How School District Central Offices Drive Equitable Teaching and Learning | Gutman Book Talks

Academy: stories and events
54 followers
Good afternoon everyone. Welcome to our last, our final book talk of 2024.
Thank you for being here. I would like to start by introducing Shannon Davis,
who's the Senior Acquisitions Editor at Harvard Education Press.
Shannon, you can take it from here. Thank you, Maayan. Thank you all for
joining us today and welcome to the Guttman Library Book Talk for From Tinkering to
Transformation. As Maayan said, my name is Shannon Davis and I'm Senior Acquisitions
Editor at Harvard Education Press. Today, it is my great pleasure to introduce you to Meredith
Honig, co-author of From Tinkering to Transformation, How School District Central
Offices Drive Equitable Teaching and Learning, published by HEP last November. Dr. Honig is a
professor of education policy, organizations, and leadership at the University of Washington,
where she also founded and directs the District Leadership Design Lab. Her research and
partnerships focus on the redesign of school district central offices to ensure that all
students experience an excellent and equitable education, particularly Black, Indigenous,
and Latinx students, students living in low income circumstances, and others historically
underserved by public schools. She is co-author of Supervising Principles for Instructional
Leadership, a Teaching and Learning Approach, with Lydia Rainey, published by HEP in 2020,
and a co-author of Learning-Focused Leadership in Action, Improving Instruction in Schools and
Districts, published by Routledge in 2014. Meredith, thank you so much for being here today.
Thank you.
It is also an honor to introduce our moderator for today's book talk. Please welcome Dr.
Jennifer Cheatham, Senior Lecturer on Education here at HGSE and co-chair of the Public Education
Leadership Project. A former superintendent of Madison Metropolitan School District, Dr. Cheatham
has extensive practice experience in leading for equity and transformational change in school
districts. She is currently the co-chair of the Collaborative on Political Leadership in the
Superintendency and co-author of Entry Planning for Equity-Focused Leaders, Empowering Schools
and Communities with Rodney Thomas and Adam Parrott-Shafer, published by HEP in 2022.
Welcome, Dr. Cheatham, and thank you for being here today.
Thanks, Shannon.
Yes, and thank you, Gutman Library, for hosting this book talk. We will listen to your conversation
and then reserve the last 15 minutes or so for a Q&A from our viewers. And with that,
I will turn it over to you, Meredith and Jen.
All right, thank you. Hey, Meredith.
Hey, Jen, how are you?
Good. I'm really excited about this conversation with you. And I want to highlight just a few
more things or additional things or punctuate some things about your background, because I
really appreciate what it is that you do and what you brought to this book. I mean, of course,
you're a researcher, a scholar who has studied a variety of policy reforms, but you also used to
run the EDD program at the University of Washington. So you've worked with many
doctoral students over the years who are striving to be practitioners in the field.
And you are the director of the District Leadership Design Lab, which is an entity
that works directly with school districts on the transformation of central office and key
divisions within central office. So you bring, you know, your research background,
your background as someone who has supported doctoral students striving to become system
of elite. Jen, we lost your volume.
Jennifer, sorry, we can't hear you.
Did I disappear there for a minute?
That was fun. It was a good start.
I, we've known each other for a long time, but even before I knew you, I was using your work
as foundational to the work of the central offices, the central office.
Your volume went out again.
A question that has been on my mind. Can you hear me okay?
Now we can. Yeah, it went out again.
I'm going to work on figuring this out. But in the meantime, let me ask you this question.
You are one of the only people now.
Sorry, Jennifer, we cannot hear you again.
No, sorry, we couldn't hear you. We can't hear you still.
I'm happy to get started. I know what you're going to ask me.
It's amazing how that works. You were going to ask me, you're one of the only people, you know,
maybe the only one who thinks this much about the role of the central office in school districts.
You don't exactly write this, but why the hell do I do that?
I think you actually wrote, why did this become such an interest of yours,
which is a much more Harvard way to say that?
And how has that interest grown or changed over time?
I really appreciate that question.
If you asked me 20 years ago, when I started this work,
if I'd be looking at school districts or even looking within schools,
I might have been surprised to find out that's what I was going to be doing.
Because I started my career, I started my work
caring about school community partnerships and the relationship between
community resources, community assets, and schools.
