A reply to @letsasksekisensei How would a Samurai Master Fight with a Longsword?

Ancient Swords
6 followers
13 Video Views·Dec 15, 2024
As I got asked by a few folks to comment on this, and as I enjoy watching Shogo and Seki Sensei anyway, I took to a chill rooftop, behind a noisy London street to record some thoughts on their video about the Longsword.
Hi there, this is Obaidu Shogu and Tasemi Sensei. Thank you very much for your very interesting
video about European longsword. My name is David Rawlings, I'm the founder of the London Longsword
Academy. My name used to be on the synthetic that you are actually using to train with.
So there's a few things that I would like to mention. I'm very deliberately wearing one of
my school's hoodies and the reason for this is that most of us within HEMA, before we started
having professional equipment made, started off wearing things like hoodies and jeans and this
and these have little openings of fabric which are quite easy for your sword to snare on.
And yep, absolutely, we very often did stick our cross guards in these things but it's really a
case of familiarity with the weapon. So after a while you get used to its limitations, you get
used to its rotations and you get more used to not putting it into things that you don't want to
and hopefully into the person that you want to. So yes, it absolutely did happen, we used to stick
this. A few things that can make a difference though is it's very tempting to think of the
European sword being held edge aligned towards the cutting knuckles but it's not always done so.
Very often if you look in some German material, if you look in Achille Morozzo, a lot of the guards
are held with the thumb apparently on the flat of the sword and this really changes the alignment.
So as you can see here, I'm not turning the cross guard into myself, this is now aligned top to
bottom and it only really starts turning as it comes forward in towards the opponent.
So this makes it much less likely that you're going to snare your clothing when you use it.
I have no idea if this is the reason they did it but it's a thing. This again aligns the cross guard
left to right and really when we're talking about how the cross guard is used, it's much more useful
as is when we're talking about cuts to look at all of our grips and holdings of the sword as
being utilitarian so that we will sometimes hold the sword like this but if I want to hit with the
long edge I'll just turn in, if I want to continue to the back edge I'll just turn in to where it
needs to go. So our grip on the sword is varied according to our need. Now the next thing I would
mention is you immediately grasp the utility in striking with the flat of the sword and striking
with the flat or even striking to the flat of the opponent is very very very common. However what I
would say with the European longsword and again this is really I would say something that varies
between authors rather than necessarily being you would do this with the European longsword,
different authors have different ways of handling the longsword, is that really every single part
of the blade is used to displace when it's appropriate. So in some cases for example you
might hold the sword like so and I might displace with what we call the long edge I'm just going to
wait for this blade to go past. What we may do is we may hold the sword as we discussed and we may
use the long edge to throw and then to hit with the back edge. Now one of the advantages of doing
this is that if we feel the opponent is striking back up returning their blade back towards our
head this structure is then imposing itself on the opponent's return structure of their blow
so that when they flip up rather than doing something like so which may allow the blade
to cling back into our head this structure actually covers ourself and then you saw another
displacing at a kinetic almost Newtonian displacement of the sword with the flat there
which very similar to what you're saying is we can send the blade to one side before cutting again
in this case with the back edge but we could turn to cut with the long edge so obviously we can do
exactly the same thing with the flats we can do the same thing with the outside flat and I'll move
this to where we're covering the head to show you a very very similar aspect to that but yes you can
use both the long edge you can use the flats on both sides and you can also when it's prudent
use the back edge to do the same thing so there's really not so much worry about which part of the
sword you're striking with only which part of the sword is the most prudent for you to use
at a specific time and that might vary according to configuration of your blades so if I'm here
and I find myself like so it might be more prudent for me to strike with the back edge backwards but
this very much depends on the alignments of our blades relative to each other so oh what else
I'd like to talk a little bit of the idea of displacing the blade to one side with this kind
of rotational movement and this again is something that is very very doable and I would suggest that
when we're doing this with the European nozzle perhaps we're not so worried about which edge we
do it but after a period of time certainly there's no problem with that displacement
passing through this barrier in order to strike whatsoever because we're not worrying about where
the rotation is taking us so much we put the shield in we rolled and then we cut accordingly
so again these actions I would suggest are not better with a curved sword not better with a
straight sword but they are more easy to do when you have more experience with that blade so it's
just a matter of time and how long you spend with that particular blade in your own training again
I feel that if you spent a little bit longer with a straight blade you would be able to do it with
just as much confidence and celerity as you are with the curved blade at the moment so there's
not much really to add to that I don't think other than maybe again another example of where we may
displace with the flat of our sword but also we could do it with the the long edge of our sword
or the back edge of our sword okay so long edge and back edge basically the long edge is the one
which usually you would align so we'd associate that with curved edge on a katana the back edge
or the short edge is really what we'd associate with the inner curve the concave curve okay so
when we're here for example again we can use the flat and the flat is slightly more efficient in
this context to displace swords and again either strike with our back edge or with our long edge
really depends one thing that is very very common when you're doing a lot of these strikes so if I
wanted to strike down simply with the long edge here is that we will move ourselves to one side
when we do this and the reason fundamentally that we do this is if I do this and I strike your sword
down with the long edge is it opens space for you to move very very easily around to strike me on
this side whereas if I move to this side you have to go over the under the entire length of the sword
before you can do the thing so very often we're making our strikes more advantageous to ourselves
and again this is really referenced when we're throwing swords aside and this kind of thing
or throwing the sword down we're making the position more advantage advantageous to ourselves
by either moving into the blow as we make it or moving away from it so that our opponent has to
travel the length of our blade to get to us so there's an awful lot that we can unpack and it's
really one of these things that requires experience and it requires conversation and it requires going
through different manuals and talking to each other about how different authors approach different
things but hopefully this gives you a little bit of an insight into how the structure of this
is sometimes held differently and how that makes things easier to do with this structure
grip as I say is purely utilitarian you change it to do the thing that you want you want to do
a back edge you release your grip you make it more relaxed you hold it a little bit more in
the back end you want to do a long edge blow very very simple you want to do a long edge vertical
blow with your palm through like so then you change your grip again all grips are utilitarian
and again here all grips are utilitarian for blocking as well it's been real pleasure to
talk with you I apologize but I'm beginning to stutter a little bit it's quite cold outside
but a real pleasure to talk to you and I hope you find this informative
