Knightly Pollaxe & Halberd: Differences and Use

MELEE Weapons
4 followers
14 Video Views·Dec 15, 2024
Polearms are great and still somewhat underrated (although that has gotten a lot better in recent years). The poleaxe (or pollaxe) and halberd are particularly iconic for the Middle Ages and Renaissance. But what even are they? How do you distinguish them from each other and from various battle axes? Let's take a look at the practical use, background, definition, and how they're made.
When is an axe not an axe? When it's a hammer. Who would call this a hammer?
Oh, you know, some medieval weirdos, you know how it is.
All right, so pole axes and halberds, what's the difference? Before I dive into the finer
details of definition, just some practical aspects. First off, for visual reference,
this is a pole axe. This is a halberd. Again, this is a hammer, but still called an axe. We'll get
to that. And lengthwise, it's quite a difference. So this is a bit short. If you have the butt spike
as well, it would probably be more like this. But either way, typically, as a rule of thumb,
a pole axe tends to be no longer than the user, often shorter, and halberds are typically at
least the length of the wielder, often longer. As with any rule, you can find exceptions. You can
find particularly long pole axes and particularly short halberds. So there might be a bit of overlap,
but that's usually on average what you're dealing with. That also determines the usage to an extent,
again, with some overlap. The pole axe like this, you'll hold it with a fairly wide grip,
the hands relatively close to either end, and generally you have either a metal butt or spike
at the end, also called keux in French. So this is used quite a bit for thrusting. And don't
underestimate the effectiveness of even a blunt keux. This is a friendly competition with safety
gear, and look at how much it rattles that guy's dome. You can use the other end, of course, as
well for thrusting. You can strike with the hammer or axe and with the spike as well for puncturing
armor, of course. And also you can use it for hooking, you know, hooking, pushing, anything
like that. So the point of holding it in this sort of balanced grip is that you can switch pretty
quickly between either end. So if the opponent strikes you, you can set it aside with the butt
end and then either thrust like this or, you know, strike with the hammer. If we get into grappling,
I'm able to use the bottom of the handle to hook the legs, the neck, the limbs, etc. Things like
that. And also I can still strike pretty effectively even at close range because I'm
holding it like this. If I want more power, of course, I can slide the hands down and strike like this,
which is going to hit way harder. But of course, if I miss, it's also going to take a little bit
longer and be more exhausting to recover from that. And you can swap your hand position depending on
which side you want to strike from. Because if your right hand is on top, striking from the left
is pretty awkward. Like, you could try to tuck this under. It's an option, but it's more effective
to actually switch and strike full power like this from that side. And you can also use false
edge strikes, you know, like here with the spike, for example, coming down. And you can deflect like
that as well. So if a strike comes from this side, you can deflect like so. And then you already
in position. A halberd, you can also hold like this. You sometimes see it in the manuscripts. This
simply depends on the distance that we're dealing with. If this is where we're at, then yes, I will
want to hold it like this so I can strike well. But ideally, I want to make use of the reach with
this long weapon. I have to basically be out of frame for this. And by the way, apologies for the
dubious lighting. And unappealing background is the best I can do inside here. And the outside
world is covered in snow and ice right now. So it is what it is. Anyway, so one way to use it
is basically like a spear. So you can thrust with the point, you know, with this kind of sliding
thrust or, you know, stepping into it like that. And of course, you can strike from here. Again,
use the hook or spike in various ways, either for attacking or controlling, manipulating,
hooking. And the maximum reach you can get by holding it this low is significant. So it's
quite a bit farther away. If you imagine this with an axe blade instead of the hook, you can
see the clear lineage here. This is the grandparent, basically the Dane axe, you know,
any kind of two handed axe. You see a gradual development from this to, you know, different
axe shapes with a spike at the end. And then eventually they get the idea of putting a spike
on top as well. And eventually you get to the pole axe and the halberd in its various different
forms. There's definitely some gray area, some overlap, sometimes looking at some of the historical
depictions, it can be difficult to figure out what is this. Is this an early halberd? Is this a pole
axe? Is this, you know, just a battle axe? I mean, arguably a pole axe is a battle axe, just a
particular subtype. The big difference in use between these two is the circumstance of armor
development. At the time of the Dane axe, the best armor you could get was male. And with this, of
course, you have plate armor, depending on the exact time period, you know, anything from plate
combined with male to a full on pseudo plate, where male is really only used for the gaps as
voiders. And this has some pretty significant implications. For one, this, of course, is the
response to such highly developed armor. You want to be able to do more damage to the armor, either
with strikes, you know, be it with the hammer side of it, or with the point and thrusting into the
armor. And it's also quite useful for grappling. And at the same time, it's also for use in armor,
because now you can carry a two-handed weapon on the battlefield while being much safer than you
would have been in earlier times. You know, if you think about the presence of arrows and javelins
and various other projectiles on the battlefield, carrying this is quite a significant risk if you
don't use a shield. Meanwhile, yeah, sure, you could sling a shield on your back and have some
passive protection. But for the most part, while you're using this, you can be rather vulnerable.
In full plate armor, you don't have to worry as much about it. So this becomes much more viable.
All right, so terminology and definition. This would have made sense to do at the beginning,
right? But I just didn't want to go in dry. This is a very dry topic. So I've got to do it anyway,
right? So what even is a poleaxe and a halberd, respectively? If we go by the dictionary definition,
they're kind of all over the place. The Free Dictionary defines it as a medieval battleaxe
consisting of a long shaft ending in an axe or a combination of an axe, hammer, and pick. That's a
very general definition, because there are a number of battleaxes that would fall under this.
