Did Early Christians Believe in Reincarnation?

Mysteries of Life
3 followers
When I say reincarnation, your first thought probably isn't Christianity. But believe it or
not, reincarnation was a theological concept for some early Christians. How does what early
Christians taught about reincarnation differ from what we as modern people understand it to be?
Was it a common idea, or did those who espoused it receive pushback and censorship from their
fellow Christians? And why isn't reincarnation still a Christian concept? Stay tuned for all
Welcome to Misquoting Jesus with Bart Ehrman, the only show where a six-time New York Times
best-selling author and world-renowned Bible scholar uncovers the many fascinating,
little-known facts about the New Testament, the historical Jesus, and the rise of Christianity.
I'm your host, Megan Lewis. Let's begin.
Many people in the modern Western world view reincarnation as a belief predominantly from
Eastern religions, especially Buddhism and Hinduism. Today, we're going to be talking
about ideas of reincarnation in early Christianity and origin of Alexandria,
one of the concept's main proponents in the Christian world. Before we get into that,
though, Bart, how are you doing today? Yeah, I'm doing all right. We have,
when this airs, we will have finished our new insights into the New Testament
conference, and we're moving on now to other things, and so this online course thing, the
courses on Christian origins, is going great guns, and it's very exciting, so I'm doing pretty well.
I'm very pumped about the conference. So, how are you doing? Yeah, I am okay, thank you. I am
currently battling a cat who wishes to headbutt the microphone, which is adorable, but not very
helpful for recording purposes. But no, I'm good. I'm good, and I'm, you're finishing up
organizing one conference. I'm about to start organizing another. We're just starting to
contact speakers and things for our third Hit Points in History archaeo-gaming conference,
which happens in March-April time. So, yeah, we're starting to ramp up organization stuff now.
Wow, okay, yeah, no conferences, yeah, okay. They take a lot of work. People,
I didn't realize at least, but they take a lot. Yeah, yeah.
But reincarnation, is this something that you have really talked about or thought about a lot
before now? Is this something that comes up a lot in when you're talking and teaching about
early Christianity? Well, yeah, it does, and it actually sort of, it came up the other day,
actually, but not because of my teaching. I was actually watching one of my favorite movies,
Bull Durham. When I moved to Durham, North Carolina, I had just seen Bull Durham, which is,
you know, this Kevin Costner movie and Susan Sarandon, and it's my favorite baseball movie
of all time. It's great. It's a great movie, but in this Annie, who Susan Sarandon plays,
is going on, she's always going on, and it's kind of her ideas about things, and she starts telling
Crash Davis, which is the figure that Kevin Costner plays, about her reincarnation state,
you know, and she starts talking about what famous people she had, and he just kind of said,
finally, he says, why is it that whenever anybody's reincarnated, it's always from somebody
who is famous? Why not just like just some average person? Because surely most people
who are average people, nobody's ever heard of. Why is everybody, somebody famous?
It is one of those kind of typical responses that people have, but you know, yeah, no reincarnate
people. People subscribe to it, and I hear about it all the time, and I have dealt with it actually
on an academic level. So why do you think reincarnation and early Christianity is an
important thing to talk about? Well, you know, the views of the afterlife in early Christianity are
one of its most distinctive features. The place I talk about reincarnation is in my book, Heaven
and Hell, where I'm trying to explain what different views early Christians had about the
afterlife, and this was one of the views, and I know Christians today, not many, but I know some
Christians who still believe in some form of reincarnation, and as we're going to see, this
actually is a widespread view at some times and places. Never the majority view, but it's fairly
widely held at some times in Christianity, oddly enough.
In the ancient world, was reincarnation a common view, or was it somewhat unusual?
Yeah, I don't, you know, in the Greek and Roman worlds that I focus on, so the kind of the
foundation of our culture, it was never, you know, the prevalent view at all, but it had been around
for a long time by the time Jesus came along. I think the person normally attributed with
first really kind of pushing it on intellectual grounds was the Greek philosopher Pythagoras
back in the, you know, before Socrates, so we're talking like 500 years or so before Jesus,
and then you have Greek philosophers who state it, and it's actually in Plato. In Plato's largest
book, The Republic, in book 10, he has a figure who comes back from the dead to explain what he's
seen, and he describes how people get rewarded or punished, and then they come back to have a
second shot at it, and then a third shot, and it just goes on like that. And even in Roman circles,
where you might not expect it as much, because they aren't quite as philosophically oriented,
but Virgil in the Aeneid has an account of reincarnation in his description of the afterlife,
and so it's very much in the air in various different kinds of groups, but it was never
the majority view. Most pagans, people who were polytheists, didn't believe in any afterlife.
