Odysseus: Historicity, Inspirations and Themes from Ancient Greece

Golden Age
35 followers
42 Video Views·Dec 14, 2024
Kings and Generals animated historical documentary series on the Ancient Civilizations continues with an episode on the Homer's Odyssey and its hero Odysseus of Ithaca, as we discuss his journed in the aftermath of Iliad, and the historicity, inspiration and themes of the epic myth of the Ancient Greeks. The video will discuss the historiographical context of Homer's Odyssey, its transition from Bronze to Iron Age, themes of ethnicity and colonization, aristocratic and mercantile values, ritual and psychological events, as well as the Greek worldview and their outlook of the Barbarians and how at times Odysseus can be seen as a hero and an anti-hero.
The Odyssey is a tale of unparalleled cultural significance, both for the Ancient Greeks
and for those of us in the modern world. The adventures of Odysseus are, alongside the Iliad,
one of the two surviving epics of the Trojan cycle from Homer during the archaic period of
Greek history. They are also a mirror into an age in transition, the transition from the Bronze to
the Iron Age of Greek history. It would be impossible to pinpoint whether the Odyssey
is based on any historical events as we did with the Iliad or the Ancient Indian Mahabharata in
our previous videos. What we can do, however, is investigate the social context behind the Odyssey,
exploring Ancient Greek values towards religion, heroism, and ethnicity represented in the lessons
it imparts to its audience. In so doing, we can see how the worldviews of both the Archaic Bronze
Age Greeks and Classical Iron Age Greeks are represented in this iconic tale. Welcome to our
on the historical inspirations and meaning of one of humanity's greatest literary journeys,
the Odyssey. Make sure to also check out the companion video on our sister channel,
Wizards and Warriors, where we tell an abridged version of Homer's grand seafaring epic.
This video is sponsored by our youtube members and patrons, who get two exclusive videos weekly,
not available anywhere else, for their kind support of our channel. You can join their
ranks to watch more than 160 videos, including our series on the Pacific War, Punic Wars,
Persian Wars, Spanish War of Succession, Russo-Japanese War, North African Campaign of
World War II, History of Prussia, Italian Unification Wars, Risorgimento, Albigensian
Crusades, and much more. Click the link in the description or pinned comment to get the exclusive
videos, early access to all public videos, our schedule, wallpapers, access to a special discord
server where we are very active, and much more. Thanks for supporting us, we couldn't be doing it
without your help. Lots of ink has been spilled on the Odyssey's meaning and it would be impossible
for us to cover it all. We will not be delving into topics like whether the Odyssey had one author
or many, or whether Homer was a real historical figure, both of which have baffled scholars for
years. Instead, we will focus on how cultural patterns and themes are reflected in the Odyssey,
from ethnicity to ritual meanings to the encounter of aristocratic and mercantile values.
Explained in its simplest terms, the Odyssey is a story that spans across multiple eras.
The original tale was likely conceived in the Bronze Age, around 1200 BCE. For centuries,
it was passed down by word of mouth, in the form of a variety of oral traditions, until around 800
to 600 BCE, when the story was finally standardized and written down. Because of this, the Odyssey
reflects elements of both the Bronze Age, with its aristocratic, elite warrior culture, evident
in archaeology, and the Iron Age, with its increase in Greek colonization via trade across
the Mediterranean Sea. Thus, the main goal of our video today will be to try to unpack the social
nuances present in the Odyssey, determining which parts of it represent the values of the
classical era Greeks, which parts represent the values of their Bronze Age ancestors,
and which parts are indicative of the transition between these two different
eras of ancient Greek history. The most defining feature of the Odyssey is its role as a bridge
between the Bronze and Iron Ages of Greek history. The Bronze Age, also known as the era of Mycenaean
Greece, lasted from the 15th to 12th centuries BCE, and was a period of militaristic elites ruling
from large palatial centers, and constantly trading with their Near Eastern neighbors.
