What Do We Want Research to Answer

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Dec 22, 2024
education, english skill, learning english, intellectual skill
Hi, I'm Craig and I'm the co-host of the MQ Open Mind podcast.
On behalf of my co-host Professor Rory O'Connor and myself,
thank you so much for watching the first half of season two.
We hope you were able to gain a further insight into the world of mental health research
whilst understanding a little bit more about yourself and those around you.
For this special episode of Open Mind and in honour of Research Appreciation Day,
here are the questions that our guests would love to be answered by mental health research.
Open Mind will return in the autumn and we hope to see you again for more lived
experience stories and more mental health research.
Season two began with Dr Anne Duffy, Professor of Psychiatry at Queen's University, Kingston,
where we discussed understanding bipolar disorder,
supporting students' mental health and whether mental illnesses can be genetic.
If you had 10 million pounds, more than your 10 million Canadian dollars,
what would you want to prioritise in terms of mental health research?
Well, I guess in terms of mental health research is really big.
So, I guess in terms of the high-risk study, I think what's really key for psychiatry is
we really have a stumbling block with these very broad diagnostic categories.
It's really hard to figure out what the mechanisms are, what the pathophysiology is of cancer.
You know, you have to drill down into specific subtypes and we really need to start really
researching very narrowly defined phenotypes of illnesses and really understand what the
genetic underpinnings of those illnesses are so that we can actually then understand what's
happening and, you know, develop tests for do you have bipolar disorder and also develop
specific treatment.
So, I think psychiatry is really stuck because we haven't moved along in our diagnostic
construct and that's really been hampering us.
In terms of student mental health research, I think we're on the right track.
You know, I think we need to understand from the students who are increasingly looking
more like the general population of young people, what's going on?
How come anxiety and depressive symptoms are increasing both in university students and
in the general population of young people?
What's contributing to that using rigorous research methods and theoretical models?
And then developing, you know, student-tailored interventions, but we need partners at the
table.
And, you know, as I say, you know, different universities differ on this.
All universities agree that this is a priority, but how to go about it?
It's interesting because I'm doing a paper with a historian from Swansea and Sarah Crooks
and we're becoming increasingly aware that the same arguments and the same conversations
happened in 1960 as are happening now.
And so, why can't we get past that?
So, looking at translating, we can develop findings, then how do we translate that in
an efficient, effective way?
And we need student advocacy for this too.
So, we're continuing to partner with students.
You know, not for us, without us kind of thing.
Absolutely.
Two brilliant answers as well.
In March, we spoke to Associate Professor in Psychology at Durham University, Dr. Ben
Alderson Day, where he explained the idea of presence, the research behind hallucinations
and the fourth man phenomenon.
But if somebody said to you, what was the key priority we should be focusing on in terms
of mental health research, what would you suggest?
What would you like to see us focusing on as a community?
As a community?
Gosh, well, that is a real million dollar question, isn't it?
I think from a basic science perspective, there's still fundamentally this question,
you know, what is psychosis?
Not from a definitional level, but, you know, why would our minds have this sort of response
or reaction in the direction of the senses or our beliefs that would lead to these extreme
states?
Because psychosis is something that happens all around us, you know, through many, many
different conditions as well can lead to those states of like losing grip of reality.
But I think in terms of, to step away from the basic science, really the kind of the
focus for research also needs to be on how can we take into account a plurality of ideas
and interpretations about these experiences?
How can we draw upon the power of lived experience in an equitable way to really enhance our
understanding of that phenomenon?
And I think we still have, in large part, a system of research and of commissioning and
of treatment development, which is still fairly top down and isn't great at harnessing that
kind of wisdom and that power.
So I think that's the big challenge.
So I'm aware that I've given you two answers there, basic science and more of a really
a policy answer.
But I think, you know, I think that's where the field is going to need to go, really.
And there are some steps towards it, but it's hard to do.
So, yeah.
No, great, great.
