đŠ Les chauves-souris, reines de la nuit

Hello everyone. Thank you for joining us this evening for this Science Cafe organized by the
editorial staff of the Sciences West magazine in partnership with the University of Rennes
as part of the weaving project. Tonight, we are going to talk about bats here at the Café des
Champs-ĂlysĂ©es in Rennes like every first Wednesday of the month with Ăric Petit.
So you are a Research Director at LINRE, the National Institute for Research in Agriculture,
Food and the Environment in Rennes. Good evening.
Good evening.
So, bats are quite fascinating animals. They represent more than 20% of all mammal species
and they are also the only ones capable of flying. They are remarkable in many ways that we will be
able to discuss this evening and it is in particular for all their particularities
that they interest scientists who are still far from having uncovered all their secrets this
evening. So, we're going to focus on the western part of bats and their rather unique way of life.
Then, it will also be an opportunity, I think, to deconstruct some preconceived ideas about this
animal that often still has a bad reputation. So don't hesitate to ask your questions throughout
this discussion. That's really what it's for. There will be plenty of opportunities and there's
a microphone that's provided to circulate. Just give us a sign and that's it.
Those who are regulars at Cafés des Sciences know that it's important to speak into the
microphone simply because the meeting is recorded and broadcast as a podcast on the
Cafés des Sciences YouTube channel and on the Science West website.
That's it for the introductions. Eric, thank you for being with us this evening.
We'll perhaps start with some pretty impressive figures. As we said, there are 1,400 species of
bats recorded in the world. They alone represent 20% of mammal species and I think it's the second
most important order after rodents. That's it. That's it. These are figures that you should
perhaps keep in mind in particular. So, I don't know what your culture is in terms of bats for
some and others. Uh-uh but we hear about, I hear about it very often, I'm told the bat. There you
go, heard about bats in the media, it's the bat as if it were I don't know if it's the emblematic bat
that we all have in mind but you have to know that it hides an enormous diversity. More than 1460
species today. That's increasing every day, a little more, we'll soon be at 1,500. And uh in
this diversity, lots of lots of stories uh to tell, natural stories, scientific history. There you go,
I hope we can approach it through your questions in particular. So, are there bats everywhere in
the world on all continents? So, they are everywhere except when we go beyond the arctic circles,
Antarctica. So, when it is too cold, there are more of them. But otherwise, we find them pretty
much everywhere. I think that one of the good ways, one of the good gateways to just approach
the diversity that is hidden behind the word bat could be the diets which are very varied.
Can you explain the diversity of these diets to us? Yeah, so they eat everything. So, that's a
bit of a quick answer. They eat everything but some of them are obviously specialized.
So, the ones we know if we take the European bats, they are insectivorous. Uh, with a few
exceptions. These are fairly recent discoveries. Uh, the large noctual. I don't know if you know
the large noctual. So, I was talking to you about some names. Bat names are always very poetic. They
are full of very pretty names. The great noctual during the passero migrations also feasts a little
on small birds which are migrating above certain passes in the Netherlands in particular.
Otherwise, you have bats which are frugivorous, which are nectarivorous. You have some which are
fish-eating, which are piscivorous. And then for bats, we will say the most, uh, perhaps those
which are the most frightening. There are some which feed on blood. Uh, then, it is not many
species. It is a species which is specialized. Two others which sometimes also do not hesitate
to eat a little blood when they find some. But in fact, there is a species and it is called
the vampire. So, it is really an animal species which exists. The vampire you were telling us,
I think, stop me if I'm wrong, that there are plants that are only pollinated by one species
of bat. That means that without bats, there are plants that would not exist. Exactly.
Awesome. So, we always talk about when we talk about pollination, we always talk about insects,
especially bees. But there are also plants that are pollinated by other animal species,
especially bats. And there are some species of plants. So, those that are pollinated by
different pollinators, bats can be part of it. And then you also have some species that are
only pollinated by bats. There are very particular specializations. There is a
species that lives between Central America and Northern South America. It is the species that
has the longest tongue for a mammal. And it is particularly because it is adapted to a plant
that produces nectar at the very bottom of a tube in the corolla which is very far away.
So, it needs a very long tongue to go and get this nectar. And obviously, when it goes to get
the nectar, it catches pollen and then it will put it on other flowers. And you have some food
products that are linked to that. I don't know if you drink tequila. Tequila is thanks to bats,
for example. I have a bit of a subject. What unites, I have the impression, bats, is that
they come out mainly at night. So, first of all, is this the case for all bats? And why then why
do bats live at night? I have a beginning of an explanation. Do I want to ask you the questions
now? Does anyone have an idea? Uh, I tell myself that in fact bats are still pretty good. They're
small so they're probably quite preyed upon. So, maybe there are fewer predators for bats at night?
