Bye Bye Buehler :: Let's Play OOTP 25 :: Ep. 9 (2026 Second Half)

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Welcome back to Out of the Park Baseball. It is time to draft and now and only now do we understand
we cannot make any draft signings above the slot value of the pick. Full stop. Owner will not allow
it. That's important to know because we will pick sixth because we did manage to land in the lottery
after a pretty poor regular season performance from us last year. And we'll also pick 14th,
a comp pick for not signing a first round pick in the previous draft. So just so we know going
forwards no signings above the slot value of the pick. We've simulated the first five picks. It's
all been prep bats. High school hitters so far with Grady Emerson leading the way. Number one
overall to our rival Los Angeles Angels. I believe the best player available is this starting pitcher
Davon or Davon Bowie who just has incredible projections as far as his projected ratings.
Love the 75 control. Love the pitch mix here. Six different pitches. That's pretty crazy.
High work ethics. So that gives him a better chance to actually develop into being at least
somewhat around these projections. That being said, his demand is for 11 and a half million,
which is well above the slot value of the pick. So we will not be drafting him because we would
not be able to sign him. I'm torn between three guys here. One is Daniel Covett, Cuvée. I'm not
entirely sure how to say that last name. He is a college bat of the University of Miami. Doesn't
project to be like an awesome third baseman by any means, not particularly rangy, but the power
projection is definitely there for him. Another one would be Dorian DeVries. This is a high school
hitter. Right-handed outfielder. Good defensive ratings. 75 projected power. This avoid case
scares me. Don't want to end up in a Joshua Meir situation. The best player is probably Chris Greer,
another high school bat. Don't love that he's lefty because we have just so many left-handed
hitting outfielders. It's insane. But I mean, these are really balanced as far as his hitting
profile is still with 65 power. High work ethic. I'm going to click meet demand here instead of
draft player so I can at least remember what his demand was. And maybe we'll save some money that
way because we're drafting well under the slot value of our pick. So moving on to our second
pick, which is the 14th pick overall in the draft, the Pirates ended up with Davon or Davon Bui,
who I said was the best player available, but we couldn't afford him, so we'll see if the Pirates
can sign him. The decision is already kind of made for us. The slot value for this pick is around
$6 million, which would make it difficult to sign DeVries. And this is a comp pick,
so I wouldn't be able to get a comp pick in return. So pretty obvious answer here. I'm
going to sign Daniel Covett. By that I mean draft, I suppose. And he is the college third baseman,
although he may project more as a first baseman. We'll see. But out of the University of Miami,
he'll be our second first round pick. Second round here, I'm going to pick Eric Segura,
who is a college pitcher out of Oregon State. Three-pitch mix. I like his projections as far
as stuff, movement, and control. He's also high intelligence, which hopefully will aid in his
development meet demand. Third round here, I've got my eyes on Hunter Dietz, a lefty,
also a college pitcher out of the University of Arkansas. Also a three-pitch mix, high work ethic,
and we're looking for control guys. We like control guys. Give me Hunter Dietz. This is our
second pick in the third round. It is also a comp pick. We'll be drafting Eric Palmer,
a right-handed outfielder with some good power projection. He's only 17, so it's going to be a
long time to develop, you know, given the length of this series. We're probably not going to see
it. I understand that, but that's who I'm going to draft, Eric Palmer. Fourth round here, a lot
of the guys I shortlisted for around this range have gone, so I'm going to kind of wing it here.
I'm going to draft Brayden Holcomb, who is a power bat, first baseman type out of Vanderbilt.
So, Brayden Holcomb. That's a very Vanderbilt name. And in the fifth round here, I'll draft
another outfielder. This one, a high schooler, 70 outfield range. I mean, I know, I know. I'm
beating this drum every time, but 70 outfield range is 70 outfield range. Oh, his demand is
way higher than I can afford. Okay, let's not do that. How about a switch hitting middle
infielder named Steven Milam again, out of LSU? I think we've drafted some LSU guys already.
