"Welcome Back to my channel! Thank you for your support as always. The video you have been waiting for! In this video I'm going to be sharing with you my insights on the very recent exam of N.M Tsiskardize. Firstly it is very interesting to watch and see this change in the school. It is such a different approach to exams than it used to be. Here I am sharing my honest critic with the upmost respect for the work and dedication gone in. I am sharing observations and differences to what it used to be like, not necessarily saying change is bad, but changed it has! These exams are renowned for being tough and part of my whole philosophy is sharing what it is really like and. what it was before! I would love to hear your thoughts. Please keep comments respectful and tasteful. All other comments are subject to be removed. Please like Share and Subscribe!
Thank you for watching! "
Hello everyone and welcome back to my channel with myself Isabella. Thank you so much for
joining me here today. If you're new here my name's Isabella and I'm a graduate of the
Vaganova Ballet Academy. I then went on to dance with Michalowski Ballet and Eifman Ballet
before I returned to London and founded BWI which is an online platform filled with classes, courses
and we host intensives worldwide for adults and soon vocational students which I'm super excited
about. Before we begin hit that subscribe button so you never miss another episode. Today is a super
exciting episode and one which I have had many messages from you asking if I can react or analyse
and share my opinions about the most recent Siskarici grade seven or year seven exam. These
girls are one year away from graduation. Now when I was there it would mean they were actually two
years away from graduation so when I was there Altenay Asilmuratova who was the former director
who we all love and definitely miss, she added another year on so it was kind of like it was
added on then it was taken off and etc but I really appreciated having that extra year because
it gave me more time to develop especially because I was very tall so it took me longer to
get a bit stronger. Bear that in mind when we're watching this video these girls are two years away
they're around 15-16 years old some of them may be 17 and then next year they would be more towards
17-18 so they may be mostly 16-17 in this class. This is a very interesting exam. Number one I was
kind of shocked that Nikolai Siskarici had taken on a women's class. It's not very common that
that happens. Most of the time a woman will lead the ladies just because you know much like
it's uncommon for a woman to lead a male class you know there are certain things which are very
female orientated and that's not to say male coaches are not useful for women. I mean I've
had some fabulous lessons with coaches but giving them the responsibility of teaching women full
time is something different altogether. Like my beloved Gnadi Zalewski was very close with
many ballerinas and helped coach them and helped work with them but you know that's different you
know coaching variations coaching pas de deux all these kinds of things and so having the
responsibility like I say of taking on a whole class is different. So as we all know watching
the Vaganova exams those that are familiar you've probably noticed that they look a little bit
different and they definitely do. So recently last year I reacted to the graduation class of Kovalova
that class already looked slightly different probably from the director's influence.
I'm really interested to see and share my thoughts about this recent exam. I'm not going to watch the
whole thing because it is an hour long and we'll be here a long time but I will watch most of it
with you and so you'll definitely get a an idea as to my thoughts and I'm really looking at not
necessarily to criticize anybody or to criticize the girls at all either it's more so to analyze
the differences between when I was there and from when Altenai was there and even before that you
know before I was around you know it's very very different it looks kind of like a different school
or to be honest almost. So let's have a look and I'd love to hear your thoughts you know this is a
very open space I'm just sharing my opinions and it's I'm not saying what's right what's wrong
it's just my open thoughts which I know you all appreciate. So let's watch together and enjoy.
He looks happy. What's funny is oh there's my my teacher Gribanova who has been around
a long time and she's actually doing really well she's really building up
her status and she's really actually producing some great dancers we love her.
There's Angelina Voronsova there who was obviously a real muse of Nikolai and he really looked after
similar to how I said Gennady Zalewski looked after people like Yulia Makhalina he was kind of
coaching her a lot since they have a good relationship. There's Marina Vassilyeva
and Kovalova in the background there who's obviously been around a long time and speaking
to her is Svetlana Ivanova from the Mariinsky and that's Kasenkova there with the black bag
who's one of the most recent teachers in the last like 10 years
and Ayubova who is a great dancer oh my gosh.
What's interesting is usually the role of Nikolai is not usually this involved
but he's very much almost every role in one leading the school.
And now a women's class so these girls as I said if I was there at the same time
they would have two years left but now they just have one.