In the spirit of mental resilience, we spoke to endurance athlete and motivational speaker
James Gwinnett to discuss recovering from addiction and using sport to improve your
mental health.
If you had all the money in the world or somebody said, here's a big problem to fix and we'll
give you whatever money is required, what would you what would you think is number one
or what would you like us to address as a mental health research community?
I would like to know why the mind is so negative.
And I say that from the point of view of doing endurance challenges.
But it could be it could be anything from meeting a deadline to learning to drive your
car.
It could be anything.
For some reason, there is there is something in our brains that tells us, no, you can't
do that.
Don't bother.
Go and, you know, suck it off.
Go and have a drink.
Don't worry about that.
We'll come back to it tomorrow.
I need to think about that.
That's a good, interesting question.
I'm trying to think, is the brain by default negative?
Because I would argue that it's well, there's huge individual individual differences.
And if you think about negative affect versus positive affect.
So some of us are more we're habitually more likely to respond if something if a neutral
event happens or some of us are more likely to interpret as negative versus positive.
And then you get this vicious cycle.
So I'll have to think about whether on balance, the evidence is that the brain is negative.
But that's a really interesting question, actually.
So whether or not it's interesting.
Yeah, I mean, it happens every time I go for a run without fail.
And that is not an exaggeration.
I might go for a run.
I'll get two kilometers in and my brain will go, oh, why don't you just, why don't you
just go and head home?
Yeah, the sofa is really comfy.
There's a bottle of water in the fridge.
Just go and rehydrate, go and feel better, go and have a slice of cake.
And then I think, it's ridiculous.
I'm only two kilometers in.
And I have to override that in order to keep pushing through.
And then I mean, that will happen 100 times on an ultramarathon.
What's this going to say?
You're pretty busy.
No, why does my brain do it?
And every time I have to override it.
No, no, I'm going to put one foot in front of the other.
I'm going to keep going.
I'm going to make the next kilometer.
I'm going to get to the next checkpoint.
I'm going to have a energy gel, whatever it is.
That negativity is, I just, I don't know where it comes from.
It's fascinating.
Yeah, well, when I go, I just focus on the next lamppost.
Exactly.
Yeah, it's the next master.
Ultramarathon running is, as is life, is all about mental fitness.
It's all about putting one foot in front of the other.
Whether it's literal or metaphorical,
it comes through a difficult period in your life.
If you can put, just keep going, just keep going, it will come to an end.
Same with the literal running thing.
I think it was Winston Churchill that said,
if you're going through hell, just keep going.
That, you know, it's that kind of mentality that we all need.
And quite why the brain tries to convince us otherwise is,
there you go, there's your research.
That's a good question.
That's a good question indeed.
To discuss young people's mental health,
we spoke to academic psychologist and author Dr. Lucy Fox,
who also explained the importance of finding appropriate treatment for your needs
and her book, What Mental Illness Really Is and What It Isn't.
So we give you a million quid, right?
MQ give you a million quid.
What's the one question you wish you would try to address for that million quid?
So, I mean, there's one thing that I'm doing at the moment,
but I already have funding for this,
is to try and understand whether school mental health interventions cause harm.
So there's this sort of, I'm sure you're aware of it,
but some new studies that have come out
showing that some teenagers are worse off having these,
especially this kind of whole group, you know, universal interventions,
worse off having them than not having them
in terms of it leading to an increase in reports of mental health problems.
So that's one thing that I'm very interested in.
Even if it's for a minority of teenagers,
that can scale up across the country.
So we really need to understand whether teaching teenagers about mental health
actually leads some of them to report or experience more of these problems.
So that's one strand that I'm really interested in and already doing.
But what I would do if I had a million pounds of research money
would be to start trying to experimentally demonstrate
whether the way you talk to people about mental health
can actually affect, you know, in the lab,
how they report and how they experience certain symptoms.
And there's tiny pockets of people trying to do this already
being shown with physical health symptoms.