All right, I'm going to finish up the draft, and then we will go to the signing negotiations.
All right, we have finished our draft, and negotiations will be pretty simple. We're
either meeting the demand or offering the slot value of the pick. That's all we can do, really.
It is July 14th. We're getting close to the all-star break, and we have been on a really
rough stretch. Since June 24th, we have won four games, and we've lost a lot more than four games.
We are continuing just an awful July, just a horrendous July. Zach Jackson, tired arm, out
two to three weeks. That hurts, too. He's been actually in our closer role, or closer equivalent.
We'll probably call up Zach Brixey in a corresponding move. Actually, I'm going to go
with Freddie Tarnock, just because he's been doing extremely well at the AAA level, and sometimes
you just try to play the hot hand. Well, we've reached the all-star break with a 42-56 record.
We are 16 games behind Seattle for the division lead, and as you can see, we're playing 500-ish
ball the first three months, and in July, we have just completely fallen apart. We're 3-14.
The team still has not hit at all whatsoever, and the pitching has regressed so that we have
more average pitching, at least in terms of our starter and bullpen ERA. All-star game
rosters have been announced. Our lone representative will be our ace, Mr. JP Sears, who has had an
excellent season so far. Looks like Garrett Cole will be starting the all-star game for the
American League. Looking to see who here is having an absolutely massive season. Andres Jimenez,
batting .333, and when you're getting that sort of offensive output from someone with his,
you know, base running and defensive chops, that is a big value player. Jackson Holliday also
pacing for a 7.5 war season. Julio having a big year as well. Could he be going for
back-to-back MVPs? We'll see. In the National League, the starting pitcher will be Max Fried,
although his ERA is not that great. It's a 4.32. That's a little bit below his standards.
And as far as who's having a massive season in the National League, it's definitely Corbin Carroll.
Corbin Carroll is batting .396 right now, OPSing over .1100, pacing for almost 6 war. I mean,
is this a .400 watch? If you make it to the all-star break and you're batting .396,
that is pretty insane. Also on pace for 62 stolen bases. Moving into the second half here,
I think it's safe to say we'll be a selling team. We've just got about a week until the deadline,
and the player that we'll be receiving the most calls about, without a doubt, is Walker Buehler.
We have rehabbed him. He's looking pretty good in his second season, pacing for 210 innings pitched,
pacing for a 5 war season. His ERA does not tell the full story here. I mean,
look at these ratings. He's a 3.5 star pitcher. We haven't had one of those. We haven't seen one
of those. We haven't seen what a 3.5 star player is. So he is going to be a hot commodity,
and hopefully we can seriously get something in return here. Another option would be Anthony
Santander. His contract is expiring. His ratings have gone down. He has not necessarily performed
for us, but if we could package him with the Buehler trade, for example, then we might be
able to get something out of that too. And look at this little jerk, Anthony Santander. Three days
before the trade deadline, chronic back soreness, a four-week injury. You little jerk, Anthony
Santander. One of my favorite players in real life, by the way, but a disappointment for me in OOTP
with the Oakland A's. It is July 30th. The trade deadline is tomorrow. This will be Walker Buehler's
final start. Please don't get hurt. Please don't get hurt. Please don't get hurt. He's good.
