83rd Presidential Advisory Council on HIV/AIDS (PACHA) Full Council Meeting | Dec.12, 2024 | Pt 3

USDOHAHS
156 followers
Dec 20, 2024
>> Marlene McNeese: All right. Well, good afternoon again. We are getting all that we need
from this engagement here in Alabama. I know I am and really, really appreciate all of the effort
and time and attention that many Alabamans have brought to PACHA and to our federal colleagues,
over the last couple of days. This part of the agenda will focus on hearing directly from you.
How we typically do this part of the agenda is we actually will face you. I will ask my PACHA and
federal colleague members along that back row if you can turn and face. Those of you who are along
the sides, if you can at least face the room, and then this part of the room will come nearer
to you. We are going to have lots of note taking because what is vital to us is that we do not miss
any of the important information that we hear from you all today. So we capture everything on notes.
And what we do with that is PACHA members and subcommittees, we actually take that back, and
we use that when we are planning and strategizing what do we do. I'm not sure about getting Medicaid
expansion in Alabama. We'll work for our PACHA agenda for 20 but we are absolutely there with you
and absolutely know and believe there's some vital things that we can do as a body and so we do want
to hear from you to take action. So we will have this next part of the meeting facilitated by -- we
wouldn't dare be in Alabama and not ask Ms. Ward to co-facilitate this engagement session, and
we have -- and our another rock star, Ms. Alicia Diggs, who has kindly agreed to co-facilitate for
her last meeting as a member. So I just want us to turn the floor over to you guys, and, hopefully,
the community, the audience is geared up both online, if there are some online, as well as
those of you in the room to give it to us. So this is your time to shine. Go ahead, Dafina and Alyce.
>> Dafina Ward: All right. Thank you so much, chairwoman McNeese. Good afternoon,
everybody. How are you all feeling? How's it going to you? Oh, this is good. Thank
you all so much for joining us today. PACHA to the people is all about hearing from you.
And I do also just have to give a shout out to that last panel. So I
think set the stage perfectly for this conversation. And we were touring the
legacy museum yesterday. There's a quote going into the reflection room that said,
we stand on the shoulders of so many who have done so much more with so much less.
It is true that you all are doing so much with little, and we know this.
And so this is an opportunity to stand up and state strongly what it is that you need,
the opportunities that PACHA can support. We work here in Alabama across the south
and beyond for our friends who are online. So our first speaker, and we will invite you
to raise your hand up because I know folks have some things you want to say. I've been
sitting here quiet all day and yesterday. So we know folks have some things you want to say,
but I want to start with Charlie Peterson. And we'll give you an opportunity to speak,
and then we will go on and and have folks speak from the audience. Here you go.
>> Charlie Peterson: Thank you. Okay. I mean, that might -- that might not help. Yes. All right. So,
I actually was going to speak this morning,
so I've got a little bit of a spiel. And then I do have a couple questions,
so I'll be tacking them on to the end of my presentation. So good afternoon.
My name is Charlie Peterson. I use he pronouns,
and I'm the director of business development and community engagement at Neelix Labs in
Chicago. I serve on the board of directors at AIDS Foundation Chicago. AFC has 8,000 clients
served through 40 Ryan White case management partners with viral suppression rates over
85 percent and 1200 housing units because housing is healthcare, and with 23 percent of
funds going to black led organizations. I'm on the Vermeida Great Council for Howard Brown Health.
Howard Brown is the largest LGBTQ plus health care system and FQHC in the Midwest with 40 plus
1000 clients and nine clinics. I'm also the highest ranking nongovernmental member of
the Illinois Department of Public Health's Illinois HIV Integrated Planning Council,
IHPSI. So, we've mentioned many important issues and populations at this meeting,
but I'd like to highlight three groups that I actually have personal ties to. People of Latin,
Hispanic, and of Spanish origin, LHS. Both recent immigrants needing language justice,
who are on or underinsured and working hourly jobs and established LHS individuals.
Two, LGBTQ plus folks. But I'd like to use my gay visibility to highlight that individuals
of trans and non binary experience, TGMB, are overlooked in healthcare with trans men and trans
masculine folks being the least represented also intersex. Thank you to our colleagues yesterday,
Tori and others who asked about initiatives and data tracking for individuals of trans
expansive experience. Three, indigenous people often in rural healthcare deserts facing high
rates of syphilis and other treatable conditions after decades of healthcare underfunding. From
discussions yesterday and the visit to Selma, people have seen what rural life can look like.
