Employer Healthcare High Prices from Medicare Advantage

Smart Insurance Choices
22 followers
Hello, this is Dr. Eric Bricker and thank you for watching A Health Care Z. Today's topic is
employer health plan high prices are closely linked to Medicare Advantage. What? Employers,
Medicare, what do they have to do with each other? Well, there's a few big concepts that we need to
go over first. First of all, employer-sponsored health insurance prices are much higher than
Medicare rates. They are 200% to 500% Medicare rates from Blue Cross, United, Cigna, Aetna.
Now, those insurance carriers also have Medicare Advantage members, people who get Medicare through
an insurance company. Now, when those insurance companies pay hospitals for their Medicare
Advantage members, they only pay the Medicare rate. Maybe it's 95% of the Medicare rate,
maybe it's 105% of the Medicare rate, but it's about the Medicare rate for the facility fees.
That's what we're talking about here, the hospital system facility fees. Okay,
let me give you a specific example. So, for a total knee arthroplasty, a knee replacement,
the Medicare rate is $12,539. That's what a Medicare Advantage person, if they go in and
get their knee replaced, the insurance company is going to pay the hospital about $12,539.
Now, if someone with employer-sponsored health insurance, they're 55, they go in for a knee
replacement, the insurance company or the employer, if they're self-funded, is going to pay
$50,156. That's 4X, that's 400% of the 12,000. Okay, that's concept number one. Concept number
two is the insurance carrier and the hospital, when they're negotiating their rates, they negotiate
total contract value. So, the hospital system says to the insurance company, look,
you need to pay us like X millions of dollars or X billions of dollars. We need to get to this
number and we need to come up with a combination of rates that kind of get us to that number.
Now, let's use a specific example. Let's say that an insurance company has only five members and
two of those five members have employer-sponsored insurance through their job and three of those
five members have Medicare Advantage. Well, and they all have total knee replacements. Well,
then the claims that the insurance company is going to pay out for the Medicare Advantage folks
are going to be $12,500, $12,500, and $12,500 for the three Medicare Advantage folks.
But the hospital system says, look, that's a super low rate. That's the Medicare rate.
And frankly, for these five members that you have, you need to pay us about $137,500. Somehow,
we need to get to $137,500. So yeah, we'll give you this little dinky $12,500 for these Medicare
Advantage folks, but we've got to make up for it with your employer-sponsored health insurance
plan members. And the insurance company says, okay, we'll pay you $50,000 for a total knee
replacement for every one of our employer-sponsored plan members. So there's two of those, $50,000
plus $50,000. So you add up the $50,000 plus the $50,000 plus the $12,500 for those three people,
and that gets you to the $137,500. So that's the total contract value. And the hospital has gotten
what they want, and the insurance company has gotten what it wants. Okay, that's concept number
two. Concept number three, why have such low Medicare Advantage rates? Why is the commercial
insurance company wanting ... Listen, they could get to this $137,000. They could make them all
the same. Or they could make, instead of it being $12,500, they could make it $25,000. So why does
the insurance company want to keep those Medicare Advantage rates so low? And it's because the
insurance margins on Medicare Advantage are so high, whereas the margins on the employer-sponsored
plans are much lower. What does that mean? That means that the insurance margins for an
employer-sponsored member are only $745 per member per year, whereas the insurance margins on a
Medicare Advantage member are $1,730 per member per year. It's more than double. Okay, so the
insurance companies keep their Medicare Advantage rates low. They keep them at the Medicare rate
so that they can maintain that margin. Now, remember, it's not just margin. It's also times
the number of lives, right? The total earnings or the total profit that they make is the profit
margin times the number of members that have that margin. Okay, so now let's look at that
membership for employer-sponsored members versus Medicare Advantage members. Okay, so
for insurance companies, their employer-sponsored membership is pretty flat. So nationwide,
it's 178 million folks are on employer-sponsored plans. And that number actually went down about a
percent from the previous year. So that's not a growth market for them. They're not growing
employer-sponsored lives. And each individual insurance company, they don't really gain or
lose that many employer-sponsored lives in a year. It stays pretty flat. However, for Medicare
Advantage lives, they've been rapidly growing. So 10 years ago in 2014, there were only 15 million
people on Medicare Advantage. And now in 2024, there are 33 million members. It has more than
doubled in 10 years. So Medicare Advantage is higher margins and it's a growing membership
base. Now, the number one thing that the insurance company, if they're publicly traded,
what they care about is their stock price. And in order for their stock price to grow up,
they've got to grow their earnings. So really the growth of an insurance carrier is in the higher
margins and the growing membership of the Medicare Advantage lives. Okay. Now let's go
back to that total contract value negotiating table between the hospital system and the insurance
carrier. Now, especially after COVID, all of the hospital systems were like, look, we're going to,
we need to increase the amount of money that you insurance carriers would pay me. Instead of paying
me $137,000, now you need to pay me $150,000 total. And so what the insurance company does is
they say, okay, well we need to protect our margins on these Medicare Advantage folks. So
we're going to keep them at the Medicare Advantage rate of $12,500 for the knee replacement. And so
the hospital says, that's fine. If you want to keep your Medicare Advantage folks at $12,500,
well then you better really jack it up on the employer sponsored insured members in order to
get to that $150,000. And the insurance company says, okay, we'll do that. So now it goes up to,
instead of being $50,000, it's now $56,000 for a total knee replacement on an employer sponsored
plan. Now, why is an insurance carrier so willing to throw their employer sponsored lives under the
bus? Why are they willing to do that? Because you got to remember that 65% of members in employer
sponsored plans are on self-funded plan, where the insurance carrier is not taking risk on that
$50,000 or that $56,000. So when an insurance carrier raises their rates on their employer
sponsored plans, they as an insurance carrier are not decreasing the margins on their insured
members by much because so much of that risk is borne by the employers on the self-funded plans.
So they essentially use the self-funded members and the self-funded member high rates to pad
the overall reimbursement to the hospital systems. Now, this then gets us to the final point, which is
for many employers out there, they've been beginning to turn to these direct contracts.
Sometimes it's a direct contract with a hospital system. Sometimes it's a direct contract with an
ambulatory surgery center. Sometimes it's direct contracts through a separate vendor that just
sets up direct contracts between employers and the healthcare providers, the hospital systems.
So why is it that these direct contracts can then get favorable weights? Well, because when you're
dealing with a direct contract, those direct contracts, they don't need to pad their total
reimbursement by these super low Medicare Advantage rates. They're free from having to do that.
And so what they can do as a direct contract is they can be like, look, we'll do a total
knee replacement for $25,000. And the hospital system says, well, shoot, $25,000 is not as good
as $50,000, but it sure is a lot better than the $12,500 that we're getting from Medicare.
So sure, we'd be, I mean, for the sake of patient volume, if you can give us patient volume,
then yeah, we'd be happy to take patient volume at $25,000 instead of $12,500. And so that's why
those direct contracts can get lower rates than the commercially insured plans, than the employer
sponsored health insurance plans, because there's none of that padding of Medicare Advantage that
needs to happen. And so listen, as a specific example, look, there is an ambulatory surgery
center that I've talked about before on A Health Care Z called the North Texas Team Care. It's in
Mesquite, Texas. And for a total knee replacement, they'll do it for 20 grand, right? Because they
are more than happy to do a direct contract because 20 grand is certainly a lot more than
what Medicare has given them. So just know that when you as an employer are paying very high
contracted rates, very high allowed amounts for healthcare services with a hospital system,
just know that is because the insurance carrier is trying to maintain very low reimbursements
on their Medicare Advantage members. And that's my point for today.
Thank you for watching A Health Care Z.