Allowed five runs. We lost. Don't care. Let's trade him. We're gonna start with a more minor
trade. We're gonna trade Nick Allen in OG Oakland A. Don't love to do that. His ratings have come
up some. Like, he's a 2.5 star now. His contact is a 60. He hasn't performed well for us this year,
but you know, in general, he's been our utility infielder type guy. We'll also be trading Henry
Bolt, who is a prospect we've followed, having a good year in high A at the age of 22, about to be
23. That said, I look at his projected ratings, and I see he doesn't hit well enough to be a corner
outfielder, and he doesn't defend well enough to be a center fielder, so I don't really think he
has a place. In return, we'll get Joey Ortiz, who this is the first time we've tried this, but could
be our answer longish term at shortstop. The 75 infield range is the key rating right here. 70
rated at shortstop. We like that a lot. He has an injury, a strained back. We'll just have to see
how that, you know, he'll hopefully get him back in the lineup soon, but in between then, we will
have Isaiah Caner-Falefa, who's just a guy they signed on a minor league deal, will be a creation
after this year, but, you know, can also play shortstop, so he, you know, replaces basically
the Nick Allen role, if that makes sense, and Matthew Wood is, you know, catching organizational
depth at best. So, we are going to head and complete this trade. John Daniels says I'm not
leaning for or against it. I am leaning for it, and this is the big doozy. We're trading away
Walker Buehler. His contract is expiring. We've looked at the idea of offering him an extension.
Way too much money. We do not have that in the budget, so it's the obvious move to trade Walker
Buehler. The Orioles really, really wanted him. We're going to give them, or we're going to get
in return D.L. Hall, who I think we can actually just chuck in the rotation, and they're also going
to give us some young international free agent signings. This is Ernesto Correas, a contact
oriented outfielder, and David Covina, a third baseman. So, this is a total no-brainer trade
for us. I think it's going to help a lot in the long term, and it'll help free up some cash,
because we have a little bit of a budget crunch coming up as well. So, we'll go ahead and complete
this trade, D.L. Hall definitely being the centerpiece. Here's our top prospects list.
It includes the Colombian catcher Luis Castellanos, a power hitter, who is ranked number 15th among
all prospects in Major League Baseball. This is good. One of our goals was to develop a top 20
prospect. We have one of those. We gave him our entire budget, but we have one of those.
I thought about graduating him and having him play, you know, in the Dominican League,
but his ratings are just still kind of borderline for me. I don't like that 20 contact, so I'll
probably wait until he's 17 rather than 16. A couple injuries, Julio Canete, who was a scouting
discovery. He has a fractured elbow, out seven to eight months. His ratings have kind of come down
as most likely a result of that injury, at the very least. Moving up the system here, we do have
one player that got promoted from this. As you can see, we have many in rookie ball. We're a very young
system, but we do have one player that was promoted to full season A ball, and will finish in full
season A ball to end the year. That's Terrence Keel, who is our 2024 second rounder. Good defensive
outfielder. The ratings, though, I mean, hitting wise, not looking great. I mean, he may, you know,
lose his special prospect status, and I may let the CPU handle him. Ronnie Green's been an
interesting one for me to follow. He was our 2024 fourth rounder. That was the first draft we did.
His ratings don't say he should necessarily be able to do this in high A to me, but he's just
absolutely crushing high A, and so he went ahead and moved him to double A, so he gets the promotion
to double A. Don't know what his future would look like with the team, necessarily, with those
ratings. Also in double A is Devin Taylor, and he is killing it. He was our 2025 first rounder. I think
he was picked fifth overall. He's the number 60 prospect in Major League Baseball, and thought
about promoting him to triple A, but I'm gonna leave him in double A. He'll finish the year in
double A, and then we've got a couple guys in triple A as well. Enrique Bradfield's down there. He made
his debut in the Majors. Brock Jones is down there. He's hitting like this. Not amazing, and then
Zach Brixie made our opening day bullpen, but we sent him back down, and he's been doing all right
in triple A since. We may see him come back up before the year's over, especially if there's
some sort of injury in the bullpen. Anthony, I now know his last name is pronounced Sigler.
I didn't know this guy was kind of a big deal. He was a Yankees first round draft pick, and he had
viral videos where he was playing every position. I didn't know this about him. I wasn't quite paying
attention to the draft back then, but yeah, he's 27. I mean, even though he's on my prospect list,
he's basically organizational depth at this point. Oh yeah, and this also includes our new draftees
like Chris Greer, all my draftees signed. So that's your prospect check-in. Let's continue
with the season. August 8th, we're 47-64. Denzel Clark with a one-week injury. We're adding him to
the injured list, and we're still awaiting Joey Ortiz, who has a strain back with an uncertain
return date. Seven days left on his IL time, so he won't be able to come back till at least then.
