Differences Between Academics vs. Private Practice | Salary, Volume, Work-Life Balance

Flex Flow Forum
37 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 26, 2024
Good to hear both sides of every story.
And I never thought I would find myself in private practice,
but here we are.
Good morning, everybody.
I hope you all have your beverage of choice.
Today's coffee chat is going to be about something
I find very interesting,
and that is the difference between academics
and private practice,
and why I have chosen one over the other,
specifically why I chose to leave academics altogether,
unfortunately.
But we'll talk about my own personal choice
at the end of the video.
So I hope you have your beverage,
and let's get into it.
Before we start, oh my gosh,
this is a very full cup of coffee.
I have to show you this very cute vertebral body mug.
Did you see how cute it is?
It is so cute,
and it's actually very comfortable to hold, surprisingly.
It is RSNA on this side,
but I'm right-handed,
so this is how I'll be drinking it throughout this video.
Before we get into this video,
I do want to say that there is no right or wrong choice
when it comes to choosing
between academics and private practice.
It all comes down to what you want out of your career.
If you are someone who is very passionate about research,
you have a very strong research niche,
very passionate about teaching residents
the future of medicine, things like that,
then obviously academics is for you.
And if you are someone that wants to grind out
over a million a year,
and you just want to work, work, work,
and earn, earn, earn, and it doesn't matter,
then private practice is for you.
This video is really for those of us
that are somewhere in between.
I could have seen myself going either direction.
I definitely was leaning more towards academics
because I feel like we are constantly told,
academics, academics, academics is the way to go.
A lot of us trained at academic institutions.
I mean, most of the residency programs,
fellowship programs are at big academic institutions.
So inherently, we are sort of already surrounded by academia
just going through training.
And I feel like if you're in that in-between stage,
you may not know which way to go.
And I hope that this video helps you.
First things first, let's talk about money
because that is sort of always the elephant in the room
when it comes to being a doctor.
What is the salary like?
Academics, historically, is always going to pay you less.
Private practice, historically, will pay you more.
Okay, that is sort of just how it has been for a long time.
Recently, there have been changes
where academics are starting to pay more
because we are in a major radiologist shortage
and everyone is trying to recruit.
And if the academic institutions
want to compete with the private groups,
they have to up their ante.
And so a lot of the salaries
are sort of becoming equalized.
However, there are some places where private practice,
you're just gonna out earn your academic peers
and there is just no comparison.
When it comes to being a partner in a private practice,
a partnership track group, and you become a partner,
there are often, I mean, commonly,
you'll hear that people will double their base salary.
The base salary between academics and private practice
will probably be around 350 to 450.
And I give a range because some places are in the 300s
for a base salary, even 325, I have heard.
And some places will be closer to 425, 400, 425, 450
for both private practice and academic groups.
Academics, in general, the way to earn more
is A, to moonlight, so work more.
Not every academic institution has that, but many do.
B, to climb up the academic ladder,
and we'll get into that later.
But in some places, and again, not all places,
the higher you go on the ladder,
so from assistant to associate to full professor,
you might get a small pay bump, whether it's 10K to 25K.
And I'm giving you all these numbers
just based on what I've heard, okay?
This isn't specific to one institution,
this is just based on things I've heard.
I've also heard of places that give zero bonus
to anyone who goes up the ladder.
So just keep that in mind.
You have to do your homework with every single institution.
And if you wanna earn more money,
then you also take on more admin roles.
Because sometimes you get a stipend, for example,
again, 10K, 15K, even like 5K,
for certain admin roles that you may take on.
Whether it's a program director role
that might come with a stipend,
whether that's a, I don't know, chair of education,
vice chair of education,
some sort of administrative role that you take on
that might come with a stipend.
That being said,
academics also likes to pay you with time often.
So you may also, instead of getting any money,
you might get both time and money.
And when I say time, I mean academic time.
You might get some time and you might get some money
and you might get both, or you might get neither.
I hope you don't get neither.
So if you do take on like a program director role,
that will come with academic time.
So maybe you have like a day every week
that's protected for that.
And you'll also might get a stipend of some sort.
So just things to consider
that academics does like to pay with time a lot of times
and also sometimes with money.
So that's the academic side.
Private practice side is definitely eat what you kill.
So if you want to earn more money,
you will probably work more.
In general, private groups
are much more open to moonlighting.
People like to sell their call.
So if you wanna take more call, you can earn more money.
Shifts that people don't really wanna work.
