Secrets from the Archive: E1 - The Mystery Cat of Connecticut

Hidden Ocean Files. 🌊
2 followers
28 Video Views·Dec 21, 2024
For thousands of years, people have told stories about strange experiences that we cannot explain.
Stories that conflict with our understanding of reality. Some of those stories found their way
into print, to be read by hundreds, thousands, or even millions of readers before being consigned
to the oblivion of the archives. In this series, we dust off forgotten newspaper clippings,
magazine articles, and letters from the library of the late Gary Mangiacopra, one of the most
prolific collectors of strange stories in the world. Join us as we uncover the forgotten secrets
of the archive. Exhibit one is an item from box one, folder 33, of the Gary Mangiacopra archive.
This folder contains stories written by Gary Mangiacopra himself, along with co-author Dwight G.
Smith, for the magazine The Anomalist, edited and published by Patrick Wieg and Dennis Stacey.
This particular article was published in the winter 1995-1996 issue, or volume three,
of that publication. This story is perhaps the most comprehensive dissertation on the Glowacus,
a mysterious predator said to haunt the forests of New England. The following is a slightly
condensed summary of Gary Mangiacopra and Dwight Smith's intriguing article on this elusive,
cryptid, or hidden animal. Enjoy. The New England puma, also known as the New England mountain lion,
cougar, panther, or catamount, was believed to have been wiped out in the 19th century.
However, there have been sporadic sightings in recent years, including reports of mysterious
black panthers. These sightings raise questions about the true identity of these enigmatic
felines. Eyewitnesses from all over the United States, including Connecticut,
claim to have encountered these black panther-like creatures. Historical records from the Hartford
Current and the New York Times reveal a history of puma and black panther sightings in Connecticut
spanning three decades. Known as the Glastonbury Glowacus, this cryptozoological phenomenon
captivated the public, the various sightings being connected by a thread of uncanny similarity.
The story begins in Glastonbury, a town in Hartford County, Connecticut. In the weeks
leading up to January 15, 1939, locals were plagued by spine-chilling cries from a mysterious
creature that seemed to possess the traits of both a dog and a feline. Witness accounts
led to speculations that the mysterious creature could be a mountain lion. A hunting party led by
Charles Alshouse, the game warden of Hartford County, was organized for the purpose of
investigating these encounters. The party included a trained cat hound from the Ozarks.
Despite the hound picking up the trail and tracks of a feline, the pursuit was hindered by the
tracks of two local hounds. After an eight-mile trek, the hunters returned empty-handed,
except for a fox they shot along the way. The identity of the creature became a matter of
speculation and debate in Glastonbury. Most believed it to be a mountain lion, although
the official records stated that pumas were no longer present in Connecticut. Some suggested it
could be a rare Canada lynx or a more common bobcat, but the local residents, who were familiar
with the wildlife, disagreed. Rumors spread throughout Glastonbury, some suggesting the
creature was a carnivorous monster that had escaped from a menagerie. Others speculated
that it was a mountain lion that had been freed from a Vermont zoo during a recent storm.
The possibility that the creature had found a food source in the local rabbit population
gave credence to the mystery. In an attempt to find answers,
Warden Alshouse organized another hunt in the snowy hills of Glastonbury. Despite their efforts,
the hunters were unable to find any trace of the elusive creature. Disheartened, they named it the
Glastonbury Glowackis, on account of its habitat and elusive nature. The aftermath of the hunt sent
a wave of unease through the town of Glastonbury. One night, a resident's hound returned home in a
pitiful state, covered in injuries that proved fatal. Farmers later discovered a scene of struggle
in the woods, marked by red-stained snow. More sightings followed. A citizen came across the
mysterious creature in a woodland clearing, describing it as feline-like with a long, furry
tail. The wildcat observed the witness before disappearing soundlessly into the forest.
The creature didn't limit its haunts to the woods, but also startled people on highways,
as reported by the chief of police. The sightings were so numerous that patrol cars were sent to
pursue the apparition. A third hunt was organized, the participants being armed with rifles and
shotguns. Just before the hunt, a goat disappeared, another suspected victim of the Glowackis.
Deacon Wells Strickland of the Buckingham Congregational Church provided a detailed
description of the creature, which he claimed had a feline face and a long tail.
Eyewitness accounts influenced John P. Benson's somewhat inscrutable opinion that the Glowackis
resembled a large wildcat rather than a mountain lion. Similar sightings were reported in Nebraska.
The news attracted attention from journalists, who sought updates from the police chief.
Sightings continued in Glastonbury. Mrs. Charles Bell reported her greyhound's injuries from a
run-in with the creature. A woodsman encountered a colossal creature while setting a snare.
