The Geeky Difference That Can Transform Your Tea: High vs. Low Pouring | Don Mei

TEA & Brewing
11 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 24, 2024
We conclude our series on pouring water over tea with this final video. It may seem geeky, but the way you pour—high or low—can truly change the flavor and character of your brew. Discover how this small detail makes a big difference in your tea experience!
Hey teaheirs, this is Don from Mei Leaf. Today I'm going to be teaching you how to pour water.
I know, tea geekery knows no bounds, but it makes such a big difference how you pour your
water over your leaves in order to change the expression in your brew. Now, I've done
videos before about direct brewing versus indirect brewing, aka, rim brewing, the difference
between those being the water being poured directly on the leaf versus on the rim of
your pot, or Gai Wan, or on the edge of your pot, etc., so that it doesn't actually hit
the leaves directly. I've also done a video about rim brewing comparing fixed rim brewing,
where you're pouring always on the same place on the rim, versus clock brewing, where you're
pouring in different places for each infusion, versus continuous rim pouring, where for every
infusion you're pouring around the entirety of the rim. You can go check out those videos,
but I'll give you the quick catch-up. Okay, so the quick catch-up is direct versus indirect.
If you brew directly on the leaf you're going to extract much quicker, much stronger. It
also means that you're going to be pulling out more of the inner leaf material much quicker,
which means you're getting more of the texture of the tea, you're getting more of the astringency
of the tea, you're getting more of the low to mid notes of the tea, and you are going
to be getting a very rich tea very quickly, versus rim brewing, where you're going to
preserve more of those transient, high, light, bright aromatics of the tea. You're getting
more of the aromas which come from the aromas that are on the outside of the leaf, that
tend to be more those sort of fruity, floral, transient. When I say transient it means it
dissipates quite quickly high, bright aromatics. You're also more likely to get a softer tea,
because you're not pulling out so much of the astringent notes in the inner leaf material.
So therefore, direct brewing is very different from rim brewing. With the second video that
I did, fixed versus clock, versus continuous rim brewing, the takeaways to that is don't
bother with fixed, because it just creates a one-dimensional tea quite quickly, so I
don't like that method. Clock brewing, where you're brewing and you're hitting different
parts of the Gai Wan for each separate infusion. So infusion one would be here, infusion two
would be here, etc., etc., and you make it like a clock around the Gai Wan, or pot. That's
really good for preserving the longevity of your session, because you're going to be
brewing different areas of the Gai Wan. I know it sounds crazy, but honestly, it makes
a difference, the way that the water pours on the Gai Wan into the leaves. You're going
to be brewing them sort of in bits, in parts, and therefore you tend to get a longer session
less dramatic changes between infusions. You get preservation of sort of the initial phases
of a tea for longer. When you're doing continuous brewing you're getting much more of a rich
brew from the beginning, and that brew is going to change. The character of that brew
is going to change through infusions in a more dramatic arc, and that is a good thing
or a bad thing. It's neither. It depends on what you're looking for. If you're looking
for maybe you've got less time, and you want to really sort of experience of tea with less
infusions, then you might want to do continuous. Also, if you want to have more of a richer
experience, and for you to really experience the difference that the infusions make as
the leaf gives up its flavor through infusions, then again, continuous might be better. If
you're looking for a more long session with more infusions, and a more consistency in
terms of flavor, so a more sort of slow arc between infusions, then you may want to choose
clock brewing. So those are the takeaways. Today I want to sort of wrap it all up, bring
it all together, with the final parameter that I haven't really talked about, which
is high-pouring versus low-pouring. Now I'm going to be talking about direct brewing,
so pouring directly on the leaf, because if I'm pouring high and I'm trying to hit the
rim it's just going to go everywhere, right? I'm talking about direct brewing. So for the
times that you want direct brewing, what's the difference between high-pouring and low-pouring?
You will maybe have heard of the expression,
high water, low tea, which basically means that the expression is basically suggesting that you
pour your water from a height over the leaves, and then when you're pouring the tea out from
the Gai Wan you're pouring it very low to the Gong Dao Bei, so that you're not like adding too
much oxygen once the tea is brewed. But is that true? Does it make a difference? Let's find out.
