Medieval Pollaxes: Size & Weight

HISTORIC Weapons
3 followers
4 Video Views·Dec 16, 2024
How long and heavy were original medieval pollaxes, used by knights between the 14th and 16th centuries? We take a look at the historical evidence, and originals in museums.
How big and heavy were medieval poleaxes and why is that important to know?
Hi folks, Matt Easton here, Scholar Gladiatoria. Now I'm just back from a weekend of armoured
training and armoured fighting with poleaxes. I ran a poleaxe class, as did my good friend
David Rawlings of the London Longsword Academy as well, and so we were looking intensively at
poleaxes. Now one of the things I noticed over the weekend was that a lot of people had a lot
of different poleaxes. Now in HEMA we tend to use training weapons that aren't sharp and pointy like
these because we do lots of thrusting at the face and thrusting at the armpits and things like this.
Obviously we can't use sharp ones, obviously, but even blunt ones are a little bit too offensive so
we tend to use wooden or rubber-headed weapons that are usually a bit lighter than the real
thing, it has to be said, but primarily it's about the safety of the points, top and bottom end
included, and of course the axe blades and the beak if you have one. But in attendance at this event
were lots of replica steel poleaxes like this one I'm holding here, and they varied a lot. They varied
in size, in length in other words, but also they varied in weight. Now given that a poleaxe is the
design that it is, and if you are going to add weight to the thing it tends to be weight up here,
then you end up with very different handling weapons. So for that reason it actually changes
drastically how you move the weapon and how you use the weapon. If you're given a weapon, whatever
it is, whether it was a sword, a mace or a spear or whatever else, if you change the overall mass
and size of it, it does change to a large degree, if not totally, it does change how you use that
weapon, what kind of techniques are practical to use, even the guard positions that you hold that
weapon in. So as I mentioned if you make a poleaxe heavier it tends to be heavier at this end because
this is the end with the langets, with a guard if you've got one, and with the head. So the extra
weight tends to be concentrated all up at the hitting end which really changes how the weapon
moves. The other thing to mention as well is what the nature of what you've got at the back of the
weapon does change the weight and the kind of weight balances as well. So I got to thinking,
look we've got all of these different poleaxes here and actually I'm demonstrating things with,
it might be a waster with a wooden weapon or I demonstrate it with this which is relatively
decently weighted and balanced, and someone else over there has got a much longer poleaxe or a
shorter poleaxe, it might be much heavier, might in some cases be much lighter, how does that actually
change things? Well it actually changes things quite a lot. So I wanted to know what about the
originals? If we go looking at original poleaxes how big are they in artwork and surviving ones
and indeed how much do they weigh? Now before we go and investigate that point I want to mention
there are a few difficulties with answering this question. First of all in regards to size,
one of the issues is we could just go well let's go and look at original surviving ones
in museums. There are two major problems with that as a strategy. Number one, there aren't many
surviving in museums. So poleaxes are not insanely rare to find in collections, you do find them in
collections in numerous countries in the UK. If you look at all the museums in the UK there's
probably in the region of about 20 or 30 poleaxes. Original 15th and sometimes 16th century poleaxes
in museums in Britain and you know you might find similar things in France or Italy or Germany
wherever you go. So they're not hugely rare but that being said they're not also they're also not
hugely numerous and more importantly perhaps it's not always possible certainly for me at this point
in time to tell you what what the size of all of those sample of that relatively small sample is
because it's not necessarily recorded. But here's the real elephant in the room, this is why I'm not
going to look at originals in collections for the size part of this. I will be looking at weight
but for the size and that is because for the most part the original wooden shafts do not survive.