And always cared about scale, always cared about policy, and so wanted to, you know,
was really thinking about how to make more of these rich partnerships I was seeing between
schools and community agencies that were trying to serve whole children and really embrace
historically marginalized students' cultures and knowledge as resources
for their own learning, for other students' learning, and for schools.
And I was working for a couple state agencies early in my career, and my charge included
supporting school districts and supporting schools in realizing those kinds of projects.
And through that, really early on, met amazing people working in school district central offices
who were really trying to innovate, to rethink their work, and do that in a way that was really
responsive to what was working at the school level.
And then, you know, as I was working in these state agencies, found just a real lack of research
on school district central offices generally, and specifically related to how they support
schools and kind of being their best selves, being their best places for kids.
And I did my first research project.
My first research project, like for many people, was my dissertation.
And I was working with a school district trying to understand how, you know, that problem that
I brought from my practice, so how are school districts trying to help schools innovate,
in that case, specifically around school community partnerships.
And from there, really, you know, district leaders, district staff showed me the way.
So my first study was of these kind of renegade alternative central office staff people trying
to use the experience of school community partnerships to leverage change in the central
office, and they ran up against so many barriers as they were trying to figure out what their work
is and how do they push for changes in the rest of the system, and then met central office people
trying to move beyond those kinds of initiatives.
They were working on new small autonomous schools initiatives, which said, okay, we want,
as a central office, we want to foster school innovation.
How do we make that the main work of the system, not the work of just like an initiative,
like a school community partnership initiative?
And then just we, I just think, got very lucky at that point because we saw the limitations of
trying to leverage central office change, even through a district-wide initiative.
And you know this.
You were in Chicago at the time trying to do some of that work and got lucky in the
sense that we found districts that were taking the central office as the change project in
and of itself and really seeing that the central offices we have are not the central offices
we need.
If we're now going to do the work school systems need to do, which is foster deeper
learning and embrace diversity and foster culturally responsive teaching.
I love that, Meredith.
And sorry for my tech glitches earlier.
Someone came to the rescue.
Thank you, Jalmeta, for sending someone over here.
Jal is watching.
I have two teenagers at home, so I just start talking whenever there's an opportunity.
I'm so glad you just jumped in there like that.
But I do want to ask you, Meredith, I mean, I love that this has become your interest,
that your interest has grown over time.
It will continue to be something that you work on in partnership with school districts.
But tell us a little bit more about the research that you have done.
Like, how do you do it?
Where do your findings come from?
Tell us about the research.
Yeah, I mean, my students ask me often, you know, how do we decide what methods to use?
And I always say you start with your questions.
What do you want to know?
And what's the best way to know that?
And what are your values?
What knowledge do you value?
And I have always valued the daily work of people in school systems who get up every
morning and try to do the right work on behalf of kids.
So our research is very much grounded in the practice of what people are doing.
So the book that we're talking about today is based on really over 1,000 hours of observations.
So we sat in on meetings that sometimes people in those meetings would turn to us and say,
why are you here?
I don't want to be here.
But we love those meetings of central offices trying to do the work, trying to figure out
what new work is within central offices.
We shadowed people.
We followed them to their cars.
A lot of them, just no one ever asked them, hey, what do you do?
And how's it going?
And so it was not challenging to have people call us on their way home from work and tell
us about their day and what they were working on.
But it was really important that we be there in real time observing things as they unfold.
And it was also really important to us that we take a strengths-based approach.
I mean, I'm a student of decades of scholarship on implementation.
We already know there are many challenges to implementing anything of value in education
and in other sectors.
So we don't want to rediscover all that.
And we don't think we need more stories of what's not working.
So we try to put ourselves in districts where we think based on other people's research,
based on theory, based on just our living in the world and practice, places where we
think people are doing the right work.
And we assume that it's hard.
And we try to pick places where the conditions seem right for it to go well.
And we normalize that the work is hard and that there are challenges.
And we try to understand how people navigate their way through those.
But the doing of research as part of our commitments to advancing educational equity,
and I know I speak for Lydia on this as well, was really important to us because we both had
been in different arenas, connecting with practitioners, being in practice,
and just finding major gaps in knowledge.
And so we felt like this was a particular contribution we could make to the field.
That's great, Meredith.
This is not a question I was planning on asking you, so bear with me.
But I understand why you focus on central office because it's so overlooked, quite honestly.
And I understand more based on what you just said about how you go about
learning about central office, especially those who are trying to do effective work.