The Iron Age, especially the geometric period of the 11th to 8th centuries BCE,
and the archaic period of the 8th to 5th centuries BCE, were far different. During these two periods,
Greek city-states were more decentralized, and their trade with other regions was less frequent,
until colonization really took off. The Greeks, in the era of the classical city-state,
had far different values and social norms than their Bronze Age predecessors. The Bronze Age
Mycenaeans lived in monarchical and aristocratic societies with centralized economies. The Iron
Age Greeks had oligarchic and soon-to-be democratic regimes, and their economies were
more based around small independent artisans. In the Bronze Age, the Greeks were a regional people,
overshadowed by much larger empires like the Hittites and Egyptians. However, by the Classical
Age, they had become one of the foremost colonial powers of the Mediterranean. The Odyssey, likely
composed over time during this transition period, and fully formed during the 8th to 7th centuries
BCE, shows elements of both stages of Hellenic history. The descriptions of the Greek states
that Odysseus' son Telemachus goes to in search of information on his father, such as Pylos and
Mycenae, were more important during the Bronze Age than they were in the later Classical Age.
Moreover, the relations between the royals reflect the aristocratic values of the Bronze Age.
Odysseus himself is a king of Ithaca, as opposed to a hero like Perseus, who rises from poverty to
royalty. This is a remnant of the aristocratic values that had survived from the Bronze Age
to the Iron Age. There are, however, Iron Age elements in the story as well. Odysseus is not
a hero who triumphs through might or martial values, as opposed to the quintessential martial
hero Achilles in the sister epic of the Iliad. Rather, he wins through guile and deception,
a trait that comes from both his ancestor, the messenger god Hermes, and his patron,
the wisdom goddess Athena. Such values are reminiscent of those of a merchant who travels
far away to trade and gain wealth, a very Iron Age pursuit. Both aristocratic and mercantile values
often appear in the same episodes of the Odyssey. For instance, Odysseus defeats the suitors who
wish to marry his wife Penelope by displaying his archery skills, but only after infiltrating
the palace as a beggar. This sequence of events represents both Bronze Age martial values of
might and Iron Age mercantile values of deception. Another aspect of the text is that of how the
Odyssey tackles ethnicity. The Odyssey was written in a period when Greek city-states
were forming colonies across the Mediterranean. Thus, for many Greeks who embarked onto foreign
shores and encountered non-Greek peoples during that classical seafaring age, the Odyssey
represented their early conceptions of Greekness and otherness. The Odyssey's depiction of the
journey home to Ithaca is intriguing because it depicts the various locations that Odysseus
washes ashore upon as exotic and other. For example, the land of the Phaeacians, which Odysseus
visits before his final return home, is rich and pristine, carrying some stereotypes reminiscent
of the Iron Age Greeks' perception of Eastern peoples such as the Lydians, Phoenicians, and
who were considered to be wealthy and opulent. It is possible the skilled mariner culture of
the Phaeacians is inspired by the Phoenician seafarers that the Iron Age Greeks would have
encountered throughout their travels in the Mediterranean. Other foreign lands like the
island of Kyrgyz set up civilizational boundaries by depicting different ways of life, such as the
female Kyrgyz's ability to dominate men, something that would be unthinkable back home in Greece.
Another means of understanding ethnicity is through the notion of nostos, the Greek word
for repatriation or homecoming. This is a theme that is at the heart of the Odyssey,
appearing at the very beginning of the poem. Nostos is Odysseus' ultimate goal,
and it is what compels him to renounce a life of immortality with the nymph Calypso on the
lost island of Aegygia and return home. In the text, people who forget about returning home,
like Odysseus' comrades who eat the fruit of the lotus eaters, are portrayed as disdainful. The
notion of home, alongside familiar institutions like family, is part and parcel of the Odyssey.
They thus reflect the anxieties of Hellenes travelling in the Mediterranean,
of the adventures they have to go through, and of the homes they wish to return to.
We will now discuss how aristocratic and mercantile values are presented in the text.
There is a debate amongst scholars as to whether the Odyssey praises or disdains either aristocrats
or merchants, which is important to understand what the meaning of the epic is. The tension is
best evidenced in the part of the Odyssey where Odysseus descends to Hades to receive instructions
on how to return home. Amongst the shades of the dead lie both his mother, Anticlea,
and his former comrade Achilles, the hero of the Trojan War. In his heartbreaking encounter
with his mother, he hears of the tragic state of Ithaca, and how his house is now full of
drunken partying suitors in his absence. The tearful Odysseus can be an analogy for an
aristocrat who has failed in his duties by being absent in the open seas. However, his encounter
with Achilles can be subtly read as showing a disdain for aristocratic martial values.