Gonna do what we did last time this happened and bring up Enrique Bradfield Jr. and arrange like
we did last time. And Enrique Bradfield Jr. has a five-week elbow strain. All right, who wants to
play center field? Is anyone watching this want to play center field for me? I guess I'll take
this opportunity to debut Brock Jones. Welcome to the team, Brock Jones. We'll play him in center
versus right-handed pitching, and we'll bring in Lazzarito versus left-handed pitching in center.
So Freddy Tarnok, who we brought up, has not been good for us in the bullpen. It's only five
and a third innings, but he's allowed 11 runs. He's allowed two home runs. You can see these ratios
and strikeouts and walks. It's not looking good. He is an OG Oakland A, though, so unfortunately
with him being out of options, I can't just go ahead and demote him. So I'm gonna have to
waive and DFA because I would like to get Zach Brixey back in the bullpen here. As of August 15th,
Joey Ortiz is finally ready to play for us. He was one of our big trade deadline acquisitions,
so we can send down Drew Swift. And this is the first time we've had a shortstop who isn't
necessarily a stopgap, so I'd be interested to see how we do this last month and a half.
We feel confident about Joey Ortiz being our shortstop in 2027. It's time for us to find out.
And speaking of trade deadline acquisitions, D.L. Hall with an absolute gem for us in his third
game. One hit and one walk versus the Marlins. No runs allowed in seven innings, 11 strikeouts,
and a 1-0 win. Denzel Clark's ready to come back. That's good. That means Brock Jones goes down.
Only got into four games, but did collect his first couple Major League hits as well as his
first RBI. August 22nd, we are 52-70. Just, you know, we've been really stinky since about June
or July. But yeah, I'm gonna bring Santander back in. He is healthy now, and we will have the
closest thing we've had to a full-strength lineup in a while. All right, we've hit September. It's
kind of the same story as usual with us. We don't score runs, and I know we play in, like, what the
game rates as a serious pitcher's park, but we don't really score runs, and we do our best not
to allow them. We're second in terms of the important defensive stats. That's efficiency
and zone rating, but I'd like to be first, if anything. 56-76, and it's time for roster
expansion. I'm going to bring up Joey Loprefito, who has been up and down, up and down for us all
year. And then for another pitcher, I'll do Ken Waldachuk. September 10th, we're 59-81. We have
clinched that there will not be a winning season yet again in Oakland. Braxton Ashcraft with a
moderate injury day-to-day. No need to risk it. He'd been hot lately. He'd actually had some
really good starts for us, you can see right here, for a stretch. But no need to risk it. No need to
risk a minor injury turning into a major one. We're going to put him on the IL and probably put
Gibson Long back in the rotation and grab another bullpen piece. September 22nd, 63-87. We've been
officially eliminated from any sort of playoff contention, and Shea Langeleers has a fractured
finger. That'll end his season, but he had a great season yet again. This is another really
good season for Shea Langeleers, and I'm glad I've kept him around so far. Unfortunately for Anthony
Sigler, he has an injury of his own, so we're going to use this as an excuse to just bring up
Silas Ardoin. He's someone who's kind of lost his interesting prospect status with us, but
it's good to get someone we've traded for in the big leagues again, you know? And it's an easy
platoon because Reese McGuire, our backup catcher, bats left-handed, so he will face right-handed
pitching, and Ardoin will face left-handed pitching, although certainly not batting cleanup.