I have here some sweet-spiced JJM, gorgeous Jin Jun Mei. I've picked a Jin Jun Mei because
it's a young, delicate leaf, buds, and therefore it's going to be very reactive to this potential
difference. So what I'm going to do is I'm going to brew them both identically,
both 5 grams in these Gai Wans. I'm going to brew them exactly the same time,
there or thereabouts. Hopefully, I will try to be accurate in this one. Let me see. How do I
get that clock going here? Just double-check. Yeah. I'm going to put a stopwatch up on this,
because I have a feeling that this kettle is going to let me down again. So I'm going to
get a stopwatch going here. Right. So I'm going to be pouring this one high and this one low. Yes.
And I'll do them 10 seconds apart. So I'm going to start the stopwatch now so I can see what I'm
doing, and at 10 seconds here I'm going to pour high. I'm going to try and pour as high as I can,
just to sort of really exaggerate the effects here. I'm not going to do a rinse, so high pour.
There we go. Then we wait 10 seconds, and then low pour. But again, directly on the leaves,
and we shall see the difference that it makes.
For all of those who are watching that are like, sort of, relatively new to Gong Fu tea,
this might seem like craziness, but these small changes, incremental changes, to amount of leaf,
amount of the temperature of the water, all of these changes, all the way to how you pour,
makes a major difference. All right. So I'm going to be pouring this out now.
So this has been a nice 40 second brew, and we pour this one out. Now let's see
if we can see a difference in the liquor before we taste it. Put these to the side.
Right. Let me see. Now, I can see a difference. I don't know if you can. You might struggle,
but... Come on, focus... Apart from the fact that this one somehow has more liquor,
which is a bit odd. I'm not quite sure how that happened, because I seem to be pouring the same
amount in. This one definitely has a cloudier look to it. It's definitely stripped off more of the
hairs on the tea, the trichomes on the tea, but also it has just got a cloudier look in general.
This looks very clear compared to the high pour, which is as to be expected. You're pouring from
a height, you're getting a lot of agitation, you're stripping off a lot of the hairs on the
leaf, but also you're extracting, potentially, much harder, so you're going to get, potentially,
a little bit more cloudiness. Let's see if we can pick that up in the cup. Maybe, maybe not.
I don't know. Definitely, to my eye, this one is cloudier. So from an aesthetic point of view,
you may prefer, and this will vary in terms of the intensity of the difference of this cloudiness
versus clarity, depending on the tea. If I picked a tea which was very, very furry, and very,
very small leaf, then you'd see it in an even more extreme way. The reason why I picked this
slightly larger Jin Jin Mei is because I wanted to sort of bridge the gap between... Because we're
going to be talking about Oolongs, and we're going to be talking about green teas. I didn't want to
go too far so that it wasn't applicable to other tea types, if you know what I mean. Okay, so let's
give this a taste. So high pour. Gorgeous tea. Loads of cinnamon notes coming out. Good physicality.
Nice thickness in the mouth. Mineral stoniness coming through.
Some rose, but then yeah, this slate quality to it. Oh, so sweet in the aftertaste. Okay,
let's compare that to the low pour. Very different. Same amount of thickness,
which is surprising, because I would have thought with the trichome release there would be
more thickness. But softer. Noticeably softer in terms of its texture.
A much softer mouthfeel. Much less astringency.
Flavor-wise, less strong. Volume has been attenuated. Obviously, this is a stronger
extraction compared with the low pour. So it's slightly less rich, but obviously there's more
for this tea to give. So it'll probably extend the length of the number of infusions that you're
going to get if you do low pour. But definitely softer. In terms of taste, apart from the fact
that this is stronger, there is a difference in the balance of flavors. This is much more
mineral heavy. I'm getting more of the rocks and the stone in this tea. This one here preserves
more of those top notes. Mmm. More of the slightly syrupy rose quality to it. The cinnamon notes
are there too, but they are just generally lighter and brighter. It has a little bit more of a sweet
caramel note to it. More spice. More energy. More buzz and fizz on my tongue.
Much more physical. We're going to brew this one more time, and I'm going to do the same thing,
obviously, high pour, low pour, and we'll see how that expresses itself in the second infusions.
But as you can see, there's nothing hugely shocking here, but it's something that I think
is another aspect that you should consider when you are brewing your tea. Certainly, this idea
of high water, low tea is not a universal, as is almost... As with everything in tea,
there are no universals. So the idea that you should always pour high with tea, which is what
that expression suggests, is certainly not the case. It all depends upon what you are trying
to get out of your expression of your brew. Very, very different. Very different. Soft,
more delicate, more high aromatics, richer, more physical, and more of the sort of mineral and
mid-tone aromatics. I'm going to reset this, and we're going to do this again, one more time here.
