Navy SEAL Reacts To "SEAL Training Has Become Too Harsh"

Navy Life
5 followers
37 Video Views·Dec 15, 2024
I saw, I quoted this in my newsletter this week, about the stats of how few Americans can join...
76% of American adults aged 17 to 24 are either too obese to qualify or have other medical issues
or criminal histories that would make them ineligible to serve in the US Armed Forces
without a waiver. I wish that number was higher. I'm being dead serious. I hear people... I'm all
about inclusivity. Like, I don't have a problem with inclusivity. It bothers me when it's inclusivity
for inclusivity's purpose. And just so we can say we're inclusive, I think that the military
should be very exclusive. I think it should be extremely difficult to be able to join and
proceed down a pipeline that you want to go down. Because at the end of the day, I look at what is
it that you want to do and what are the standards for that job? What are they based off of? And I
can only speak through the lens of my own previous military experience. The standards that our job
was based on and that we were held to came from the battlefield. And I don't give a shit about
your woke ideology because none of that matters when you're covered with your friends' brains.
Not a single stretch of that shit matters whatsoever. All of those ideologies and all of
these platforms and ideas that people want to put onto the military just so they can say that they
did, I think that they should be removed. I think it should be super hard to get into the military.
We should exclude most people from it because they don't meet the physical standard.
Whatever standards are listed with the intelligence standard, the educational standards,
all of those things, that's a good thing. I think we are headed down the wrong path when we just
start opening the doors up and letting all of those people in. Because that is not a military
that is based to operate in the environment that the standards are based upon. I had a conversation
with Heather MacDonald, who has written a book called When Race Trumps Merit. And she's talking
about how affirmative action for different ethnic groups is causing meritocracy to be
thrown out of the window. And it's really uncomfortable actually to go through because
there's a lot of pretty harsh and disquieting stats that you start to learn. But the main
thing that I realised was most people, most sane people, wouldn't have a problem with the military
having an incredibly rigorous standard for entry because they understand that if you get this wrong,
mortal danger is on the other side of it, right? If you have somebody that is unable to keep up
with the rest of their platoon because of their physical fitness or because they've got diabetes
or because they've got a gluten intolerance or whatever, that person puts themselves and
everybody else at risk. But really, almost all industries are just a difference of degree,
not a difference of kind away from that. So she used this example of under-representation
within Alzheimer's research or Parkinson's research. But the problem that you have if
you start to do an excessive amount of affirmative action in that, especially if you completely
disregard and mostly disregard meritocracy, is that you slow down Parkinson's and Alzheimer's
research, which is directly impacting people's quality of life. So okay, it's not mortal danger,
but it's like health span and lifespan. And it's mortal danger for some.
Precisely. So you go, okay. So at which point, all the way down to the checkout operator,
you know? At what point do we say that this doesn't have a... operating based on merit
doesn't have a place to be within this system? It's really hard to find a line at which you go,
yeah, it's about there. It's about the person that professionally does crochet or fucking
cakes or something like that, you know? I mean, I think that the conversation
should be had and it's probably going to be a shifting scale depending on what you're talking
about. Should it be as difficult to join the military as it is to work at a Dunkin Donuts?
No, right? We need to be able to have a sliding scale. We're an advanced
species. We have the ability to think. Let's use that skill a little bit more.
Did you see that criticism around Navy SEAL selection being too harsh
as SEALs were sprayed with tear gas and forced to sing happy birthday?
Yeah.
You see this video?
Yeah, it's fucking awesome.
What are your thoughts on that?
I mean, I say that a little bit tongue in cheek. First off, anybody who's been through that
pipeline has experienced that. And there's a few ways that you can look at it. From my
understanding, from what I have heard from other instructors that were there,
those particular instructors were a little bit off the reservation. And this can happen because
instructors, again, you wear this blue and gold t-shirt and your hat and your shorts and you roll
your socks in a super dumb way. It's just people. They might all look the same to the outside
perspective, but just because you're an instructor or even a SEAL doesn't mean that you're a good
person by any stretch. You get the wrong person in the wrong role, bad shit is going to happen.
So the amount of CS gas that they were exposed to, from my understanding, exceeded what the,
what do they call it? It's a, God, of course I can't remember right now. It's an evolution
cheat. So everything that happens in SEAL training, the room for imagination is almost
non-existent. It's basically like pull the three ring binder. Here is what we are trying to
accomplish. It's like, you know, the mission statement, here's what we're trying to accomplish.
Here's our boundaries. This is the evolution. This is what it is. This is how long we're going to do
it for. The students don't know this. So as a student, it's very chaotic. I didn't know this
until I went back as an instructor. I'm like, holy shit. Like basically every day, the limits are
unbelievable. And the safety net should be incredibly robust, but also invisible to the
students. There's a portion of that training. I'm like, yeah, you may, maybe you should feel like
you're going to die. You're not going to die. We're not going to, we're going to do our absolute
utmost to prevent you from dying, even though it does happen. But there's a psychological
test there as well. It's a physical and mental crucible. So I have no issue with people being
exposed to CS Gas, because I was exposed to CS Gas. The third phase of training occurs out on
San Clemente Island, which is where that video came from. The problem I have with it is the training
and those evolution sheets, and again, those standards, you can draw a very precise breadcrumb
trail. Why do we expose people to CS Gas in training? Well, because one, it's very common,
and the first time that you're exposed to it probably shouldn't be for real. So what do we
need to do? We should expose it to people in a training environment where we can have a robust
medical staff. Problem is from my understanding, they involved people in that that actually
weren't necessarily directly involved in the training pipeline. They exposed them to far
too much gas. And one of the biggest issues I have with it is that there was some fucking idiot
there filming it with a cell phone. Do your job, because I tell you right now, filming it for your
Instagram page is not your job. And I don't know what you think is going to come from that. And
the reason they make you sing happy birthday is that that requires you inhale and exhale.
Is that what you did? They didn't have us sing happy birthday. There's all these frogman songs
that you sing when you're in training, and they'll just have you do something that increases your
respiration. Because there's some people out there that can hold their breath for a long time.
Now that holding your breath in an environment where it's on your clothes, it sucks.
What's it like?
It burns. My sister one time had a little mace spray thing, and I had it in my pocket,
and I sprayed it on myself and then wiped my eyes. I was gonna say, have you ever done that? But most
people haven't because they're not idiots. So it burns. It really burns. Your eyes water an
unbelievable amount. Within a few seconds, you'll be questioning how it's possible that your body
creates as much mucus as is coming out of your body. You cough. It can make it seem like people,
it's hard to breathe. For some people, they describe it as they're inhaling flames from this,
very hot. Is it going to kill you? Unless you have an underlying medical condition, I think it's
so highly unlikely. Does it feel like it's going to kill you? Probably to some people.
And that's the point. We have to expose students to those things that they may be exposed to
overseas. I would rather have a student have that experience and know the cognitive decline,
the physical decline, the emotional decline, and the impact that it's going to have on their
ability to do their job in training before it happens in real life. Now, if the instructor
staff went 1% beyond what is on that evolution sheet, then they are wrong for doing that because
that evolution is based on that real-world requirement. If they used 5x the gas or 10x
the gas, then they should be punished for that particular activity. But the evolution in and
of itself is essential. Now, somebody looking at that on Instagram could be like, oh, well,
that looks like torture. It's like, you don't know anything about this job. I'm not saying
your opinion isn't valid. I'm just not going to pay any attention to it because you don't know
what you're talking about. What's happening, people? If you enjoyed that, then press here
for the full unedited episode. And don't forget to subscribe. Peace.
