Mythology Matters - Australian Aboriginal Myths - Extra Mythology

Mythological Stories
26 followers
Hello everybody and welcome back to Myths Matter with James Portnow.
This week we are going to be talking about our aboriginal myths and specifically we are going
to talk about sources. But don't run screaming because this is actually really interesting,
at least I found it really interesting. When we do extra mythology episodes we always try and use
sources from the culture that the myths come from. And this is especially important with
living cultures, with extant cultures. But there's a difficulty we've run into
multiple times. When you're dealing with a culture that has largely an oral tradition
and the culture is displaced by colonial groups, very often what happens is that a lot of the
stories literally and very tragically die out. The only versions of these stories you can find
are sometimes early colonists or colonial authors writing down these stories. And you always have
to take it with a grain of salt because sometimes and very often you'll have other cultural biases
injected into these stories or you'll have certain goals that the anthropologist writing
these things down will have, such as very often they'll be by Christian missionaries
trying to Christianize the very groups of whose stories are recorded. So when doing the aboriginal
myths I ran into a book that I thought was actually really good. I was like wow this is
really interesting. These feel a little bit more like traditional myths told by some of these
cultures. The book itself was written by a fellow named William Ramsey Smith. And so I looked this
guy up right and I've got to tell you about this fellow because oh boy. So this guy was a doctor,
sorta. He was a doctor and in the 1890s he went to Australia to fill a post as a doctor there.
Within three years something happens and he has a bunch of the staff at the hospital he's at
reporting him to the British Medical Association and he's not only like kicked out, he is banned
for life. But he must have some friends or something like that because he gets basically
a tribunal or something like that to overturn this lifetime ban and he's back practicing medicine.
And soon he's made the coroner and the chief medical officer or whatever you want to call it
of Adelaide, Australia. He serves there during the plague which okay sure but by 1903
there are 18 charges against him as coroner for misuse of corpses. In the investigation of this
it was found that he had repeatedly removed the heads or skeletons of the corpses in his charge
for medical purposes. He was considered indiscreet by the board that investigated it
and he was once again fired. But not long after he was back practicing medicine
and back very literally looting corpses. Not only coroner's corpses but he would go to graveyards
and would steal corpses and not only steal them but also steal them to ship overseas
often to museums that wanted aboriginal specimens. It was pretty bad. Not only that but he was later
found to have desecrated a number of graves and to have practiced his marksmanship on corpses
deposited at the coroner's office. So yeah this was a dude who was busy shooting dead bodies.
Okay right I'm not gonna use this source. It's like oh man I was surprised it was so well written.
So I looked into it a little bit further and you know what came to light within like the last 30
years? All of this entire book like pretty much the entire thing was actually plagiarized by
from a guy named David Unyepon. You probably those of you from Australia probably know this
name and know it better than I do. But this guy was incredible. He was a aboriginal native
member of Australia who had sort of grown up. There was a period where very often aboriginal
children were separated from their families and placed with British Christian families. He grew
up with a Christian family but he grew up in British society and learned English. And not only
learned English but oh my god he invented a ton of stuff. He was he was an inventor who had laid
the groundwork for hundreds of patents. Some of the modern sheep shearing devices are based on
some of his ideas. It's arguable that he came up with the principle for a helicopter off the way
that boomerangs work. And he had all this stuff. He was also very much a proponent of aboriginal
rights and aboriginal self-determination and was very very vocal with the government. He was also
a prolific writer and so he actually wrote down a number of these aboriginal stories. This other
fellow, our corpse shooting colonial doctor, paid a small sum of money for his collection
of stories that he had written down and then published it in England under his own name. So
for a hundred-ish years all these stories were published under the name of Ramsey. But then
recently a number of universities started to investigate this and certain teams found
first that this had incredible similarities to David Unepon's writing style. And then looking
in actually found the historical record of the sale and found certain original documents and
found that more than 95 percent of this was word for word exactly what this aboriginal author had
written. So while this is another horrible case of somebody in a position of power stealing
someone else's work, it turned out to be great for extra mythology because legendary tales of
the Australian aborigines is actually written by an aboriginal author and one who I hope
some of you go look up after this because fascinating fellow, real interesting life
story. For those of you in Australia he's the guy on the back of the $50 bill and it was just
fascinating to me to find this and made me wonder how many other times I've read books by colonial
authors that are not only just transcriptions of native tales but perhaps stolen whole hog like
this. So this was just a fascinating weird quirk to me and I have this great text that I morally
couldn't use because the dude who wrote it was at the very least super creepy and pretty terrible.
And then I found out that no actually in part of his being super creepy and really terrible
he had just stolen it from native authors. So yeah so that's our tale and that's the story
of how some of this got made and hopefully some of you will look up David Nippon and hopefully
you'll join us for Aztec mythology after this which is gonna be great. Might need some warnings
at the beginning because some of it's a little gruesome but it's fantastic stuff so hopefully
I will see you all there. Take care everybody!