The wildcat quickly vanished into the wilderness after being seen.
Rhododee Herrick spotted a sinuous figure on the New London Turnpike,
its tawny figure melting into the surrounding bush. The start of a monumental fourth expedition
marked a significant turning point in this mysterious saga. A hunter named A. Joseph
Bonvouloir, accompanied by the brave Bogey Brothers and their loyal coon hounds stumbled
upon a puzzling creature in the woods. Determined to track down the elusive animal, they gave chase
with one of their dogs. However, when Bonvouloir fired his gun, the creature vanished into the
covering remarkable distances with each stride. Bonvouloir was left bewildered,
recounting his encounter with a powerful black creature that strongly resembled a panther.
The strangeness of his account was further compounded by the fact that other witnesses
had described the creature as having a tawny hue, similar to a mountain lion.
As time went on, more reports emerged supporting Bonvouloir's claim,
including one account stretching back into the mists of history.
In the remarkable occurrences for January 1685 written by the respected Puritan clergyman
Cotton Mather, a thrilling tale unfolded. Shuba L. Smith, a servant of the esteemed Mr. John
Hollister and a renowned builder of stone forts, witnessed a monstrous creature by the riverside.
This towering tiger stood seven feet tall, with a single horn on its forehead reminiscent of a
unicorn, talons like those of a harpy, and an unusually long tail with a bluish-gray tint.
This creature, named Monstrum infandum gallinobacchus, or a strange monster gallinobacchus,
by the wise pastor of Wethersfield, served as a testament to the enduring mystery that
has captivated the imaginations of New Englanders. In a more recent confirmation of Bonvouloir's
sighting of a black panther, a local resident shared his own encounter with a Hartford newspaper.
During a hunt in the Buckingham district of Glastonbury, he and his two brothers were
startled by a glossy black creature emerging from the thickets. The creature was about three feet
long, with a sinuous two-foot-long tail. The beast stood just a few steps away from them,
prompting one of the men to take aim. Unfortunately, his gun misfired and the
creature bounded away. The game warden, Allshouse, obtained a canine named Leed,
a mix of Irish setter Airedale and Ozark coondog, to track down the elusive gloackus. However,
Leed's reaction upon catching the scent of the quarry revealed great unease as he barked and ran
across the uneven terrain. The hunting party eventually found Leed whimpering in front of a
stone wall. Such behavior was highly unusual, especially coming from a hound trained to pursue
wildcats, suggesting that the creature Leed encountered was unlike any prey he had encountered
before. There is no doubt that Glastonbury was witness to a series of strange sightings and
sounds related to large felines over a period of five to six weeks. However, starting on Sunday,
January 22, 1939, the serious pursuit of the gloackus began to be met with ridicule.
The townspeople's inability to capture or even catch a glimpse of this black creature on two
separate occasions caused a shift in the tone of the local newspaper reports, with reporters
adopting a more light-hearted approach to the dispatches coming from Glastonbury.
The fifth and final attempt to track down the elusive gloackus culminated on Tuesday,
January 24 in the area known as Dark Hollow, not far from the town of Marlborough. This terrain
was characterized by a maze of thorns, fallen trees, and treacherous cliffs. Amidst the waning
interest of the hunters, the press remained steadfast in their enthusiasm. A well-known
journalist and chronicler named Lowell Thomas informed his radio listeners on that very same
evening that the mysterious creature plaguing Glastonbury had been given the name gloackus
by a scientist from Connecticut. In fact, this so-called scholar was actually just the assistant
state editor of the Hartford Current newspaper. Despite the expectation that the gloackus would
fade into obscurity after a week and a half of intense media coverage, the creature re-emerged
on Thursday, January 26. A resident of Columbia named Mary Romanik witnessed the creature as it
its way southward along the Hartford-Willimantic Highway near the Windham town line. Romanik
urgently asked a service station attendant named Ernest Hart to report her sighting of a black
beast with a long tail resembling a panther to the Willimantic police. Three days later,
on January 30, the Hartford Current published a fabricated photograph depicting a buckwackus,
a perversion of the name they had recently coined, claiming that it had been captured alive while
entangled in a tall tree. Esteemed naturalist Howard Cleaves sarcastically declared that this
creature was not the real gloackus. As amusement continued to be generated by Glastonbury's most
enigmatic resident, another prank unfolded on February 5, 1939. A bird-like replica of the
elusive creature, constructed from baling wire, cardboard, turkey feathers, and a long golden beak,
was hung from the top floor of the former Hartford-Etna bank building to deter starlings.