Everything's like a performance with him you know very musical
and the exams in his case they've changed slightly they really feel like a show
and interestingly we never used to applaud in the exams they used to be more quiet
and something that you know we watch in silence unless something was particularly impressive but
the amount of times they applaud in this is a lot and yeah it's not it's not what we used to do.
It's nice though for them I'm sure that person whose phone went off is going to be fired.
After watching I have watched this a little bit I feel like the plie is the only one and only calm
moment the exam for them. I also noticed the girls are a lot smaller and sort of more athletic
looking now I don't know whether that's if that's just this grade this year because you know each
class can change quite a lot and because these girls are quite young still in their development
you know they've still got a lot of strength to build and they all will keep building it until
into their mid-20s you know into their 30s. I find I imagine Nikolai has these has this sort of ideal
these ideal exercises in his head with the music he's obviously a very musical
person I reckon he finds the music first and choreographs to the music rather than
choreographing exercises but you can just see some of the girls I mean these double
soutenus are nice impressive but I've but it's kind of like we've done plie and now
we're just going to go a little bit crazy the double soutenus are impressive though
so yes I imagine he finds the music and then um nice backbends but like I don't know why
they're clapping now you know but as you can see like it does it does get really quick for them
um which I don't think is always necessary but the exams are visibly quicker you know
especially when we start doing the grand jeté and those are nice to look at the swings of the leg
but because it's so quick you can see how especially these girls on the side like
you know we can't they can't get the legs up to the Vaganova extension height you know
the grand rondes just don't go as high they're like just above 90 which maybe he wants
but every extension so far is is quick there's not many there's not many holds of the legs you know
which is again interesting even when we lift the leg it's relatively quick
our breasts are kind of 90 degrees because obviously he's put in
a lot of pirouettes and the extensions they're it's funny they're okay
um but they're very different to how Vaganova what Vaganova is known for you know we're kind
of known for our extensions I do like the music I do like how he's put in the music um
so it kind of continues but also is giving them a rest that girl on the end has a nervous a nervous
fidget like me I had that I do like the girl in the middle she's um got a nice nice physique um
I do feel like Nikolai is obsessed with pirouettes they're they're in every single combination
and not just once but a thousand times but you see even when we're lifting the legs like it's
a little bit smacked up and coming down there's not there's not many holds nice clean doubles
and that would usually be quite high so it just seems um there's a difference in
priority you know there's a difference in what is felt to be important to show off important to show
which is very interesting um and now it's frappe which means we're not just going to get a little
you see they start to look a little not so together
straight into combat mode so it's interesting I kind of watching that and this is to no fault
of the girls or anything I'm just kind of interested in seeing they didn't feel it
didn't feel like there was a definitive adage moment you know like oh beautiful lines beautiful
I didn't really see that and that's that's something which we're used to seeing just like
in awe of um the the expression and the artistry
there's not too much of that and he does love a little balançoire at the end
I think if you compare that to one of his um we're coming to the center now
I think if you compare that to one of his boys um the first boys class he did the exam
there's loads of similarities loads of swinging of the legs and
lots of balançoire really quick changes of direction tons of pirouettes yeah he likes those
whether it's necessary I just feel like because they've got a year left um they still have
some strengthening to do um they look a little a little bit like they've been trained in a
oh I'll be very interested to see the other teachers as well also to see how like
different years develop with different teachers especially ones that have been there pre
so now we do the tendu and now they have their pointe shoes on
and this is something I I don't know much about um in terms of why
he I mean he's changed many things but um why he put them in pointe shoes straight away
almost straight away so they do the jumps in the pointe shoes and I can probably guess
why to have them more sort of company ready to and get be more used to the pointe shoes you know
being able to jump in them it's and being able to do adage in them requires more stability
and not only that you can probably do more combinations within the hour
because it's still the same length of time for the exam but um but yeah there's so there must
be you know more jumps and obviously he does a lot of uh very nickel I think you know makes
them do little variations and um little things it's just very quick all the time all the time
it's very quick I mean nice and already jumping I mean they're warm but you know still
but at the moment I would say as well what is also interesting is um there's no real definitive
