Dr. Drew: Erosion of the Patient-Physician Relationship

American Thought Leaders
2.4K followers
383 Video Views·Dec 27, 2024
and a member of the school board came in
and said we're going to lock the schools
down and I said why why are you doing
that who did you consult with did an
infectious disease doctor come in and
say you've got to do this no it's just
the right thing to do I knew then that
that there was big big big trouble Drew
Pinsky popularly known as Dr Drew is an
addiction medicine specialist and host
of the TV series ask Dr Drew for decades
he has been studying public health and
drug addiction in America exposing its
ongoing challenges in nationally
syndicated television and radio programs
The Physician patient unit is so badly
encumbered and so badly adulterated
right now it's hard for it to function
the idea that medicine can be
centralized and and algorithma tized is
disgusting to me there are a lot of
parallels between America's covid
response and the policies that led to
the opioid crisis he says there are some
of us that can't get over Co not the
virus the way our country dealt with the
co just mindboggling this is American
thought leaders and I'm Yan
Kell Dr Drew Pinsky such a pleasure to
have you on American thought leaders
pleasure to be here so you're going to
be giving the keynote pretty soon at
this Roundstone conference but tell me a
little bit more about like what you're
expecting to see here what what you hope
to get out of it you know uh it's
already exceeded my expectations um
Jeffrey is Jeffrey Tucker Brownstone is
such a genius at
uh we live in a weird time uh of almost
salons you know of of these gatherings I
I have the privilege of having been in
several of David Rubin salons where I
met interesting people learned a ton
this is the same phenomenon uh
fortunately I've also uh interviewed
many of the people here and I it's
always been at a distance via Zoom some
a lot of it started during Co where you
weren't allowed to travel or come see
anybody um but it was great to meet
everybody in person and and to hear them
and to have them sharing hot thoughts
amongst themselves it's been been just I
I mean I I just took notes all day long
I just found a a thrilling experience
well and it's really interesting you've
been doing something that I've really
only been doing I.E like being on camera
talking to people I've only been doing
this for maybe five pushing on six years
you've been doing it for quite a let's
see five number 35 years 35 years be
more precise yeah a long time and you've
had you know you've had quite the
evolution in your thinking that's what I
uh thinking keep
going because I've had evolution in my
what I've been do fundamentally I got
involved in media to try to do good to
to use this Juggernaut this this this
Leviathan that his media to try to help
people be healthier make good choices be
happy on if there's anything I can use
the media to try to climb into even in
environments where I don't belong if I
can reach people that need what I've got
I'm happy to go there and so this all
started my digital stuff I I do I a
thing called ask Dr Drew now uh
primarily Tuesday Wednesday Thursday at
3:00 Pacific time in Los Angeles and we
started that during the darker hours of
the lockdowns in Co particularly in
California which were draconian
and I uh just started answering
questions live on this stream um
actually I think we even started on like
Facebook live or something we we just
started just I just wanted to just
interact with people and try to reduce
their anxiety and answer their questions
and about boy a month into it I I
started feeling like I was the French
underground I mean it felt it felt
illicit
and it's like they they they were so
um aggressive with not allowing for any
discourse or any opinions to be offered
I I just it felt weird to me so I just
answered questions as I saw it and then
it evolved into other things well but
you know even before this you you
focused on for example opioid addiction
right addiction General that's a lot of
my life was running a large addiction
program right and I mean that that
hasn't gone
away no it hasn't gone away but uh
there's movement at least I mean look
The Playbook by which the opioid
pandemic was delivered at least the
pharmaceutical opioid pandemic was the
exact same Playbook that was used in Co
that that's something I'm going to talk
about on my uh Presentation tomorrow
night well maybe you know to tell me
tell me yeah tell me a little bit
because you know we're not we're going
to publish this after so the first
opioid crisis in this country was it
towards the end of the 19th century the
hypodermic needle morphine sulfate
methanone these things were all
developed the latter part of the 20th
19th century and uh the Physicians were
the uh delivery system for the opioid
pandemic in that area and it was massive
the Harrison narcotic act that came in
the early part of the 20th century
actually is alleged to have jailed as
many as 20,000 Physicians for their
excessive opioid prescribing and it
stopped immediately and that that
intervention was so Draconian that
Physicians turned away from opiates for
80 years or at least certainly 60 years
uh and we were sort of cautious about