In a letter to the Hartford Current on the same day, Frank Ray from West Simsbury proposed that
his red setter dog, with its large paws, may have unknowingly sparked reports of the gloackus.
Ray speculated that his dog, known to wander into the wilderness with neighboring hunting
dogs and return with the remains of a goat, and, on another occasion, an ox's hoof and limb
may have created the purported gloackus tracks. It seemed that the depredations of roaming dogs
could explain the disappearance of certain livestock that had mistakenly been attributed
to the gloackus. On February 8, the proposal put forth by Representative Alan F. Benke to
establish Glastonbury as an exclusive sanctuary for the gloackus failed to gain legislative
approval. It is worth noting that Benke had received letters from as far away as Texas,
Missouri, and even Washington, D.C. claiming the presence of similar creatures in their own
wild landscapes. On the tranquil morning of February 24, the Andover woods were bathed
in a gentle glow. It was in the midst of this serenity that Mr. Harold Roberts,
a resident of East Hartford, made a remarkable discovery—fresh gloackus tracks. These tracks,
measuring four inches in width, meandered for two miles, leading eastward from Glastonbury's
Diamond Lake. The distinct paw prints, believed to belong to a mountain lion, revealed a creature
with purposeful strides. The absence of deer in the area and the remnants of rabbits suggested
the presence of a lurking predator hidden in the shadows. This discovery marked the final
tangible evidence of the elusive gloackus for the winter of 1939. One might have assumed that
with the onset of World War II, the mystery surrounding this creature would fade into the
folklore. However, fate had other plans. Fifteen years later, these mysterious pumas and black
panthers would once again emerge, casting their enigmatic shadow upon the land. During the Second
World War, the Hartford Courant refrained from reporting on feline apparitions in Connecticut.
However, it did captivate its readers with tales of similar sightings from distant corners of the
United States. One such story, on September 22, 1946, told of a group of 150 armed men in
Okowoc, Illinois. These men embarked on a valiant but ultimately futile mission to find the mysterious,
cat-like beasts that had instilled fear in their small village of 800 inhabitants.
The search involved a dozen coon hounds and three low-flying airplanes scouring the densely wooded
area across three miles. Unfortunately, their efforts yielded no captures, despite multiple
sightings of creatures reportedly measuring seven feet in length and two feet in height.
Although the creatures hadn't harmed any humans, there were reports of a significant decline in
the village's poultry population. District Conservation Inspector Guy Taylor of North
Henderson, Illinois, interviewed those who claimed to have witnessed these creatures and became
convinced of their extraordinary nature. Various explanations were offered to account for these
sightings, ranging from pumas and colossal lynx to a more exotic wildcat released by a traveling
circus due to food scarcity during the war. The resurgence of the Connecticut gloacus was heralded
by sightings in Mansfield during the mid-1950s. One notable sighting occurred near the Mansfield
Hollow Dam project, witnessed by Willimantic resident Lionel Rock and his companions.
On August 3, 1954, they spotted a gargantuan, feline-like entity, similar in size to a Great
Dane, with a distinctive swooping tail that ended in a tuft of white hair. They watched in awe as it
approached a section of the dam before bounding away, leaving an indelible impression upon their
senses. Another intriguing sighting took place the following evening in the picturesque village
of Willimantic. Joseph Hemingway, a resident of this serene town, ventured out in search of the
enigmatic creature. To his surprise, he witnessed its agile form darting through a marshland near
the dam. An experienced puma hunter, Hemingway confidently identified the creature as a cougar.
However, Thomas E. Rose, a ranger from the State Department of Fisheries and Game,
expressed skepticism and attributed the sighting to an optical illusion.
Some had less conservative theories. Members of the Glastonbury Sportsmen's Club, for instance,
suggested that the creature could be a pterodactyl, the flying relic of a prehistoric age.
They claimed to have encountered this creature firsthand in the Connecticut forests.
One club member, James Kinney, recounted his experience on December 21, 1955,
when he claimed to have come face-to-face with a solemn-looking creature with a wingspan of
approximately six feet. Another club member, Robinson Gilbert, spotted the creature while
out on a horse ride. This sighting led to an intense pursuit on January 21, 1956. But
unfortunately, Gilbert and his companions were unable to capture any evidence of the elusive
creature. In the aftermath of Christmas in 1957, Mrs. Hugh A. McIntyre of Granby, Connecticut,
observed a sleek, black creature resembling a panther on Route 20 at 10 o'clock in the evening.
The creature moved with a relaxed air of nonchalance as it made its way across the meadows,
disguised by the tall grass. Its long tail added to its mysterious appearance.
