CMM126 Information Technology Law For Healthcare Professionals

NUS Medicine
8 followers
2 Video ViewsยทDec 17, 2024
On August 12, 2017, the patient passed away after spending 20 days in hospital.
The doctor later concluded that the patient had died from glaucoma infection and they
were dead.
This lead to severe loss of life at Montgomery Regional Court on January 17, 2018.
The case stemmed from an incident in 2017 when a patient covered under their insurance
such treatment at Brownsville Medical Hospital for leg pain.
Dr. Nthamma Hanarone diagnosed that the patient with tendonitis and prescribed them to go
along with oral medication including norepinephrine, lupine, and tramadol.
The patient had previously been prescribed norepinephrine and lupine.
The injection and medication were administered at around 6.16 p.m.
After a brief observation period of 10 minutes, the patient was charged at approximately 6.30
p.m.
However, upon returning home, the patient experienced late weakness, difficulty breathing,
and chest tightness.
Despite using the bronchodilators and the patient had asthma, the condition worsened.
The patient's final words were, I can't breathe, I can't make it.
He was losing consciousness.
The patient's sister called emergency hotline 1669.
However, the padded taxi was used to transport the patient to nearby hospital by 7.30 p.m.
The patient had suffered significant blood pressure, respiratory failure, and required
intubation.
A diagnosis revealed severe brain damage with the pupil dilated to 5 mm and unresponsive
to light.
The patient was later transferred to Brownsville Medical Hospital.
The hospital decided under their insurance coverage.
They were admitted to ICU and placed on ventilators on 23 July 2017.
Three days later, brain scan results indicated brain swelling and brain stem state.
The patient ultimately passed away on August 12, 2017.
The lawsuit filed on January 17, 2018 named three defendants, the insurance office, defendant
No. 1 responsible, to organizing healthcare facilities of insurance-benefit carriers.
Patumran Company, defendant No. 2, a legal entity operating around the medical hospital
which provides services under the supervision of defendant No. 1.
Dr. Dutama, defendant No. 3, a physician working at Brownsville Medical Hospital.
A section of the lawsuit states, action of defendant No. 3 as outlined in item 2 constitutes
blood negligence in treatment due to lack of cohesion derivation from the level of care
and diligence expected from medical practitioners.
Defendant No. 3 failed to emphasize sufficient cohesion which directly leads to patient death.
Specifically, defendant No. 3 prescribes the dry prophylaxis injection to patients who
have history of asthma.
The medication is contraindicated of asthma patients.
Furthermore, after administering the injection, defendant No. 3 failed to offer sufficient
observation for severe adverse reactions that could have occurred such as allergic
reactions, bronchocastomies, respiratory failure, or hypotension.
The central report issue in this case is whether the third defendant, the medical professional,
was negligent in administering the coconut to a patient who has asthma.
First of all, we will inform to you guys what is the coconut.
The coconut is a proven commonly prescribed non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug, also
known as NSAID, that has anti-inflammatory and anti-paralytic properties used in patients
with joint, muscle, and bone problems, including arthritis, tendonitis, or may be used after
dental surgery.
This may be seen carrying the serious risks for asthma patients, including allergic reactions
One of the most significant legal issues in this circumstance is breach of duty of care
as a healthcare personnel.
The important duty is providing care to meet accepted medical standards.
In this circumstance, the physician prescribes and administers the coconut, which is well
established the contraindication in asthma patients in medical literature to patients.
This could be seen as a failure to adhere to professional standards.
And another issue to consider is the patient, the physician failed to monitor for adverse
reactions.
This could be considered as negligence.
Once a high rate like diclofenac is administered, the physician should have monitored the patient
closely for any signs of allergy, bronchospasm, or others, observing the patient for an appropriate
period of time after administration, and preparing to respond to any respiratory or
cardiovascular symptoms are what need to be done in this circumstance.
Uninformed consent and patient autonomy is also one of the legal issues.
The healthcare personnel must provide patients with adequate information about the risks
and benefits of a treatment or medication so the patient can make an informed decision.
However, in this circumstance, the patient's condition and the lack of medical expertise
may not have understood the full scope of the risks associated with diclofenac.
Although the patients have the right to be involved in their treatment decisions, the
patient cannot override personal medical judgment, especially when patient's decision could be
harmful.
The physician cannot claim that they administered the medication because the disease insisted
or it is problematic.
In medical ethics law, if the healthcare professional agrees to the patient's request despite knowing
it was potentially harmful and medically inappropriate, they may be considered as failed to inform
consent and patient autonomy for letting the patient's decision override proper medical
standards.
Type Penal Code Section 291
Section 291 stipulates the liability for negligence act causing death punishable by up to 10 years
imprisonment and a fine of 200,000 baht.
The doctor failed to adhere to the standard of care and monitor the patient constitutes
a cause of negligence.
Directly leading to the punishable death did fulfill the condition for criminal liability
under Section 291.
Civil and Commercial Codes Section 420 establishes the liability for intentional or negligent
acts causing harm to another by negligently free peacekeeping and administering diclofenac.
The doctor unlawfully caused harm to the patient's life making the doctor liable for
compensation.
Improving the healthcare system requires a broad standard of treatment and patient care
to ensure safety, quality and effective treatment.
For every disease, even complex cases like asthma that involve high-risk medication,
there must be clear up-to-date clinical guidelines that override human steps and monitoring methods
of advertised symptoms.
Equally important is the continuous training of healthcare professionals, doctors, nurses
and other personnel on identifying treatment risks and monitoring open communication with
patients about potential side effects.
This not only improves patient understanding but also will improve patient well-being.
Implementation of this culture of clear regulation should require continuity, specific post-treatment
monitoring period and for hospital accountable for ensuring patient's well-being, while
also protecting the right of medical professionals.
Another important reform involves improving the justice system in medical cases.
Establishing specialized medical courts with judges who have basic medical knowledge would
allow for more informed discretion making.
At the same time, promoting alternative disability solutions or ADR methods.
Such as medication offer that faster and more comprehensive ways to resolve conflicts,
helping preserve a healthy patient and by integrating this initiative, the care system
can achieve a balance of safety, fairness and efficiency that benefits everyone.
Thank you for watching!