So whether that's swing shifts into the evening,
overnight shifts, those tend to pay more.
And then there is the idea of partnership track.
So a lot of times private groups
own outpatient imaging facilities
and whatever income that you get from those
like facility fees and things like that
will eventually come out in a distribution
at the end of the year
where those earnings are distributed among the partners
because you technically are a part owner of the group
and a part owner of those imaging centers.
So if your group owns an imaging center
or you own a building and you're leasing it out,
like all of those profits will somehow make their way
into your bonus at the end of the year
or however, whatever distribution situation
that your practice has.
As I mentioned earlier,
a lot of times that bonus can be equal
to what your base salary is.
So they are not small amounts of money.
Keep in mind that in private groups,
sometimes there is a buy-in.
So that means maybe for the first three years, five years,
your bonus will just go back into the group as your buy-in.
And sometimes you don't have a buy-in
and you can just get that bonus right away.
So a lot of homework that you have to do
when you are joining a group,
but if you really are looking for money specifically,
private practice is probably the way to go.
The next thing I wanna talk about
is just what your day-to-day life will look like
in both academics and private practice.
Private practice is sort of straightforward.
You come in, you do your work, you leave.
Really, that's it.
There's not usually too much administrative stuff
unless you are specifically in like a role
in which you would have to do those things.
Like for example, in breast imaging,
there are some people that are considered
like the lead interpreter of the breast section or something
and maybe that person has a little bit of admin stuff,
but again, usually not a daily thing,
not even a weekly thing,
probably just once in a while type of thing.
You have to get everything ready for your audits and stuff,
but not really something that you do on a daily basis.
Or deal with on a daily basis.
Most private groups, you're gonna come in,
you're gonna sit down, you're gonna do your work,
you're gonna leave.
Academics is much different.
Academics will involve doing research.
If you are someone who's into research
or you want to get involved with research,
you will be teaching.
I mean, a big part of your practice
most likely will have to do with teaching residents,
fellows, even medical students.
And so you might have trainees in your reading room
who you are reading out cases with
or doing any sort of activities,
preparing conference, things like that.
And you'll probably be spending a lot of your time
doing committee work.
So as I mentioned in academics,
you're very encouraged to join a lot of committees
to sort of bring the institution forward.
And also in case you want more academic time
or if you want a higher stipend for those things,
like you're encouraged to take on these leadership roles.
And in order to get to those leadership roles,
you do have to sit on a variety of committees.
So whether that's an admissions committee for something,
whether that's an education committee,
wellness committee, diversity,
there are hundreds of committees
that you can set quality and improvement.
I mean, there are so many different committees
that you could be on.
And a lot of those committees,
most likely you'll be part of multiple
and they all have meetings.
So you might meet quarterly, you might meet monthly.
I mean, if you're working on a project,
you might have to meet even more often
like while you are trying to submit your grant
or anything like that.
So keep in mind that your day-to-day work in academics
is going to be a lot of collaboration.
It's going to be a lot of committee meetings.
It's going to be a lot of teaching, which I love.
I love teaching.
And a lot of like maybe setting aside time to do research.
Now, as I mentioned, you get paid with time
in academics a lot of times.
You end up with a day, maybe two days.
So you will have some time set aside for those meetings.
However, keep in mind that everybody at the institution
will have probably academic time.
And many times not everybody's academic time
is going to be on the same day.
So you might end up having to leave the reading room
and leave your clinical work to finish up
on all of these other tasks.
And then you reemerge and you end up doing
a lot of the readouts and everything
in a more compressed fashion.
That's at least what I found.
So you're still doing all your clinical work.
And then you're also on top of that
doing administrative work.
So that's just a different practice
between private practice and academics.
Your days just look a lot different.
There's a lot more variety in academics,
which people really enjoy.
I will definitely agree that there is just
a lot more going on.
So that's academics versus private practice
sort of a day in the life.
Let's talk about the next thing, which is volume.
Historically, I'm gonna use that word a lot
because things have changed.
Things have changed a lot in radiology.
But historically, volumes in academics
was a lot lower than volume in private practice.
I mean, private practice stereotypically
is known to just churn, churn, churn.
Basically, just a lot of pressure
to get out as many cases as possible,
to read as many scans as possible.
And historically, academics is known
to be more slower paced, more relaxed,
more time for teaching in the reading room,
and things like that.
Now, as I mentioned, things are changing.
And why do I say that?
That's because volume everywhere has just skyrocketed.