I applaud yesterday's presenters for inclusive programs that are improving outcomes,
health equity, and access to services, and for finding ways to circumvent conservative political
jurisdictions. We must yet improve accessibility and syndemic approaches to health by, one,
increased funding for clinicians with functional Spanish knowledge and the cultural finesse
to navigate both recently immigrated and established LHS groups. Yesterday,
we talked about the importance of words and of othering, and I can't think of a better example of
this than people not being able to access health care because of inefficient language justice. Two,
creating pathways for LHS, indigenous, and TGNB individuals to enter healthcare and or
capacity building programs. Three, investing in decentralized testing and treatment approaches,
including remote testing, point of care testing, or healthcare access points.
We need that, right? So, FQHCs, pharmacies, public health departments, local, state,
community based organizations, institutions of higher learning, departments of correction,
and street medicine with mobile units. And four, integrating care for HIV, STIs, behavioral health,
and harm reduction as these challenges overlap in underserved communities. So, my questions,
how can PATA help push for more visibility, more representation, more program implementation to
help these communities, especially since all three are disproportionately impacted by many
health care conditions, with LHS being the only group with rising incidence of HIV and
social inequities determinants of health, and also to really engage LHS individuals because
all our data and numbers is not represented -- a representative of the LHS reality. If people are
hiding from ICE and deportation, we're most likely not capturing them in our reports.
Also, I'd love for us to acknowledge that we're on the lands, first inhabited by the Creek, Cherokee,
Choctaw, and Chickasaw. Visibility matters. Next question or answers?
>> Dafina Ward: Pause. Let's see. Any person from PACHA would like to offer
any thoughts or reflections. Thank you so much, Charlie,
for your comments and for your question. Are there any initial remarks or answers?
>> Charlie Peterson: Can I restate the question?
>> Dafina Ward: Of course. Charlie, you can you
restate your question. Thank you. And we're also captured.
>> Charlie Peterson: All right. So how can PACHA help push for more visibility,
more representation, more program implementation to help these communities? Let's see -- and
also really engage LHS individuals because the data is just not there.
>> Dafina Ward: Thank you so much. And that is a powerful and important question, Charlie. So we
are capturing it because there might need be a need for some reflection by members,
if that's okay. Okay. Would you like to ask your second question just to see?
>> Charlie Peterson: Also, I understand because I can almost never answer a question
without thinking about it. All right. Second question, how can this council
also commit to increasing accessibility to prevention, testing, and treatment?
We've done some good work, but the political climate will probably dictate
a lot of conversations with electeds and legislators for appropriations
beyond and above level funding, pilot program ideation and implementation,
and the creation of good old policy informing clinical protocols.
>> Dafina Ward: Any initial thoughts and response to any
of the remarks that we've received from Charlie?
>> Dafina Ward: Oh.
>> Marlene McNeese: No problem. No. I'll respond and just remind everyone of PACHA's mission,
and part of the work that we do is really inform and make recommendations to the
federal response. And so you'll see, I think, tangibly, a couple of examples just later this
afternoon following this session with the work that we are set to vote on, potentially passing,
a couple of resolutions that speak, a little bit to what you're describing, but just ongoing.
We are committed to ensuring that evidence-based, science-based,
community led, community voiced intervention is what is being supported through our federal
sources. So I just wanted to make sure that everyone and you were clear about that is
our core. That is our mission. That is what we're going to do. But I really do appreciate
the charge and the challenge. I hear you loud and clear about what we need to do. Thank you.
>> Hansel Tookes: I was gathering my thoughts on your first question. I'm Hansel Tookes.
I'm a physician in Miami. I have to ask a clarifying question to you, Billy. In Alabama,
are you treating an undocumented folks for HIV? Okay. I -- because that was very heavy. I've --
>> Dafina Ward:
Can you acknowledge Billy?
>> Hansel Tookes: Yeah. I've -- I'm acknowledging him. So, yes. So,
Billy is saying that people who are undocumented are eligible for Ryan White here. But even,
you know, the questioning of it, I can see how it's - it could be hostile territory
for our brothers and sisters who have recently immigrated to the country.
So, you know -- yes. I'm sorry. I just had to clarify that point because that was very
surprising to me. I come from Miami where we treat and love many undocumented folks. All of
the doctors, we all speak Spanish and English. You know, that would be my hope for everywhere.
>> Billy Kirkpatrick: We're expected to gather Social Security numbers from
folks that we've --- you know, we've -- the way we document those things
can be pretty destructive if we have to do a certain way. So that
was really the point of my question. Not that we can't serve those with runway.