In fact, the Dane axe would technically fall under such a broad definition. You know, a long
shaft ending in an axe. It also suggests it's simply another term for a battleaxe, which is,
you know, not wrong as such. But basically, while every poleaxe is a battleaxe, not every battleaxe
is a poleaxe. It's a more specific type. Lexico also says it's another term for battleaxe and
defines it as a short-handled axe with a spike at the back formerly used in naval warfare for
boarding resisting borders and cutting ropes. They're talking about something very different.
And this is kind of the problem with the term poleaxe. It sounds very general, right? You know,
it could be any axe mounted to a pole. So almost any axe, you know, depends on what you call a pole
or a haft or a handle or what have you. This is very broad. Dictionary.com is much more specific.
A medieval shafted weapon with blade combining axe, hammer, and apical spike used for fighting
on foot. That seems very appropriate. By the way, sometimes it's spelled without the E.
You know, whether you spell it AX or AXE is basically preference. AXE is more common,
but there's really no difference. It's just different spellings for the same thing. Speaking
of spelling, there is also the P-O-L-L spelling for poleaxe. And apparently there's been some debate
about which is correct and where it comes from, what it means. You know, some people say the poleaxe
is, you know, in the sense that it sounds an axe mounted on a pole. Other people claim that the
pole, P-O-L-L, refers to the hammerhead, you know, the hammer pole being attached to it.
I don't really know. And frankly, I don't care. It's just spelling. The more common one is P-O-L-E,
which is the one I'm going with. You can use P-O-L-L to narrow down. It seems like if you
type it into the search, you find more of what I would call knightly poleaxe, the specific type
with axe blade, hammer, and apical spike, the way dictionary.com defines it. But I think if you
really want to narrow down, it's probably better to call it knightly poleaxe to make clear that
you're not talking about any kind of axe on a pole. As is so often the case, people in history
didn't really care that much about specific terms the way we do now. If we look at Italian
fencing master Fiore, he calls it simply an axe, atza. Some German manuscripts use a term that
translates to murder axe, but most sources simply call it an axe or a battle axe. In fact, even when
it's clearly depicted as a hammer. The French manuscript Le Jeu de l'Ache also calls it simply
which is battle axe. All right, halberd. The free dictionary defines it as a weapon of the 1400s
and 1500s having an axe-like blade and a steel spike mounted on the end of a long shaft.
Dictionary.com shafted weapon with an axe-like cutting blade, beak, and apical spike used
especially in the 15th and 16th centuries. And Lexico simply defines it as a combined
spear and battle axe, which is interesting. Definitely not wrong. By the way, you might
have heard of the term Lucerne hammer, which is a 19th century term named after a town in
Switzerland, which consists of a pronged hammer on the one side and a beak or hook on the other
side, which is called bec de corbin, which is crow's or raven's beak, sometimes also called
bec de faucon, which just means falcon's beak. This is also a pole axe, or again, in the historical
sources, they sometimes simply call it axe. Personally, I prefer to call this simply a pole
hammer to avoid confusion. It can be a little tricky to figure out what's the earliest halberd,
because as said, there is a gradual transition from various battle axes to halberds, and it's
kind of up to personal opinion where you draw the line exactly. You can't really, there's going to
be some gray area. But usually the Battle of Moorgarten in 1315 is typically named as the
earliest evidence of the use of halberds on the battlefield. This illustration here, by the way,
is from over 150 years later. So this form here, what's called early halberd, the top right there
doesn't even have a back spike. The bottom one is halved differently, more like a lockaber axe
or a vulge. Now, is a vulge a halberd, perhaps a proto-halberd? Some have no back spike, sometimes
the spike is a separate piece. Whether or not you want to call it that, I think this illustrates
the difference well. On the left you've got a vulge, on the right a halberd. So the halberd was used from
the 14th century, depending on exactly how you want to define it, perhaps as early as the early 14th
century, and then particularly in the 15th and 16th century. The practical use of halberds was generally
discontinued by the early 18th century, although it was still carried by sergeants and officers as
rank insignia, basically, and you still see them made as ceremonial pieces as late as the 19th
century. So the halberd has quite a long lifespan, while the poleaxe is pretty much limited to the
14th and 15th centuries. One way to distinguish poleaxes from halberds is by looking at the
construction. Halberd heads are generally made of one piece, while poleaxes consist of multiple
pieces. One is the langitz, that's actually one piece that fits over the head and attaches to the
haft, and the top spike is forge-welded or brazed onto it. And then the side spikes that you
sometimes see are actually the ends of a pin through everything to secure the head,
the langitz, to the haft. Sometimes the ends of that pin are just domes, sometimes they're shaped
into spikes. Another distinctive element of poleaxes is that they often have a discard
attached to them, which is not a feature you find on halberds. All right, after all this, I sincerely
hope your question won't be, which is better? Because if that's your question, then I have failed.
Or your attention span seems to be that of a severely concussed knight after being knocked
in the helmet by one of these. If you're really itching for some sort of scoring, this is what I
came up with. Basically, they're very close, with the exception that the halberd is longer and has
thereby more reach and is harder to carry. The poleaxe is better against armor, and I'd argue
it's slightly slower because it tends to be heavier on average than a halberd, although I'm sure that's
debatable. And a halberd should generally be more affordable, seeing how it was often a soldier's
weapon, not always, while the knightly poleaxe is an upper-class weapon. All right, hope that helped
clear things up a little bit. Let us know what you think in the comments. Thanks for watching,
and have a good one, folks.
