CAS Hanwei Lowlander Greatsword Review - Sure it's 6' long, but why?

Ancient Swords
6 followers
27 Video Views·Dec 14, 2024
Today I'll be taking a look at the Lowlander greatsword made by Hanwei in China and talking about why great swords may have used, albeit sparsely, throughout history.
Hey everybody, the format of this video is going to be a little different from normal.
I usually like to record in front of the camera, holding whatever subject is being discussed in
order to help convey things like scale and balance, but since the subject of today's video
is nearly six feet long, I figured it would be difficult if not outright dangerous to do indoors.
I didn't really want to put the point of this sword through the wall into the next room.
So for today, I'll be running some pre-recorded footage with a voiceover and hope I recorded
enough pre-recorded footage to not have to blatantly loop anything.
The subject of today's video is the Cas Honwei Lowlander Greatsword.
Now historically, greatswords offer greater length than any other type of sword,
and not quite as much as a polearm, and are also far more expensive and more time-consuming to
produce. In addition to that, they also require much more specialized training to use effectively
than those other weapons, so they never really had that much widespread use, or at least not
nearly as much as other swords and polearms, but particularly polearms.
So why did so many countries and cultures produce a greatsword, and why have they endured
over the course of history if they're not nearly as practical as other swords and polearms?
Right around the time I originally started planning for this video a few months ago,
School of Gladiatoria did a video exploring why so many different cultures throughout history
produced a greatsword, or I should say, what they used a greatsword for,
what they might have used a greatsword for, and since I'm not a historian,
I'm only going to mention a few of those reasons that he discusses and refer you to his video.
I'll put a link in the description, and hopefully I won't misrepresent that too badly,
so I certainly encourage you to go check that video out if you're interested and want to see more.
So while it's true that greatswords were occasionally used for anti-cavalry,
like China's Zhanmadao, which is also known as a horse-cutting sword,
it seems like it was by and large supplanted by polearms for that purpose.
Matt also mentions in his video that it's possible a nobleman or a high-ranking official
might commission an elite guard be issued with greatswords for the intimidation
and general flex factor that comes with a large and expensive specialist weapon.
So my favorite scenario that Matt mentions is that a greatsword could excel at crowd control,
particularly while guarding entryways or other bottlenecks and using these large,
fluid, sweeping motions, which I'll let him demonstrate because I can't do any of this stuff.
In this instance, a greatsword, with its full-length edge,
would also be more difficult to grapple than something like a polearm.
Regardless of the reasoning or the historical prevalence and practicality of a greatsword,
I really just wanted one of these because they're really damn big,
and that's why I ended up getting the Lowlander.
As I mentioned before, the Lowlander is made in China by Cass Hanwei.
It has an overall length of 68.5 inches.
It is made of 1566 high-carbon steel with an overall blade length of 48 inches
and weighs just under 7 pounds.
The advertised weight, I believe, is 6 pounds, 14 ounces.
The sword came to me disassembled in the box,
which is to say the guard was not mounted to the sword.
It was affixed, if I remember right, via tape and some bubble wrap to the blade,
and the grip and pommel was screwed down loosely to the blade as well.
Now, that's because the guard is 17 inches across, so if it shipped all assembled,
it would take a massive box and would probably get damaged more often than not.
To assemble the sword, you just unscrew the pommel, remove the grip,
slide the guard on, slide the grip on, and then screw the pommel down.
The out-of-the-box edge profile was alright.
It had a continuous grind off of the primary bevel,
but the edge itself, while toothy, wasn't particularly sharp.
So I ended up taking it over to the worksharp to touch it up,
which itself was pretty challenging due to the size of this thing.
I ended up having to take it outside so I had enough room to move around without,
again, putting a gouge in my drywall.
And cutting performance was pretty good after the sharpening.
Even with the extreme length of the sword overall,
the grip is long enough that it really does help with the balance,
and it doesn't feel as cumbersome as I thought,
considering everything on this sword.
It's huge.
So it's not that difficult to wield around,
but it's definitely far more challenging than a typical two-handed longsword.
Now, the common complaint that I've seen online with the sword
is that the pommel tends to loosen up over time,
resulting in a loose and rattly guard.
So when I assembled my hilt,
I went one step further and I used some orange threadlocker,
which is the same that I use for optics mounting on guns.
I have a lot of experience with screws coming loose with vibration because of guns.
So I also used a strap wrench to tighten the pommel down
just to see if I could eliminate or mitigate the pommel loosening issue.
That did seem to help.
And after cutting quite a few bottles,
there didn't seem to be any perceptible looseness in the guard.
So I went one step further and started using the sword
to cut back a green overgrown tree limb to see how it would hold up.
The blade held up well,
but in the process of cutting the tree limb,
I bounced the guard off of the tree itself a few times,
the trunk,
and ended up bending the guard a little bit.
So I placed the guard on a wood block and I used a rubber mallet to straighten back out.
Now after I did that,
I noticed the guard started to loosen up.
The hilt itself still seems fairly snug.
The pommel is snug and hasn't worked loose,
but it rattles quite a lot now.
Now to me, this is not a functional issue.
This is a cosmetic issue,
but it's definitely worth calling out because it does bother a lot of people
and it will definitely impact some people's enjoyment of the sword
and definitely their perception of quality.
I think it's something that could be corrected.
I think you could potentially shim the shape around the blade
just to keep that guard from wobbling back and forth.
I really don't think that tightening the pommel down anymore will help at all
because there's just a little bit of play
between the shoulder of the blade and the guard.
So if you're looking into buying this sword
and you see the reviews online that mention that rattly guard,
my experience with one purchased in 2021
is that does in fact seem to be the case still.
That does seem to be a consideration still on something that wasn't corrected.
And I also assume that that has to do with having to ship the sword disassembled
and having to assemble it yourself.
Really the only thing that I'm watching and kind of not really concerned about
but keeping an eye on is the leather wrapping and the wood of the grip.
They both just feel pretty soft.
Nothing has started to work loose,
but I'm wondering how that's going to hold up over time with use.
We'll see.
And if anything changes, I'll definitely make a follow-up video.
So definitely not a perfect sword.
There are some cosmetic issues.
There are some quality issues around the hilt.
But overall, I'm pleased with it.
Again, for the price, it's a functional huge sword
and that's really all I want it to be.
Well, I hope you like the video.
Please click the like button and subscribe if you haven't already.
And I hope you have a good one.
