"The vortex of declining values in commercial real estate is getting wider and increasingly threatening. Imagine you bought a property for $300,000 expecting the investment would not only pay off overtime but also appreciate due to the normal dynamics of the real estate market. Fast forward to 10 years later, you find out that your property has become virtually worthless, even though there's nothing damaged on its structure and your neighborhood hasn't changed significantly. You are still paying off your mortgage loan, and after prices have plunged seemingly overnight, now you're buried on negative equity and stuck with a property no one seems interested in buying. Well, that's what's happening to commercial real estate owners and investors. But instead of $300,000, we’re talking about properties that were initially sold for between $3 to $300 million dollars or more."
The vortex of declining values in commercial real estate is getting wider and increasingly
threatening. Imagine you bought a property for $300,000 expecting the investment would not only
pay off over time but also appreciate due to the normal dynamics of the real estate market.
Fast forward to 10 years later you find out that your property has become virtually worthless
even though there's nothing damaged on its structure and your neighborhood has not changed
significantly. You're still paying off your mortgage loan and after prices have plunged
seemingly overnight now you're buried in negative equity and stuck with a property
no one seems interested in buying. Well that's what's happening to commercial real estate owners
and investors but instead of $300,000 we're talking about properties that were initially
sold for between three to three hundred million dollars or more. This year the commercial real
estate market is crashing and it is crashing hard with some office and retail buildings
losing up to 97 percent of their value. But many of these buildings are still being paid off by
their owners and investors who are having little choice but to default on their mortgage loans
and put thousands of banks that lent the money at risk of total collapse. Can you picture now
that the whole financial system is literally hanging by a thread and that thread is thinning
according to financial experts. A recent analysis by Fitch Ratings predicts that the ongoing
commercial real estate crash will wipe out more property value than the financial crisis of 2008.
More ominously Fitch believes any recovery from this crash will be slower than the rebound from
2008 and the gains will be lower. Analysts say that the term lost value doesn't even fully
capture the current landscape's reality. As noted by James Carlini a financial strategist and
president of Carlini and Associates this seems more like a vortex of declining values.
He argues that the market is being plagued by a reverse of musical chairs dynamic. The pandemic
has fundamentally changed the way businesses operate. For retailers declining foot traffic
at physical locations, lost sales and higher operational costs resulted in mass store closings
increasing the square footage of empty retail space. Meanwhile in the office sector companies
identified that a segment of their workforce could operate permanently from home which created a
significant bifurcation. About 35 percent of office employees have started to work remotely
leading the demand for leased office space in both downtown and suburban locations to drastically
shrink over the past four years. As a result the surplus of vacant commercial space and dwindling
demand has sparked a reverse of musical chairs effect. Carlini explained buildings with low
occupancy today risk even lower occupancy rates as leases expire and tenants migrate to better
cheaper spaces. Office buildings are being particularly affected by this trend because
obsolete buildings are not attracting new talents. In the third quarter the rate of empty office
spaces hit 20 percent that is a 40 year high. Carlini said that's a problem for more reasons
than the casual real estate observer might understand at first glance. First there is no way
any building with a 20 percent vacancy rate is generating profit or even covering basic expenses
like mortgage and insurance. But the underlying issue is that all pieces of commercial real
estate's value are tied to how much money it's making. Unlike homes whose values can be propped
up by factors like curb appeal and buyers emotional attachment commercial real estate valuation is a
pretty cut and dried equation where prospective buyers use current rent rolls and revenue receipts
as the primary matrix. In other words a commercial office building or an entire portfolio of
commercial properties with vacancy rates of 20 percent is depreciating every month.
While empty stores can be leased by other retail brands empty office spaces at all buildings are
not being reoccupied. The sector has already entered a depression stage. Take for instance
the suburban Ohio class B office building that was appraised at four million two hundred fifty
two thousand six hundred dollars back in 2020. After reassessment its value plummeted to two
million five hundred sixty three thousand in 2023. Now up for a court ordered sale the reserve is set
for only one million seven hundred thousand dollars. The property lost nearly 60 percent of
its value in four years. Even more alarming a New York 23 story nine hundred twenty five thousand
square foot building redesigned by the famed Gensler architects team sold for eight point
million dollars last week. The build was first sold for a whopping get this three hundred and
thirty two million dollars. This represents a 97 percent decline. Located at 135 West 50th Street
the office tower was auctioned off by UBS on an auction website called 10x earlier this year.