Achilles in the Iliad was eager to fight and gain glory, even if he was to die young,
but now, in the shades of death, he is regretful. His speech to Odysseus shows this quite well by
saying, Don't give me consolation about death, glorious Odysseus. I'd rather be above earth
and labor for someone else, a man with no land of his own and little livelihood, than be king
over all the lifeless dead. In this quote, the Bronze Age aristocratic value of achieving martial
glory through an honorable death is challenged through Achilles' pessimism about his own
ostensibly glorious death. Mercantile values are discussed in the text in similarly intriguing
ways. Homer goes to Panes to discuss how Odysseus' raft was built upon leaving Ogygia,
showing his skills as a craftsman. The skills of Odysseus as a nautical navigator are shown
extensively in the epic, and can be described as a positive depiction of his guile and cunning.
However, while there were many benefits to the life of a seafaring merchant,
there were many perils as well, and this is something displayed in the dangers Odysseus
faces on his own oceanic journey. For instance, the companions of Odysseus often die in cruel ways,
through no fault of their own, like in Polyphemus' cave or between Scylla and Charybdis.
They are often reckless and cause their own deaths, such as when they eat the sacred cattle
of Helios on the island of the sun. This is the contradiction that is often seen in mercantile
and maritime values, it is a dangerous but skillful endeavour. Sailors and merchants can
be cunning, but also foolish, and taken away by the waves of fate. Not even Odysseus himself is
immune from this, his nautical skills eventually take him home, but he also unduly causes problems
by bragging to Polyphemus about blinding him. The contradictions and role of aristocratic and
mercantile values in the text are essential components of the Odyssey and how the ancients
saw it. The Odyssey can also be viewed through the lenses of psychology and rituals,
all too human elements and values that are always expressed by folklore. There are many rituals in
the Odyssey, sacrifices with honey, wine, and blood are used to summon the dead, and religious
rites are used to appease the gods of Olympus throughout the journey. By contrast, offending
the gods, like the sailors did with the sacrifice of the cows of Helios, is a catastrophic error
that causes death and ruin. The world Odysseus travels through is cruel and indifferent to him,
mythically explained through the anger of Poseidon. Thus, the support of the Olympians,
like Athena and Zeus, is what allows him to survive the journey and dodge the wrath of
opposing deities, like Poseidon and Helios. This is an interesting insight into the worldview of
the ancient Greeks. Their gods were forces of nature, but also deeply human and thus flawed
figures. The role of rituals is both a mystical insight into the supernatural that people cling
to during times of distress, like travel and exile, but also a means of communication with
and taming of these human forces. The psychology of the gods in an indifferent universe risen from
chaos is key to survival, something the ancient Greeks understood when they heard the Odyssey's
tales. The psychological themes in the Odyssey are most evident in the titular character of Odysseus.
We have discussed the emotions linked to Gnostos already, but there are other patterns of emotions
prevalent in the story as well. These are linked to the stress of the journey and how this changes
Odysseus. Odysseus may constantly seek to return home, but often he becomes anxious or stays in
places like the island of the Witch Kerky for a long time. He often loses himself in the journey
and embraces it. When he faces hardships, he also sometimes loses hope and is depicted as
suffering from clear signs of emotional trauma. Odysseus can be focused and stoic, but he also
often becomes arrogant and emotionally unstable. This multi-layered, often contradictory portrait
of a man culminates when Odysseus arrives at Ithaca and doesn't recognize the place until Athena
indicates where he is to him. This is a subtle indication that after 10 years of misadventure,
Odysseus' homeland of Ithaca has become a foreign land to him now. Odysseus has changed so much that
his arrival is not a repatriation, but a coming to a new space. This is an interesting theme as it
shows what many ancient Greeks felt about trade and colonization in the classical Iron Age period.
These new lands were alien for many colonists, but they were meant to be a new home. Trade often
changed people, as did war, and the psychological impact upon returning to the homeland could be
immense. The Odyssey describes these themes for a Greek audience that faced them in their attempts
to set up new homes in the Mediterranean. The Greek worldview of the boundaries between nature
and civilization, as well as what constituted each, is apparent in the Odyssey, and we will
discuss it here. For the Greeks, there was a distinction between nature and civilization.
The former was harsh and brutal, while the latter was the tool to survive and thrive in the former.