um dancer or dancers which are really kind of catching my eye you know they're all they're
all nice dancers um but there's no there's no kind of real I want to say you know august
manova type star kind of quality coming out at me I'm not even talking just kind of lines and
technique I'm just I'm just talking about even just kind of aplomb and presence um I feel like
I'm more focused on the combinations which are in front of me and looking at the impressive
choreography and combinations rather than noticing a particular dancer or I want to say star you know
yeah you know even in Maria Horovitz class who was um obviously she had Kovalova and Kovalova
would really bring out the artistry in people there was there was several several definitive
dancers in her classes in her class including obviously Maria and obviously last year in Maria
in Kovalova's class the other Maria who's gone to Bolshoi was also
very interesting but she um you can that's the 2023 reaction analysis I did she looked very
Bolshoi though and it kind of suits her that she's gone there um she's doing really well
she's great but she did she did look Bolshoi just a little bit more
out there less classically refined looking it's sort of like a Novikova so now they do this kind
of this sort of variation thing um with lots of passe's and retirees I think um which again is
interesting I just don't know whether it's um strictly necessary but um again why not
but I'm trying to think you know what does this um what would this necessarily
show other than sure a little bit of character
a little bit of character but it's not necessarily technically technically challenging
but maybe it's his way of getting in some of the some of the syllabus in there
but I'm also yeah it's interesting but it just seems it just seems to me a little bit
out of place like with the the clicking and things
while it's nice it's like let's save this for character
but again I just feel like he he likes to
put on a whole performance but it's that honestly seemed like
that wasn't really that necessary and it seemed like let's let's tire them out for not much
not much reason you know and especially because it was really short as well it was kind of like um
not really sure what that was but again it was nice and enjoyable I just don't know whether it's
um needed right now and then we go back into the exam it just felt a bit a bit strange to put in
there I would understand if someone wanted to put in maybe like queen of the dryads you know like
oh let's do or something like that that makes more sense to me I do like this girl in front
I would say she's the the most interesting one to me you see this girl in the middle just looks
like she's a little a little bit more in touch with her artistic side and the lines a little bit
these are really tough you know they're doing very well like I said there's no there's no issue um
necessarily with technique they're they're very capable and they're not going to have
um too much shock when they join a company in terms of speed and they'll be prepared um but
it's more so at this age you kind of want more priority on certain things potentially you know
like for example even when you when you compare to someone such as you know
May Nagahisa in the Marinsky who trained at Princess Grace and who obviously has developed
and grown up in the Marinsky under fabulous coaches she has beautiful beautiful quality
about her um and even people like
Renata Shakirova who's recently been named ballerina prima ballerina
she was less like you know um Novikova or Lepak kind of type but more energetic
terrestrial type but there was still that kind of very star quality coming out
so now we're jumping a bit more
and again because it's quick we can't they're not massively showing
the lines you know just above 90 the legs just above 90
I want to see those legs up
I want to see nice heels forwards these girls look kind of quite small don't they
I wonder how tall they are
I'm just curious
I mean it's all challenging yeah they get run of course that's a good
it's it's very challenging technically but I feel like um you know I want to see a little bit more
detail in how they're landing and the turnout and things like really drill that in more so than
making them go faster obviously some schools do that and it's it's like the way they do things
it's just um what I'm focused on here is how it's different to before because it is very
very different like you know let me know if you want me to do even even a comparison of um
a few exercises of you know seventh grade in this exam the seventh grade a few years back
because even less so about the girls themselves it's more like we can see the difference in
combinations and and also just see if it's possible you know more possible with you know
slightly more focused combinations to bring out that artistry you know because I think
it it is more focused on I know that girl's very struggling doing these these three
difficult difficult turns to ecote
tricky so quick so quick I mean gosh me me at um 16 and 17 I would struggle
they're coping I mean they've been doing this every day so they get it but my gosh
you guys know I practiced in the studio a lot at night I would be practicing
trying to force my body all right let's pause there trying to force my body to
make it go quicker good my goodness me so now we're gonna fast forward a little bit
and just see more towards the end so the last few 20 minutes to the end I'd love to know your
thoughts as well all right so let's continue now so we're gonna just watch the last 20 minutes or
so and I'd love to know you know is anyone really standing out to you bearing in mind these girls