Okay now that is entirely what dictates how long this is. Okay obviously the head and the the top
spike has a certain length to it but in most cases poleaxes that survive in museums the head is
original some part of the langets are usually original although not all of the langets quite
often so the head and the top spike very often the bottom mounting whatever it should be if there was
one they didn't always have a bottom spike but often they did are very often missing usually
missing and if there is something in the museum on the end of the shaft it's usually a replacement
from later centuries for display purposes. So I'm not going to look at the size from museums so
instead we're going to look at the size of them as represented in art. Now inevitably this is also
has some issues with it because art isn't always literal especially medieval art and renaissance
art is not always literal when it comes to sizes however we can note some general tendencies by
looking at the art when a poleaxe is stood on the ground next to a person. So very generally speaking
most people in modern HEMA or living history or reenactment or anything like that tend to go for a
with the head whatever style of head you've got hammers or spikes or whatever axes with the top
spike tends to come up to about the same height as the person you'll notice standing on the ground
so I'm six foot one I think about 184 and this poleaxe is actually pretty much the same height
as me so that's about right for me or is that right so to speak so there is that I have noticed
some people particularly reenactors things will go around orally and everyone will go I've heard
I've been told that the correct height for poleaxe is the same height as the person not that simple
in medieval art as we will see here so indeed there are a lot of poleaxes in medieval art which
are about the same height as the person however from my looking through medieval manuscripts and
paintings there are essentially four main groupings for poleaxe height okay now the first grouping
we've just mentioned is about the same height as the person the second grouping is about a height
whereby the axe head is just above the person's head height this seems to be a common sizing so
when you look in medieval art very often poleaxes are actually about that long so about maybe 30
centimeters longer than down there okay so they tend to be above head height with the hammer and
axe blade at about the height of your helmet that's the next common grouping that we see in
medieval art now the next common grouping we see in medieval art is coincidentally or not
I don't know is more similar to the height that people generally reconstruct dane axes I've just
put the poleaxe down for a second so this tends to be quite a popular size for poleaxes as well
and it's often represented in medieval art by people leaning on the top now it's a funny thing
because that's quite a specific artistic thing and actually gives us a degree of confidence
in the medieval art because it is because the artist has seen people leaning on the top of
their poleaxes like this now if they're leaning on the top of their poleaxes clearly that axe head
has to be about the height of the armpit okay so we see this in all the way back with dane axes
in the Bayeux tapestry but we equally see it in 15th and 16th century art as well so that's the
common grouping or common sizing for poleaxes is about the height that you can lean on the top of
it okay now the final grouping debatably is and isn't a poleaxe and that is something that appears
to be a weapon that you could use from horseback you could at a stretch use in one hand although
it's probably not very well weighted and balanced for that but it's essentially like a poleaxe that
has had the shaft chopped off and so you're left with a weapon that's about the length of a long
sword and very often in art we see these held down by the side of the person and the person's
holding the point the tip of the poleaxe leaning the butt where there's no spike of course because
it's short leaning it just down on the ground here now those are clearly weapons that the person
holds at the bottom end here imagine there's no shaft below my hands here and they're using it
like a sort of archetypal battle axe or a long sword essentially so it's about long sword length
so there we've got the four main groupings that we can see in art very common to find them up to
with the point up to about head height very common to see the axe and hammer or spike at about head
height so about 30 inches sorry 30 centimeters taller about a foot taller very common to see
them so you can lean which i can't with this because this one's too tall but where you can
lean on them like that and not uncommon and this is the rarest type not that uncommon to see them
much much shorter more kind of long sword length so how much do these things weigh well that's one
of the main things i actually noticed at the event is apart from the length variation in people's
pole axes most people's pole axes were about the height of them okay so there was no problem with
the techniques there incidentally why is that so important well the length of your shaft so to speak
makes a big difference in the certain techniques and how they work there are certain techniques
for example there's one where you want to slide the whole weapon back to your hand here and you
actually put the the top spike or the top of the axe into the person's armpit pretty much grappling
at wrestling range it's an anti in fact the person's trying to throw you at the time so they're
kind of in a wrestling position and you break it by slipping the weapon all the way back to here
now clearly if you've got a particularly long weapon that becomes unwieldy conversely there are
other techniques for example in Anonimo Bolognese where you want to be able to stab the person in
the foot with your bottom spike well if your pole axe is too short you can't reach their foot
equally in Anonimo Bolognese there's another one where a person stabs your foot and you parry the
stab at your foot with the bottom end of your axe and you can immediately respond with a hit to the
head with your top end of your weapon so there are some techniques where the length of the weapon
is very critical and you need a certain amount of length to be able to do certain techniques and