them afraid to use them not using them
in the 60s and 70s we started seeing the
Advent of more effective treatments of
cancer and so we had a lot of people
living with cancer and developing more
advanced stages of cancer before they
died with pain and a group of people
emerged who said this is ridiculous we
should be treating this which was
absolutely great for sure that was true
and opioids were the answer for acute
cancer and surgical pain opioids are the
solution they were
never ever shown to be useful in chronic
pain in other words after about two
weeks opioids they generally don't work
they cause headache back pain and
something called hyperalgesia which is
an intensification of pain so all opio
everyone was getting strung out of oral
oral opiates because my back hurts well
that was the opioid withdrawal and the
pain was over overwhelming and disabling
because of hyperalgesia all opioid
induced so that's the background where
that that group that came in that um
started managing uh pain in the cancer
setting surgical setting getting very
good at pain acute pain management and
cancer pain management looked around and
said you know what there shouldn't be
any pain we are the saviors for the
American public we're going to prevent
them from ever experiencing any pain I
have all these quotes from the pain um
the pain specialist of the day saying we
considered ourselves a white white hat
profession we were going to rescue the
world from pain then the Evangelist from
that discipline of pain management which
became a highly ins sconed specialty of
medicine Psychiatry and anesthesia he
became a structured board-certified
discipline the leaders in that group
went out and got control of the
regulators so these evangelists went out
and got the medical societies the VA the
local Departments of health and the
first to adopt was the VA system who
took the position adopted what these
pain management guys were suggesting
which is that pain is more important
than any other Vital sign forget your
pulse what's the Pain Scale pain the
fifth Vital sign do you remember that
slogan pain is the fifth Vital sign that
was a that was a mandated measurement
when you got the pulse the blood
pressure the temperature respiration and
the Pain Scale top of every physical
every time a doctor interacted with a
patient mandated by the medical
societies the insurance agencies the
medical societ every Everybody the V
everybody mandated it and doctors were
trained to give as many opiates as the
patient wanted if they left with less
than 60 pills of Vicodin you were
potentially doing patient abuse at the
same same time as all these regulatory
standards kicked in the lawyers caught
wind of this and started again now this
is the legal system stepping in and
suing doctors and criminally Prosecuting
doctors for under treatment of pain so
in North Carolina Florida in California
doctors were going to jail again for not
using enough opiates when that happened
immediately doctors froze stopped
prescribing sent everything to the pain
management teams and Pain Management
said pain is what the patient says it is
pain controls what the patient says it
is so if that's true you don't really
even need a doctor and in some parts of
Florida that's exactly what happened for
instance where you could walk into a
pain management clinic and just go yeah
I'm in pain I'm a nine out of 10 I need
that demoral I need that fenil I need
then and then you walk out with your bag
my patients were killed by the hundreds
by those practitioners of course opiate
addicts love that and so they were
causing opiate addiction on one side and
they were killing opiate addicts on the
other and I I got so tired of taking
patients off opiates their pain going
away it was the same thing with every
single patient you they come in they go
what's your pain on a scale of 10 they'd
always say 15 or greater always then 3
days in we detox and we take them off 3
to 5 days later you go now you they
would not talk about pain anymore but
before that's all they could talk about
and they would you'd ask them what's
your pain on a scale 10 they'd say five
with no treatment off just get them off
other than detoxification off the op and
so so this was happening to me all the
time that I was getting these patients
off opiates they were their pain was
being managed they were not troubled by
pain anymore but they're drug addict so
they'd go back to their doctor and the
doctor would go why do you listen to
those people yeah I told you you're
going to need to stay on this the rest
of your life dead killed so many of my
patients that way Drew we're just one
quick sec we're going to take a quick
break and we'll we'll be right
back and we're back with internist and
addictionologist Dr Drew Pinsky that is
that is not a story that I'm aware of
until this moment and now think about
covid you have these bureaucrats who are
um evang evangelically possessed that
they're in the right guys like Scott
Atlas and Robert Redfield try to reason
with them with data they're like you're
an outlier get out of here we know
what's right for the American public
Burks evangelizes in every state gets
control of the governors and The
Regulators now you have lockdowns same
Playbook the exact same Playbook again