So private practice went from crazy
to even more crazy.
And academics went from reasonable
to crazy levels, I would say.
So everyone is sort of now on a similar playing field.
I think that still maybe academics
has a slightly less volume than private practice.
But I will say that in my short time in academics,
I did not feel like the volume was so low.
It was not, it was pretty busy,
probably on par with what I'm doing now in private practice.
So the volume is not a significant difference.
And a lot of times people used to use
that volume difference as like a reason
why you're getting paid less in academics.
But nowadays, the volume is very similar.
Again, unless you're in a crazy private practice
that's very understaffed,
and you really are just working all day
and all night to get the numbers out,
like you're probably not gonna be doing that in academics.
You probably will be slightly more protected.
But the volume day to day is probably very similar.
And that being said, the cases that come
through academics tend to be much more complicated
because academic centers tend to be
tertiary referral centers, tertiary care.
Everyone is coming there,
they have maybe a large catchment area.
And so you're going to be getting much more complicated
cases versus a lot more negative studies historically
that you see in private practice.
So just a difference there where you're seeing
a lot of volume and more complicated cases in academics
versus in private practice.
Usually you're gonna do a higher volume of studies,
but a higher volume of those studies
will be normal or negative.
So again, something to keep in mind,
just a difference between academics and private practice.
One major difference between academics and private practice
is just this idea for me of the hamster wheel.
So there is always a push for more career advancement
within academics.
In private practice, you may be trying to become a partner,
and that's sort of an end goal.
Once you become partner, beyond that,
you could become the chairman of your practice,
but usually it's not like you are continuing,
continuing, continuing to try to prove yourself.
And for me personally, I found academics,
which again, I wanted to do academics,
that was the first thing that I did.
I found it to be a continuation of everything
that I'd already been doing in training.
So you go to college, then you want to get into med school.
Once you get into med school, you want to go into residency.
Once you get into residency,
you have to get into a good fellowship.
Once you get into a good fellowship,
you want to find a good job.
And it was just this idea of having to do more,
doing more, do more, lots of projects,
things to put on your CV, join committees.
And again, I enjoy, I still enjoy it.
I am voluntarily on committees at this point.
I am not saying that this is something
that is a waste of time at all.
However, the idea that all of these things are done
in order to advance your career or to go up the ladder,
for me, I actually found it sort of mentally exhausting.
But that is, in academics, that is the culture.
You are going to be meeting with your chairs,
your department chairs, your division chiefs,
talking about your CV,
talking about how you can do the next thing,
talking about how you can climb the ladder,
getting more speaking engagements, giving grand rounds.
That is your daily life, and that is what you will be doing.
There are people that are in academics that just,
quote, coast, who just stay assistant professor forever
or associate professor forever.
But that's not what I have found to be the average person.
The average person really is trying to push
to get more grants and more academic time
and more stipends so that they can earn more money
for their family and kind of climb the ladder in that way.
So it's different.
Private practice, you just have sort of your end goal
of maybe wanting to become a partner
or maybe not.
Like, honestly, I'm an employee.
I'm not a partnership track, and I'm super happy.
I only do the things that I wanna do
because I want to do them.
Like, I legitimately want to do them.
I don't have an ulterior motive.
I don't have any sort of end goal at this point
aside from just wanting to feel fulfilled.
So it's sort of like a different beast
in the sense that I do think that academics
does create that sort of hamster wheel feeling,
and you really are always trying to add to your CV
and do more.
And if you find that fulfilling,
then I think academics is a great place for you.
And I think that if I had stayed in academics,
I probably would have found it fulfilling.
However, not having to do it is sort of a big relief
and a big change and a mental shift
that I actually did not see coming.
So that's one thing.
One thing I will touch on just here briefly
is that of remote work.
Remote work is definitely something that has been,
I wanna say, like, championed by private groups.
Teleradiology really was like a private practice
type of thing in the past.
Academic institutions are now starting
to hire more remote readers
just to try to keep up with the volume.
However, private groups have honestly
been doing it for longer.
There is just less red tape in private practice.
Like, if you wanna have a remote workstation,
it's just easier to launch all of that
versus in academics, you have a lot of IT issues.
You have to, like, talk to a lot of different departments
to make sure everyone's on board,
get a lot of approvals for things like that.
And so it's just slower paced.
But nowadays, there are a lot of places
that are giving out remote workstations, even in academics.
But in private practice, like,
you can just sort of do it immediately.
It's much faster.