conversely there are some techniques where if the weapon's too long it's too unwieldy to use in a
closed space so length is important but weight was the thing i really noticed most people's pole axes
were kind of this length but some people's pole axes were much heavier than others and some of
also having a counterbalance at the back end with a spike or some kind of butt gives a little bit
better balance but equally if people have got i've noticed one of the things that makes the
biggest difference to the weight of pole axe is what kind of langets these are the protective
iron bar well plates really strips that go along the side of here and as mentioned in previous
videos those serve two purposes one is to protect the shaft from the enemy's weapon
and secondly it's also to hold the shaft of your weapon together when you're swinging it at someone
and they suddenly parry or you hit them really hard in their armor you stop it snapping somewhere
up here basically so it's to hold your weapon together and if people have particularly thick
langets and i do know a couple of manufacturers that use i would say overly thick steel for their
langets it makes the entire weapon much heavier than it needs to be so how do we find out how
heavy the originals are well in this case i can't tell from art so we're gonna look at museum
examples now two problems here number one there aren't a huge number to draw upon so i'm just
going to look at a few examples from a few museums secondly sometimes there are pole axes in museums
and i don't have access to the weight data okay so for example the royal armories have some pole axes
on their online collection website but they haven't listed the weight so that's not useful to me
the other issue you might say is well they don't have the original shaft so how do we know the
weight well all of those that i'm using do have replacement wooden shafts so yes indeed they might
not be exactly the same weight they might not be exactly the same length as the originals but bear
in mind that with the pole axe a lot of the mass comes from the head and the langets so so long as
we've got head and langets and some type of stand in wooden shaft there then we should at least get
an approximate idea of how much these pole axes are weighing and for reference before we go into
those museum examples this replica here from a casto in the czech republic bought via armor
bohemia this weighs two and a half kilograms so 2500 grams so this first example here is from the
royal armories now first thing i have to say about it it's a 15th century late 15th century
pole axe but it is missing some of its langets in fact it's probably missing about 50 of its
langets so it is going to be lower than it originally would have been in total mass but
nevertheless it's a very attractive and sort of relatively typical shape of head probably
probably french and it is 1835 grams 1835 grams so there you go it's actually you know that's
relatively light isn't it but as i say it's missing its langets so at a guess i'm guessing
if you add langets onto it which will be front and back and the sides i suspect originally this
would have been in the region of about two and a half thousand grams or 2.5 kilograms the same as
my replica or possibly slightly below that so anyway very much within the same ballpark as my
replica example this example also from the royal armories now i have to say i'm a little bit dubious
about this one because the constructional method on it is a bit odd so i'm not 100 sure that this
is a genuine example that being said the royal armories description doesn't say that it isn't
but conversely it doesn't give a date for it which doesn't fill me with confidence with this one but
nevertheless it looks well made even if it is a good replica it's a good replica based on originals
and it is 2.4 kilograms i should reiterate i'm not saying it is a replica i don't know i only
know from this one photograph i haven't examined this poleaxe in person but it's in the royal
armories so let's assume it's a genuine object 2.4 kilograms so again we're in very much the same
ballpark here so 2400 grams now this example in the uk's royal armories is relatively famous and
it is gorgeous it is just one of the nicest surviving poleaxes i would say very very ornate
and i love the the beak sticking out of the hammer it's like should we have a hammer or a beak
yes anyway so this is very ornate and as a result it has kind of more stuff on it particularly on
the langets although it does have piercings through the langets which does again reduce
the weight so anyway nevertheless i would say overall it looks like a relatively heavy example
compared to some of the other ones we're looking at and the total weight is 2.92 kilograms so 2920
grams so again very much in the same ballpark a little bit heavier this one's close to 500 grams
heavier half kilogram but nevertheless again in the same ballpark for anyone who's wondering about
the imperial measurements here incidentally that is six pounds seven ounces that particular example
so to give you a rough you know we're talking about below seven pounds again the royal armories
in the uk in leeds this is a 16th century so it's a later period poleaxe this would have probably
been predominantly used for tournament fighting but then again it could have been used on the
battlefield at this date so it's early 16th century 1510 to 1530 it's been dated to it has
a crescent axe blade you'll notice a slightly different design some of the 15th century ones
although you do find poleaxes of this design earlier in the 15th century as well so i think
it's a good example to use this one's very interesting it is at 2155 grams so this is
lighter this is a lighter one so 2155 grams and it is a complete weapon with a complete shaft
it's got its langets and so on so forth so again we're in the 2000 between 2000 and 3000 grams
mark now before i move away from royal armories examples i'm just going to show one example which
doesn't have an axe blade so this example has a hammer and a beak as they're called um beck to
corbel is the long spike on the back so by nature these tend to be lighter so the type with axe
blades tend to be heavier the type with a hammer and a beak tend to be lighter and again that does
make a difference to techniques i should reiterate that many of the treatises we look at don't show