But why is central office important?
Even if they were to do their work well, why do we need them?
Well, tell us a little bit about why they matter.
Right.
And I was planning to do this, and so I am going to ask you after I say something
to say something yourself because you are an area officer in Chicago Public Schools.
You're superintendent of Madison Public Schools.
So I would just love to hear your thoughts on this as well.
There's increasing talk now of the importance of districts, of states
across the political spectrum being agents of what we care about.
And especially in an equity arena, districts in the United States are just in this incredibly
important position between schools and their communities and broader government,
from which many resources flow despite local funding formulas.
They're just in such an essential position to understand what we know at the school level,
which is often an untapped source of knowledge, informing policy.
And to mediate for schools what is coming from the federal government,
the state government, and also private funders who have major initiatives,
I know, and other potential distractors from the right work.
And also in the last 10 or 15 years, there's been a great amount of work
that's really important about the district role in fostering research use and data use
within schools.
So it's just like the nexus of so many things.
And because it's been so neglected, there's both that challenge of not having had
investment over time in building their capacity, and also this incredible potential
not to do the same old thing, and really think about new ways of working in that essential space.
Yeah, I love that, Meredith.
I think similarly, meaning that the central office is well-positioned to create the conditions
for schools to do their best work on behalf of children and families.
I mean, schools are so close to children and families, right?
When it comes to kind of the granular day-to-day decision-making about what's
right, that is the school's purview, as it should be.
But the central office is a place that can both provide resources, right?
Not just resources, time, money, people, technology.
But also they're well-positioned to address barriers to progress.
And I like what you said about how they also can be kind of a translator,
but they can also be a hub for information exchange, right?
Not just locally, right?
Across schools in a community, but across districts, right?
Helping us share and learn from one another.
Central office is a really well-positioned to do so.
Yeah, I mean, so much potential if they function well.
For sure.
And as a student of equity scholarship, I think that scholarship also has not
spent much direct time focused on central offices.
In fact, when I was first starting out as a researcher, a very famous equity scholar
whose opinion I deeply value and work I admire said to me, in the most loving way possible,
she said, if you care so much about equity, why would you focus on central offices?
And I think, I mean, so I think your question is really important because I think some people are,
when things are challenging, when things aren't working,
we can sometimes maybe too quickly give up on the central systems we have.
Yeah.
I mean, a great promise of school districts is to be the keepers of equity.
And when they don't do that, they get in the way of equity.
So as you know, like from the first chapter of our book, we start with a review of equity
research, which doesn't name central offices, but it names just a long list of central office
functions that typically interfere with realizing equity in schools.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
We have to pay attention to that, especially since, you know, you didn't go to work in a
school district central office and say, hey, how can I get in the way of equity every day?
And your, you know, central office staff across the country are often,
that we need to ask the exact opposite.
So why is it that those systems have been so impervious to the values and the orientations
of the people working there?
How can we center central office staff as drivers of how those systems work?
I love that.
Okay, Meredith, let me ask you this, because the book's title is about transformation.
And so we're not just talking about, you know, well-functioning central offices.
We're talking about central office transformation.
Tell us more about what it is and what it's not.
And maybe you want to start with what it's not before you tell us what it is.
Yes, for sure.
So anyone who's heard me talk before know I'm a big fan of the reorg.
The central office reorganization, which is the number one strategy
of every superintendent across the country.
You had a reorg.
Did you love your reorg?
We all reorg.
I know, yes.
I've been through multiple reorgs.
Yeah.
I know what you're talking about.
Yeah, so central office transformation isn't the reorg.
It's not, although it includes a new organizational chart, which is what we're talking about.
But it's not mainly the moving around of offices.
It's not the renaming of offices.
And it's also not cross-functional teams or the closer connecting of central office to
schools in and of itself, right?
So the reorg in and of itself and decentralization strategies, cross-functional teams themselves
tend not to get to transformation, which we and the people we've worked with define as
fundamental shifts in the core work that central office do.
So if a reorg is the result of a deep rethinking of the values that drive a central office
and work realigned to those values, then it could indicate transformation.
But typically, it's more, here's what our new offices are.
Here's our staffing pattern without the rethinking.
Similarly, with all good intentions, central office staff will say, we want to be in schools
more.
We want to learn more from people at the school level, and then we'll know how to serve them
better.