So if you want a remote job,
you can look at both academics and private practice.
However, I think that there will be more opportunities
in private practice than academics for a remote job.
Speaking of, I will give you one example,
since you have watched this far already.
One example, I interviewed for an academic position
at an institution for a remote job.
And the volume that they asked me to read,
because I was remote, but also it wasn't
significantly different from someone on site,
was really high.
It was not like a academic type of job
in the sense that there was low volume.
So the idea that, again, academics is more chill,
I think might soon be something of the past.
I think now everyone will be expected
to be reading a pretty solid volume every single day.
Again, there are exceptions to every rule.
There are definitely gonna be places
that are more chill and whatever.
But in general, it's getting busier
in all spaces right now.
A lot of people will say that, you know,
culture in academics versus culture
in private practice is different.
I don't think that that's necessarily true.
I think that you will find good cultures
and bad cultures in both private practice and academics.
There are toxic private practices.
There are toxic academic institutions.
So I think that you just sort of have to ask around
and sort of you'll find out about the truth
about these places, or you will experience it,
unfortunately, and you will realize
like what a group really is like once you join.
I hope that's not you, but that is something that happens
and people leave.
That's why people leave their jobs.
In any case, I don't think that you can really say like,
oh, well, academics is nicer or whatever
because there are, again, toxic academic places.
And then there are private practices
that are incredible, supportive, like very warm,
very willing to like work with you about what you want.
So yeah, the stereotype that private groups
are like more toxic and academics are nicer,
I don't think that that's true.
I think you just have to, I think you just have to tease out
which ones are good and which ones are not good.
I think that's fair.
So finally, getting to why I decided to join private practice
after some time in academics.
Now, let's be fully transparent.
I was in academics for about, what do you think?
Six months or so?
I wasn't in it for that long.
Had I stayed for longer,
I think that I would have a different worldview about it.
I definitely would not necessarily have the same view
that I have now.
And my life situation also really affected
like my decision-making in a good way, in a positive way.
Like it just, for that time of my life
and for this time of my life,
I think that academics was not the right solution.
And that has nothing to do with where I was.
It has nothing to do with anything else
except for the fact that like my living situation,
my childcare situation and my work situation,
they just did not end up being compatible.
That's really all it came down to.
But I will tell you some things
that surprised me about academics.
Because yes, I also went into academics thinking
that it would be a little bit more laid back
than private practice.
And I thought it would be a nice way to ease into my career.
And I do still think that.
I think that it's a very good way to ease into your career
because you have good mentors.
You have usually a very collegial group of people
that you can go to.
I mean, I assume if you're joining a group,
then that's why you're joining them
is because you like the people.
And I loved the people that I worked with.
And so that is one thing that I think you do miss
in private practice a lot of times.
Being in like a whole division of breast imagers,
for example, like that was awesome.
And I do miss that.
What surprised me though,
was how much of your life academic medicine takes over.
So I was like sort of in some administrative roles.
Obviously, like I said, if I had stayed on for longer,
I would have had more responsibilities and tasks.
But I will like, I was shocked with,
in fellowship I was surprised,
but I thought, you know, I was just like,
I just thought that I was a fellow.
So like I was supposed to be like doing all of these things.
But in academics, I was really surprised
with how much the attendings are really doing
on the back end.
Like sometimes as a trainee, your attendings leave
and you don't know what they're doing.
And you're like, I'm slogging away doing the list, right?
But during that time that you're attending is away,
they're like on committee meetings or doing,
they're doing calls.
They might be signing other reports
that they have to re-review.
They might be doing conference prep.
They might be writing some grant.
They might be writing a paper or editing a paper.
Like there are so many projects
that your attendings are working on.
And I didn't really like always realize that.
And then I became an attending and I was like,
oh my God, I have so much to do all the time.
And it was hard.
Even like a simple email.
I mean, it requires like some activation energy
to get that out.
And I've, it was hard.
It was hard for me to like balance everything.
I was working full-time by the way.
And yeah, it was surprising.
And I thought that having, so full-time for me
was four days of clinical work and one day of academic time.
And I thought that having that one day of academic time
meant that I could use that day for like what I wanted to.
Like, you know, people use it for appointments
or I don't know, like various things around the house
I needed to get done.
But honestly, like, because I was, it was my academic day.
I was scheduling all of my committee meetings
and everything I needed to get done for work on that day.
And it was just another work day,
which I understand is like how it's supposed to be.
