Law and Justice - Antigone and the Defense of Tradition - 6.5 Sophocles and Tradition

History of Law
11 followers
5 Video Views·Dec 24, 2024
Sophocles' Antigone, performed in 442 BC in democratic Athens, is truly a classic, a work
that raises timeless questions, that speaks across the ages, and has indeed inspired civil
disobedience across the centuries. But it's also part of Athenian democratic culture.
That is that it belongs in its moment, in the 440s, in Athens. What is Sophocles saying
with this, with this play? The tragedies are part of the democratic conversation. They're
part of a public culture in which the people are expected to rule, in which the people
need political education. And Sophocles' Antigone is a great statement, indeed a great warning.
The play sets up a contrast between Creon, who's a legitimate king, and Antigone, who
refuses to obey his laws. Antigone says that his laws are not the same as God's laws. This
sets up a contrast between the laws of God and the laws of man, and it has particular
resonance in its moment in two ways. One, the play is a warning to the people of Athens.
It's a warning to the people of Athens that a legitimate government is no guarantee that
it will pass legitimate or just laws. In other words, Creon is a symbol for the Athenian
democracy. Creon is a symbol for the people. And Sophocles is saying that just because
a people have a legitimate right to rule doesn't guarantee that they will pass just laws. And
so it's a warning to the Athenian people. It's a warning to the democracy to remember
the laws of God, the eternal laws. But the play, Sophocles' Antigone, represents a statement
in democratic Athens in a second way. The play, the Antigone, is a rebuttal to the philosophy
of the Sophists. The Sophists raise the distinction between culture and nature and ask, is justice
a part of nature or is justice simply a set of cultural conventions? Sophocles says that
justice is objective, that it is part of the law of God, that there is a true justice,
and that it's grounded in religion. Remember the Sophists said that we can't know about
the gods. The play, Antigone, is a statement of traditional Greek religion. It says that
there is a god, Zeus, and that his laws, his ordinances are true. The play is a warning
against the excesses of the philosophy of the Sophists. And in fact, Sophocles seems
to be saying that the Sophists are wrong and that the Athenians need to respect and remember
their traditions. The play is, in effect, a defense of tradition. It says that traditional
religion and traditional morality provide a grounds for thinking about justice. And
in the unraveling of this tragic plot that ends in bloodshed and destruction, Sophocles
is warning against those who would forget traditional morality.