Let us consider how the Cyclops Polyphemus lives. The one-eyed giant practices animal husbandry,
but has no access to any tools, so he uses large boulders to keep the animals penned.
He is a very strong Cyclops and also eats humans. Odysseus defeats him not through strength,
but through cunning. By lying to Polyphemus about his name being nobody, he gains his trust,
after which he makes a burning hot wooden stick and blinds the unsuspecting Cyclops in his sleep.
This is a metaphor for the conquest of nature by the forces of technology, and thus a metaphor for
how the civilization of the Greeks triumphed over nature both in their homeland and in the
coastal territories they colonized across the Mediterranean. The same thing happens with
Kirki. She lives on an island of magic and has the power to upend the natural order of things
by turning men into pigs. This, to the Greeks, was a twofold upending of the rightful social order.
It was both an upending of humans from their place as superior beings in the hierarchy of nature,
and an upending of men's place as superior beings to women. For the Greeks, the islands of the
Cyclops and the sorceress Kirki were inversions of what they considered to be proper, and Odysseus'
triumph over the challenges he faced in both places represents a triumphing of the Greek
social order. The most intriguing of themes that appeals to ancient Greeks is that of Odysseus
himself. As a character, he embodies many of the values of the transitionary age in which
the Odyssey was written. We see his Bronze Age-style martial strength and his classical
Iron Age-era cunning come together in his return to Ithaca and his plot to defeat the suitors.
Odysseus may be the rightful owner of the throne, but there are upstarts in his way.
Thus, he is disguised as a beggar by Athena and easily lies his way into taking back his bow
and trapping the suitors in a deadly contest of archery. After winning it with ease by shooting
an arrow through 12 axes, he then turns into the stereotypical martial hero by brutally killing all
of the suitors with no mercy. His character is one of convergence of the warrior and the trickster.
Odysseus embodies both of these values through his character, a fact that subtly receives divine
sanction through his descent from Hermes and his patronage by Athena. Odysseus is also an
antihero of sorts. After all, the suitors, in the end, are unarmed and beg him to spare them,
but he declines. This leads to a confrontation with their families, but one that Zeus dispels
by demanding peace. Odysseus is not a traditional hero, but he survives due to his driven nature,
an allegory for the Iron Age Greeks to emulate. He is so driven that he escapes Ogygia and Aeaea,
the islands of Calypso and Kerky. Both of these islands are essential nowhere to Odysseus's
nobody, places of immortality, remoteness, and tranquil pleasure. He could disappear into the
atmosphere for a million years, with the sound of the wind blowing past his ears, but the lifelike
dream isn't for him, so he instead chooses to run home as soon as his feet touch the ground in
Ithaca. His motives reflect both the Bronze Age aristocrat, a traditional hero, and the Iron Age
merchant, an antihero. As we have seen, the Odyssey is a text of multitudes and has inspired just as
many analyses by scholars. It is a text that is inspired by the Bronze Age ethos, but is infused
with Iron Age practices and values. It contains the first stirrings of understandings of an
ingroup and outgroup, as well as visions of golden ages by God and of the wild, dangerous other.
The ritual and psychological values it embodies, namely that of Gnostos, are those of an era in
which Greeks travelled far and wide, into new lands filled with promise and dangers.
Thus, the Odyssey is a curious synthesis, it is both a memory of the Bronze Age past
and a hope of the Iron Age present of the time. It shows both fascinating other worlds and the
dangers of travel, as well as the difficulty and longing of coming home. Its nature is wild,
its civilization is sophisticated, but a trickster Odysseus must navigate it all.
This traveller par excellence is thus a mirror for the Odyssey itself, filled with adventure and full
of contradictions. These contradictions are the key to what made the Odyssey such a quintessentially
important text for the ancient Hellenes. More literary explorations of the ancient world's
most iconic stories are on the way! To ensure you don't miss that, make sure you are subscribed
and have pressed the bell button. Please, consider liking, subscribing, commenting,
and sharing- it helps immensely. Recently, we have started releasing weekly patron and
youtube member-exclusive content. Consider joining their ranks via the link in the description or
button under the video to watch these weekly videos, learn about our schedule, get early
access to our videos, access our private discord, and much more. This is the Kings
and Generals channel, and we will catch you on the next one.
