
The Big Thang?
Okay, that's a B-plus.
What's your thang?
Yeah, that's before the Big Bang.
So, and by the way, when we think of Einsteinian physics, so it's relativity,
which completely usurped Newtonian gravity and Newtonian motion.
All right?
What we call the era of classical physics, which led right up to the late 1800s.
Newton's ideas reigned supreme.
All right?
And he told you what gravity did, what motion did, and acceleration in a preexisting space.
And it was working.
Okay?
It was working.
And then people said, well, wait a minute.
The orbit of Mercury is not really following Newton's laws.
And we said, oh, we got this.
We got this.
There's another planet you can't see that's tugging on it.
We even had a name for that planet.
It was called Vulcan.
Okay?
Vulcan?
Hypothetical planet, tugging on Mercury so that we didn't have to throw out Newton's laws.
All right?
So that was invoked just out of, we just pulled that out of our ass.
Right?
Said, there it is.
We'll find it one day.
Einstein comes along with a special theory of relativity, and that is general theory of relativity.
And what we find is that at high gravity, like near the sun, and at high speeds,
at high gravity and high speeds, Newton's laws completely fail.
You cannot use them at all.
So do we say, did we throw away Newton?
No, we didn't.
You know why?
Because if you take Einstein's equations and plug in low speeds and low gravity,
they become Newton's equations.
Yes.
So Einstein basically enclosed Newton's ideas as a special low speed, low gravity case
of a much larger, deeper understanding of the universe.
That is fantastic.
It is beautiful.
It is.
And so, and by the way, Newton's gravity and Newton's motion were just fine for the Apollo project.
Right.
We got to the moon and back without any Einstein relativity at all.
Okay.
So it's only if you really up the stakes in your gravity.
There's no way to understand black holes, really, with, or even the Big Bang itself,
with just Newtonian physics.
Point is, new physics does not undo experimentally verified physics.
That's the whole point of experimental verification.
That's all.
And so the Big Bang is just fine.
You want to do something else with it?
Take it, body and soul, and stick it in some other theory you have.
But you can't undo what the experiments and observations have shown.
And that is an explainer for you.
There you go.
Wow.
That is good.
Take that, Big Bang deniers.
Take that.
So that's an explainer from the octagon.
From the scientist fight club.
There it is.
Science fight club.
I love it.
All right.
So we got to end it there, Chuck.
Always good to have you.
Always a pleasure.
All right.
Neil deGrasse Tyson here for StarTalk.
Keep looking up.