Several brave huntsmen ventured into the rain-soaked woodlands of West Granby in search
of the creature, but returned empty-handed. Lyle Thorpe, steward of the State Board of Fisheries
and Game, theorized that if a panther had indeed been present, it must have escaped from a traveling
menagerie that had passed through the area. However, Ralph L. Emerson, owner of the Emerson
Wild Animal Farm, quickly dismissed this explanation, asserting that none of his animals had escaped.
Two years later, in the summer of 1959, a series of attacks occurred in the rural area of Granby.
It started in May, when a horse in a pasture in Granville, Massachusetts,
just beyond Connecticut's borders, valiantly protected her newborn foal, but suffered
injuries in the process. Shortly after, a yearling heifer on Leroy Dewey's West Granby Estate fell
victim to a vicious attack and had to be put down. In a disturbing turn of events, a group of
twenty young animals at Dewey's other property scattered in panic, causing chaos. It is worth
noting that these two properties were only five miles apart. The attacks continued, claiming the
lives of three sheep on Stanford Higgins Land. The wounds inflicted on these animals bore the
unmistakable marks of a clawed predator. Nearby, tracks were found that were larger than those
typically associated with a bobcat or lynx. Curiously, Higgins Farm was located near Dewey
Sr.'s estate, connecting their fates in this mysterious saga. Two dogs vanished from a
neighboring homestead, further heightening anxiety in the community. Adding to the unease, unsettling
wails echoed across Granby on subsequent nights, indicating the presence of a distressed wild
creature. Finally, on June 18th, the enigmatic predator responsible for these attacks was sighted.
Walter M. Silkey, a witness traveling along Route 20 in West Granby, glimpsed a creature resembling
a panther. Measuring three feet in length, with unique features like small pointed ears and a
long tail, this creature weaved through the area, mere miles from the location where Mrs. McIntyre
encountered a similar panther in 1957. The next day, a significant encounter took place in Granby.
Hans Gropper, the caretaker of Granby's dogs, found himself just 150 feet away from a dark-furred
feline creature while walking on Simsbury Road. The creature measured three feet in length, with a
long, sinuous tail ending in a blunt tip. It crossed the road and disappeared into the nearby foliage.
Gropper, deeply affected by the experience, embarked on a passionate quest for knowledge
and validation in the following months, hoping to gain the attention of scholars.
Unfortunately, his efforts went unnoticed, leaving him disheartened.
Soon, a wave of skeptics emerged, dismissing those who had encountered these cryptic felines.
One critic suggested that the creatures were not panthers, but rather a creature known as the
Clarence Robinson, a former Maine resident, described the Injun Devil as a sable-colored
wildcat, four feet in length with an elongated tail. According to Robinson, this sinister
specter posed a serious threat, occasionally attacking unsuspecting individuals, especially
during full moons. Despite these speculations, the attacks on farm animals continued, attributed to
On July 3rd, Darwin Hughes stumbled upon the remains of a heifer, displaying clear
signs of a violent demise, similar to another unfortunate bovine that met the same fate
two weeks prior. A witness also reported seeing a massive, dark figure darting across Route 20,
prompting state game director Errol Lamsons and dog warden Hans Gropper to pursue the fleeting
tracks of this mysterious phantom. News of a mysterious feline marauder spread through the
towns of Granby, Union, and Simsbury. George McKean, a resident of Avon and a salesman for
the esteemed Hartford Courant, recounted his encounter with a ruddy brown animal measuring
about four feet in length. It happened at the stroke of 2 a.m., when the animal halted under
the beam of McKean's headlights. It quickly darted away as he turned the corner to deliver the daily
paper, flashing a tail reminiscent of a fox, but much larger in size. Two days later, on July 5th,
rumors circulated that the elusive killer cat was lurking in West Simsbury. Three unsuccessful
panther hunts were organized in pursuit of this enigmatic creature. Later that same evening,
Dorothy Clapp and her family in North Granby were awakened by a thunderous roar at 1 a.m.,
originating from approximately 200 feet away. Clapp compared the sound to a lion's roar,
but higher in pitch, like that of a raccoon, accompanied by a resonating feline hiss.
In an attempt to scare away the creature, Albert Bloomberg fired his .22 caliber rifle into the
night. Prompted by the unsettling clamor, a group of brave individuals rose to the occasion.
John Monteith, Harlan Hansen of Granby, William Miller of Winchester, accompanied by his loyal
hound, and the intrepid William Rosgen of Winstead. This determined quartet followed
the elusive tracks for nearly a mile, crossing Route 189 twice, until the hound lost the scent.