They thought that you died, and it was the end of the story. And those who did believe in some
kind of ongoing existence tended to think that everybody went to Hades, and there wasn't much
to do down there, but they didn't come back. And Jews didn't believe in reincarnation by and large,
so yeah, it was never a majority view.
Do any of these ancient concepts of reincarnation differ substantially from what we might
understand the word to mean today?
The basic concept is similar, which is that you're living now, and you lived before this,
and when you die, you'll come back as a different person. Most of them also think that how you live
now will determine how you come back then. Some of these views that we saw written evidence of
in Greek sources, for example, maintain that you could come back as a human being
in really good circumstances if you've been good in this life, or really horrible circumstances
if you've been bad in this life. But you can also come back as some other kind of animal,
and if you're not really a good person, you might come back as a slug or a cockroach,
or you can come back as a plant. You may end up being a toadstool next time around.
And so in most of these systems, the idea is that you're going to get a chance for the next life,
and so what you do in this life is going to affect what happens in your next life.
And so in almost all of these systems, it's an incentive to live properly, to live a good life.
Not a life where it's just all about pleasure, not good in that sense, but good in the sense
that you're doing good and being a good person. Thank you. We are going to take a brief break,
but when we come back, we'll be looking at specifically Christian ideas of reincarnation.
Think you've got Jesus parables all figured out? Think again. These aren't just simplistic,
moralistic tales. They're some of the most enigmatic and provocative teachings in all
of scripture. But if you're only seeing them through a modern lens, you're missing half the
story. Rediscover these stories as they were originally understood in their historical and
cultural context with New Testament and Jewish studies scholar, Dr. Amy Jill Levine, in her
intriguing course, The Parables of Jesus, Jewish Insights into Gospel Ethics, Humor, and Provocation.
You'll explore the teachings of Jesus, examining the social, ethical, and economic implications
that are often overlooked today. If you're ready to dive into the real meaning behind The Good
Samaritan, The Prodigal Son, and more, this four-lecture series will take you deeper than
you've ever gone before. Visit barterman.com forward slash parables, that's P-A-R-A-B-L-E-S
to learn more or sign up today. And don't forget to use discount code MJ Podcast for a special
offer. So if reincarnation was maybe not a common idea in the ancient world, but did definitely
exist, did any early Christian groups or thinkers believe in it? And do you also see competing ideas
about reincarnation within early Christianity? So if we're talking about earliest Christianity,
that would be the period of the New Testament. And in that period, basically, the New Testament
are the books we have. But oddly, one would not expect this, but there are some passages in the
New Testament that can be taken to support the idea of reincarnation. And for people who know
their Bibles, these are fairly familiar passages, but you just don't think about them this way.
When Jesus shows up on the scene, King Herod wants to know who he is, and other people want
to know who he is, and Jesus knows people wondering who he is. And so he asks his disciples,
who do people say that I am? And some people say, well, some people say that you're Elijah,
come back from the dead. And some people say you're the John the Baptist. This is after John
the Baptist was dead. So wait, how does that work exactly? So these would be Jews thinking that he's
Elijah. It means Elijah has come back to life as Jesus. Well, that's reincarnation. And so that's
a passage. In another passage, in the Gospel of John, which was written later, but in the Gospel
of John, the Jewish leaders come up to John the Baptist and they say, who are you? And he denies
that he's Elijah. So again, you have this idea of Elijah's coming back again or something.
But in some ways, the most interesting one is in the Gospel of John, a passage that I studied for
decades before this had ever been pointed out to me. There's a man in chapter nine of John
who was born blind, that Jesus is going to heal. And he's, you know, he's suffering, he's blind.
And the disciples see the man and they ask Jesus, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he
should be blind? Wait a second. How could this man have sinned so that he was born blind? He'd have
to have sinned before he was born. And so the question presupposes reincarnation.
And so those are three passages anyway, that it's not that they had a full-fledged
understanding of reincarnation, but it does show that people were kind of thinking that
someone might come back as someone else. Do we see any maybe Christian sects or
groups who kind of take this reincarnation idea and really embrace it?