You know, depending on the information that you give people,
you can experimentally induce more or less reporting of these symptoms.
So I'm very interested in starting a strand of work that tries to look at that.
Because if you can show in a sort of contained lab environment
that the way you talk to people can lead to an increase
in how they report their mental health problems,
then that's a little piece of evidence to say
maybe this is happening on a sort of societal scale.
No, absolutely not. Two classical topics unrelated.
As the theme for this year's Mental Health Awareness Week was anxiety,
we spoke to mental health activist and author Dean Stock
about supporting people with anxiety,
the difference between anxiety and anxiety disorders,
and the benefits of using social media for your mental health.
So one of the things we always ask,
we're always keen to sort of explore in our podcast is
get different people's views on what we should be doing
in terms of research in the field.
And so with your vast experience, perhaps not as a researcher,
but obviously as an educator, communicator, reaching so many people.
And if we were saying, here's a couple of million pounds,
what would you think the research community,
what would you say your priority would be or priorities for research and anxiety?
Just to develop more techniques for people to use,
to develop more strategies, to look into reasons why,
for example, SSRIs work for some people but don't work for others,
to really pour the money into research that's funded by the right people.
So if you're looking at medication,
it's not funded by the pharmaceuticals, for example.
But non-biased research into the best techniques and tools
that we can use to help as many people as possible.
And I'm also a international ambassador for a bullying over in America.
And that's something that's really close to my heart
because psychoeducation, CBT tools, all that can be learned at an early age.
And we're just not doing enough to teach children,
firstly, about anxiety and secondly, how to manage it,
what techniques and tips we can do.
And it's a passion of mine to get that into schools as early as possible.
So, yeah, I would use the research to get it to the kids and get them educated.
I couldn't agree more.
I think, especially no matter what way we look at the evidence,
it's very clear that the mental health of young people has deteriorated
certainly over recent years.
And I think the more we can do earlier, I think you're absolutely right,
is the better.
And I think we are moving in the right direction,
but I think there's still a long way to go.
And especially given we know that depending which statistic you look at,
the majority of mental health problems happens before you're 20,
you're in your early 20s and often obviously in your teens.
So it is really, really important that we can do more there.
In June, we spoke to occupational therapist Jenny O'Connell
to discuss empathy in the criminal justice sector,
understanding neurodiversity and ensuring well-being in the workplace.
So if we were able to give you all the money in the world,
what would be your priorities, do you think?
What sort of research questions do you think we should be addressing?
Perhaps looking at, you know, like I mentioned before, the root causes.
I'm also quite passionate about, you know, going into schools.
I've worked with PRUs, so people referral units as well,
where, you know, challenging behaviour young people tend to go to.
And actually, yeah, getting to the roots of, you know, why certain conditions,
especially even neurodevelopmental conditions as well,
which is also an area that I touched in my talk,
that are often not identified at earlier stages
and perhaps may be misconstrued as challenging behaviours
where actually it could be autistic or have ADHD or something like that.
So that's the main, that's one.
And then also bridging the gap between the services and community,
especially when it comes to accessing people of different cultural backgrounds,
because especially working in prisons, I found,
and again, there are stats to back this up,
where a high proportion of black men tend to be the ones in prisons
and even section under the Mental Health Act as well.
So speaking to families and just people in the community
of various different backgrounds to educate them about mental health,
provide them with the language,
especially when it comes to seeking help as well.
So I think a lot of research,
I would want a lot of research to be had into that.
And also, I think that would definitely support even us as health workers
when we are working with families and individuals
who have a very different understanding of what mental health is
or might not know what mental health is,
to just get them, yeah, get them to have the right language
to be able to access that support.
And then also, like I said, in schools as well,
which is, I think that's where it usually begins in terms of identifying this.
Yeah, no, great suggestions.
I mean, trying to use that basic science
and really inform all aspects of treatment, care,
early intervention and so on.