these girls graduate next year so if it was August Minerva's class or something or
Novikov I keep using them as examples or Maria Khoreva
it would be clear right it would be like ah let's see what she does next year
I'd also be interested to know how many of these girls are Russian and how many are foreign
they also you know you can see that they look a little bit like different dancers they look
at like a different build a little bit more athletic looking which again is completely
fine it's you know it's it's more so the Verganova usually in like steers towards
this kind of very willowy looking shape so again but it's possible I was chatting to
a male teacher of mine a friend it's possible because because these girls are being trained by
a man you know it's possible the combinations are a little bit more
you know into the ground a little bit more maybe he does a lot of jumps
and it's possible that that would have impact on things like that
from from repertoire and each combination would feel like a little ballet within itself
whereas now it seems like each combination is kind of it's kind of blending you know
it's kind of blending and there'll be a highlight at some point but you know this is what I'm saying
kind of all these all these combinations are kind of getting lost a little bit
because the music is quite it's quite flat I really wonder what Altanay would think if she
came oh my gosh I just loved her she was great she was tough she was tough but she was so funny
hilarious and not afraid to let you know she's not happy
this combination I find very interesting because I just feel like they don't arrive
in the arabesque and it looks quite secabesque like it just kind of extends and goes down I
don't really see it and it's a little bit out to the side you know like it doesn't look like
it's behind them I love that jump it's tough it looks like it's kind of out to the side and I
don't know yeah that's a nice pose from the girl on the left I liked her that pose they must be so
tired oh my gosh what's funny is you know I wonder if this this exam ends up like I wonder
if other exams such as Kovalova's or or Grabanova's end up also filmed in this way beautifully and put
online um or whether it's it's just a showcase of Tskharitsi's lessons so he's just mentioned
something I was speaking but we'll see I imagine it it's some sort of piece again because he kind
of introduced it and they're all here okay yeah it's another another little another little ballet
in the middle of it I mean these girls also look they all look um kind of nice and and and happy
you know which is nice to see I do wonder what the relationship is like um with Tskharitsi and
whether he's nice and um I'm sure he's very good with um I hope you know considering he he really
took under his wing Angelina Vorontsova I imagine he's he's good with girls and in terms of he
probably pushes them hard but yeah they they don't look you know terrified or anything they look kind
which is good tough I wonder if it is I wonder if Tskharitsi's been on point before
and he knows how tough this is
they're doing well it's quite hard doing a double rond into another hop but they're doing they're
doing good there's his nice his nice girl he likes again I would say these girls look like
um already sort of like they're working professionals but they look like sort of
like they're company members and no one's massively standing out um if any of these
girls watch I would say you guys are doing great um again I'm just studying how it was different
to when I was there but I would say you gotta you know give yourself perform show us why you're you
and think about all those little details even more I want you to think about where your heels
are you know where your where your arm and head is like there I would leave the head more on the
rhombus a little bit and present the heels more when when you put down the heel before the the
and and lift the head when you jump
what's what is lacking for me is all the little in between steps and those are the things when
I used to watch Olga Smirnova a lot I used to watch her a lot um when um she was a year above me
this girl's nice on the left I like her she seems like she's got personality and she's cute
um but I would say like I'm I'm lacking like the in between such as how they step even
you know I want to see almost you know a bit more longer legs and taking up the space taking up the
room that was one thing I massively noticed in people like Olga is like she she thought about
every single step you know it was like I saw the feet and the hips leading and the
the arms and how she was leaving the head it's why she's so great why you're mesmerized by her
just moving her arm which I don't quite get that with these girls you know I'm not getting that
quite yet so they have one more year they have nice jumps though I mean they should
because they're training with again someone who probably focuses a lot on jumps
she has a nice I like that one in front she's got a nice nice face
they're doing well
we clap we clap
now it wouldn't surprise me now that we're progressing
that some of them start to stand out more they've got big smiles
and this girl in front is obviously very nice at um jumps but I'm not getting the um
the Vaganova purity from them you know not quite as much as it used to be
but they have quite nice jumps and they have nice nice pirouettes
but even there you know it would be it would be much more bend much more bend
and the Assemblée it's just so it's just so fascinating to me I keep mentioning it because
I just keep thinking about it they all they're all nice but they kind of don't necessarily look