So we're going to do high pour. I'm going to get that ball of leaves ready. Here we go.
Then, obviously, I am doing it in a little bit more of an extreme way than you probably would.
So there's a theme that develops across these now three videos, and it's been a while since...
Oh! This is slightly bigger, this Gong Dao Bei. Maybe that's why it looked like there was a
difference in water. Yet, you know, wrapping all of these pouring water videos together,
there's definitely a theme that develops. I think that it's good for us to just bring it all together
so that you can get the conclusion. See, this is the thing. I have all these videos in my head
of what I want to do, and it's always like,
Oh! I want this to be a series. Then I get distracted by other things that I need to be
doing, and so I'm finally circling back around and completing this series. I think there's a
few different series out there which need completing. Right. Let's see if there's a
color difference here. This is still cloudier, but less so. The difference is less extreme,
but it still is cloudier than this one, if you can possibly see it. Maybe it's better if I leave
it there. I don't know. All right. I'm going to pour these away. We're going to do this taste
again, straight in with that really, really woodsy cinnamon note. Sweet and woodsy.
Just very rich. A great rendition of this tea.
If you are into the physicality then this is going to be a delight for you.
Yeah. Everything the same. Slightly more delicate, definitely a lot softer in terms
of physicality, and the aromatics are more in the sort of bright, high aromatics.
So let's try to piece this all together. Okay. How do we do this? Let's just talk about broad
expressions of a tea. Okay. Let's talk about aromatics, and you hear me talk a lot about
the outer-leaf material versus the inner-leaf material, the high, bright aromatics versus the
mids and low, base and the mineral aromatics, and they all sort of come together as one thing.
There are chemical compounds in tea which are brighter, higher, more transient aromas. They
tend to live on the outside of the leaf more, and come from the juices that have been exposed
in the rolling process. Then there is the inner-leaf material, which contributes more to
texture, in terms of finish, and pull, and astringency, and tends to be also a little bit
more in the mid notes. Mid, like woodier notes, more stony notes, maybe stone fruit notes of a
tea. So if you are looking at the three different parameters that we're talking about, high water
versus low water, continuous versus clock brewing, and the rim versus direct, they're all
pretty much going to be of the same ilk. If you want to preserve the aromatics then you're going
to go for rim brewing, and you're going to go for clock style. So you're doing it slowly over time,
so around. So clock rim brewing is the most gentle. The next step up from that is continuous
rim brewing, where you're brewing everything in one go, right? You're getting a richer tea,
but you're still not hitting it directly. The next strength up is low direct. So you're doing
this one here. You're pouring the water directly over the leaves, but at a low height. Then the
most extreme is high direct. So you've basically got sort of four versions of pouring, from high
direct, low direct, continuous rim, clock rim, right? So if you just imagine those across your
spectrum of choice, if you want to preserve the high aromatics and have a more long, extended
session with softer, more gentle brews, then you're going to be brewing on this end of the
spectrum. So you're going to be brewing the clock rim or continuous rim, and you wouldn't be going
so much towards the direct. If, however, you want the opposite. If you want something that's rich,
you want something that is very textural, you want something that is very physical,
you want to accentuate more of those mid-notes, more of those stonier notes,
more of those mineral notes, you want to extract stronger, you want to get that balance,
then you're going to be thinking more in terms of direct brewing, and rim brewing would be less
what you're after. So that's a very clear way of looking at it, I hope. The other thing to note
is you can change the way that you are pouring the water throughout the session, and I suggest
that you do. So as you've brewed into a leaf, and it's extracted more of those softer notes,
those higher, bright aromatics, you may then start to feel like you need to push the leaf a bit more.
So you're going to be moving up into those direct brewing methods. So oftentimes I'll have
like a Dan Cong tea, or an Oolong tea, which is very aromatic, that I'm treating a little bit
more gently. I'm going to do continuous rim, or I'm going to do clock rim on it at the beginning,
but as it's hit its third, fourth, fifth infusion, and I feel like now I want to really pull out
those inner leaf material a little bit more, I might start hitting it with direct brews,
and I might start hitting it harder and higher. So you've got an intensity of brew that you can
control through the height and the style of pouring water. Right. Let me just sip this again.