Well, there are, and we don't know a lot, we don't have a lot of groups. But the one we know
best is, it's actually, this is a group mentioned in Irenaeus. So Irenaeus is this church father
writing around 180 or 185. So, you know, about a century after most of the New Testament was
written. He was a, he was the Bishop of the Church of Gaul in Lyon, which is France. Lyon,
France is where he, France is called Gaul then. He was the Bishop of Gaul. And prolific writer,
we have five books of his, Attacking Heretics. And the books together are called Against Heresies.
And he talked, he talked about one group in particular that believes in reincarnation.
They're called the Carpocratians. They're called Carpocratians because they're,
the guy who founded this sect was named Carpocrates. And so apparently Carpocrates taught
or his followers anyway taught that this world is an evil place and that we are trapped here
because we are actually spiritual beings who are trapped in our bodies and we have to escape our
bodies so that we can have salvation. And so Irenaeus is painting Carpocrates and his followers,
the Carpocratians, as Gnostic Christians who believe that the material world is evil,
that needs to be escaped. But Carpocrates had a particular slant on this, which was
that in order to be liberated from your body, your body has to have every possible human experience
before you can be liberated from it. And Irenaeus interpreted this in sexual terms,
that the Carpocrations are saying you have to have every conceivable sexual experience before
you can escape your body. And Irenaeus says that they're actually, you know, practicing this and
kind of engaging in this during their worship services as part of their ritual. Because,
you know, look, the goal of salvation is to get out of your body. So, you know,
you got to experience everything. So, okay, here's the list. I say, oh my God.
So the thing is, you know, we don't know if that's right. We kind of doubt, in fact,
we really doubt that that's right. But that's what Irenaeus was imagining these people were
saying anyway. And maybe he was right. Maybe. Now, who was Origen of Alexandria? And how does
he enter into this reincarnation conversation? Yeah, Origen is the key figure. We've talked
about Origen a little bit before on the podcast. The short story is that Origen was the most
important and historically significant theologian of Christianity for the first 300 years of
Christianity. He was an incredibly intellectual Christian. He was from Alexandria, Egypt. He
grew up in the church there. His father had been martyred, and he became a church leader
there of sorts. But he wasn't like a bishop of the church. He was an intellectual who was involved
in educating Christians in Christian philosophy. And so he was a philosopher and a theologian
and an extremely prolific author. Wrote thousands of things, and we don't have nearly everything
that he wrote and a lot of what we've written. He's written so much, a lot of it's not even
translated into English. You have to read Latin and Greek to read a lot of it. It's just so much.
Nobody's got around to translating this. He was the first Christian that we know of who tried to
organize Christian thought into a systematic understanding of what the faith was all about.
We have a kind of a précis of this, and he's got a four-volume book we have called On First
Principles, where he lays out major aspects of his theological system. So that's who he was.
He was mainly active in the early to mid-third century. He was especially riding around the
220s, 230s, 240s. He was martyred, ended up being arrested during a persecution in the year 251 and
died of the torture that he underwent then. So that's who he is basically, a very major
early Christian theologian before the Council of Nicaea, before any of that.
So what did he teach about reincarnation?
So in his day, Origen was understood to be a leading spokesperson for the proto-Orthodox group,
for the Orthodox Christians. He was opposed to Gnostics. He was opposed to people who
believed he had to keep the Jewish law. He was opposed to groups that later came or during his
day were declared heretical. And so he did have what were considered the Orthodox views of the
time. But he was trying to figure out things that were on the margins of the majority Christian
beliefs, as he understood them. So Christians agreed that there's one God. They agreed that
Jesus was a son. God had created the world. Jesus was the son who became incarnate, who became a
human, who died for the sins of the world, was physically raised from the dead. Origen knew all
of these things. He agreed to all the things. But there's so many things that need to be explained
that are not just kind of the central teachings. And so a lot of his theologizing was about these
other kinds of themes. And one of the things that he was really interested in was the question of
that God could be sovereign over the entire world. God could be Lord. He could be almighty.
And that he could have a world where some people could perennially disobey him.
Because if God's will is to save the world, then eventually everybody has to agree with him.
Because God certainly wants his will is to save the world. Well, how can that happen? Because
people die in their sins. And so Origen developed the idea that people here on earth,
the spirits of people, actually go way back. He believed in the pre-existence of the soul.
