Adobe falls on Q4 results, AI concerns

Financial Freedom
10 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 13, 2024
Seema Mody dives into Adobe’s sharp move lower, and what investors are expecting from Broadcom as it tries to compete with Nvidia.
Welcome back to Power Lunch.
Adobe is the worst performing stock in the S&P and the NASDAQ 100 today after its results.
Key concerns around its AI offerings, its ability to monetize them, Seema Modi joins
us with more.
And Seema, I'd add to that, even just where is its place going to be as these AI tools,
you know, continue to explode?
Yeah, that's right, Kelly and Tyler, we've now heard from two major software giants this
week.
It was Oracle and then today Adobe, both of their guidance has failed to really live up
to expectations.
And if we double click on Adobe, the street was really expecting more from management
on how they're actually monetizing their AI tools.
Adobe recently announcing their Acrobat AI Assistant, which helps users synthesize and
summarize PDFs and data.
So something that they're really hoping will help lead on the AI front.
But we didn't really get that monetization strategy on the call last night.
If I look at what UBS said, they're saying Adobe's been pushing an AI narrative for two
years now.
And we still see no evidence of monetization.
The second issue is pricing.
CEO Shantanu Narain was asked about how they're able to raise prices on their customer.
He talked about the premium customer, but didn't really signal that he can raise prices
on all of his customers.
So that was a concern and why you're seeing a number of analysts downgrade the stock and
also lower their price target on shares of Adobe.
This all matters because we've seen this huge rally in software stocks since the election
on the prospect of deregulation, consolidation, the prospect of more M&A.
Adobe's sort of been sitting out on this rally.
The stocks that have really been benefiting are the names that have been able to articulate
how they're monetizing AI.
Salesforce has been a huge winner in the software space, as has Asana, DocuSign, and ServiceNow.
Chris, your thoughts on Adobe?
Well, you know, I think this is a great example of what we were just talking about even with
Kevin, which is high expectations, Adobe super high multiple, almost record high for Adobe.
And the report was a little soft, but it wasn't that bad.
I mean, the revenue missed by maybe a percent if you adjust for currency, probably less
than a percent.
So, but it just didn't quite make it.
And the stock's down 10%.
So this to me is more of a poster boy of high expectations for the whole AI group than it
is a particular Adobe specific issue.
May I pick a bone with that?
Yes.
Which is just, so if I were thinking about the risk in the S&P 500, I'd say, is Adobe
just losing share, right, to competitors that either are already in the S&P or might
be coming into the S&P?
Is it, is it more of a, of a case of, look, it's tools are fundamentally the kinds of
tools that AI is, is really replacing.
So is that just more Adobe specific?
No, I think you're pointing out a real risk so that, you know, if you have a hundred percent
market share, it can only get worse.
And that's kind of where Adobe is now.
Having said that, I didn't see any evidence of what you're talking about in this particular
earnings report.
I saw revenue that went up nine percent instead of ten and a half.
And so, you know, I'd wait to make a judgment on this.
That's fair.
Well, let's pivot.
Another big name tech stock that's going to report after the bell is Broadcom.
It's lower right now, but the report comes as people wonder whether it could actually
be, seem a threat in AI chips to the biggie, NVIDIA.
And Tyler, you and I have had this conversation.
Some of the hyperscalers that NVIDIA counts on as customers are trying to build their
own in-house chips, but they need a design and networking partner.
And that is where Broadcom has been playing a bigger role.
They have contracts with OpenAI, Meta, Amazon.
Even Apple is reportedly working with Broadcom to design a cutting edge chip that will be
used to power AI capabilities expected to be released in 2026, according to a report
from the information.
Analysts say higher prices remain a sticking point for technology companies that buy NVIDIA's
chips.
That's accelerating interest in developing an alternative option.
However, as we know, it's not easy.
NVIDIA has that first mover advantage, plus what Wall Street sees as the best group of
engineers to keep innovating and delivering faster, powerful chips like Blackwell and
beyond that.
So tonight, when Broadcom reports earnings, investors will look to CEO Hawk Tan to provide
a much needed update on its progress and working with some of the biggest names in Silicon
Valley.
And when, when we'll see an NVIDIA competitor actually hit the market.
You know, we had Ron Kruszewski on yesterday.
We're talking about this and he sort of made the point that was in your report there, Chris.
And that is this, that there's NVIDIA sitting out there, the big dog in this space with
very expensive chips that can do basically everything, right?
Broadcom may be able to come in with less expensive chips that do something that is
very tailored and specific to the need of a broad biz, of a broad sector of the market
like financials.
That was Ron's argument for Broadcom.
Yes.
Did you see it that way?
I see it somewhat differently, Tyler.
It makes a good story that it's, you know, Pepsi versus Coke and, you know, that these
two big guys are competing.
But I see more of it as a win-win.
I mean, NVIDIA is like the hedgehog that knows one thing and knows it well.
It's all AI, it's the GPUs.
But Broadcom is aptly named, it's like the fox that does many things all at once.
They have lots and lots of semiconductor offering and they're terrific clients, you know, Apple
being the perfect example.
So I think there's room for both to win here.
Again, I don't see evidence that they're kind of taking lunch away from NVIDIA yet.
There's some interesting headlines, but again, I think NVIDIA's numbers still show just terrific
depth.
Yeah, it's interesting, Seema, some of the discussion is shifting, though, to whether
we need these massive AI data center clusters that are doing pre-training of all of these
LLMs or whether we're now shifting, and there's lingo that I'm not going to use correctly,
but to more inferencing, and that inferencing is actually lighter on the compute demands
and might point away from the kind of get 100,000 NVIDIA chips, you know, and bring
that online and more towards something a little bit more targeted and tailored that perhaps
Broadcom can play a big role.
And to Chris's point, this is already almost a $900 billion market cap.
So if they are a winner here, some of that might be already priced in as well.
Yeah.
There's two parts of that AI model.
There's training the AI models where NVIDIA absolutely the dominant player, and then inference
as more companies push towards actually using the AI applications.
That's where the opportunity could potentially be because there's others like Cerebris and
Grok in the private world, and then where Broadcom and some of these hyperscalers hope
to play a bigger role because that's where the market is shifting.
Yeah, which you wonder.
I'm not saying it's a fair case for NVIDIA, but the shares have kind of stalled out over
the past six months.
They have.
I think it's something to watch into next year.
You wouldn't hold NVIDIA here, would you?
No.
Too expensive for us.
I figured.
And also, sooner or later, like Adobe, they're going to miss a revenue number, and there's
just no room for error.
Yeah.
Well said.
