How Did Buddhism Begin?

People & Faith
22 followers
How did Buddhism begin?
We'll look at the context, the historical context
in which Buddhism arose.
I'm Doug Smith of the Online Dharma Institute,
that's OnlineDharma.org.
If you're new to this channel and interested in living
a wiser and a kinder and a calmer life,
consider subscribing to the channel.
And if you're interested in receiving notifications
of videos when I put them up, click the bell down below.
Buddhism began or arose around 2,500 years ago
in Northeast India near Nepal, near the border with Nepal.
Of course, these borders didn't exist back then,
so most of it was in that area.
And it was during a time which the philosopher
Karl Jaspers has termed the Axial Age.
The Axial Age is, it's very rough.
His description of this idea is one that will,
I'll discuss a bit on this program,
just to let you know that it's somewhat controversial
in the sense that not every historian thinks
this is a particularly relevant period of time.
But it seems to be a period of several centuries
in which most or many of the world's
most important philosophical systems
began to arise at the same time.
He, Karl Jaspers, puts this around between,
let's say, 800 and 300 BCE,
or some people say 500 to 300 BCE,
several millennia ago at any rate.
And during this period of time,
we see the arising of people like the Buddha,
like Confucius, like Lao Tzu, Socrates in the West.
We also see some of the Hebrew prophets at this time.
There's a number of different philosophies of great ferment
that came up during this period.
And this Axial Age, or these Axial Age philosophies,
Karl Jaspers talks about them as being
sort of, seems to be a difference from what came before.
They're distinct.
So we know about earlier kinds of thought processes
which are more interested in, let's say,
eking out a life for ourselves in a difficult world.
Eking out a life up against the terrors
and difficulties of nature,
which has not been in any way overcome, shall we say.
So there's difficulties of animals,
and plants, and storms, and all the rest.
And so the philosophies of an earlier period,
pre-Axial Age, were most interested in
sort of finding us a way to live out a normal human life.
How can we have a successful human life?
How can we become prosperous enough
to survive?
How can we become productive enough
to have productive families, lots of children?
These kinds of concerns.
And larger, broader kinds of concerns of philosophy
were really not on the table,
because what was most important
was simply learning how to survive.
Then, during the Axial Age,
these philosophies seemed to have changed,
and sort of, you might say, developed.
So they were no longer quite so interested
in the nitty-gritty of how to survive,
or how to gain the pleasure of the gods, let's say,
but rather interested in broader concerns of ethics,
of how do we live the right kind of life,
given that we're surviving?
How do we propagate ourselves into the next life?
So they're interested in features of reality
that went beyond simply one lifetime.
So these systems were interested in longer-term rewards,
rewards that went beyond
our very narrow kind of self-interest.
And another thing I think that is critical
is that in many parts of the world,
these Axial Age philosophies grew up at a time
when writing was just being developed,
or just after or before writing had been developed.
In the case of the Buddha,
his philosophy was developed perhaps a couple of centuries,
maybe a century or so,
before writing was developed in his area of India.
So it was not written down,
and was preserved orally for a period of time,
perhaps a century or more centuries,
before it was committed to paper,
at the time of Ashoka at the very least,
and then centuries thereafter.
And so in all of these cases, and Buddhism is no exception,
we might say that these Axial Age philosophies
were sort of the oldest opinions we know
from recognized people.
So, and this is, I think, one of the reasons
why these philosophies have become so predominant
and so influential,
is that they're some of the first things we know
from actual people.
If we go before Axial Age philosophies
into, let's say, the older passages in the Bible,
or older passages in other belief systems,
the Iliad, the Odyssey,
which are attached to a person called Homer,
about whom we really don't know anything,
or before the period in India,
which I'll get to in a bit, to the Vedas,
what we have are basically literary productions,
poems, songs,
that were not associated
with any really identifiable people.
They were simply productions of the mind.