In the beginning, when God created the heavens and the earth, and he created the angels,
he created other souls, and created millions of souls. And the soul's sole function was to
that's why God created them. So they would worship him. They'd live in eternal bliss,
worshiping him. But there was a fall, much like people think about the fall of Satan today,
that he used to be an angel and became an evil figure. These other souls kind of followed suit,
and they all fell from the divine realm, and they became humans. And the goal of these humans is to
return back to the bliss of worshiping God forever. But most people don't get it in this life.
Most people don't turn back to God. They die. Well, God doesn't give up on them. And so what
ends up happening in Origen's understanding of things is that this world we live in now,
this age we live in now, is one age. But there will be thousands and thousands of ages,
and everyone will come back. Everyone will come back until they recognize the truth of God,
and they turn to God, and then are saved. So God's patient. He's got infinite amounts of time.
There could be an infinite number of ages. Eventually, everybody's going to get it.
And so until you get it, you get reincarnated. And so reincarnation happens, and happens,
and happens, until in the end, everybody gets saved.
How widely accepted were these ideas? I know you said that he was a member of the proto-Orthodoxy,
which is what developed into what we would recognize as modern Christianity.
We obviously don't have reincarnation, generally speaking. So was this something that was accepted
by the rest of the proto-Orthodoxy, or not so much?
It wasn't accepted by the rest of the proto-Orthodox community, but it was accepted by a
lot of people, including some famous theologians of the fourth and fifth centuries, who continued
to subscribe to these views—actually, the end of the third and into the fifth centuries.
And some were famous. There's a group of theologians who are called the Cappadocian
church fathers in the fourth century, and they helped develop what ends up becoming
the Doctrine of the Trinity. And one of them, named Gregory of Nyssa, was a very strong advocate
of Origen's views and maintained that, in fact, reincarnation is right.
And this became a very big issue over time, because it ends up getting rejected,
vehemently rejected. And it ends up being rejected because when Origen said everyone's
going to get saved, he meant everyone, including the devil. And that was too much
for people later. Like St. Augustine, man, he was all over that. And so Origen ended up being
declared a heretic over a century after his death. But during his day, it was a plausible view,
because it was a smart view. It made sense. It made sense of a lot of things, and a lot of people
accepted it, including theologians. Did people have other problems with this view of reincarnation,
apart from the devil being saved, or was that really the sticking point?
Well, that was the major sticking point. I mean, it's kind of like if you're a presidential
candidate and you've got a hundred really good points, but there's one thing they can stick you
on. It's just like that one thing just derails you. And so it's kind of like that with some
theologians. They've got everything, which is really quite amazing, but they have this one
view. They're like, oh my God, no. And so then you end up, yeah. So it was mainly that, but also
I think the idea of the pre-existence of the soul was considered to be problematic. It's a related
thing, but you know, if we pre-exist, I mean, really? I mean, and there are biblical passages
that would suggest that in fact, everything came into existence at one time, that God created Adam
and Eve and that he breathed the soul into Adam. And it's not that there were souls waiting around
to come down here. And so they could point to biblical passages about the pre-existence of the
soul, but especially the idea of the devil. I mean, it's like today when people say, I think
we've mentioned this earlier on the podcast, people say they believe, well, everyone will be saved
because God is merciful. But then they'll say, well, except Hitler. You know, there's like,
there are some people who are really too evil and it's like that with the devil. It's like,
no, not the devil. But since the logic of the system requires the devil to be saved,
then the whole system has to be abandoned. When did Christian theologians stop arguing
for reincarnation as a Christian doctrine? Is this something that just died with the origin
of Alexandria? No, it didn't. Because as I said, people continue, there were followers of his who
continue to believe in most significantly Gregory of Nyssa. And interestingly, Gregory of Nyssa had
a sister who was a famous theologian, Melania the Younger. And she also believed in reincarnation.
We have a dialogue between Gregory and his sister, who is kind of his mentor. She was a brilliant,
brilliant woman who was a Christian theologian. And where she explains why reincarnation probably
is the right understanding of things. And people like that could cite biblical passages.
When Paul says about Jesus in Philippians chapter two, that at the end of time,
every knee shall bow to Jesus and every tongue shall confess that Jesus is Lord,
Origen and Gregory and Melania said, every means every. It means every tongue. So every creature
will confess Jesus. And so everyone will be saved eventually. And so that did, that did,
it held on for a while. But there in the, in the fourth century, there developed a controversy
called the Origenist controversy. It's a debate over Origen and his status that many of the main
theologians, including Jerome, were involved in. And this controversy involves features like this.