like like if they were all in different leotards and they weren't in this room
I'm not sure I'd think they were necessarily at least not all of them I wouldn't necessarily
think they were from him you know usually that's super obvious like oh my gosh where did you train
oh my gosh you must be from Vaganova you know just by the aplomb and everything and um
yeah it's it's not super it's not super obvious um because like the system the system's changing
for sure the system is changing
but nice nice chin up by the blonde girl there
I like this music that's nice with the head
it's all the step steps and glissades in between she's nice this this girl in front
I think they must be tired my gosh
these two in front honestly look I look um identical
like they're almost identical heights I don't know if they're related
I'm not just saying that because their heights are um the same they actually look facially
similar as well maybe they are sisters if you guys are watching I'm so sorry if you're not
sisters but hopefully you're friends I would say the jump quality in the jump is there
I would say everyone needs to think a little bit more how they're getting in and out of things
and I would say girls if you're if you're listening really think about your adage as well
and prioritize maintaining that maintaining your lines and and having beautiful lines because
those those really stand out don't lose that you know lots of hops and arabesque he does like those
I feel like we've been doing we've been doing this these jumps for
for like 15 minutes but he we are slowly progressing I think
oh yeah we're doing said a busk like I said they're all nice there's um if I went away and
had to talk about it later I would probably I would probably just remember um one of the
smaller girls who had the nice I would think what it is I would remember and what's important to me
and I would remember this girl in front because just the tall one because she has
she has some presence about her I would remember um that this one on the right because she has nice
expression and facial quality which draws me in more she has nice quality that one
she dances bigger and taller than she is you know whereas that's it you know I'm not I'm not
really remembering anyone because of their amazing technique you know um and I and I do think that's
what it chalks down to it's it's down to someone who has who has it all you know who has the
technical oh careful who has the technical ability and who has the star quality at this
stage like I'm not expecting a polished um a polished performance you know or a polished
dancer like a like a a fully ready dancer necessarily like they're still young even
la pacana when she was graduating she still had a lot of strength to do but it was very clear
she had that star quality you know you could see it and she had she had wonderful lines and
wonderful sense of music and wonderful wonderful clear sense of where her priorities were in her
dancing and walking away from that there's there's no one that sparked me as um they have that real
depth of what they're doing um in this in this class anyway
it honestly feels like more of a showcase of of choreography
I think it's about to get more complicated because we're gonna pirouette I bet for
the next the next 10 minutes what these girls would have gotten better at in the
last year is pirouettes I'm sure they do pirouettes 24 7 those turns are a lot about
coordination pk turns to be honest especially for these girls probably feels like a rest
they're not that difficult once you know what you're doing they're actually really fun
what I'd like to see more is more like step out step out a little bit more brave they've been so
doing crazy stuff you know they've been doing crazy stuff the last hour and now all of a
sudden now all of a sudden it almost feels tame you know like I'm sure those girls could do 32
you know what's also kind of lacking for me which is really interesting
is everyone's retirees just look a little bit in like they don't look quite flat
like it doesn't look like the hip is really rotated these pico turns look
look um really like they're not stepping out enough like you should almost jump on to point
you know really stepping out and all of a sudden we're going back to basics you know we're going
back to a simple pico monage and it looks like they're slightly struggling with it but that's
that's what I mean like it's it's much harder to slow down and show really show things clearly
which is so interesting my goodness I would say she I would want her to hold her retiree
that was pretty nice pretty nice see I want the retiree a little bit more open because she opens
it whilst it's still a little bit turned in these are the ones that I think are sisters they're
probably not and all of a sudden the girl who can turn very well even so I would love the arms to be
more rounded and also more supported nice at pirouettes she'd probably be a good key tree
you know lots of jumps in that lots of jumps I don't know whether Marinsky though
what's interesting is you know these girls don't they don't look Marinsky you know um
they look more like they do
they do better in like I don't know even like a Europe or America you know I can't imagine them
at Marinsky which is very strange for me to say honestly maybe this taller girl maybe this
slightly taller girl um and it's not necessarily it's not really down to her height it's down to
the quality like this girl in front I can imagine her I can imagine her at Marinsky
I can imagine her at Marinsky yeah but she doesn't stand out as
real ah something they're always together these two I mean look those girls those girls would