>> Hansel Tookes: So what I will say is, like, so the task of PACHA is to make recommendations to
the secretary. Would you be interested -- and I think that I'm very interested now in PACHA
making a recommendation to, HRSA HAB to have, you know, guidelines that are uniform so that
states aren't going beyond what is required to enroll in Ryan White, for instance, you know,
reenrollment, reeligibility every 6 months. I know there's the new guidance that you can do,
by year, but many states have remained doing six-month enrollments. Do you think that that
would be something that would be that you would like to see from PACHA? Yeah.
>> Dana Ward: I do just want to remind us, we only have about 15 minutes,
and we want to make sure we have an opportunity to hear from more folks
in the audience. And I know PACHA all had -- you have brilliant things to contribute,
and we'll make sure that we follow-up. This is a space we want to hear from you. We can take this
information and your input, process it, and put it into action, as we've seen happen in previous,
versions of PACHA to the people. So I do not want to cut off my brilliant colleagues yet.
>> Male Speaker: I was goning to say,
can you remind them that they still have until -- I forget what the date is.
>> Dana Ward: December 19th.
>> Male Speaker: To provide that public comment. And so what you're asking for can go in there,
and you can reach out to members from there.
>> Dana Ward: Thank you, DeAndre. Thank you so much. But we want to
provide an opportunity for additional remarks from the audience to leave.
>> Alicia Diggs: We also have community leaders online that would like to make comment as well.
So since I have the mic, I will go on ahead. I think it would be fair to open up the lines for,
Jules Levin to make comment. And, Jules, we appreciate you in advance,
but also remember we are, we are running short on time.
>> Jules Levin: Okay. Thank you very much. My name is Jules Levin. I'm the executive
director of the National AIDS Treatment Advocacy Project, better known as NATAP.
I've been living with HIV for about 40 years. I'm currently 75 years old,
and I'm aging with HIV. NATAP is the largest organization in the world in terms of reach.
We -- our website gets 3,000,000 hits a month. Over 1000 people register for our webinars,
and we reach thousands and thousands of people globally and in the US.
And I have addressed this body before about aging and HIV. This is a very
serious problem. Currently, as of 2019, 50 percent of people over 50, but by 2030,
we expect 75 percent of people to be over 50. Our HIV Ryan White health care system is broken.
People who are older need more attention and more care. They have multiple comorbidities. I,
myself, have seven or eight co multiple, comorbidities, and I have to see seven or
eight different specialists. And it's impossible to manage all that. And the clinics, the Ryan
White and HIV clinics are completely unprepared for handling the situation now and in the future.
When you go see a doctor, and this is my personal experience as well as many others, it's a 20
minute visit in and out, and the doctor is not educated and prepared to talk about comorbidities.
And then the referral process that -- for specialists, it's the very same thing. It's just
a system that's not working. There is systemic aging, not just in the care system, but at HHS,
and I would say the entire federal government, there's systemic ageism. Our problems are not
being heard and addressed by this body adequately nor at HHS and by the federal government.
We've been talking about this for years, but the issue for us is this is existential. Many
of us are 70 and 80 years old now, and without a better care system,
people are gonna be dying much more quickly, and they already are. People are getting early
heart attacks. They're getting advanced kidney disease and dialysis sooner than
people without HIV. So I'll just leave you with my question for the panel.
What will PACHA do to help us change the
bad care that older people are getting in Ryan White clinics? Thank you.
>> Jessie Garrison: Hi. I'm a little nervous. I'm Jessie. I work at Unity Wellness Center.
We serve five rural counties in East Alabama. My background for most of the time I've lived here
has been in linkage. That's kind of where this is coming from. And I handle all of our referrals.
But, particularly in rural areas, I do feel like we have a major
underutilization of opt-out testing in ERs and, urgent cares. And, you know,
we are still seeing a disturbing number of people that are coming in who are not
getting diagnosed after several ER visits. You know, I'm currently working with our hospital
to try to implement opt-out testing. You know, it's easy enough. There are so many tool kits.
There are so many resources. But I really do think if we're looking to end the epidemic and
we're looking to really get people in care, we really need stronger recommendations from
the government to, like, incentivizing and getting these hospitals to opt-out,
to implement -- oh, now I'm shaking. To implement opt-out testing. You know,
we just still have way too many people coming in sick and way too many people,
you know, not getting linked to resources sooner, and that's that is a tragedy.
>> Alicia Diggs: Thank you. Anyone else in the room like to share, make a comment, reflection?