And I wish that worked, but it often doesn't.
And in fact, central office staff often come away from those visits with long lists of
requests from principals and teachers that they can't manage.
And when you were a principal, when the central office staff came and left, did they help
you?
And a lot of the principals in our studies found those visits actually really stressful.
They stressed their teachers out, and they took time.
And it's not to say that central office staff should not be in closer contact with their
schools.
Of course, they should.
But central office transformation is about asking the question, what are we as a central
office all about?
What are our core values?
And how are we aligning our work to those values?
Yeah.
And if you're really serious about answering that question, you take an anti-racist historical
view of central office and start with a recognition that central offices were set up over 100
years ago not to support great teaching and learning.
They were set up to do other things, like manage enrollments and ensure compliance with
licensure and other things.
And they were also set up to socialize students in ways that really are the opposite of what
culturally responsive teaching is all about.
So now you've got this 100-year-old institution that we now look to to foster deeper teaching
and learning, as well as embrace diversity and foster culturally responsive teaching.
And just institutionally, it's not set up to do that.
So this idea of transformation is about just really understanding that institutional mismatch
between the central offices we have and the central offices we need, and just starting
from a new set of assumptions about how the central office should work.
Yeah, I love that.
In your book, you talk in one of the initial chapters about these kind of big principles.
One is that the central office works in service of equitable teaching and learning, right?
That is the role that everyone in central office matters to realizing equitable teaching
and learning, and that central office must work in partnership with school principals.
I wonder if there are any of those premises that you would want to break down a little
bit more for us, Meredith, and why they're important.
For sure.
Why don't you choose?
Which one stands out for you?
Well, they all stand out.
Can I just say that?
I mean, I know that when I was in Madison, we did a lot of work on strengthening central
office.
That's also true in Chicago and when I was in San Diego working at central office.
We've always been striving to understand the role and better execute on that role.
This feels like it's been an ongoing theme in my own professional career, but I definitely
think that over years, I've found myself continually working with central office leaders,
especially the big division and department leaders, on understanding what their work
looks like when it's done equitably, right?
What does equity folks leadership look like for you if you are the head of HR, if you
are the head of finance, if you are the head of transportation, if you are the head of
the literacy department, right?
Like, what does it mean for me to be leading for equity in my role?
We used to, at least, well, both in Chicago and Madison, we regularly got central office,
everybody together, everyone in every role together to reconnect to why our work matters,
like how it is either enabling or constraining excellent teaching and learning.
Quarterly, we would have these big meetings and kind of revisit that idea.
But the one that stands out to the most to me, honestly, Meredith, is the idea of central
office working in partnership with school principals.
I remember when I first heard you talk about that and had that same discussion with central
office leaders, that they struggled with it a little bit.
They struggled with the principal as potential clients.
And I was especially lucky to speak to that principal because I think it's different.
For sure, yeah.
And so what you're describing is really what we have, the kind of work we have the opportunity
to study, right?
So you're talking about being in your system and recognizing that the entire system needs
to work in service of equitable teaching and learning, which some people hear as kind
of a negative thing or too challenging, but it's really a strengths-based way of saying
you all matter and we need to make sure the work you're doing is the right work.
So there was a lot of what you're saying, engagement of staff to figure out what could
your work look like if it were advancing equitable teaching and learning.
And in almost every single unit, in the buildings and grounds unit, in HR and teaching and learning,
there was somebody or some team of people in larger systems who principals always said
we want them.
We want them to be our person.
We want them helping us.
And part of what the transformation reform was, was to really elevate the leadership
of those people to identify what they're doing that was working and then engage their
colleagues in thinking through how can we work differently.
So a lot of that happened within traditional work areas, like the people who provided
professional development to schools did that work, and the HR analysts did that work.
But what got really powerful is when they said the entire system needs to work in service
of equitable teaching and learning.
So the next work was, okay, we have an initial conception of what our work looks like, but
if we work in that way, our work alone isn't enough to get there.
So how do we think about our working as an entire system?
Because otherwise you get all these different parts of the central office trying to get
into schools to help, and it gets really unstrategic.
So part of this was to really be much more strategic, which I do think is related to
your calling out the partnership with principal piece, because it's really about not just
saying each one of us can be in better service to principals, but we are going to partner
with ourselves in the central office and bring principals in to think through kind of how
we can all work together as a system.