poleaxes with an axe blade they show poleaxes they're still called poleaxes but they show them
with a hammer and a beak and that does make the weapon lighter makes it lighter it makes it more
maneuverable makes it more balanced towards the middle it makes it quicker so it does make a
difference to the techniques absolutely and of course you don't have an axe blade anymore
so axe blades are useful for trapping and hooking particularly although you can do a lot of those
things with the beak as well and of course for chopping and you can't do that with this type of
poleaxe so it is a different version of poleaxe and these tend to be lighter and indeed this example
is lighter at 1780 grams which for the imperial amongst you is 3 pounds and 14 ounces so that's
quite significantly lighter isn't it so it's just done you know it's just under four pounds
so it's quite heavy compared to a sword but for a polearm not heavy at all okay this is really
quite a light weapon despite the fact it's got a hammer on it and a spike so there we go 1780 grams
now we're going to look at three examples from the wallace collection first of all we're going
to start off with the much loved and much reproduced it has to be said um a so-called
gothic probably french um poleaxe which uh has its langets it has a circular disc guard it's got
everything on it so not to say that obviously i don't think the shaft is original um but it has
got everything on it that would contribute towards its weight or mass and in this case this very
famous poleaxe which is not dissimilar to my replica actually is 2.495 kilograms so basically
exactly the same as as my particular replica so my replica very close to this and the same weight
we're talking about two and a half kilograms here now this example is a 16th century example dated
to about 1530 and this has a crescent typed blade a bit like the other 16th century one we saw a
crescent shaped blade and a hammer on the back and an interesting flared reinforced spike on the top
it doesn't have a top spike and the shaft is almost certainly not original but nevertheless
the total mass is 2.33 kilograms so 2330 grams again in exactly the same ballpark now this final
example from the wallace collection is an interesting one um i've actually held this in
fact i've held two of the wallace collection poleaxes myself and you can if you search on
my channel for poleaxe you can see a video of myself and toby capwell dr tobias capwell at
wallace collection looking at poleaxes and we've handled these and they're very very nice and very
interesting weapons this particular example is earlier and has a different constructional method
to a lot of the later 15th century poleaxes this is dated by the wallace collection to 1430.
i think it could be later than that in fact this type of poleaxe appears in art over quite a broad
period but absolutely it could be an earlier example interesting to note this is earlier but
has the crescent shaped axe blade so just to highlight crescent shaped axe blades that we've
seen on the 16th century examples they're not always a 16th century thing you do find crescent
shaped axe blades absolutely on even 14th century poleaxes and certainly on 15th century poleaxes as
well they're not always straight edged axe blades but this example has a crescent shaped axe blade
balanced by quite a thick heavy hammer on the back now the important thing when it comes to mass or
weight about this poleaxe to note is that the shaft is fully encased in langets the langets are
fully encasing they're not just in strips in the wood they go all the way around the wood for quite
a way down from the from the head now the mass of this you'll be wondering i've been high i've been
implying here it's going to be heavier and indeed it is heavier it is 2.95 kilograms so 2950 grams
so it's still in that 2000 to 3000 kind of parameter that we find pretty much all of
these poleaxes fitting into an interesting again when we're talking about parameters it's an
interesting thing to note that if something is not genuine if something's a replica sometimes it might
fall outside of those parameters not always you could have a very good replica but if something
were a victorian fake it might be very well made to look at but it might be too heavy in the hands
we often find this with fake victorian medieval swords medieval style swords made in the victorian
era they feel crap in the hand and they're too heavy so a non-genuine poleaxe you might find is
well outside of these parameters for some reason so anyway this example heavier than usual slightly
different design to many of the other ones we're looking at here in fact it's pretty much unique
survival as far as i know although you find comparable examples in art i don't know of any
others surviving that look like this so 2.95 kilograms it's a beefy one but i've got to say
in the hand it still feels very nice now let's move over to the metropolitan museum of art which
has some absolutely fantastic medieval and renaissance items of armors and armor and this
example of a poleaxe looking not dissimilar to examples in the royal armories in the wallace
collection is dated to circa 1480 is probably french could conceivably be english but anyway
it's northwest european and it's complete so this has its langets it has its shaft again the shaft
probably not original but it simulates the weight of the original shaft and but the most important
aspect here is it does have complete full langets and has all of the elements on it except maybe for
the tail spike which is always a bit of an unknown but more or less all of the elements that we would
expect to find on the complete original item when it was made and it weighs 2948.4 grams so 2.95
grams so very similar in fact to examples in the royal armories and the wallace collection and it
is at the very much at the heavier end of the scale but it's still within that 2000 to 3000
gram parameters and a beautiful and iconic poleaxe this example also in the met is dated a little bit
earlier to circa 1480 i'm sorry 1470 i'm not sure exactly why they date this 10 years earlier than
the previous example i would say they could be both made at exactly the same time as far as i
can tell but maybe they have some specific reason for that maybe they found an example in an artwork