We're going to move him down for sure. And while we've had the injuries stack up, they're mostly
minor injuries, but we do have Matt Chapman injured with diagnosis pending. Often we find
those can be longer-term injuries, so we're right here at the end of the season. Let's hope it's not
too bad. Okay, Intercostal, three weeks. I mean, that ends his season, but we can put Gelof back
in as third base for now, so that's an easy fix for us. Here are Gelof's stats for the year. He's
been kind of a part-time player for us, and he's ended up right around replacement level. He's been
most notably our DH versus left-handed pitching. As we wind down here at September 30th, you're
probably most curious about the playoff picture. So in the east, it's been decided the Orioles and
the Rays will both advance, although it's not quite clear who the champ will be yet, although
the Orioles probably have it. Guardians have clenched the central. They're the only playoff
team from there. And the west, the Mariners have clenched. They kind of ran away with it this year.
Here's what the AL wildcard picture looks like. Braves and Mets are still in a dogfight for the
east, similar to last year. Cubs and Reds and Cardinals still in it in the central. Not a great
division, and Diamondbacks have clenched the playoff spot, although they have not yet clenched the
division, and the Giants and Dodgers are right there, you know, with wildcard spots. So a couple
games left. The Orioles have clenched the east. The Rays will grab a wildcard spot as consolation.
Rangers have clenched a wildcard spot as well. It's gonna be Angels and Yankees for that third
spot, with the Yankees holding the two-game advantage right now. In the central, the Cubs
have a two-game lead, though not clenched yet. Still a fight here in the east, and the Dodgers
and Giants have clenched wildcard spots because the Diamondbacks have clenched the division.
We do get a win versus Houston, which gives us 67 on the year. That's one more than we won last
year. And finally, we win at Houston again. Our season ends with a 68-94 record, and in the
standings, the Cubs do advance. They clench the central, and that sets up for what should be a
pretty interesting playoffs. But first, for a quick season in review, when you've only got two bats
that are around 750 OPS, you know your offense is gonna struggle, but Ryan Noda was one of those.
This was probably the best season he's had for us yet in a save. And Joshua Mears, he showed us a
little something in the second half. Really funny, 251 strikeouts on the year in 598 played appearances.
That is pretty unbelievable to think about. But also, you know, 32 home runs. He was a one-more
player. He was a 102 OPS-plus guy. Like, it could have been worse, you know. Gelof was there for us.
Denzel Clark continues to be one of the better players in this save, although honestly, that's
not saying much. Alonzo struggled quite a bit, which was a disappointment. He's been kind of a
disappointment throughout this save, to be honest. Matt Chapman ended the season on the injured list
for us, but he, you know, was a three-war player, 105 OPS-plus. He was basically insanely hot in
April, and then not so good after April. Shea Langeleers, similar stats to Chapman. Also a
pretty solid year, all things considered. Pitching-wise, JP Sears held down the rotation,
another good year from him. His second half was not as good as his first half, though,
and he had the lowest BABIP in the league, you know, which could be a result of some of our
defense, which is good. Brady Basso had probably his worst year. In an Oakland A's uniform, he led
the league with 16 losses, but still not terrible. Braxton Ashcraft continues to just munch on
innings. 176 innings pitched, 192 last year. Hunter Brown was a nice surprise for us. I think he
probably opens next year in the rotation as well. And D.L. Hall, who we acquired at the deadline,
had a 5 ERA down the stretch, but it was more of a, you know, a long-term thing for us anyways.
Bullpen was all right this year. I think Ronan Cock was definitely the highlight.
You know, we've used a variety of stoppers, so nobody collects all the saves, but I imagine he
will be akin to a closer for us going into next season. Mason Miller's been kind of a disappointment,
like his ERA was about 5 this year. I think a lot of people probably use him as a starter in their
saves, but with his injury proneness is fragile and 35 stamina, I just don't really think it's
feasible. I think I would basically just break him. And yeah, and you know, Joe Boyle finished as a
middle reliever for us. He's another OG Oakland A who has been around for us for quite some time.