And I think it's also, working in partnership with principals also means really just recognizing
the key role of principals.
So central office transformation is not a top-down reform of the central office saying,
hey, principals, now you do this.
It's also not bottom-up reform where you ask principals what they need, because then
you'll get a bunch of answers.
And most principals I know, when we have asked them this, because Lydia and I did some research
on school autonomy initiatives, and so that was all about central office staff asking
principals, what do you need?
And then they'll do that.
And the number one thing principal said, nothing, please don't, please stay away.
And then when you give them permission or create space for them to want something or
to imagine what a support system could look like, how their supervisor could be a partner
with them, which is something they hadn't even maybe thought of before, they have some
pretty strategic answers.
So a lot of this work around the partnership between central office and principals is for
everyone to start to imagine what's possible and for everyone to kind of see themselves
on the same team.
There's one quote in our research that I love where a principal said, this is one of the
first times I've been in a district where I feel like we're all growing in the same
direction.
That is excellent.
And it's funny that we're having this conversation, Meredith, because I was just in the EDLD
course that I teach called Leaders of Learning, and we had an in-depth conversation about
what principals do with their teams to design the school day, right, like the school schedule,
who teaches, which teachers, when, where, and on what, like the puzzle, right, of the
school day and the school year.
As you can imagine, no, it is extraordinarily complicated work and complex.
And then we got into this conversation about, okay, what could central office do, right,
to make, to maximize their ability to do that well, right, while minimizing, you know,
distractions, minimizing barriers, right, et cetera.
And it was a tough conversation, right?
Yeah.
I mean, it was really tough.
And so I want to get actually a little more granular with you, because in the book, like
it's broken down by, I mean, really kind of major functions in central office, and you
demonstrate in the book what transformation looks like from delivery to development in
the teaching and learning division, from staffing to strategy in the human resources
division, from principal supervision to support, from operations to opportunity, from
telling to teaching and learning on the superintendent's cabinet, like you kind of
demonstrate what transformation looks like in all these kind of key functions.
But if we could just focus on the teaching and learning division for a minute, I mean,
I would really love for you to kind of break down, like what does transformation look like
in the teaching and learning division?
What are we coming from?
And where are we going to?
And I will be thinking about this instructional design conversation we've just had with my
class as you talk, and I hope they will too, because they're listening in.
Go ahead, Mary.
And please bring in illustrations of work you did that was consistent with this, because
I know you did.
So, I mean, the teaching and learning function, and I will be brief, don't worry, the teaching
and learning function of central offices varies.
It's probably one of the most variable parts of a central office in terms of what's in
it.
And in smaller systems, it can be one person.
In larger systems, it's hundreds.
Some of the functions are in HR.
But the functions that we put in that chapter under teaching and learning include teacher
professional development, school improvement planning, curricular programs, and data,
working with data.
And typically, those departments, those areas of work of the central office, they are definitely
the historical accumulation of federal funding, state funding, different initiatives.
You know, when Title I funding became available, we got a Title I director.
And then there was math initiatives, and then they became STEM initiatives.
And so we staffed that up, or in a smaller system, we added those responsibilities on
to the same 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 people without really rethinking the whole.
So, as a result, those functions typically are really uncoordinated, and there's also
a lot of competition for limited resources, like teacher time for professional learning,
and substitute teachers in districts that rely on substitute teachers, those kinds of
things.
Oh, yeah.
And they work alone, right?
So, they push with professional development as a main lever of change, when in any other
industry, they start with staffing and thinking about, do we have the right people in the
right seats with the right colleagues so they can be successful?
But HR and teaching and learning typically operate separately.
So, in the districts that we worked with, they said, let's start from what we know about
how people learn.
And people learn not when we do the kinds of things teaching and learning staff typically
do.
They don't, teachers don't learn when you pull them out of their classroom, stick them
in a seat in a central office or in another person's school and deliver a bunch of things
to them.
They get information, and sometimes they express satisfaction and exit tickets from these things.
But when it comes to really shifting their practice and some of the deep ways that teachers
need to, when we talk about deeper learning and culturally responsive teaching and learning,
they really got to be agents of their own learning.
But the values, the underlying assumptions of teacher learning in districts typically
assume if we deliver this PD to teachers, then they'll grow versus if we elevate teachers'
agency to lead their own learning in a common direction, right?
So, we're not, this is not like what anything goes, right?