perpetrated by my profession and so how
early did you see that something was
off with opioids or Co with with Co with
Co um I knew something wasn't
right as soon of two weeks to flatten
the curve so-call which to me sound like
a marketing PL but okay we're going to
see what's going on two things happened
to me one the governor California came
on and said hey man we're going to do
this we're going to lock us down I was
like what I can't believe you're doing I
couldn't believe it it just seemed like
such a terrible idea he brought in the
Navy's hospital ship into Los Angeles
Harbor and I was like what is what is
what do he expecting I don't I don't see
it but okay he's preparing for the worst
I'm a good citizen I'm I'm going to
support him uh even though I think it's
a terrible idea he doesn't need to do it
fine so that was when I was like
thinking something wasn't right then I
was doing a Nightly News broadcast in
Los anas trying to help people
understand what was going on and we were
probably a week into that broadcast and
a member of the school board came in and
said we're going to lock the schools
down and I said why why are you doing
that who did you consult with did an
infectious disease doctor come in and
say you've got to do this no it's just
just the right thing to do I knew then
that that there was big big big trouble
and that was March you know March of
2020 I just thought the people the Press
was taking advantage of us to get our
eyes make us Panic enhance their
business uh so I uh I made a mistake of
starting to run around going just don't
listen to these people just just don't
listen to them the mistake I made I kept
saying was listen to the CDC and listen
to Dr
I worked with them for years they will
get us through this that was the only
thing I really got wrong I didn't
realize how adulterated they would be I
was also saying look we in 10 12 years
ago we just went through another
pandemic did you know that the H1N1
pandemic was Nast it was a terrible
illness I had it I had patients that had
it it was an awful illness killed
300,000 people and you don't know it
happened and we're going to go from that
to destroying the world on behalf of
this one isn't there a somewhere in the
middle we could be and that went down
for the world as Drew says this is just
the flu there was a hysteria look I I
was saying at the time that if I had a
very seriously ill patient I stood at
the end of the bed went oh my God oh my
God is that going to help is that going
to get or are we going to be look we're
going to take this we're going to do the
best we can it's a serious situation sit
tight we're gonna get this that that's
how you manage people you don't scream
hysterically uh and you also
don't you you don't uh undo all your
ethical standards and uh you know throw
away the Constitution and the Bill of
Rights that was just the most that's
what I can't get over there are some of
us that can't get over covid not the
virus the way our country dealt with the
co just mindboggling I felt like my
world changed in March of 2020 I can't
believe what happened what would you say
are the biggest sort of lessons you've
learned over the time that you've
watched um Society responding to these
kind of new new medical scenarios right
like
um you know most of my learning has been
in the last four years because I I had a
lot of assumptions about how things work
before that something I was fighting
against for many years was the insurance
companies and The Regulators interfering
with my ability to take care of patients
uh that is constant
and this the covid experience has
re-enchanting relationship I feel that
we have lost that battle so much so that
I'm working now with companies to try to
deliver products and services directly
to patients and put the autonomy now
with the patient maybe with some teleah
health support but that the physician
patient unit is so badly encumber and so
badly adulterated right now that it's
it's hard to it's hard for it to
function and that the idea that medicine
can be centralized and and algorithma
tized is disgusting to me it's the exact
opposite of how we're going
to how we're going to get good health
care in this country well this is very
interesting because you know I've spoken
with a number of people number of people
at this conf at this conference on the
show uh talking about the I guess the
the hypocritic oath meaning a lot less
or you know some people would even say
being thrown out the window or something
like that um certainly not being
properly understood Well Do no harm risk
reward gone what happened I I feel like
Do no harm is my mandate and risk reward
is what I must consider in every moment
of my evaluation with a patient even
advising them to cross the threshold of
my office there's a risk reward in that
Francis Collins said it out loud that
well you just be when you're in this
position you just focus on one thing the
virus and nothing else matters when I
was training
residents the if they couldn't come up
with their risk reward analysis on every
decision they made I would crucify them
and the the thing that if they ever said
to me that was the most intolerable when
if I'd asked them why they made that
decision and the answer is I just had to
do