And then with these Axial Age philosophies,
we get real people for the first time.
And indeed, if we come to the place of Northeast India,
during the Buddha's lifetime,
and indeed just before the Buddha's lifetime,
we'll see an area of real, deep, intellectual,
philosophical, religious ferment.
Lots and lots of different ideas
being exchanged and argued about
in a very fecund way,
a way that really produced
a lot of new and interesting ideas,
and those would then become Buddhism.
Now, we'll discuss a bit of that.
But first, I would love to give you a couple of seconds
about Patreon, which is how I help to support this channel,
how I help to keep it third-party advertising-free.
I have lots and lots of benefits over on Patreon.
I've even instituted a new idea
of sort of occasional video background
and questions and answers.
I also have show notes
and many other goodies for you over there.
If you're interested, check it out at the link here.
I've got it down below in the information box
and here on the screen.
If you're not interested, that's fine.
Also, just to keep in mind
that this topic that I'm discussing today
is one that I discuss in some of my courses,
in particular the course on the Buddha's life,
which is a long course where I go into quite a bit of detail
about the time period pre the Buddha's life
and how the Buddha reacted to this.
So if this is a kind of a topic that interests you,
you might wanna check out that course
and the other courses over at the Online Dharma Institute.
So to get back to our story here,
the period in Northeast India prior to the Buddha
is a time when that area was being influenced
by what's called Vedic Brahmanism.
And Vedic Brahmanism is a belief system
that came out of a slightly different part of India.
So the Buddha lived on sort of the outskirts
of its influence,
but basically it arose with the production of the Vedas,
which are the oldest Indian holy texts
that seem to date, it's difficult to date them,
but second millennium BCE, maybe 1700 to 1100 BCE,
they're quite old,
and they were quite old in the Buddha's own lifetime.
And the Vedas, many things classify there are,
the philosophy of the Vedas is qualified in many ways.
It's a philosophy of, for one, a caste system.
So the Vedas had this idea
that there were natural human castes,
that naturally humans fell into groups,
and that the Brahmins,
who were the religious seers and leaders
and people who memorized and knew the Vedas,
that was their caste karma,
that was their ritual kind of action,
they believed themselves to be the head caste.
They were the top caste in this hierarchy.
Although, I should say, in the area that the Buddha lived,
this was still debated in the sense
that the Buddha himself seems to have come from a place
that believed that the Brahmins were not the top caste,
which shows that this was an item of debate.
But, and I should also say that Vedic Brahmanism
eventually would become Hinduism
in the centuries after the Buddha's lifetime
and into the common era.
It became what we know today as Hinduism.
But for many people, this early period,
we don't call Hinduism, we call it Vedic Brahmanism.
And the practice of Vedic Brahmanism
was one of knowing the correct sacrifices,
the correct sacrifices to give to the gods, in particular.
And these were known and done
in order to gain worldly ends,
in order to gain wealth for oneself,
in order to gain fame, perhaps,
in order to gain a successful family,
a successful marriage, healthy children.
And so, that was the reason
that one went to the Brahmin seer
and the Brahmin priest,
was in order to do sacrifices on one's own behalf
so that one could gain these kinds of worldly ends.
And also, these priests also knew the right incantations,
which were in Vedic Sanskrit.
They had to say them in the proper way.
And the Vedic Brahmins were not so much interested
in the next lifetime.
There is a glimmer of a possibility within the Vedas
that another lifetime was possible.
However, that was not really discussed in the Vedas.
And it's not clear to us, I think, at this point,
that the Vedic Brahmin priests of the day
that the Buddha was living
were particularly interested in the next lifetime
insofar as their practice was concerned.
However, in the century or two before the Buddha's lifetime,
there arose a new category,
you might say a new group of Brahmins
who are what we know today as sort of Upanishadic Brahmins,
the people who were responsible for composing
what we know today as the Upanishads,
which are forest texts written by seers
who went and discovered new things, shall we say.