There's a common district-wide direction with support from colleagues to learn throughout
their day.
Then the lid's off because in a lot of districts, they'll say, well, we just don't have enough
time for learning.
But in a hospital, in a law firm, in a grocery store, learning happens on the job throughout
people's days.
But we don't do the same for teachers, right?
So, the new ideas, which in some districts, thankfully, are not new ideas, like people
know these things.
They just got these jobs and systems where they're doing something else, is to say, okay,
we need to start from building systems that can help teachers lead their own learning.
So, that starts with a really robust professional growth planning process that's anchored in
a clear definition of the kinds of teaching practices that actually help diverse students
grow.
And then the professional learning community becomes a true community of practice where
teachers are, also have the support they need to learn well together.
Because a lot of PLC work, professional learning community work, is around planning teaching
versus supporting teacher learning.
So, part of the shift is to help make those units really learning units.
And part of that starts with staffing, making sure each team has the experience, the expertise
it needs so they can grow well together.
And then, so teaching and learning in the districts we study really shifted from the
delivery of services to the building of that kind of capacity for teachers to lead their
own learning.
They had to redirect some of those resources.
And then they said, well, how are we supposed to know how to support schools?
And the school improvement plan, they would look to those and see, oh, we remember when
we were principals.
We just took that to a coffee shop.
We just did it on the weekend in our free time.
We just filled out the boxes and sent it in.
But what if those reports were actually good intel?
What if they provided great information for us about what schools need?
So, the districts we studied were in the process of redesigning the SIP, again, from teachers
on up.
So, the SIP didn't get done to teachers.
Professional development wasn't getting done to teachers.
But teachers and their teams were trying to lead their own learning, identifying learning
supports they needed that they didn't have on their teams, and then servicing that for
the school improvement plan discussion.
So, the school improvement planning process becomes not just what are we doing for students,
but given what we're trying to realize for students, where are our teachers in their
readiness to be successful with that?
And let's have a plan for supporting their success.
And many school improvement planning processes don't include that adult piece.
Right, right.
And then you're in the central office, and then you're having a very different conversation
with your principal, because your orientation is to support capacity building for leading
your own learning at the school level, not do PD to schools.
And the principal and their leadership team are just getting smarter and smarter about
what their teachers actually need.
Principals always know, like they have a gut sense.
But principals tell us over and over again, you know, I had a hunch of this, but I really
got the data from teachers, and it reaffirmed my thinking or challenged my thinking, extended
my thinking.
So, that kind of rich data conversation about teaching practice is part of the shift.
And then the central office thinks about how can we staff those teams so they can lead
their own learning, and then we'll provide some targeted assistance to each school.
Not everything.
We can't blanket schools with all this support, because the more support, the less support.
There must be a Murphy's Law about that.
Right.
Well, how does that, let me challenge you for an example from your practice, because
I know you have one.
Well, I mean, I have so much bouncing around in my head as I hear you talk, Meredith.
But I actually want us to go into some of these questions.
So, I'll just say quickly that your example, well, there's so much in what you just said.
Your example of using something as seemingly mundane as a school improvement plan and the
related school improvement planning process as a lever for rethinking the relationship
between central office and schools really resonates for me.
And I definitely used it in that way as a tool for empowerment, right?
For school empowerment, so that schools were truly designing a plan that would help them
improve teaching and learning and relatedly the capacity of adults to deliver, right,
on that teaching and learning.
But a tool for insight to central office, but also a tool for reciprocity.
So, maybe you taught me this, Meredith.
I don't know.
Now I'm maybe taking credit for something that you told me to do years ago, which is
totally possible.
But I know we decided when we revamped our school improvement process for these exact
reasons, we also had an attendant plan for the central office departments for every school.
There was an attendant school support plan that central office was held accountable for
by schools, which is a really good lead-in, actually, to one of the questions.
I'm going to go to the questions that I'm seeing come up in the Q&A, and there's one
question that picks up right where I left off.
This is from one of our EDLD students that says, what are some examples and potentially
non-examples of ways that central office leaders can measure the impact of the supports they
provide, right?
So, let's say that they do have a central office, like a support plan for schools.
How do we know whether or not central office is, like, how do we know if they're doing
their work well?
We're really good at measuring schools, aren't we?
Yeah.
Maybe not so good at measuring central office effectiveness.
Yeah.