Unfortunately, their pursuit came to an end when the sun rose, yielding no results.
A renewed effort was made in West Simsbury that afternoon, after three keen witnesses
reported seeing the creature. The first to spot it was young Larry Graham, a 12-year-old boy.
While retrieving a toy from the back of his house, he spotted the creature resting on the grass,
a mere 100 feet from the doorstep, near the family's garbage disposal area.
Startled by Larry's presence, the creature bounded away into the nearby woods.
Larry rushed inside to inform Mrs. Clayton Pirro, who was looking after the children.
He described the creature as larger than a collie dog and completely black.
Disturbed by this revelation, Pirro quickly took her children inside and called the authorities.
Patrolman brothers Earl and Robert Higley responded to the alarm, venturing out to
investigate the reports. Earl had a confirmed sighting of the creature as he walked along
a dirt path near the woods, across from the Graham residence. The creature suddenly leaped
into view, revealing a shadowy form around 4 feet long and 2.5 feet tall. Mrs. Graham,
from her home, also glimpsed the creature. Although the distance made it difficult to
make out specific details, she also described it as sleek and black.
The Granby Killer Cat gained such notoriety that attorney William Pease had to intervene
to restrain the eager hunters, many of whom came from distant counties armed with powerful rifles.
Six hunters faced reprimand for violating local hunting statutes,
bringing an end to this curious chapter in Granby's history.
Around the same time, three young boys, Kurt Rush from West Hartford and Brian Mahoney and Tom
Washnock from Farmington, reported seeing a large black feline near Route 75, close to Bradley Field.
Policeman Edwin Sheldon bravely ventured to the area but found no trace of the enigmatic creature
after a thorough, hour-long search. Despite numerous daily reports of sightings and the loss
of farm animals, State Fish and Game Director Lyle G. Thorpe remained convinced in the probability
of a conventional explanation. He believed that the depredations and sightings could be explained
by stray dogs, dismissing the claims of cat-like creatures as mere figments of the imagination.
One July evening, shortly after the Bradley Field incident, a young boy named Kurt Larson
applied the knowledge he learned from scouting in an attempt to identify the eerie cries that
echoed through the area. Playing his guitar, Larson attracted the attention of a puma,
which responded with mournful howls. Drawing from his experience as a Boy Scout,
during which he had learned to recognize the sounds of wild animals, Larson concluded that
the cries were, indeed, the cries of a puma. Accompanied by his friend Howard Langdon,
Larson discovered two sets of tracks in the area from which the haunting cries had issued.
One set of tracks belonged to a large creature, while the other was from a smaller creature.
Unfortunately, when Hans Groper arrived to investigate the tracks, they had already been
erased by the weather and farming activities. The concerned citizens of Granby, including the
rural inhabitants and farmers, became increasingly frustrated with the state fish and game department
officials, who dismissed their worries about the possible presence of pumas or cougars in the area.
Eventually, the citizens sought help from Governor Ribicoff's office.
A tuft of hair found near a dead cow owned by Darwin Hughes had reportedly been sent for analysis
at the University of Connecticut two weeks prior. But Conservation Officer John Somalis had not
provided any results. In addition, John Montieth shared that a representative from the state fish
and game department seemed uninterested in the situation. On July 13, 1959, Lester Loomis,
a farmer from Simsbury, lamented the loss of a calf's tail, which had been gruesomely stripped
to the bone. Just days later, the mysterious New England wildcat narrowly escaped gunfire
once again. On a fateful Friday evening at Windswept Acres Farm, owned by Dr. Robert J.
Sadler in Barkhamstead, the creature was spotted prowling near a pond filled with waterfowl.
Richard, one of Sadler's sons, quickly ran into the house and told the family about the
feline-like creature. Determined to protect their property, Richard and his brother Robert fired
five shots at the creature, but missed every time. Thirty minutes later, the elusive creature
returned. Richard, finished with his dinner, ventured into the hayfield again to search for
any signs of its presence before darkness fell. With his trusty Winchester rifle in hand, he saw
the creature about 50 feet away. Before he could take aim, however, the panther skillfully retreated
into the thick forest. Under the cover of night, the creature revealed itself again around 10 o'clock.
Robert Sadler, an experienced veterinarian, used his flashlight to explore the darkness
and caught sight of a pair of glowing green eyes about 200 to 300 yards away.
This time, the earth bore clear evidence of the creature's passing. During the following weekend,
Hans Groper oversaw the delicate process of preserving the creature's pawprints in paraffin.