And they were largely, we believe, Brahmins
who believed basically they'd found
a new interpretation of the Vedas.
So that they were less interested in these sacrificial ends
and more interested in the questions of rebirth,
the questions of how we could live the right kind of life
so that we could become reborn.
And then when they were interested in that question,
then a problem seems to have arisen in their minds.
Now, this is perhaps reading back a bit,
but it seems to be that once we come up
with the question of rebirth within that context,
we begin to understand that there's a problem
because there's no escape from this round of rebirth.
In other words, we do well for a time perhaps,
but eventually we're gonna slip up
and fall down into a worse rebirth later on.
There's no real way to become permanently successful here.
And so these Upanishadic seers
basically began to be more concerned
with ways to escape from this permanently,
to find some kind of permanent refuge
from the ups and downs of daily life
and indeed even the ups and downs of life
within a rebirth context.
And that is where we find the Buddha coming into it.
In particular, the Buddha seems to have confronted
some of these ideas of these Upanishadic seers.
The idea that's most prominent in the Upanishads
it's relevant here, is one of becoming unified
with what's called Brahman or the universal principle.
So a Brahman is this kind of understanding
of the universe as a thing,
as a kind of a grounding of reality,
which is called Brahman.
And it's also understood,
sometimes personalized as the deity Brahman.
And I think it's probably not a coincidence
that this is the same,
basically sounds the same as Brahman's
these professional religious leaders,
that that's the same word being used or a very similar word.
In any event, what these Upanishadic seers believed
is that we can become unified with this universal principle
by deep insight into the nature of ourself.
That if we did deep forms of meditation,
which they seem to have promoted,
these deep forms of meditation would reveal to us
our unity with Brahman,
that ourself is the same as the universe,
that we are the universe.
And they seem to believe that this awareness
of our unity with the universe
would lead to the ending of rebirth,
would lead to indeed a kind of an awakening,
an escape from reality,
where we would no longer have to contend
with bad rebirths in the future.
We would sort of escape the wheel of rebirth.
And another new idea or new philosophy
that arose just in the period prior to the Buddha's lifetime
was what we call today Jainism.
Jainism is indeed a religion that continues today.
And it seems to again have arisen perhaps
in the century or so before the Buddha's lifetime.
It's difficult to know.
It seems to have been active while the Buddha was teaching.
And in Jainism, there's quite a different idea.
The idea in Jainism is that we should undertake a practice
of complete non-harming,
that anything we do is going to harm something.
Even the smallest action we take
is gonna harm minute creatures in the world.
And so by taking on a practice of non-harming,
we're taking on really a very difficult practice in Jainism.
And the Jains also believe that since we have in the past,
before we were Jains, and even while we're Jains,
we've harmed so many creatures during our past lifetimes,
because they believed in rebirth as well,
that we need to undertake very austere practices
of self-mortification in order to burn off bad karma.
Because the Jains believe that karma
was a kind of physical thing that attached to our soul,
our permanent soul, our eternal soul.
And so by undertaking these penances, if you like,
these practices of extreme self-mortification,
we could burn off this bad karma,
which would then reveal the inherent wisdom in our soul
and allow us once again to become awakened,
to escape this round of rebirth
that is all due to our bad karma.
Now we come to the person of the Buddha,
Siddhartha Gautama, as he's known,
who lived from around 480 BCE to around 400 BCE,
in that timeframe, roughly speaking.
Now, what the Buddha did was he accepted
certain parts of these other philosophies.
Indeed, he seems to have practiced them
before his own awakening.
And he seems to have accepted some of them,
and he seems to have also rejected some of them,
and in so doing, created his own kind of synthesis,
his own system, which was unique to him.
So what did the Buddha accept?
Well, the Buddha, from Jainism,
accepted a philosophy of non-harming,
a philosophy where the main ethical practices
were built around this ideal of non-harming.