And again, Jen, I'll invite your thoughts about this, too.
In our book, we talk about measures of performance that are relevant to what each person is doing,
right?
So, it's not meaningful to hold buildings and grounds accountable for improvements in
student achievement.
It's also actually not always meaningful to hold the teaching and learning professional
development people accountable for that, either.
There's so much in between that needs to happen.
And there are so many other influences besides schools that influence test scores and other
things that we continue to relentlessly insist on measuring.
So, in the districts we studied, the staff themselves really came up with performance
metrics.
And at first, many of these related to efficiency things, like speed of response.
But eventually, they became much more related to teaching and learning.
The challenge to them was, can you relate what you're doing to teaching and learning
improvement in a meaningful way?
So, for example, buildings and grounds staff in one of our districts, they were documenting
the increased speed with which they responded to principles, as well as they're being proactive
with principles, right, to make sure that they weren't even taking a minute of principles
time.
But then they can add up those minutes and say, we have just created the potential for
this amount of time by principles to be reinvested in teaching and learning.
I love that.
I think that's terrific.
Yeah, I know we did a lot of thinking about this question.
And in addition to some of the things that you talked about, people kind of defining
their own metrics.
We did do like a regular survey of principles.
I don't remember how frequently it was.
It was at least once a year by department and encourage school-based teams to kind of
rate our service quality, efficiency.
And, you know, I don't remember exactly what the categories were, but people found that
information to be really useful and helpful.
So, and we had the districts we studied had satisfaction surveys also.
And what was really important was that they didn't just have them, but they used them
like in a real, like to support central office staffing getting better.
Right, right.
Which goes to another question.
There's one here about capacity building of central office.
This is the question says new values may drive new functions that require new skills
that present central office may present central office staff may or may not have.
Are there examples of where transformation was possible and co-constructed to leverage
and build capacity?
So this is something about like, how do you actually build people's capacity to function
in a new way?
Yeah, interpreting that.
Yeah, go ahead.
Yeah, so I think the central office transformation stories that we tell are co-construction stories.
There's stories of saying, oh, this person has shown a way forward in terms of what the
new work is.
Here's what the new work is.
Let's start from there and invite staff to think about their readiness to work in those
ways and identify their learning needs.
And so cabinet members, superintendents, chief operations officers, chief academic
officers made investments in central office staff in ways they hadn't before.
So, you know, in one district, they created a pathway to get associates degrees for certain
staff who had hit so many barriers with access to higher education.
And, you know, part of that started with asking central office staff, what do you need?
I mean, in districts with great responsive cultures, we find central office senior leaders
asking schools all the time, what do you need, but not asking their own staff.
And so let's shine that same, you know, humanistic light on our own immediate reports.
And so much of what really helped build capacity at the central office level, like you said,
the simple things we have, like the mundane, like having a new school improvement planning
process, showing staff what their work is.
Yeah.
It's just a huge resource for staff.
Like I, in the book, we have this example of an HR staff person saying, oh, like basically
I was shown to my desk, given a handbook and said, get to work.
And one time I presented that example to a team in an HR unit in a district, and someone
said, that's amazing.
I said, what do you mean?
Because what do you, I mean, you're left, I, what I thought they meant was like, that
isn't that horrible.
And they said, no, it's amazing that they even had a handbook.
Right.
So, yes, a lot of what these leaders were doing was saying, like, we are, as we discover
what the new work is, let's make it really visible and let's help staff know what they're
trying to do and move in that direction.
I mean, it's what we know to do.
And we often don't make that kind of investment in our own central office people.
And then, you know, sure, there are some people who were hired to work in a central office
that I say this all the time, but it's not the central office we now need.
And their skill set is suited to the old way.
And there's plenty of roles those people can play in transition to keep running the system
that a district has while transitioning to the new one.
And we also find many of those people are close to retirement.
And so I guess the key I want to say is the central office leaders really tried to build
capacity of their staff by caring for them.
Yeah.
And so when they it was not uncommon for them when they were dealing with a staff person
whose skill set was outdated, given what the transformation work was to say to them, hey,
what do you think?
Like, is this even a job, this new job?
Do you want to even do it?
Can we find you another position?
Like, what makes sense for you?
And some of those people decided to retire early.
Some of those people said, that's a really great challenge.
Like, in my last years here, I'd love to learn how to do that.
Yeah.