something no way I'm not going to be
kind to that let's just say because
that's how you harm patients it's the
opposite of Do no harm and it's the
opposite of it risk reward
consideration and what about this
element of you know I guess disclosure
of risk right how that's that's no that
is uh informed consent that is the basic
job when you offer a treatment for
somebody you have to make sure that it's
done with the patient I mean I look I I
it may have been before my time that
doctors would just do things and you
know the patient would trust it I was
trained that the it's a it's a
co-decision and it's every single
decision is made with the patient and
the treatment is agreed upon with the
patient based on my ability to
communicate the risk award analysis to
them you know I I've recently become
aware of this uh actually it was talked
a little bit about in today's uh today's
meetings about you know kind of the co
increased commodification of the human
being um and you know the rise of Bio
this utilitarian bioethics and I haven't
I haven't haven't been following this
closely at all I've been reading uh
about it and I'm curious if you're if if
you've followed that and I I don't but
but uh Brett Weinstein said something
very I thought preent today when he
talked about the the public health being
the opposite of Health Care that the you
know a master in public health is is
somebody trained in a system of
transference of the well-being of one
person to somebody else or the whole and
then is anathema to healthcare I I I
can't even imagine that we allow that
let alone train people to do that except
that public health I mean there is a
place for public health right looking at
things from a broader perspective sure
that's enacting yeah and provide that
information to the doctors and to the
local community so they can make the
decision where they can weigh these
things and make a good decision I see so
it's it's like this uh what is it
subsidiarity principle right that yeah
it's the mandating it's the decision
on high uh look Alexis dville when he
ran around this country he's a French
Aristocrat uh was here ostensively to
evaluate our Penitentiary system as it
was called at the time because it was so
effective and he on on the DL actually
wanted to figure out why democracy which
he thought was the New Movement
worldwide that was inevitable in all
countries why democracy was working in
America so he wrote a book called two a
two volume book called Democracy in
America and he concluded that the reason
democracy worked here was because of the
the mindset or was practiced all the
time but most importantly it was a local
practice of
democracy local decentralized it's why
this country Works centralization
federal government was never never
supposed to be in my life supposed to
deal with interstate commerce make sure
the states got along common defense
that's it
maybe protect some rights okay done well
so you have you thought about at least
in the medical context how to challenge
that I guess that's why we're here
trying to figure it out trying to again
i' I've been working with companies of
trying to get services and and
medication things directly to patients
in a cost- effective way that that's
been my latest thing because I I don't
know what to do with the the practice of
medicine generally it's just it you know
the Young The Young Folks are being
taught to look at the computer and just
fill out forms do an algorithm uh look
things up if you don't know I mean I
don't know how you develop judgment I
don't know how you think about a risk
award if all you're doing is following
an algorithm on your electronic medical
record it's really disturbing a final
thought as we
finish um I can't believe I live in the
world I live in much like Jeff Jeffrey
Tucker said his opening remarks today
but I'm so grateful uh that we're here
having these meetings that there are
this many people that interrupted their
lives and came to Pittsburgh and were
sharing ideas and interested in making a
difference even if we're radical
Outsiders at least we can try to move
things in a in a healthy direction I I'm
I'm a little bit optimistic we'll see I
mean I I'm tired on the opioid on the
drug addiction front I've been screaming
about that for years same thing with
other serious mental illnesses we treat
brain diseases differently than other
diseases For No Good Reason which if
somebody's on the street with a heart
attack we treat them if somebody's on
the street with a seizure we treat them
if somebody's on the street with
schizophrenia we leave them
alone it it's rid it's it's stigmatizing
it's Draconian it is uh medieval and it
has nothing to do with modern medicine
and these people should not be involved
unfortunately it had echoes in the covid
epidemic and a lot of what happened
there um I have shared similar similar
frustrations we have to find ways to
restore sanity and
decentralize much as Alex doville
suggested in 1829 that it's the local
practice the local relationships that
makes thing make things work in this
country well Dr Drew Pinsky it's such a
pleasure to have had you on appreciate
it thank you all for joining Dr Drew
Pinsky and me on this episode of
American thought leaders I'm your host
Yan kellic
[Music]