>> Landon Nichols: Hey, I know y'all got to hear a little from me when you came on the community
engagement visit. But one policy that I just want to highlight that I think would really help us,
especially in rural places recruiting physicians, is if Ryan White Part C
Clinics were auto approved sites for the National Health Service Corps. So there are several types
of clinics that are on the auto-approved list, and Ryan White clinics can apply,
but there's additional administrative burden. So I think that's one thing that could help.
>> Dafina Ward: Thank you. Can you tell us who you are, please?
>> Landon Nichols: Yes. Hey, you all. I'm Landon Nichols.
I'm the chief advocacy officer for Five Horizon's health services. Thank you.
>> Dafina Ward: Thank you so much.
>> Alicia Diggs: I saw a hand over here.
>> Myra Franks: Hello, everyone. My name is Myra Franks. I'm from Fayette, Alabama.
I'm from Fayette, Alabama. Very, very rural area here in the state.
And that's pretty much done, pretty much cover everything that goes on,
but I would like for you to amplify that in the rural communities where education is lacking.
Reaching the people. I not only deal with people living with HIV because it's only
15 according to the CDC in Fayette County. And, you know, because of HIPAA laws, I can't reach
everybody. But the ones I do know, they don't want to talk to me a lot because I wear buttons. Yeah.
Because they don't -- they don't want to. But I deal with people who are not living with HIV.
And just like it was either TC or who was they said that that they didn't know a trans they've
never met a trans person. In fact, that's the only -- they've never met a person with HIV,
which is unheard of in this day and age, you know, health care providers, the local health
care provider. I did find one that would see me, but she had never met a person living with HIV,
but she was willing to learn. She was willing to let me be the subject matter expert with
my health care, and she interacted with my infectious disease doctors.
What else was I going to say? You all covered so much. Okay. Peer-to-peer education is rare, that
would file among the types of ways of meaningful involvement of people living with HIV. And because
it's just living with HIV, you don't understand another person who is going through HIV.
A black woman would understand a black woman. A black woman who is
raising his grandchildren living in the church. I've been without understanding,
you know, all I was going through. That's a lot. Okay.
So in this, I'm talking about peer to peer engagements, the paper serum. There are many
people living with HIV who have been in the field who do not have the brains that can do the work.
And if they are paid accordingly, they could sustain the livelihood. They could get formal,
not affordable, but safe, sustainable housing. They would be able to counsel themselves.
So there are some insurance issues. I personally had having found out that
I had to register the part for older as a older person living with HIV. I had 2
percent even one day my insurance did not pay for it. And I was in Saint Charles. You know?
So the clinic was, like, 90 miles away. So I had to make
two trips for that. These are just some of the issues. So as a black woman of
lived experience with almost 24 years. I was diagnosed 2001, January of 2001.
We must address my mental wellness, and I must address my substance misuse disorder.
I've got all of those intersections, plus I am aging. So I know I will have more
core modalities just like the gentleman just said online. You know? So make preparations
for me and the other 50 percent of all people who are living with HIV.
You know, get reinforce. And I do believe that we need more, like,
groups in rural areas. I commend all of the work to the of the people who do the
work in rural areas because I know that the work is hard. And as long
as there are people living with HIV, the work is going to be good. Okay. Thank you.
>> Sarah Robinson: Hi. I'm Sarah Michelle Robinson,
AKA first lady for tech resource center. I'm going to encourage every -- each person in this room,
including my group members, we cannot give up. We got to keep fighting,
keep thriving because God got more in store for us to keep doing.
Because when God opened winning doors, he got something to serve for everybody else
to keep going to work because when the work is finished, God got more for us to do. We got to
keep on thriving, keep pushing half days, and have more encouragement for our community. Because when
your community has had to do whatever it takes to have the courage to keep pushing,
because the right thing is in us, I have to pride in ourselves to keep going. We both now said,
we going to make it right. Doesn't matter what we do in life, we still got to keep going.
No matter what you're going to play, it doesn't matter how you got it. It
doesn't matter how you did it. No. That's the young. That's the one.
>> Alicia Diggs: Excuse me, sir.
>> Lary Cowen. Good afternoon. For those that have not met me before,
I'm Larry Cowen. I'm the executive director of Selma Air, and I don't know how to go after
that. I'm going with Selma, but one of the things that I wanted to discuss is what was
brought up for, as far as MIPA. Meaningful involvement of people with HIV and AIDS.
I am one probably maybe there may be one or two more, but I don't know. But
I am the only one that I know of in the state of Alabama that is in a leadership
position at an ASR. I don't like that. Because if we're going to have meaningful involvement,
that means they need to be people at every ASO with little experience at an
administrative level because they can tell you what is going on and what is
right and what is wrong at your agents. I know it because I started from the bottom.
