Jaya Prakash Narayana on Manmohan Singh: మన్మోహన్ సింగ్ పాలనపై జేపీ | Big Debate | hmtv
Здоровый Образ
3 followers
Dec 27, 2024
First of all JP Garu Namaskar
Namaste Srinivas JP Garu
I know Manmohan Singh Garu is probably one of the very few people that you admire personally. The kind of
connection you have with him is
really the good he has done for the country.
It is a lot about how he worked and what kind of services he provided when he was in various positions
People are talking about your experience
Sir Srinivas sir
if we see the history of independent India one era from 1947 to 91
yes another era from 91 to 91 ok
even with good intentions but with very
moldy policies
dogmatic completely ignoring what the government should do in this country
ok and
freedom of citizens Completely dismantled economic
freedom without competition, professional monopoly,
license permit quota rule in
all fields. At a
time when there was scarcity and corruption in all fields, Manmohan
Singh
became the Prime Minister with the involvement of Narasimha Rao. As
Finance Minister, we are lucky
to be like you, a gentle,
honest, film man, a great
academician, a man
with immense knowledge, erudition, and a
man with experience in many fields of government. Governments are
so complex in our country that no matter how
educated you are, how skilled you are
If you don't have experience in the government,
combining all these departments is really a big
mess. Okay, he was made Chief Economic Adviser.
Yes, in the
1970s, he was
made a member of the Planning Commission.
Yes, he was made RBI Governor there.
From 1976 to 1980,
he was the secretary of the country's financial affairs, so he was in government and
outside the government
He has versatile experience in various forms,
so it was suitable for the time. Okay, the
second thing is that when there is a crisis, we
temporarily stop
doing some things. If there is a crisis in the country in 1940, we
borrow five billion dollars from the IMF.
Not so this time
Narasimha Rao's political will is
his political armor his skill
Due to this persistence,
even though it is limited with sincerity, the
direction of the country has been completely changed by 180 degrees,
ok, a new turn has been taken, ok,
that is what you have taken, on the other hand, while
bringing a fundamental change, the country's
political, economic, and financial picture has
changed.
Since then, the terminology in the financial sector
has changed.
No later monetization debt All these are new ideas ok
as well If there is a banking sector,
prudential norms, capital
adequacy ratio and non-performing
assets, all this is a new language, ok, and
taxes may be in the case of taxes, otherwise,
in the case of import codes, a
fundamental change has been initiated. As
if there was no major change in the For Itself Ok adaptation
Narasimha Rao with the philosophy of bringing everyone together is the same way,
he is the same way, ok, the two are the same way,
when Narasimha Rao
changed Nehru's economic policy radically, there is
nothing, or we are just continuing Nehru's policy
a little bit. They
said very well, the way they work,
yes, honesty, modesty, in
many countries in our country We will see
yes but in our country if there is a small post like
a tehsildar post and another
small word municipal councilor then there is
so much commotion the actual body language
is different like that a finance minister
or prime minister you can't
really imagine his humility yes we can't
imagine unless we are associated with him ok In many
cases, sitting with him in a meeting, he is
25 30 years older than us. Yes,
his father's age is in his experience. Either in
knowledge or otherwise in status or in position
or in everything, a man who is much superior to us can
converse with you as an equal. It is okay to listen to you with
interest. If there is meaning in it, then listen with
interest.
Sometimes I have to
wake you up and it's
1:30 for dinner. It's not polite.
No, no, it's not polite, you
gave me so much time, I used to wake him up to sit down,
ok, then he
came outside, came to the portico, was the prime minister,
ok, he sat in the car, ok, that's not necessary. He
was born in remote villages in Pakistan and later
came to India and when
he went to school some women
used to walk to and fro. Yes, he remembers all that.
From there
he studied in a normal university with Swayam Krishna and from
there he went to Cambridge with Swayam
talent and went with a full scholarship.
Okay, that is the expectations of life.
He ruled that it is possible to grow without him, so
we should remember him in many ways.
Surely this country is okay. Now, in
our country, democracies in many
countries. We see in our countries in America,
the more we shout, the more we
rush, the more we shout, we
think it is great. Yes, it is not like that. The
symbol of greatness can be amrita. Ok, we should
look at the goals achieved. The
loss without him is inevitable. After reaching the age of 92 years,
if not today, then tomorrow, but
in his life, he is for all of us.