More often than not, though, we hear from central office staff, the work now, the work
of being in a transforming system is the work I came into a central office to do.
So they have the capacity.
It's like it's just been dormant, right?
So it's like central transformation provides spaces for people to wake that up.
Oh, yeah.
I mean, all of it.
I love everything you're saying, Meredith.
I can think of specific individuals whose professional lives were made kind of fresh
and new and vibrant because they found new meaning in what they were doing in food services
and the enrollment office and you name it, because they could see the connection to equitable
teaching and learning, to your point.
I want to try to fit in one or possibly even two more questions, Meredith.
And one is this.
What advice would you have for central office employees trying to lead for more central
office transformation and coherence without a lot of collegial support for it?
So imagine the cabinet is not leading the charge.
You're the head of the department, though, and you yourself are interested in working
in some new ways.
What's your advice if you don't have the institutional support to make these changes?
Yeah, I mean, I would ask what is in your span of control?
What can you do?
What can you make?
I find central office staff have been so stuck in the systems they're in.
They sometimes lose sight of the discretion they have to start new ways of working, to
pilot things, to show what's possible.
I mean, educators typically want to see something like they want to see it in practice.
They want to feel it.
They want to they want to try it out.
So, I mean, I would say just try and engage as best you can, but just to keep going.
And that's I say that aware of different opportunities, different staff.
People have to do that.
I mean, you know, we we work with all kinds of leaders, especially like as we are you
and I are working to diversify the racial makeup, the gender makeup of the superintendency
that, you know, leaders of color have often have had experiences that are so important
to be kind of informing the work.
And many of them are in a pipeline toward the superintendency, so they're not quite
there yet.
And there there's a dilemma, right?
So we're going to get the job, probably the superintendency or the next job by demonstrating
our proficiency with the system we have.
But it's not the system we need.
So how do you how do you manage that that dilemma?
And I love the efforts across the country through different through ASA and others to
really bring people together in affinity groups, racial affinity groups, gender affinity groups
to really think about how to support each other in building those kinds of systems.
But there is there is one of one of my one of the someone who was in one of my first
studies, he used to say there's just a crash and burn element to the right work in school
systems.
You know, you have to be willing to crash and burn.
You have to push it as far as you can.
And it might crash and burn.
It probably will.
But you have created something that people coming next can use as an example.
But often those are personal choices for people in systems to kind of figure out their
support system for that kind of ambitious, challenging and risky work.
Yeah.
What do you think about that?
Well, I'm going to try to squeeze in one more question, actually, Meredith, if it's
OK, because it seems very timely and maybe a good question to end on in our last few
minutes.
So this is going to be tough to be pippy, maybe.
But let's try.
One of the questions, comments in the chat is about the change in presidential administration
and concerns about what that may bring, especially when it comes to ideas on gender and race
in schools.
Given your commitment to equitable teaching and learning, right, and your belief in central
offices' inherent commitment to equitable teaching and learning, I guess I'm curious
about what should central office leaders be thinking about, especially given where they're
positioned as this new administration steps in?
What do you think?
I appreciate that question.
I mean, we can have a longer conversation about this.
You can buy the lunch.
But in the meantime, I would say a main theme of the incoming administration is local authority,
local leadership.
So let's go.
Yeah.
The time.
Take advantage of it.
And locally, let's figure out what that means for our communities.
And I also think a theme from the election, which other people have highlighted, is much
of America feels unheard, unsupported, uncared for, school systems or places that can turn
that around.
And so, I mean, I think now more than ever, the right work's the right work.
And diversity, multiple cultures, multiple cultural resources, they're powerful
resources for strengthening communities.
And so maybe that's a bipartisan position we can agree on.
I appreciate that answer, Meredith.
Yeah.
Central offices, school districts are positioned in a way to move forward on their community
shared values.
And at the end of the day, I mean, there's plenty of research that shows a declining
interest in school choice.
I mean, people want their public school system to be good.
Yeah.
So I think, I mean, the mandate for strong public school systems that are serving the
public is stronger than ever.
All right, Meredith.
That's a good note to end on, I think.
Thank you so much for spending this hour with us.
We couldn't get to all the questions as usual, but we got through quite a few of them.
Mayim?
Yes.
Thank you so much, Meredith, Jennifer, Shannon.
This is our final Book Talk of 2024, but we'll be back next year.
So stay tuned.
And thank you.
