Homer: Works in Greek

History TV Epic
4 followers
22 Video Views·Dec 19, 2024
Description: Fred Jenkins, associate dean of University Libraries, discusses the controversy among ancient scholars, asking, “Were all Homeric works written by a single author?” Interview is an online supplement to the University of Dayton exhibit Imprints and Impressions: Milestones in Human Progress—Highlights from the Rose Rare Book Collection, held Sept. 29 through Nov. 9, 2014.
I'm Fred Jenkins. I'm the Associate Dean of Libraries at UD, and I also teach Latin and
Greek for the Religious Studies Department. So, one of the big questions in Homeric studies is
who wrote the poems? Was there a Homer? For a long time, modern studies started with Friedrich
August Wolf in the 18th century, who raised the question of were both poems by the same person?
And was there a Homer? And then there was a long time when you had the Unitarians who said, yes,
Homer was written by one genius. And the analysts who picked them apart and said, well,
these are put together by some later editor. And then in the 1930s, Milman Perry went to
Yugoslavia, and he studied traditional Balkan epics that were performed by singers.
And there was no written text. They had formulas that they would plug in.
And he compared this to Homeric verse. So, one of the notable features of Homer is every character
has characteristic epithets, swift-footed Achilles, cunning Odysseus. And if you study this,
virtually every combination of a name and an epithet is designed to fit a metrical
space in the line, and there's only one for each space. So, this and other stock phrases
were used by people who would perform these extempore. They'd have a traditional story,
they have stock phrases, and they put this together at every performance.
So, the text we have was put down on papyrus, presumably sometime probably mid-8th to mid-7th
century BC, not AD. And after that, the text was fixed. And obviously, whoever put these down
was very careful. They're very well constructed, which is why people have for many years argued
there was just one author. Well, the written form is, for the most part, all we have.
There were a lot of variants early in the tradition. And one of the reasons, I mean,
work on Homer per se, but you can't escape Homer if you do classics because his influence is so
pervasive. But I have a strong interest in the history of classical scholarship,
and Homer is really at the center of the beginnings of literary and philological scholarship.
Pretty much all later Greek and Latin writing, one way or another, is a reaction to Homer.
The book that will be on the exhibit was edited by Demetrius Calcondalus.
So, he edited Homer. That was his first big project. And this was the first time that the
text of the Iliad and the Odyssey were printed in Greek in the West, or printed anywhere.
They were finally readily available then to people. I mean, one of the interesting features
is that the first letter of the section is left blank. There's a little box there. Because early
printers tried to imitate manuscript practice. So, these were designed so that each person who
bought a copy could have a scribe go through and put in a fancy capital to start the paragraph.
This particular copy, they're blank. So, obviously, someone who bought this was
mainly concerned with reading it, rather than being a collector who wanted a personalized
copy with fancy features.