The feeling shared or the
good done to this country should be remembered for a long time by this nation.
He said a word in
the press, sir,
that is, in a press meet, when reporters were asking those very
tough questions,
if there was no media today, I
hope the history of how much the opposition criticized me would be kind to me.
Schemes today are either Director Benefit
Transfer or else Nuclear
Deal or JNN or Aadhaar for many other things.
All these are also Right to
Information Act or all these
when he was the prime minister, maybe
many intellectuals like you also work together as a team in
bringing out all the good things. Really,
I know you and I
have met him more than a few tens of times and discussed with him.
What did it really feel like,
sir? It is
absolutely true that history will
definitely remember him very well
because in this political
heat where winning elections is the only
sign of greatness for us,
what election did he win? win
yes it is the measure of greatness but
he has no greatness yes but greatness is the measure of
life lived as the results achieved
but surely history
remembers ok so what he
said is completely true ok
not only when he is in office but also when he is not in office
he is the leader of opposition in Rajya Sabha do
you remember or we all also the
details of criminal acts The said effort to put out
the State has created a big reward in the country if it
goes to the Supreme Court then the Supreme Court election All
the parties
opposed it. OK, finally
Pranal Chief participated on behalf of the Congress party and
he opposed it.
The parties like who are they? They said that what we are saying is
nonsense. The Communist parties
opposed it. I was very surprised. OK. The
leader is the leader of Annamata and he
went to the ante-chamber in the chambers
together I told him that
now if you don't buy it
then there is another chance if you
don't buy it even if the Congress party is the
main opposition
then Pranav Mukherjee has already
spoken against it in that all party meeting.
If he was busy in some other program,
he could not go because he was busy with the committee meeting
I don't know
why Pranab
said that because of that reason but I don't know why Pranab said that but normally he is
very resident and hastily gives words,
there is no such thing but he
gave me a specific word Jayaprakash I will
talk to the party presidents and
do what you said one hundred percent just to
meter ok in three days from Sonia Gandhi to
Swayam Dasturi I got a letter
she said she was ok
fully supporting it ok like this 97th
99th Which is the Constituent Assembly, the National Judicial
Commission, and
I formed a committee when I met with two Chief Justices, and when I met
him,
I told him in full detail, OK,
what are we doing every moment to the Prime Minister? He
said that we are making arrangements and
he knew every detail.
After everything was done, I went with both of them
Ok immediately they took it positively and
immediately ordered it to be arranged
ok well you will remember
dahaka scam came yes when that
scam came it is
normal to put them in jail isn't it normal to put them in jail like in any quarrel in our country
but before they said that what is put in jail is what is
put in jail yes now we
argued from Loksatta that ok What
you are putting is not something that will happen but
at least take this as an opportunity and
arrange honest money for the cost in the party yes if
sitting with him Then the Congress party
formed a committee under his chairmanship for that reason. Yes,
he looked into what we got and
gave it as a party report.
The party report that you brought as the Political Funding Bill
means
what was given by the internal party report of the Congress party. This
NDA government is salt fire and other scope for
us. It is known, yes, yes, the
NDA government accepted it as it is and
passed the law unanimously in the parliament,
so there is a change in that country with a lot of depth, even outside the power,
yes, without shouting, OK, in every
respect.
I remember very well that the man who girded his waist was beyond the parties
and everyone said that BJP will not
work for Modi.
Then sister
Medha Bhaskar did a lot of movement in the name of Narmada Bachao agitation.
I was the first to say against it.
It should be kept and used. In the period of lack of water,
if there is no irrigation water, there will
be no drinking water If there is hell in Patnam, there will be no
industry, but farmers'
interests should be
protected, this Medha Bhaskar did a big
movement, then yes, what about hunger
strike, Amaraksha, okay, in those days, there
was no social media. For
whatever
reason I met him that day OK, on the day I met, the
big paper photo came out like this: America met me and she
Okay, when Manmohan Singh came,
he said to me, Jayaprakash, I have not had a
single lump of rice for three days, I
am very worried,
why are you so worried, this is the matter,
I know it is a good idea, but her
concern is wrong, the demand she is making is
very little.
Justice should also be given to the farmers at the time and he said that he was thinking about what to do,
you
Prime Minister, you
don't need to be so desperate, you are 100% correct.