You're working full-time, but the flexibility
that everyone was sort of telling me about in academics,
I just didn't find that it was there.
Again, obviously I would become more efficient
and I would understand like what my role is
within everything if I stayed for like years and years
and you sort of really establish
who you are at an institution.
But just starting out, I was definitely like very overwhelmed
and then they were like, there was just so many meetings.
It was just so many meetings, so many, yeah.
Like meetings, I would leave the reading room,
then I'd come back and try to catch up
on all the work that I missed
because like you still have to sign off everything
that came through while you were gone, right?
Like just because you have other people helping you
doesn't mean that you don't have to look at those studies.
So it was a challenge for me.
If you are someone who can balance all of those things,
maybe it would have been easier
if I didn't have a toddler at home.
It would have been easier if I lived closer to the hospital.
So as I mentioned, just life things
got in the way of this job.
And so that was why I ended up leaving academics.
But I am so happy right now with my current job situation.
Like I didn't think that, again,
I was someone who would necessarily enjoy private practice.
Like to me, I think of, no offense to my dad,
but I think of people like my dad who work all the time,
I mean, to their own detriment,
who take so much call, work every weekend,
not available on holidays.
Like that is, in my mind, a stereotypical private practice.
And that is not what I wanted for myself.
And so when I used to hear people say,
oh, well, I'm gonna go into private practice,
I was like, why would you do that to yourself?
That sounds terrible.
But it's not like that anymore.
You know, like I have, I work part-time.
I work in private practice.
It's just, yeah, it's just a totally different beast.
And I feel like I actually have more flexibility now
because I, when I'm working,
like I'm the person who gets to decide what I'm going to do.
Obviously you have to have the volume
and you have to show that you're being productive
and you have to do these things,
but you have to do that in academics too.
Like no one is slacking off in academics.
So the idea that academics is like going to make your life
more chill, while it may be true,
I think that you can find that in private practice
as long as you sort of do your homework
or maybe find the right job.
And so anyways, all of that to say,
I am very happy in private practice.
I love working part-time.
Yes, I'm not at a partnership track.
I'm not going to double my salary with passive income
from outpatient imaging centers.
I'm not gonna be doing any of those things,
but I wasn't gonna be doing that in academics either.
So I'm very happy.
I no longer am sort of chained to my email
the way that I have been in training and whatever.
I get maybe one email a month, honestly.
Like I don't have so many emails coming in.
I don't have so many things I have to do for work.
I just do my work and then I get to be with my family.
And so I'm very happy with private practice right now.
I think that maybe someday I'd go back to academics.
And I'll say again, another myth that the idea
that you can't go back to academic, why?
Like who made that up?
Who said that you can't go back to academics
after private practice?
I think that it's sometimes hard
because you might be taking some sort of pay cut,
but the idea that you can't go back is not true.
So I have found that for me, private practice is a great fit.
I love it.
I love being able to be present at home.
I love being able to do good work.
And I also really like that I can stay involved
with committees outside of my institution.
So like I am still involved with RSNA.
I am tangentially involved with ACR at this point,
not as much as I was during training,
but I still get to talk to like the people
that I connected with through all of those things.
I got to give a talk at RSNA this year.
It's just been like, I don't know,
I can publish on what I want to publish on
if I want to publish.
There's no pressure for me to do it.
And it has felt really nice to just be able
to like sort of slow down on that side,
get to enjoy being home, get to enjoy being with my family,
get to enjoy watching football on the weekend
and not think about like, you know,
all of the pending to-do items that I have.
So just a different perspective.
I think as a female, a lot of times we are said,
we are told, a lot of times we are told
that academics is kinder to women.
Not sure.
I think it's totally just all about what job you find.
And if you find a good private group, that's amazing.
And I think I have found a really good private group
currently, so I'm fingers crossed
it's gonna work out for me.
I hope this provided some sort of like clarification
and yeah, clarification about the differences
between academics and private practice.
And I'm not trying to provide like a contrarian opinion
here, I think it's just good to hear both sides.
Good to hear both sides of every story.
And I never thought I would find myself
in private practice, but here we are.
So, cheers.
I hope you all have a beautiful holiday
and I will see you all in my next video.
Thank you so much for watching.
And if you made it to this point,
leave me a comment about what you wanna hear about next
because I'm really trying to get more content out
and I'm enjoying doing this very much.
So, bye guys.
To it.
If I put this on the couch, on my beautiful white couch,
is this going to spill?
Yes or no?
