The Death of Ivan Ilych by Leo Tolstoy | Chapter 4
2 Video Views·Dec 29, 2024
Course Hero Literature Instructor Russell Jaffe provides an in-depth summary and analysis of Chapter 4 from Leo Tolstoy's novella The Death of Ivan Ilych.
In Chapter 4 of The Death of Ivan Ilyich, as the months pass, Ivan Ilyich sometimes has
a bad taste in his mouth and feels discomfort in his left side, which gets worse and makes
Ivan irritable and quarrelsome.
His wife, made miserable, begins to wish he would die.
She realizes that wouldn't help because then she'd have no income.
Not even his death could save her from her unhappiness.
One evening, Ivan Ilyich admits that his bad temper results from how ill he feels.
Preskovia suggests he see a highly reputable doctor.
Just as Ivan Ilyich did in his court career, the doctor sums up his findings, but seems
unconcerned with their gravity.
Ivan Ilyich feels bitter because the doctor is so callous and nonchalant when Ivan's condition
might be serious.
Ivan begins taking medicine and hears from the doctor that there was a contradiction
between the indications from the examination of the urine and the symptoms that showed
themselves.
Ivan realizes that the doctor had misdiagnosed the problem or doesn't know what he's talking
about.
He becomes preoccupied with illness and tries to convince himself that his pain is getting
better.
Yet as soon as something goes awry in his life, the pain intensifies.
People at work also treat Ivan Ilyich as a man whose place might soon be vacant.
Ivan realizes that through his illness and depression, he was poisoning the lives of
others.
Lying in bed at night, Ivan is wracked with physical pain and fear.
He feels that no one understands what he's going through.
Ivan Ilyich's suffering is both physical and psychological, and it's made worse by the
isolation that walls him off from others.
Ivan's colleagues react to his illness mainly with selfishness.
When they realize he's ill, their first thoughts are about how the vacancy at work, Ivan's
death, might result in their promotion.
Same goes for his wife.
When Ivan is irritable at dinner, Preskovia begins to feel sorry for herself, and the
more she pitied herself, the more she hated her husband.
Leo Tolstoy's description of medical professionals and their self-importance and superiority
is likely a critique of the West's rational, egoistic elevation of science above everything
else.
In these chapters, the doctors behave as if they're knowledgeable and competent, yet
they cannot or will not answer Ivan Ilyich's most basic human question about his condition.
Was his case serious or not?
The doctors refuse to address this existential but non-scientific plea.