It received just one bid. The building has leased office space for many big companies over the years
such as Zales and Sports Illustrated. But this year vacancy rates hit 65 percent as more companies
reduced their physical footprint. That's why Fitch doesn't see a commercial real estate bounce back
like the one the residential market experienced after the 2008 crisis. Carlini added in my view
junk is still junk even at a discount. Obsolete buildings will not attract tenants unless they
undergo significant upgrades to support critical corporate applications. Although some believe that
the current decline in real estate values is a temporary phenomenon tied to the pandemic's high
vacancy rates this view is myopic. The strategist stressed the work forces permanent bifurcation
and the obsolescence of many buildings due to technological advancements suggest a lasting
shift he said. In 2008 conditions were different because most of the distressed assets were single
family homes and condos which are properties all Americans need to live a normal life. Despite the
decline in values it was only a matter of time before Americans got back on their feet and
started buying houses again. On the other hand the pandemic permanently changed the game.
On top of the popularization of out of office work the inflation spike led the federal reserve
to aggressively raise interest rates putting restraints on the broader economy and record
high rates have triggered a kick on effect for commercial office owners and lenders that has
been absolutely devastating. Commercial real estate investors and landlords who took out
short-term financing at low interest rates to snatch as much commercial property as possible
over the past decade are now finding themselves unable to refinance their debt at the same rates.
If they want to refinance they'll have to pay roughly double the interest rates as before.
Those who have got dozens hundreds or even thousands of commercial real estate assets
in a portfolio are completely cooked. More and more landlords are stopping to make interest
payments on their commercial real estate mortgage loans because they don't collect enough in rents
to pay interest and other costs nor can they refinance maturing loans given that the building
doesn't generate enough in rents to cover interest and other costs. They also cannot get out from
under it because prices of older office buildings collapsed by 50 percent 60 percent 70 percent or
more with some office towers becoming literally worthless the property going for just land value.
Add that to the fact that even if these semi-vacant office buildings find new tenants
the new tenants will be paying less per square foot than their predecessors and it becomes easy
to see why Fitch is forecasting that commercial property values may never return to their
pre-pandemic levels and even if they do it'll take a long time for that to happen. The rebound
if there is one will probably not be strong enough to stave off a tidal wave of commercial debt
that's set to mature in the next several years. By some estimates nearly three trillion dollars in
commercial debt is set to mature by 2027 and almost one billion dollars of that matures in 2024.
To sum it up you have commercial landlords drowning in debt on rental assets that they can't fill
and mortgage lenders holding trillions of dollars in loans on totally toxic assets.
When you look at the problem that way it's easy to understand why everyone from Fitch analysts
to the International Monetary Fund is sounding alarm bells about the possibility that the
current commercial real estate crash could be worse than 2008. Over the past couple of years
the U.S. banking system is losing its stability due to the rising number of mortgage loan delinquencies
and defaults. At large banks the delinquency rate for office loans has surged to 10.5 percent
marking a concerning deterioration in commercial lending. They are now just a hair below the worst
months during the financial crisis meltdown when office delinquency rates peaked at 10.7 percent
and that's according to data by TREP which tracks and analyzes the sector's latest data.
The trend is particularly worrying because we're now learning that several financial institutions
in the banking sector have more exposure to the commercial real estate market than they
previously stated to their customers. In fact a data analysis from a finance expert at Florida
Atlantic University showed that more than 60 out of 100 biggest banks in the country
are at increased risk of failure due to their commercial real estate exposures.
67 out of 100 big banks have exposure to commercial real estate greater than 300 percent
of their total equity as reported in their 2024 regulatory data and shown by the U.S. bank's
exposure to risk from commercial real estate screener. Rebel called PhD Lynn Eminent scholar
chaired professor of finance in FAU's college of business stress this is a very serious development
for our banking system as commercial real estate loans are repricing in a high interest rate
environment. At the moment the institutions facing the highest risks are Flagstar bank and Zion
bank corporation according to the screener. Flagstar bank reported 113 billion dollars in
assets with commercial real estate making up for 51 billion dollars of total assets.
Similarly Zion bank corp had a total commercial real estate portfolio of 440 percent of its total
equity. The bank reported 87 billion dollars in assets and total CRE assets of 26 billion
but only 5.8 billion dollars in total equity. These are the two largest banks with excessive
exposure to commercial real estate. Cole revealed both rely heavily on uninsured deposits which
makes them vulnerable to a bank run similar to what forced regulators to close three large banks
during spring 2023. Those bank closures have led to concerns about the stability of the U.S. banking
system over that long term. Banks with less than 10 billion dollars in total assets are in danger
too. Among banks of any size 1,871 have total CRE exposures greater than 300 percent. 1,112
have exposures greater than 400 percent. 551 have exposures greater than 500 percent and 243
have exposures greater than 600 percent. Cole predicted three banks have failed in the past
year and now we have several candidates where their exposure to commercial real estate is over
500 percent. Should another bank fail it's likely that depositors will pull their money out of these
highly exposed banks which could lead to a banking panic similar to what we saw during spring 2023.
If you couldn't see it before now I bet you can visualize that the thread holding the financial
system together is about to break and break big time. This isn't just a commercial real estate
crisis it's the beginning of the great financial collapse we've all been warned about. We look
forward to reading your comments and thank you very much for watching.