But now it is indeed time for the playoffs, and we can begin with these wildcard series, which
are a best of three. Dodgers and Cubs taking—oh, Dodgers and Cubs, we got all sweeps here except
for the Orioles took three games to knock off the Yankees, but that sets up our division series,
which will be a best of five. Early lead here for Cleveland. Cleveland are the defending World
Series champs, they sweep. Mariners advance, Cubs advance, and Hula advance between the Dimebacks
and Dodgers. Division rivals, it goes to a game five, and Dodgers advance. So that sets up our
final four. Let's meet our final four. The Mariners won 99 games in our division. They have Harry Ford
up, who has been, you know, turning into a monster player for them. They have Julio, of course, who,
you know, will be in contention for yet another MVP award. He won that last year. And of course,
the rotation. They have Kirby having a huge year. They have Castillo having a good year. 226
strikeouts leads the American League. Bryce Miller's there. And they also have Cade Cavalli
of Washington Nationals fame. Looks like they traded for him early 2025. And Munoz in the
saves. That's the Mariners. They will face a Jose Ramirez and Steven Kwan-less Cleveland
Guardians. Nonetheless, they are defending World Series champions. So we're seeing some new names
for them here. We didn't see Mike Brasso out there for them last year. We didn't see Luke Raley out
there for them last year. We certainly didn't see Sandy Alcantara. I would have noticed that,
but Sandy Alcantara was traded to the Cleveland Guardians, and he has absolutely crushed it there.
And he will definitely be key for them. Daniel Espino, though, and this guy is known for his
stuff and his fragility, you know, has not pitched much at all. I mean, he's pitched eight
innings for them in the regular season this year, but he will be in the rotation as well. So that's
kind of an interesting wrinkle. Here are the Dodgers, who did not win the division this year.
They have Ha-Sung Kim leading off. That's kind of gross. They also have Kyle Isbell,
who we traded to them. Although honestly, he hasn't crushed it. He hasn't crushed it,
so I don't feel too bad about that. They will not have Juan Soto. He is eligible to return
after the League Championship Series. So if they advance to the World Series, he will be there.
And then they have a very Japanese starting rotation with Yamamoto, the fictional Sakamoto,
and of course, Shohei Otani. Here's Shohei Otani's stats from this year. Not a great
pitching season for him necessarily, although the ratio is probably better than the ERA implies.
Hitting-wise, 41 home runs, 12 stolen bases. And then finally, it's the Cubs, and the Cubs
have come along because they're powered by some of their recent draftees in real life.
That includes Matt Shaw. Matt Shaw is up here, although honestly, not that great numbers.
Pete Crow Armstrong absolutely crushed it for them this year. Wow, a .307 average. I mean,
if Pete Crow Armstrong were to hit like this in real life, it'd be unbelievable. Like,
what a great player that would be. They also have, I saw, Kate Horton, another big-time
prospect for them in real life. 198 innings pitched for them, 177 strikeouts. That's a
pretty good season. And of course, they have Brandon Woodruff, who we noted that they traded
for the previous offseason. Or no, they signed him. Signed him, right? Yeah, they signed him.
All right, well, let's see how these League Championship Series go. I'm curious about
Los Angeles in particular, because they would get Soto back, were they to advance to the World
Series. And they do have a 3-0 lead. Cleveland has a 3-1 lead on Seattle. And that's how it's
going to set up. It's going to be Cleveland versus the Los Angeles Dodgers. Let's begin.
Now, where's our game? Cleveland's going to take Game 1. Dodgers respond by taking Game 2.
Dodgers take Game 3 versus the Guardians. Guardians tied up, though, 2-2. 3-2 for the
Dodgers. Ooh, and it's going to go to a Game 7. This is for all the Marbles. Cleveland win.
Cleveland go back-to-back in this series. Wow, unbelievable. Good for them. Here's your box
score for Game 7. Wow, the Dodgers tied it up in the top of the ninth, only for Cleveland to
walk it off in the bottom of the ninth in Game 7. Gabriel Arias was named World Series MVP.
Congratulations again to the Cleveland Guardians. Let's move on with the offseason coming up next.