From the paraffin blocks, molds of the prints were made. These impressions were then sent to
Ralph Palmer, a respected zoologist from Albany, New York. On July 22, Palmer examined the plaster
casts and conclusively identified the prints as belonging to a canine species. Meanwhile,
the tuft of tawny fur found entangled in barbed wire near one of the dead cows was analyzed by
Abraham Stolman, a renowned toxicologist who determined it to be from a red fox.
It seemed the fox had been drawn to the deceased cattle for an opportunistic meal. Palmer did,
however, declare that the secondary prints of the killer cats, obtained on July 19,
were undoubtedly from a feline. Further classification was elusive, but Palmer was
certain they did not match the prints of a lynx or a bobcat. This finding added weight to Hans
Groper's claim of spotting a massive cat asserting its dominance in the Granby area.
The dispute between the officials of Granby Township and two state agencies regarding the
mysterious killer cat continued despite the passing of a month. After diligent investigation,
state investigators discovered canine fur at the scenes of two cattle mutilations.
Groper suspected that the work might be attributable to a pack of wild dogs.
The officials initially pursued this theory, but ultimately settled for a pair of roving canines.
Unfortunately, the evidence did not support the idea that these dogs were responsible for the
attacks. The incidents occurred near human habitations, where the barking of dogs should
have been heard. Additionally, the injuries on the neck, dorsal and forelimbs, and the
fractured spinal columns of the deceased animals suggested the work of a feline.
Groper is quoted as remarking that he would like to see the dog capable of leaping onto a cow's
back. By the end of the summer of 1959, the second series of sightings came to a close.
No further incidents were reported, but accounts of a similar creature,
sighted 90 years earlier, emerged. On August 21st, 1869, the Tolland County
Journal documented the concern of Uniontown residents near Lake Moshapog, who were disturbed
by the presence of a true Scotland devil. One man, upon encountering this mysterious creature,
hurried home in such fear that he could not provide a coherent description of the apparition.
Later, a young observer of 16 or 17 years saw it while transporting hay along the road.
Although filled with dread, the boy described the subject of his sighting as,
about the size of a large Newfoundland dog, black, with a face resembling a feline's,
and having massive paws and elongated claws. The creature approached him until he shouted,
at which point it turned, jumped over the fence, and disappeared into the woods.
Others claimed to have heard its nocturnal noises, while reports of slaughtered sheep,
lambs, and calves came from the towns of Brimfield and Stafford.
The Granby Panther reared its head again in 1960, initiating a third series of sightings
that would last for seven years. In May of 1960, a Granby resident reported seeing a feline-like
creature weighing an impressive 100 pounds seeking shelter in his garage. The following
October brought the discovery of a peculiar carcass resembling a small bear or a remarkably
large raccoon. Found by Peter Marhefky on the outskirts of a field in Collinsville during
a hunting expedition, it possessed a face reminiscent of a gorilla, a tail resembling
that of a dog, and a coat like steel wool. Initially believed to be of Canid descent
by James Bishop, a respected game biologist at the State Department of Fisheries and Game
in Farmington, doubts arose when the creature's mange-ridden coat displayed hues of sable and
russet. Weighing a substantial 120 pounds, it defied classification as a raccoon, bearing
closer resemblance to a small bear, except for its incongruous three-foot-long tail and
two-foot stature. The events of October 1962 evoked memories of the events that unfolded
in 1959. In the days leading up to October 23rd, Oxford experienced a wave of attacks
attributed to a wild cat, culminating in the killing of pheasants and three cattle.
During a horseback ride, 15-year-old Sandy Gladding from Southbury found herself attacked
by what appeared to be a puma which launched itself from a towering tree. The horse initially
reared, dislodging the cat, and fled in terror, leaving the unharmed girl to recount her horrifying
encounter with the mystery feline. In Harwinton, two 150-pound Harlequin Great Danes,
accustomed to traveling in pairs, were brutally attacked in broad daylight near attorney Paul
Smith's home. After hearing terrifying screams, Smith's wife discovered the dogs covered in blood
in a field. One of the dogs had a chunk of its head chewed off. Upon examination by a vet,
it was discovered that each dog had 30 or 40 puncture wounds, not slashes. These two attacks
prompted a widespread search on October 26th involving troopers from the Bethany Barracks,
officials from the Fish and Game Commission, and numerous hunters with the assistance of
bloodhounds. On the night of Sunday the 26th, a panther attacked Thomaston resident Edward R.