It's a certain difference. Really, really clear difference. So if you imagine this spectrum from
the more aggressive, high direct, all the way to the least aggressive, low clock rim brewing,
you can also then apply this to how much time you've got. Right. Let's say you don't have time
for a long session. You've only got time for like five, six infusions, and you need to be on your
way. Then you might be thinking about brewing richer tea earlier, with less of an expression
that is subtle through the expression of change, which is subtle through the infusions, and you
want more of a direct experience, a quicker arc between the differences between the infusions.
Then you might be moving into the more aggressive, let's say, forms of pouring water.
How does this apply to tea types? Obviously, like I said, there are no universals.
Every tea that you brew should be considered separately and differently, depending upon
your mood, how much time you've got, what you're looking for to get out of the tea, and the tea
itself. However, I think you can make some broad generalizations. Teas which respond,
I think, better to, let's say, the more gentler brewing styles of rim brewing, be it clock or
continuous, I would say are ones that are very aromatic. I would also be looking at how easily
a tea would get astringent. So teas that are very delicate leaf, small leaf, and high in
catechins. So we're talking green teas, we're talking about small leaf black teas, we're
talking about green Oolongs that you want to preserve those aromatics, and you want to preserve
the softness, and can tend towards being more astringent. Now, obviously, you're going to
control astringency with temperature and other ways, but this is just another tool that you can
use. So, small leaf black teas, green teas, especially delicate green teas, more delicate
and light and green Oolong teas. I would say I would generally start brewing those teas a little
bit more in a gentler way. I would also include Hei Cha in this. Hei Cha being ripe Puerh teas,
or other dark teas. Even though we tend to advise to brew at hot temperatures,
boiling point water, I do think that given their small size you want more of a clarity in terms
of the liquor. You want more of a softer brew, because if you hit it hard it can become a bit
too... it can pull out too much, because they can get very strong, but also it can be a bit too
cloudy, the infusion. Not just in terms of look, but the taste becomes a bit too mineral,
and a bit too stony. So I would say small leaf Hei Cha, small leaf black teas, green teas,
lighter Oolongs, and more of those aromatics like Dan Cong Oolong teas, which are prized for those
aromatics, and can get astringent quite quickly. Focus more on the gentler side of clock,
and continuous rim-brewing. Larger leaf material, Yan Cha, rock Oolongs, that really so much of
their character is about that rockiness, right? Pulling out the rock, that mineral quality.
Large leaf black teas, large leaf Puerh teas, so raw Puerh, Sheng Puerh. I would suggest,
and some people like to brew gently with their Sheng Puerh, but I would suggest that you
are a little bit more bold with those teas. You want to pull out those inner leaf material a
little bit quicker, for me. Also, bear in mind there's a difference between cake-pressed Puerh
tea and loose. For loose Puerh tea, raw Puerh tea, large leaf Puerh tea, and large leaf black tea,
you know, even if you fill up a Gai Wan with those leaves there's so much air in between
those leaves, because it's all sort of straggly leaves, that if you pour direct
you're not actually really hitting a lot of the leaf. A lot of it is hitting air. So therefore,
I think you can afford to be a bit more aggressive in terms of the way that you're
pouring the tea. If, however, it's like a very tightly compressed cake then you might want to
be a little bit more careful about it. Obviously, ball-rolled Oolongs, the first infusion, you might
want to get the water hitting those leaves to try to open them up a bit more. So the shape of the
leaf also makes a difference. But I hope that this concluding video, in how to pour water,
helps you to understand the broad differences that the pouring makes, the broad different styles,
from rim brewing, low-clock, low-continuous, to direct brewing, low, and high. It gives you
at least sort of a nice spectrum for you to sort of consider when you are considering how to pour
your tea, pour your water, and of course, as I said, it will change for every tea and throughout
this session. So as you have brewed into your leaf you might want to get more aggressive as you see
fit. Let me know your thoughts. Is there anything that I've missed here? Let me know in the comments.
But I think that that concludes our series about how to pour your water, and go experiment,
and find your own styles as you get to know each individual tea that you brew. That's it teaheads.
Check out our other videos, taste our teas wherever you are in the world by browsing
Mei Leaf dot com, and come visit us if you're ever in London. On that, I'm Don from Mei Leaf.
Thank you for being part of the revelation of true tea. Stay away from those teabags,
keep drinking the good stuff, and spread the word, because nobody deserves bad tea. Bye.