And after this Origenist controversy, Origen ends up being declared a heretic. And after that,
if people subscribe to ideas of reincarnation, then they have to, you know, they have to go
basically. So it exists on the margins and still does down to today.
Have there been any modern attempts that you know of to reintroduce
reincarnation to Christianity? Or is it like you said, just something that remains a marginal thing?
Well, it's definitely a marginal thing. But as I said, I do know Christians who subscribe to it.
I don't know, you know, people might correct me on this in the comments to this, because I
actually haven't looked into this. But there may be some small denominations that groups of churches
that subscribe to this and talk about it. But the mainline churches, Protestant, Catholic, Orthodox,
have all reject that. The more traditional idea has become prominent that a person lives once.
You know, the Book of Hebrews says it's given but once for a person to live. And after this,
the judgment. And so people tend to subscribe more to that idea that you've got one chance,
and that when you die, your chance is over, and then you face judgment. And so no reincarnation.
I will say though, that there is a, there's not so much move toward reincarnation, although some
people are moving that way. But the bigger move is towards some other kinds of universalism.
Because in a way, Origen's doctrine of reincarnation was a way of expressing how God's
power ultimately will dominate. That you cannot stop God. You might try, you might resist, but you
can't. And in the end, you too will be convinced. And in Origen's view, God's not forcing you to
agree. You know, he's not. Just over time, you know, after a few million ages, you're going to
realize you're wrong. Because you are wrong. And so God's being merciful. But this modern
universalist movement is really a lot more about that. It's that it's not just for God to say,
look, okay, you've died now, time's up, boom, you know, okay, heaven or hell. You know,
why don't you get more chances? Why not after death? Or why isn't God merciful? Why does he
torture you for trillions of years for 20 years of sin? You know, it just doesn't make any sense.
And so people are moving toward more of a universalist model, even evangelical Christians.
Many, I know, evangelical thinkers, apologists, theologians who are moving in that direction.
But reincarnation tends not to be the way of doing it. And it may be because it just has that kind of
fuzzy, new-agey feeling to people that it's like, you know, this isn't serious theology. This is
like, you know, people who are into crystals or into reincarnations. I don't know, you know,
theologians tend not to move that direction. Thank you very much. That is all I have for
this week. We're going to take a brief break, but then we will be back with
some news on upcoming events, very exciting course coming up, and then a Bart's Soapbox.
Okay, today we are announcing a Synoptic Gospels course, which will be taught by none
other than Dr Mark Goodacre. This is going to be 16 lessons and is starting, I think, next week,
so the week of October 7th and going through the middle of December. So actually not next week,
the following week. This is for $249, and you can sign up for a 14-day free trial as a special
introductory offer. And I'm going to let you talk a little bit about this, Bart, because you're
launching a brand new Biblical Studies Academy, which sounds amazing, and I definitely think
you're better qualified to talk about that than I am. Yeah, no, this is a really good development.
You know, when we started, when I started doing these courses online that we now call the,
we just call them Courses in Christian Origins, CCO. The original idea was, you know, like I do a
couple lectures, you know, we call that a course. But then I started doing these eight lecture
things on a weekend. Saturday, Sunday, I'd give eight lectures, and we're going to continue doing
those because those are, they're great fun for me, and they are, they're, it's so, it's people,
people really appreciated these things. And so our company has grown, and we're moving into new
models. I'm not giving up the old models because the old models are fantastic, but this new model
is this Biblical Studies Academy, and this will be university-level courses spread out over a
semester, a semester. So the first one we're doing is kind of a truncated one because we wanted to
get one in in the fall, and so it's going to be eight weeks. And this will be, it'll be like a
university course for outsiders, where we, there'll be reading that you can do, there'll be
two lectures a week with Mark Goodacre, who is, by the way, one of the leading scholars in the
world on the Synoptic Gospels, Matthew, Mark, and Luke. He's going to give, so two lectures a week
with Q&A, and reading that you can do, and quizzes if you want to take them, and you can take this
course. And it's like taking, he teaches at Duke University, which as you probably know is like
ranked as one of the top universities in the English-speaking world, and he's the guy, I teach,
one of the guys who teaches New Testament there. And so this will be like taking a course at Duke
University. And so, what can I say? I mean, so we're going to start doing this. We're going to,
we're going to ever, we're going to have a course going like this. We're going to be doing probably
three courses like this a year, only most of, most of them are going to be longer. And so this one,
we wanted to get it in the fall. And so we're starting it after the, after our conference. And
so, yeah, so people should look into this because this is, this is going to be great. It's presenting
cutting-edge scholarship on Matthew, Mark, and Luke on every issue connected with them in one
course by one person who's not me. And so you'll get a different perspective from things you might
have learned from me, but also one that is by a top scholar in the world. So I'm really, I'm very,
very excited about this Biblical Studies Academy, and I'm really excited Mark agreed to do this
first course on the Synoptic Gospels with Matthew, Mark, and Luke. And really, it sounds like a
fantastic place to start a more advanced dive into New Testament studies. I mean, the Synoptic
Gospels are, I don't want to say they're it, but they're pretty foundational. They're hugely
foundational. And you know, I, I've done, I've done eight lecture courses on Matthew and Mark.