Although he wasn't, shall we say,
quite as strict about that as the Jains,
he had his own idea of what harm entailed
and the importance of intention to that harm,
which the Jains didn't seem to have.
But nevertheless, that was primary to his thinking.
In so doing, the Buddha also accepted
the Jains' deep reliance on ethics,
that ethics was central to the Buddha's philosophy,
just as it was to the Jain philosophy.
Now, turning to Vedic Brahmanism,
the Buddha accepted this idea of deep meditative insights,
that meditation, the practice of meditation, was critical,
as it wasn't really so much,
doesn't seem to have been so much in Jainism.
In Vedic Brahmanism, or I should say
in Upanishadic Brahmanism, it was essential,
where these Upanishadic seers
who were retiring into the forest,
trying to sort of re-understand the Vedas,
believed that they could retake the practices
of the seers of the Vedas themselves
by undertaking these meditative practices,
and the Buddha accepted that,
and indeed, in particular, accepted the notion
of deep absorptive practices of meditation
being critical to the path.
The Buddha, however, also rejected
certain critical aspects of these competing philosophies.
With Jainism, in particular,
he rejected this notion of extreme austerities,
of extreme self-punishment,
this idea that the Jains believed that,
as they say, pleasure comes through pain,
that it's only through inflicting pain upon ourselves
that we can gain higher pleasures.
The Buddha rejected that.
In particular, he rejected that
because he believed that some of these
deep forms of meditation, what are called the jhanas,
cause pleasure to arise on their own,
a pleasure which is not blameworthy.
And so, the Buddha seems to have believed,
and indeed says he believed,
that pleasure comes through pleasure.
Certain kinds of meditative pleasure
can help us to become awakened.
And so, for that reason and certain others
revolving around ethics
and the role of intention in our ethics,
that intention is critical,
what we really intend is critical,
he rejected Jainism.
Now, he also rejected Upanishadic Brahmanism,
and indeed Vedic Brahmanism, for that matter,
for different reasons.
Both the Vedic and Upanishadic Brahmins,
all of them together,
believe in this idea of an eternal soul,
of an unchanging soul that we were supposed to be,
that our practice was revolving around.
And the Buddha believed that this attachment
to a permanent soul was a deep error,
that there was no such thing
as an eternal, unchanging soul.
Because, indeed, if we undertook, the Buddha believed,
if we undertook the practices
that these Brahmins recommended,
the meditative practices,
if we undertook these practices,
we found that all things change,
that even all things change within meditation.
And that when we leave meditation,
once again, and to go to our normal life,
things once again change.
And so, it's through these meditative insights
that we realize, the Buddha believed,
that there's no such thing as this permanent soul.
So that any kind of a practice
that was supposed to be finding out
the unity of this soul with Brahman
was going to be a practice that led us nowhere,
nowhere reasonable, nowhere important.
And the Buddha also, it's important to say,
rejected the philosophy of the Vedic Brahmins,
the earlier Brahmins,
because he didn't believe that sacrifices
and doing certain kinds of rituals,
which is what they were really involved in,
that any of that would lead to awakening.
All that that could do is lead you to a better next life,
but it would not do anything further.
So as a result, the Buddha rejected all of these
and constructed a new philosophy
based around this idea of non-self,
around this idea of meditative insight,
that meditation was really critical,
around this idea of ethics and non-harming.
And it's important, I think, if you want to go further,
in my YouTube channel, I have an earlier video
about the Buddha's six competitors, plus one,
where I discuss these six plus one,
seven competitors of the Buddha
and how he was different from all of them,
because there's more than I've just discussed today.
More people with more ideas in the Buddha's lifetime
against whom he argued and had arguments and conflicts.
And it's by seeing these
that we can really see the character
of the Buddha's teaching.
So I'll put a link to this up on the screen.
I hope all of you, I hope to see you all in another video,
and I hope all of you will be well.
