Powell was confusing on labor market and unclear if Fed will cut at all in '25: Hightower's Link

Financial Freedom
10 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 19, 2024
Stephanie Link, Hightower Advisors CIO, joins 'Closing Bell' to discuss the Dow's declines, the Federal Reserve knowledge of what to expect, and much more.
We are in the market zone here on Closing Bell. Hightower Stephanie Link and CNBC Senior Markets
Commentator Mike Zantoli here to break down these crucial moments of the trading day. It's great to
have you both with us. Step up, go to you first. 9.63 is the decline as we speak on the Dow,
but it's pretty broad-based. Very broad-based, but remember we're still up 23 percent year-to-date,
so we have had a great year, but this was not the meeting that we wanted. This Fed, I mean,
it was a hawkish cut. Not only that, but they said it was a close call. We all expected 25
base points, but the close call, you mentioned there were four that did not want to cut,
that don't vote, but they didn't want to cut. One dissent, that's number one. Number two,
I mean, four cuts to two I think was kind of expected. Some thought maybe three,
but then again, he talked about, well, the reason we're not cutting as aggressively is because
inflation is too high. Well, then that begs the question, why are they cutting to begin with?
I thought he was very confusing in terms of the labor market. He went back and forth. Is it hot?
Is it cold? I don't know. So the point being is, why did they cut today, and are we now going to
have to think about next year them not cutting at all? And that's what the market is digesting.
I mean, he was explicit, Mike, really, in saying that he doesn't see a hike as one of the possible
outcomes, but the point was made today, you just don't really know, and they don't really know.
They just don't know what inflation is going to do. It's been stubborn,
slightly stubborn, I think is how he characterized it.
Well, you never know, and he always tries to wave you away from the summary of economic projections,
but the reality is there's a lot of dissonance in there, all right? So they're saying year-end
PCEs only gets down to two and a half percent, and yet somewhere there's two cuts in there,
and yet four people said don't cut today, even before we get down to two and a half.
And so naturally, as you get toward neutral, and you start to have both mandates kind of
almost have this interplay where it seems like they're working against each other,
then the market has to throw up its hands. Now, the market was also in a very brittle spot.
That's right.
Super narrow. The Nasdaq 100 is getting crushed right here. Tesla down 7% after being up a few
percent. So all that mechanical stuff looks very short-term, like a systematic sell-down,
a liquidation, because you had the VIX jump to 24. I said earlier, very wrongly,
that the VIX at 15 looked high based on the S&P being so static for a month. And that's clearly
the case that too many people thought this might be a clearing event, and we get a catch-up by the
average stock. We're getting a catch-down by the mega caps. All the round numbers are gone,
6,000 S&P, 45,000 Dow, 20,000 composite. So we're going to reset. We're at the 50-day
moving average in the S&P. So technically speaking, this could be your flush. This could
be where you finally have people lose a little bit of their hope for the short term. Not that
much has changed. I think the big problem here, though, is if rates are going to be around this
area, you're just not going to clear the housing market. Mortgage rates are above 7% again.
Which the Fed chair himself called weak.
Exactly. And so I think no more cuts is perfectly fine if everybody had maximum confidence of the
durability of the economic growth trajectory.
But you're still at about 3% GDP growth without housing.
You are.
That's number one. So I think the consumer is still in fine shape,
and that's the bulk of the economy. That's what we care about.
You used the word resilient when you were talking about consumer spending.
Because that's what the facts are. But on the other side, I'm a little disappointed the yield
curve is flattening too, right? So that's starting to go against what I was thinking. We want a
steeper yield curve for a lot of various different reasons, and that's not happening.
It's bear-steeping, meaning the short-term yields are going up a lot,
because you're just taking cuts away.
Right.
One of the issues, you mentioned it, Mike, about some of these stocks that have gone up a lot.
Broadcom is down 7% now, up like 25% since Friday.
Ridiculous.
Some of it got a little bit asymmetric to the upside when you look at what the fundamentals
were. And that's a good case study to look at. You own that stock.
I mean, it was ridiculous. It was up 41% in three days. And it was a fine quarter.
Guidance was better than expected. It has lagged NVIDIA. So I think you had some selling NVIDIA,
buying Broadcom. It's a great story long-term, but my goodness, no way it deserved to be up that much.