I know it's all started from the bottom, and now we're here, but this is not it. I started
from the bottom, and I worked my way up. And I know there are many -- that all of these
ASOs, they can have their exact same involvement. So I want to charge you all and ask you all,
what are you all going to do to push for these ASOs or seeding roles to have client
level involvement, not at just the bottom, but at the administrative level as well
because they can give you the information that you can't go out there and get it.
>> Female Speaker: Hello. Oh, is this on. okay. Yeah. I'm loud.
It's not a question. It's a comment and a sense of deep gratitude to PACHA, since CHOP,
like, has always had a long relationship with PACHA, and it's often one that, you know, has,
like, a air of opposition to it in terms of the positions we take and the interest that we have.
And I don't want to speak for anyone else, but I'm very, very worried and very, very nervous
as far as what happens on and after the 20th of next year. And part of how I'm dealing with that
as a leader is to remind myself and remind our staff and to remind each other that even
if this body isn't -- act like in actualization, CHOP is still here as a partner in the work that
each of us do as agencies and as individuals. I know mainly our involvement in PACHA, like,
has been around, more consent and other concerns as it relates to MHS, and that's
still going to be, a focus area of ours. And I want to just offer many of our other resources.
CHOP is probably most known for our resources and data around the criminalization of HIV.
CHOP has just updated all of our maps. So hopefully, it's a tool that folks can
use and will use as we're having these sort of conversations. Now we have several maps, like,
that talk about, various aspects, you know, of this issue. Our staff attorneys have worked to
update our timeline, and, also, our staff attorneys have actually worked up to draft
a model database policy that we're hopeful, state and local health departments are able to
use as we engage at the state and local level on data privacy. It was released on World AIDS Day.
And so all of that to say, I'm hoping that the work that we have done so far
and continue to do that even if this is not the body that's able to do it,
that us as individuals and agencies are still able to continue to work together.
CHOP is here. We're not going anywhere. I know that's true of everyone in this room, so I'm
just hoping that the work is able to continue even if, you know, other factors are not play.
>> Dafina Ward: Thank you, Mandisa. [inaudible] Thank you, Mandisa.
>> Therese McGee: Hello, everyone. I'm Therese McGee, the director of the Office of HIV
Prevention and Care with the Alabama Department of Public Health. I just want to -- I would love
for the federal government to rethink how we use the funding that we have. We have HRSA funding,
CDC funding, and rebates. Our office receives very limited state fundings with restrictions
to those. So how is it -- how do we serve non-positive high-risk people that need housing,
that need transportation, that need all those services that Part B provides,
but you have to be positive. So, even if it's just rethinking the allowable use of rebates,
how can we help those organizations like the ones that spoke today to ensure people remain negative,
but are at risk and are allowed you know, are able to receive those services?
>> Lain Hinton: Hello? Hello? My name is Lain Sheree Hinton,
and I have a question for the agencies. How is it that the minorities of African American,
why is it so hard for us to obtain life insurance until we have to reach 50 or 51 years of age?
>> Dafina Ward: Good question. That's a very good question.
>> Lain Hinton: I've been trying ever since I was in,
around about my twenties, mid-twenties. And due to the underwrite, I had to wait until I turn 50.
>> Dafina Ward: The challenges is accessing life insurance. All right. Thank you. We're
capturing that for the record. Okay? Is there anybody you said agencies. Does anybody want
to attempt to respond or have an additional follow-up after that? Okay. Would you like to?
>> Jerome Elvis: So I am Jerome Elvis. I work for Rodney Health Services. I am the
prevention retention coordinator there, and I have done, insurance previously
in my past careers. The reason why they see that a person who's living with HIV,
they see you as being at higher risk. So they want to place you into a -- as a category so
they can make your premium higher. And as you're paying with higher premium,
it's giving you a smaller gap to be into a more kind of traffic group. So, yeah.
>> Hansel Tookes: But, Dafina, can I just add?
>> Dafina Ward: Yes, please.
>> Hansel Tookes: To expand on the context, it is a industry,
that has not updated the facts about HIV. And so it is an industry that still believes that,
you know, Day 1, you have HIV, that you will transition Day 30. I'm just
using some numbers. And so, it's this acceleration for people living with HIV,
and I think that is a topic that PACHA could possibly address in the future. So thank you.
>> Dafina Ward: Thank you so much for that. Now we're done.
>> Hansel Tookes: I see.
>> Dafina Ward: I think we've reached time. We've reached our time limit. Thank you all so much for
sharing at PACHA to the people, and I feel safe to talk to everyone moving forward. Thank you.