I'm going to be doing another one on Luke. And those are, those are great, great fun. This is
going to be very different. And people, and you know, it's one reason to have someone else doing
it because it'd be different perspective. Mark and I disagree on some key things. For one thing,
Mark, Mark Goodacre doesn't believe in the Q source. He spent a good lot of his career trying
to show that there was no Q that actually, so that Matthew and Luke were not dependent on some of the
lost source. And I'm, I'm a big believer in Q. He's a big disbeliever in Q. And so you'll be hearing
that side of it, but also he's just like, he's, he's like unbelievably knowledgeable about these
books. And so this, yeah, yeah. So it's a good one to start with. It's the first three books of the
New Testament. Absolutely. And people can learn more at barterman.com forward slash MML, MML for
Matthew, Mark, and Luke. So that's pretty easy to remember. And you can always use the code MJ
podcast when you check out for an additional discount on first month. So go take a look,
see if it's something that you think you'll be interested in. We are going to go now to a soap
box. So just stick with us. Take cover fundamentalist Christians and mythicists. It's time for Bart gets
on his soap box. The segment where Bart exposes the belief systems and social constructs that
So Bart, it's been a while since your last soap box. We've kind of added in some additional bonus
features. What are you soap boxing about today? Yeah, well, this one is less of a rant and more
of a kind of a puzzle puzzlement for me. It's probably will turn into rant knowing me, but I
mean, so I, I'm always confused by people who are highly intelligent people who use a certain level,
certain kinds of rationality in their lives. And they apply that rationality to everything,
except their religion. And I don't understand it. I mean, I understand that religion is a matter of
faith and I, you know, so I get that, but there's still things that you're asked to believe that you
ought to have reasons for believing. And they ought to be, it seems to me, they ought to be
rational reasons for believing rather than irrational reasons for believing. And so,
so again, I don't want this to be a rant, but I'll just give you an example. This is kind of what
made me think of it as a few weeks ago, I was talking with somebody who happens to be, in his
career, he's a prosecuting attorney. So he's, he's a lawyer who prosecutes, you know, in court. And
we were talking about religion and faith issues, and we're talking about the Christianity and he,
he was a Christian. So of course, I don't know what he was at all with. And, but he, but he said
that he thought that he had, you know, he had good proof that, that Jesus did miracles. And I said,
so I was interested because I'm interested in this topic. I said, well, what's the proof? He says,
well, I know miracles happen. So, okay. How do you know that? And he says that he was,
he was in a church some years ago that had wheelchairs hanging on the wall. They're
like a huge wall with a huge number of wheelchairs. And these were put there by
people who had been lame, who were unable to walk, who were healed and able to walk.
And so it convinced him that in fact, these people had been healed. And I, I was puzzled.
So what? I mean, do you, did you talk to any of these people who put the wheelchairs on the wall?
No, no, no. But they were hanging on the wall and they hang there because they'd been lame,
they healed it. Well, how do you know that? How do you know that's why the wheelchairs are there?
Well, that's what they told us. Well, did anybody there tell you they saw any of these things
happen? No. How, I mean, how do you know they're telling the truth? How do you, I mean, how do you
know? I mean, I said, I'm not, I'm not saying they're lying. I'm not just, you're that, you
know, but how do you know it's not just like a story floating around or how do you know?