probably do quite well at the Royal Ballet or something I can imagine them doing Cupid or
something I can do imagine this girl doing like key tree or something but I'm not sure if
necessarily Marinsky that would be interesting um to find out where everyone ends up with these
kinds of pirouettes oh I would love the Ritteri to finish more to the front because you can see
if I pause that and slowed it down the Ritteri would be coming down a little bit parallel
like you can see it's just not quite opening but she finishes clean which is good
she finishes clean good I'm all about clean I feel like everyone's disappeared and it's
just like it's just a lot it's suddenly now just these four I mean what's very interesting
you know I don't think Yuri Fateev is here today um he will come and watch next year
the director of Marinsky this girl is nice this girl has some sort of like purity and precision
about her and and clean aesthetic and lines she's the closest to the Vaganova academy look
um from this
but it seems like we're approaching the end more emphasis on pirouettes more emphasis on speed
more emphasis on on quickness and choreographic showcase a bit more flashy a bit more tricksy
oh my gosh they must be dead oh very sweet very sweet oh my gosh I would love to get in the heads
of people I wonder what they think lots of flowers yeah the pianist was great though she worked very
hard she basically did not stop for an hour she did really well that's hard oh she's so lovely
she's so lovely bless her bless her the pianists kind of see everything you know they're an
observer of the highs the lows this is very interesting oh there's um Tarasova one of the
coaches or at the Marinsky love to know what she thought my gosh I mean everyone's hugging him and
everything so interesting so interesting wow so I would say oh my gosh interesting I would say that
went really well for them like you know they all did they all did really well they all did what
they were needing to do for Tiscalizzi like and um in the exam like nothing visibly went wrong
and I'm sure that was I'm sure they've spent the whole year on that like getting their speed up
being able to do you know double soutenus again and again a thousand pirouettes and it is an
impressive exam um where my point of view is someone who was there before with Alton Eye and
who obviously adores um the classicism and the purity of the Vaganova method the Vaganova
academy Vaganova method you know as opposed to the bourgeois um Vaganova method um which is
obviously slightly different um it's it's very interesting for me to see because it's um extremely
different and it's producing different dancers you know as you can see like they look different
they don't look pure Marinsky you know they look like um a little bit more flashy a little bit more
brash um like for example if you put one of those girls in next to Smirnova and Maria Horova
even at their age um it would be like night and day in terms of the style the style would look
very different and the maturity of artistic um artistic presence and um ability to express
in an extremely artistic way would also be um kind of obvious so yeah and then so I feel like
there's so much emphasis on speed there's so much emphasis on on technical pirouette ability I mean
our teacher you know not to say our teacher didn't focus on it like we did many many difficult
pirouettes um many many difficult things but it wasn't wasn't like the the main focus you know um
the main focus was being extremely correct extremely pure um having extremely beautiful
lines and expression and bringing she was she was bringing that out of us daily you know it really
felt like she was um really trying to make us into our own individual artists nonetheless it's going
to be really really interesting to see so guys thank you so much for watching I hope you don't
mind my very honest feedback and opinions um I'm not here to necessarily say what's happening is
is wrong I'm just kind of observing and letting you all know my honest thoughts and um yeah I
think it's kind of obvious though that we can see that it's changing um but deep down deep down in
my heart I would um I'm really desperate for it to retain its beautiful purity and classicism and
what makes it so wonderfully great you know and there is a there is a little worry in me that
that's changing there is a little worry in me that priorities are put elsewhere but
things change and we'll see what happens but um I hope it's all for for the greater good
so guys let me know what you thought in the comments I hope you enjoyed this video I know
a lot of you wanted to hear my thoughts so there they are and I wish you a wonderful day keep
dancing and really focus on those details and your artistic presence your maturity whilst you're
dancing make all your lines extremely beautiful extremely clear and really build those foundations
well because it will build you up to be able to to be able to do anything you don't want any
limitations and I'll speak to you guys very very soon bye for now before you go if you enjoyed this
video you're really going to enjoy my bwi platform try it for 14 days absolutely free whether you're
a beginner or a professional we have everything you'll need to succeed we have classes courses
which are in-depth lessons plans as well as bespoke plans whether you're struggling with
organization and you just really need to know exactly what to do maybe you watch endless videos
on youtube but you don't even know if the level you're watching is catered to you well that's
where bwi comes in try it for 14 days and you won't regret it