Rupees is the fact that you
insist and give leadership to this,
what should we do? I mean,
you hold an all party meeting. Ok,
all parties agree. I
know that. Ok, take it and immediately
address the country. All
the people
say aside, that is not his characteristic.
Yes, he is a little behind the state. How do
you want help? I need a favor. I
don't need a favor from him.
I need a favor from the Prime Minister. Favor from you
said what does it mean I
will set up a committee, there
is a case in the Supreme Court, ok if dam height should be increased or
not, if you are there, then the
committee will work fast, it will work fairly.
If you say you do it, then the prime
minister will do it easily for you, but
if this is the way, then the committee will be
formed. The
height has increased
since then and till now Narmada
came again and the debate in the country is permanent, that is,
without any aggravation, without arrest,
without arrest, the problem
is solved completely and permanently. Ok, there Gujarat
government is different. Narendra Modi is BJP. In order to
increase the prices, this license permit was
also primed by many leaders in the Congress in those days,
PV Narasa Rao himself.
Even when he was a minister, the
MPs of the party said that how should he take this to the people? If the
prices of fertilizers are increased, there will
be opposition from the people,
even from the farmers, they have also entrusted the
matter of talking to the MPs to address Manmohan Singh. What is
strange is that the Congress party is not ready to end this license permit
regime.
Because if there is a meeting in the Congress party on that day,
who will agree that
deregulation should be done, economic liberalization should be given,
economic freedom should be given, the government
should reduce its role and work efficiently,
otherwise the economy will be destroyed,
who will agree on that day,
Manmohan Singh, Chidamanam,
both of them, on behalf of Narasimha Rao, the
party members, the leaders, all the details.
He was informed and presented The
first glory belongs to Keerthi Narasimha Rao
because
he came unexpectedly because of his immense experience. He
did not think that he would become the Prime Minister. Yes, if he
was coming home after all the sanyas and Rajiv Gandhi was on the way because of the death of Rajiv Gandhi,
suddenly he had a plan.
Crisis came In 1980 when Indira
Gandhi was the Prime Minister, crisis
came Five two took a loan
from the IMF, yes, but it was a temporary
spell, paid the money again, and
continued as usual.
He has nothing to do with politics,
so he just
says objectively, whatever, because he has credibility
If there is a problem, those who try to tell through him are
ok, like sir Aadhaar, sir
Aadhaar today
we cannot imagine the real India without Aadhaar.
Such ideas as
a unique identity for everyone in the country
did not exist until then.
If you think it will work,
how should you implement them sir? The
Prime Minister's
Congress leadership thought that let's
make everyone the education minister for months. Ok, due to various political reasons, it was
decided within the party that it is not possible to make him the education minister.
Then they said what should be done, that is, if he
gets another post, whether he wants it or not,
we want to use you in some way. You should think about it.
He said, thinking that all these are small
government positions for me, I don't want them.
Apart from the value of identity, the
implementation of this welfare, but if not, the
removal of irregularities, the
curbing of corruption, but
why is this Aadhaar for everything, why did it get that name? They
did but they were very much
obstructed by this person like Jagdambaram who
was also the Home Minister and tried to
obstruct by saying who am I and what is another empire
but the Prime Minister stood by him.
Ok at the same time Narendra Modi
should be chosen even if that government did
ok next government again this is
Nandala one day he said again what
will not happen to me ok when he went to Delhi
he called Nandana in the election he
contested on behalf of Congress and lost you remember
yes even if he contested on behalf of the rival party
ok keep it in mind Without
any hesitation, he said that I will explain to you together, and he
immediately
gave time, yes, that is also 45 minutes. They are
attracted to it and are convinced and
are using it fully today. Today welfare
schemes have changed the face of welfare like no other country in the world.
Also Sir this Cash
Direct Benefit Transfer is
also DBT It is said that it was during Manmohan Singh's reign that if it
was transferred there, then the government also
continued it. Ok, now we
are able to save ten thousand crores of rupees. Ok, it is not fair to say that the
welfare of the common man is 100%,
but 99% of it
is being implemented efficiently.
Some have come into force,
some have come into force, for example,
retainers No
one in that party has much understanding,
no desire, they fought a lot and
achieved it, but why do they want it because the
parties have no integrity, as if the things in Orei's mouth are scattered with a running nose.