And he says, well, because these wheelchairs were hanging on the wall. I say, I get this. But like,
if you're in a court of law and somebody says something, you just believe it because they say
it. I mean, like somebody says this happened. They're surely criteria for deciding how things
happen in a court of law. And so how, how, why do you do that in a court of law? But not, see,
I'm starting to rant. I mean, it's like, it's like, why, why, why is this evidence that these
people were actually healed? And then I told him a story, you know, when I was an evangelical
Christian, I believe these things happen almost always on hearsay. And sometimes I saw miracles
happen. I saw a guy who was virtually blind healed. I did. I mean, I did. I was 19. And
the next week he wasn't healed anymore. And so like, and so, you know, so I don't, this is not
evidence. And so, so I'm not saying that people have to have evidence for, you know, their faith.
I mean, faith is not a matter of evidence per se, but if you're claiming you have evidence,
shouldn't the evidence be the kinds of evidence that you accept in other situations? Because it's
not evidence otherwise. It's faith and faith is fine. If you want to believe these people got
healed, that's fine. If you want to believe that, but don't tell me you have evidence for it.
So anyway, I, I just, I don't know, something about that just kind of gets me a little bit upset
because I just think that, you know, if you I think people should believe I'm happy for people
to believe what they want, as long as they're not hurting somebody through their faith.
I think that it's good to have reasons for what you think, even if it's just personal experience
that you just what you personally think, and there's like no hard evidence against it. Okay.
But, but to think that you really are being rational and claiming evidence for why you
believe something when in fact it's not evidence at all, that I think that I, I don't think that's
good. I don't, I don't think it's good for us to behave that way when it comes to religion,
but not behave that way in every other part of our lives. I would agree. You need some
kind of criteria. Well, you know, why, why this instead of that, you know, if you want,
if you, if you believe one thing, it means you're choosing not to believe other things. So which,
you know, why, how are you, is it because you were raised that way? Well, then just say,
well, I was raised that way. Okay. But then you believe everything you thought when you're four,
you know, it's like, well, what? So anyway, yeah. I mean, I know I'm a bit of a rationalist,
but it does seem to me that, you know, and I'm not opposed to people having faith just because
they really just, this is how they resonate with the world. And I, I get that, but even then you
can still be rational about it. Well, thank you for sharing those thoughts. I'm sure that
the commenters will have some things to say about it. They always do. A lot of people just generally
come on and say that they agree with you and they appreciate what you're doing. So.
All right. Well, that's good too. But they should have reasons to agree with me. I tell my students
disagreeing with me is not the point. That's in fact, contrary to the point.
You're supposed to come up with reasons yourself.
Now, before we finish for the week, would you mind just summarizing what we talked about?
Well, we're talking about this interesting idea of reincarnation. I mean, do people come back
again? And there are arguments against that, of course, in the modern world, you know,
rational arguments against it. There are people who absolutely believe it, who are completely
rational people otherwise. And so the people, some people believe in reincarnation. Most people don't.
But the question we were dealing with is, was this idea around in early Christianity?
And one might not expect there to have been, but there was. And there were Christians,
including Christian theologians, who fervently believed in reincarnation. And it became a
debating point in the third and fourth and then fifth centuries. And so there probably always
have been Christians who believe in reincarnation, but it never was the majority view. People
sometimes tell me they think that reincarnation used to be the majority view of Christianity. It
was not. Definitely was not. But it was a minority view that's worth knowing about.
Thank you so much, Bart. Audience, thank you all for listening. I hope you enjoyed the show.
If you did, please subscribe to the podcast to make sure you don't miss future episodes.
Remember that you can use the code MJPODCAST for a discount on all of Bart's courses
and Mark Goodacre's upcoming course over at www.barterman.com.
Misquoting Jesus, we'll be back next week. Bart, what are we talking about next time?
We're talking about one of the most interesting apocryphal works that I'd say most Christians
have never heard of these days called the Act of Pilate. It's an alternative account
of what happened at the trial of Jesus before Pontius Pilate that is linked closely to Pilate's
views. We're going to talk about that one next time. Thank you all and goodbye.
This has been an episode of Misquoting Jesus with Bart Ehrman. We'll be back with a new episode next
Tuesday, so please be sure to subscribe to our show for free on your favorite podcast listening
app or on Bart Ehrman's YouTube channel so you don't miss out. From Bart Ehrman and myself,
Megan Lewis, thank you for joining us.