that dates to 1470 that looks like this i don't know but again a bit like one of those royal
armories examples this has got the beak sticking out of the hammer really cool combination so you
get kind of the best of both worlds kind of not but anyway it looks super cool and this is also
important in that it seems to have pretty much all of its elements again it's got the full langets
it's got a shaft probably not the almost certainly not the original shaft i would say it has clearly
got a little bit of the outer langets that come from the top spike broken off so it has lost a
little bit of mass certainly this definitely has lost a little bit of mass but we don't know how
much and this one weighs 2976.7 grams so 2.98 kilograms so again it's at the top end of the
weight scale here it's just under 3000 grams or three kilograms for the imperial amongst you that
is six pounds nine ounces so this is again it's sub seven pounds okay so under seven pounds
under three kilograms but close up there so it does seem that when you see a polax in art for
example if it has very extensive langets or very ornamented langets you can make an educated guess
based on the surviving examples that the mass is going to be about three kilograms or slightly
under now this example also from the met is dated by them to circa 1475 now you'll notice it has a
crescent shaped axe blade on it balanced by a hammer and a top spike dag that's shaped kind of
like a spearhead or pike head now a lot of people identify this particular style of polax with venice
so oftentimes when you find a 15th century polax that has a crescent shaped blade it will be
described as venetian that's because some survive in venice in collections there and artwork associated
with venice that being said you do also find crescent shaped axe blades from not from venice
so what the attribution for this i'm not actually sure i don't know if it's definitely venetian but
there's a good chance it could be italian but nevertheless it's got a crescent shaped axe blade
so it looks a little bit different to say the french and english type of which often have a
straight axe blade on them although they also sometimes have curved blades on theirs as well
from the artwork we know but this is dated to circa 1475 by them i would say it could be later
than that it could be up to 1500 could even be over past 1500 but nevertheless they've dated it
1475 and the weight which is what you all want to know is 2920 grams so 2.92 kilograms so again
we're very close to three kilograms but we're sub three kilograms imperial six pounds seven ounces
so again we're under well under seven pounds it's about six and a half pounds so six and a half
pounds just under three kilograms this is the kind of mass that we're looking at even though
the design of this one is completely different to the previous two we've seen still in the same
weight category and the final example i'm going to give also from the met this is a polax that
they date to circa 1450 i would say it could be anywhere between 1450 and probably about 1480 but
nevertheless we're looking at the middle of the 15th century to the latter part of the 15th century
and it's of a type which is almost certainly french or northwest european could be dutch
could be english and again we've got the beak sticking out of the hammer it's quite a characteristic
type and i think very cool looking type and this is a little bit you'll notice it looks a bit leaner
it's not it's not particularly fancy it's not got lots of decoration on it the langets are
relatively slender and indeed this is reflected in the weight the weight is 2466 grams 2466 grams or
2.47 kilograms and in imperial that is five pounds seven ounces so this is sub six pounds in fact
it's about five and a half pounds and about two and a half kilograms so this is notably lighter
that being said there's always the great unknown did this originally have elements on the shaft
such as guard and remember the guards the discards you can have one or two of them and it makes quite
a difference to the mass equally a tail spike it could have a very minimal tail spike it could have
no tail spike or it could have a really substantial tail spike and that equally will change the total
mass and the balance so i hope this has been useful and illuminating essentially to summarize
we've seen that pole axes can come in roughly four different varieties of length about head height
above head height about chest height or all the way down kind of like hip height okay there are
roughly you can split them all into those four length categories the most common ones shown in
art seem to be about head height or a bit above head height or a bit below head height okay so
roughly kind of from here to here in in height is kind of where most pole axes and art are shown
in terms of weight as we've seen if it's an axe bladed type it tends to be quite a bit heavier
than the hammer headed type so if you've got hammer and a beak that's generally lighter although i
showed one example here i have looked at others and they are almost always lighter quite notably
lighter like about a pound lighter okay so if you've got a hammer and a beak that tends to be
lighter it will therefore balance closer to the middle of the shaft and will be a quicker more
nimbler weapon if you have an axe blade obviously that gives you other options but if you have an
axe blade balanced by either a spike or a hammer that is usually around two and a half kilograms
sometimes it can be below two and a half kilograms and quite often it can be all the way up to nearly
three kilograms but none of the examples i've looked at have been over three kilograms all of
them have been sub three kilograms i hope that's been interesting and useful um this has been
in fact i've enjoyed it this is something i've never done before and i'm really useful for
really grateful to have this data to hand now because i'm sure it'll be useful in lots of future
discussions so thanks a lot for watching if you're not subscribed please do so and come back
again for my next video which i hope will be as equally riveting as this one was i'm matt easton
i will continue to be and i'll see you back here soon cheers folks thanks for watching we've got
extra videos on patreon please give our facebook a like and subscribe if you haven't already cheers
folks