In the final rate, the farmers will get 70 percent rate, the
incomes will increase, we
have lost, but
I will show you in many areas. Acted like that sir,
RTI is the key, that is your total
participation, RTI
means giving information on that day, it is the government's
monopoly, it should not go out. It is
said that if Manmohan Singh didn't try to achieve it, then the
community law would have come immediately in those days. In 120 days there is
also a rules frame for it. Even now
we have bold laws which are not a rules frame for a decade.
Moreover, the
government is determined to implement it quickly.
How can we understand that the government was able to bring RTI in 2005 on the very first day of the formation of UPA One. It means that there
is some background to
it. The Vajpayee government should also
get some glory because H
There is a company called Common Cause with D Shourie Arun Shourie
's father is very honest He was a
social activist like Parud um under his leadership
that Vajpayee government set up a committee
Right Information Act Namona um
after that model Aruna Roy garu
I
then George Fernandos in one case
he and
many others later Justice
Sawant
was made a judge in the Supreme Court and made the chairman of the big press council
We all sat down and made different models of these If
Aruna was invited by both of them, the
prime minister started inviting them,
that means the will
was understood in itself. Ok, there was a promise to do it in the national NCMP. There
came a time, but it was implemented with sincerity. What
was asked of them was that
we recognize privacy
but not to make all the confusion in the name of privacy and
not bring any organization under the ambit of RPI. You say ok
let's keep them aside so that everything else
will come under the scope ok secondly
even if you grant exemption even if it is not covered within this scope then
two things
please cooperate a little one if there are
allegations of corruption then there is secrecy then
ok ok like that public welfare is
bigger
than the protected interest.
If it is important because of public interest then
information should be given there, what is it,
if the interpretation is not in the court then the information
commission will do it. Okay, okay, all this was
completely accepted by Manmohan Singh and he gave a metaphor for that model.
Okay, I was disappointed in one thing.
Okay, what I proposed that day
is that in the appointments of the Information Commission, if the
leader of the opposition is not the chief minister of the state, then
at the national level, then the prime minister, okay, then the
chief justice of the Supreme Court, then the
chief justice of the state.
Jayaprakash we
are already seeing that many times
we have discussed that justice system is
overstepping the bounds of justice system again
why killing in killing let's leave it alone
we ok then him
As per the suggestion it was put aside
so
a big discussion was held after thinking about everything
thoroughly ok some people are idealistic and
some people have impractical ideas
even if they are ideal yes I
told us immediately what the ministers talked about in the cabinet yes yes
yes I was with the public minister
sitting is not possible work ok
in the cabinet you talk if outside the
cabinet is the cabinet is
collectively responsible to the people
so you naturally have a church internally there
are differences of opinion they
co-ordinate The government
comes to a decision, we need to know what
decision was made and why it was made. Also,
what did any minister say. If any minister
opposes it, the government will
fall tomorrow. They
accepted it completely. That is the way it is formed in the law.
Therefore, the law
was made very carefully. Manmohan Singh
's role in it is his experience of governance.
Justice should be done to the people and at the same
time the administration of the government should be efficient.
His role is to coordinate both of these.
He expressed his grievances and said that especially in relation to the health sector as well as the women and child welfare association, I have to admit that after being the prime minister for 10 years, I could not do enough for the sectors.
However,
what should be done at the national level, if any Prime Minister
thinks that he has done everything brilliantly, he
needs to be ignorant, otherwise, he
needs to be arrogant. Manmohan Singh is an honest
man. So he is a
man who is very clear about the extent to which he has achieved what he had set out to do. Okay, that
was demonstrated. For example, in the field of health, he
proposed that day.
That was done completely 70
sets 175 is there for ours not like that
but that pattern should be brought to the end
ie common man rich difference good
standards for all at all levels
basic health for all We
said second and made an arrangement for it, ok, he
tried hard and told me,
Jayaprakash, this is too radical, it is
not possible, ok, let's reduce it a bit, ok, it
is possible, otherwise, nothing will happen.
I am included
in the task post under the chairmanship of the Prime Minister,
I am only a few members, I have been
put in the task post, we
have tried. It got some results,
okay, so he
felt it was incomplete, okay, and
doing everything that he wanted to do in many fields,
because of the politics, then the
coalition government was also exactly the
coalition government, the
communists in the first term, the government with the communists, the government is for the
communists.
Thank you Mr. Right JP in many ways, thank you for your valuable time