Sanford, leaving scratches on his back and chest and tearing his clothes. The director of the
State Board of Fisheries and Game, Lyle M. Thorpe, declared his conviction that the mysterious animal
causing havoc in the Woodbury-Southbury-Oxford area was a panther, specifically a black leopard
brought into the state by someone. Theodore B. Bampton, the district supervisor in Bethlehem,
collected eyewitness reports describing the animal as a black panther, approximately three
feet long, with a similarly long upturned tail and small ears. The panther moved close to the
State Police determined that the hamstrings of its leg had been torn by the attacker,
leaving it crippled. That night, Edward Orlosky Sr. of Terryville spotted the panther while
driving along Todd Hollow Road. The animal ran across the road, appearing to be approximately
three and a half feet long and 18 to 20 inches tall, with a long tail. Orlosky returned home,
retrieved Alexander Romashak, guns, and a dog, and attempted to find the panther in the heavily
wooded, hilly area. The pair were unsuccessful. State troopers also searched the area,
but could not locate the animal. On November 1, Ruth Chaney, the esteemed director of the
Children's Museum of Hartford, speculated that the descriptions of the panther in Connecticut
resembled those of the rare Melanistic African leopard, a genetic anomaly born with a solid
black coat. She further proposed that the elusive panther might be an escaped domesticated feline.
Fugitive or not, the wily ebony cat was spotted by a farmer in the Washington Hill precinct of East
Heartland on that same day. Theodore Lagite, a 60-year-old man, recounted the encounter in
meticulous detail. He observed the creature from his kitchen window at approximately 7.30
in the morning. It was ascending a rise in the land around 500 feet away from his home.
It moved swiftly, with a graceful trot-like gait distinct from that of a canine.
The panther's path took it to a pasture where nine young heifers were grazing on his nephew's farm.
Two weeks prior, a black angus had disappeared from the same enclosure and was never found.
Initially, the feline approached Lagite, but suddenly changed direction and rapidly crossed
the area, disappearing from view over the crest of a hill on the other side of the pasture.
The ebony-hued creature measured three feet long and two feet tall, with a tail longer than two
feet. State Trooper Victor Zordon of the Canaan Barracks was called to search the area around the
pasture but found no trace of the black beast. This sighting in East Heartland was approximately
35 miles away from the Woodbury-Southbury-Oxford region, where a similar creature had been spotted
the previous Monday. On the following Sunday, hunters combed the dense woodland and mountainous
terrain in Terryville in pursuit of the mysterious prowling cat. It had been a full week since anyone
had caught a glimpse of the legendary panther. But on a Sunday in November, Gus Carnivalini and his
wife spotted the elusive creature in Colebrook. They immediately reported their five-minute
observation to the constabulary. The panther was stealthily prowling through the lush green grass,
occasionally pausing to stare at them. The Carnivalinis stumbled upon this breathtaking
sight during a leisurely drive, finding the panther in a field off Penny Road at around 4.30
in the afternoon. They brought their vehicle to a stop and watched as the panther lay behind a snow
fence in the meadow grass. When Gus closed the car door, the creature stirred and slowly moved
through the grass. Mr. Carnivalini let out a feline-like growl, causing the panther to briefly
pause and acknowledge them. It then made its way across the field and disappeared behind a stone
wall. Both Mr. and Mrs. Carnivalini described the panther as a cat the size of a German shepherd,
with a foot-long tail and a pure black coat. Despite initial reservations, the couple decided
to report their encounter out of concern for the safety of the local youth who might be put at risk
by this magnificent creature. The following day, a huntsman named Anthony Scheleski of Winstead
managed to take down a 23-pound wildcat in the woods of Colebrook, but this was not the panther
that had captured everyone's attention. Subsequently, more bobcats were killed.
With a few exceptions, the Ebony Panther of Connecticut evaded newspaper headlines for a
full two years. This spell was broken one night in November 1963 when three Winstead policemen
came across a breathtaking sight. While patrolling, they saw a gigantic black, cat-like creature dart
across Main Street and disappear into a field near the Mad River. One of the officers, David Pequigno,
managed to illuminate the creature with his flashlight, revealing its impressive size.
The officers unanimously described it as three feet long with a height of 18 inches and a tail
nearly a foot and a half long. On a tranquil Thursday morning in November 1967, a prominent
executive named Thorvald Hammer, the husband of Senator Lucy Hammer, witnessed a most extraordinary
sight. As he enjoyed his morning meal, an enigmatic creature paraded down his driveway with
an air of regal confidence. Intrigued, Thorvald stepped outside to observe the creature's stately
promenade along a secluded path. Eventually, it disappeared from sight around a bent. Alarmed by
this strange visitation, Thorvald promptly reported the sighting to the authorities.
A formidable team of police officers and game wardens armed themselves with shotguns and rifles
embarked on an intense search of the estate. The search party was later unsettled by a loud
roar emanating from the depths of the woods, sending shivers down their spines. Despite the
unwavering efforts of tracking dogs, their hunt yielded no results except for the peculiar
discovery of a mutilated squirrel near a pond. Such was the alarming nature of these events
that precautions were taken to ensure the safety of nearby children at their bus stop.
An armed sentinel was deployed and nearby horses were discreetly relocated to a place of refuge.
The enigmatic visitor remained a mystery, leaving the town of Colebrook on edge, wondering about
its origins and intentions. More drama unfolded on a somber Monday in November when authorities
were summoned to investigate reports of a baby tiger roaming the West Hills section of New Haven.
A fleet of police cruisers responded swiftly to the alarming report given by a bus driver named
Joe Hoonahan, who had a disconcerting encounter with the mysterious creature as it strolled
through the area. This sighting followed a previous encounter with a Thorvald tiger in
Branford, 10 miles to the east. After the incident in New Haven, there were no further mentions of
the enigmatic visitor in Connecticut. The puzzling zoological events that occurred in Connecticut
over several decades warrant closer examination. Despite ruling out incidents involving dogs,
bobcats, and domestic or feral cats, there is still tangible evidence of feline paw prints
and credible eyewitness accounts of pumas and black panthers. The credibility of these accounts
is bolstered by the fact that they come from trained police officers and state conservation
officials. This leaves us with a fascinating mystery. What really were these mysterious
felines spotted throughout Connecticut? One possibility is that pumas have made a comeback
in their former habitat in Connecticut. The state's landscape, characterized by the return
of forests and the decline of cleared farmlands, provides a diverse and plentiful habitat with an
abundance of prey year-round. The reappearance of coyotes in Connecticut, filling the ecological
gap left by the eradication of wolves, serves as a relevant example of how ecosystems can change
over time. Given these transformations, it is reasonable to consider the return of pumas.
Another more controversial theory suggests that captive pumas may have been introduced
into the Connecticut wilderness, either intentionally or accidentally. As the cost
and risks associated with keeping these animals increased, it is conceivable that some were
released into the wild. Over time, these former captives may have adapted to their new environment
and successfully reproduced with wild pumas. Both of these theories help explain the reports
of tawny-colored pumas observed by witnesses. However, the sightings of coal or jet black
panthers remain a mystery. Two conflicting theories attempt to shed light on this phenomenon.
The first theory proposes the existence of a melanistic subspecies of pumas that coexist
with the conventionally tawny Felis concolor. However, without verified evidence of melanistic
pumas, this theory remains unproven. The idea that the sightings of black panthers in Connecticut
could be the result of escaped jaguars or leopards released into the wild has gained
some traction. It is suggested that after being released, these animals could have adapted to
their new environment and remained hidden due to the potential legal consequences for their
previous owners. The presence of melanistic jaguars and panthers could explain the reports
of black panthers over the past few decades. However, this theory does not explain the
tawny pumas or resolve the mystery of black panther sightings. It remains a subject of
controversy and speculation. Notably, respected researchers Lauren Coleman and Mark A. Hall have
documented numerous instances of black panther and lion sightings dating back to the 18th century
in the United States and Canada. These occurrences cannot simply be attributed to introduced foreign
felines. As a result, two cryptozoological theories have emerged to explain the phenomenon
of black panthers. One suggests that the sightings could indicate the presence of relict populations
of the giant American lion, which existed until around 10,000 years ago. The other theory proposes
that the creatures could be manifestations of the saber-toothed cat, a formidable predator
that lived alongside the dire wolf and North American jaguar during the Pleistocene era.
These creatures hunted large herbivores that roamed North America during the Ice Ages.
However, the saber-toothed cat and other Ice Age fauna disappeared roughly 8,500 years ago,
coinciding with the end of the Ice Age and the arrival of North American Indians.
The reasons for their disappearance are still unknown. Overall, the mystery of black panther
sightings in Connecticut remains unsolved, with several intriguing theories but no definitive
answers. There are other items in Box 1, Folder 33 of the Gary Mangiacopra Archive,
all of them articles for the Anomalist magazine written by Gary Mangiacopra and Dwight Smith.
One of the articles explores a 1947 collision between a passenger steamer called the SS Santa
Clara and what witnesses described as a sea serpent. The other chronicles a convoluted
saga of the Phantom of Broad Mountain, a specter once believed to haunt the scene of a grisly
murder. If you would like to read these stories and other items in the Gary Mangiacopra Archive,
please click on the link in the description.