So, that's part of the hypotheses because what I'm going to tell you is still a hypothesis.
No one has really been able to prove which hypothesis is the right one and that's part
of the hypotheses. But the most advanced hypothesis today is that of predation,
but it would rather be an effect of competition with birds because of bats.
Uh, so we have to go back a little in time. These are also fairly recent discoveries,
thanks to fossils in particular. There have been quite a few hypotheses put forward on whether
it's first the animals that started to fly and then to make particular sounds, e.h. These are
animals that orient themselves at night with the co-locations or first is it that it is first the
co-locations that arrive nocturnally that are put to fly. And the most accepted hypothesis today is
the same, is not for the moment it is not a very established scientific fact. It is that the two
would have co-evolved at the same time in species that initially were rather arboreal and frugivorous
There you go. And in fact, which have developed, as you may know, the flying squirrels are other
mammals that know how to glide. But the bats are the only mammals that have active flight
and active flight when it developed, allowed the bats to move initially from tree to tree
with fruits to meet other food sources in these food sources, in particular insects.
Insects is very rich in proteins and therefore there is also an advantage to eating insects in.
In fact, the co-locations would have developed because insects, there are many in the evening.
There are also some during the night and these are times when insectivorous birds are not active in.
So that the competitive advantage in, let's say if we talk about natural selection,
ah, would have led to this evolution, both of flight of the eco and towards a nocturnal lifestyle.
But to come back to your question from the beginning, no, not all bats fly at night.
There are many regivorous species in Southeast Asia, in Africa that move around a lot at nightfall.
And then you have species in Europe that live. So I was talking to you earlier about the Arctic
Circle, but between the Arctic Circle and before the Arctic Circle, you have days at certain times
of the year in summer that are very long. If bats only came out when it was dark,
they wouldn't come out much. When you go to Sweden, Norway, finally in the Scandinavian countries,
bats, you can see them in the evening, but it's daylight.
Daylight is not at all dangerous for them. Not at all. No, no, it's simply their lifestyle that
leads them to be rather nocturnal. And besides, in our country in winter, and you can see bats
flying, especially with winters that are getting warmer. In fact, they are species that hibernate,
but they can at certain times in winter. So they have sensors. These are things that are not very
well understood either. They are able to know that at certain times they can come out and eat in
winter. So seeing pipistrelles that come out around your houses in winter, and it will be
during the day because on the other hand, in winter at night, there are no insects. If they
come out, it will be during the day. Are there any questions? Are there already any questions?
Yes. Dot. Hello. Um, you were saying earlier that pollinated plants, some plants were only
pollinated by bats, and that if there were no bats, these plants would not exist. I thought
that plants could possibly adapt. That is to say that, for example, a gene M, which would make the
plant pollen attract other species could develop, which was a minority and which would become a
majority in this case, for example. Is this a possibility? This is the trap of specialization
often. So indeed, a species which loses its pollinator can suddenly very well find itself
with another pollinator. But anything which is very strong specialization is a greater risk in
the event of a lack of partners. Are there other questions or not yet? Yes. Just ahead.
What type of sensor were you talking about? Misunderstood. You had spoken about that just
before. I spoke about sensor in relation to what I don't remember anymore. I just before you said
that there were bats that flew during the day. Oh, yes. Yes. When I talked about it was there,
it was some they are actually capable of sensing even in hibernation, the variations in temperature
of hygrometry. And suddenly they have physiological wake up systems that allow them to wake up at the
right time. So when we talk about hibernation in mice, it is not at all a deep hibernation
that lasts for several months. Bats will wake up several times each winter anyway.
They need it in particular to drink. So there are awakenings that are spontaneous to go and drink.
On the other hand, we also know that these awakenings will be more or less frequent
depending on the temperatures and that in particular, if the temperatures rise,
they are capable of waking up at the right time. The studies in physiology, which have looked at
this a little bit. A bat when it wakes up while waking up in winter costs it about 10 percent of
its energy reserves. If you transform that into a risk of mortality, an unexpected waking up in
winter for a bat while it's a 10 percent more chance of going through winter. So in fact,
waking up in winter, they never happen at the wrong time and they're critical.
There you go. And so that's also a message for disturbances. When you disturb bats in winter,
in fact, when you disturb 10 bats in winter, you kill one. There you go. That's what you have to
remember if you do it at a time when it's not the right time. I think it's worth coming back
to the phenomenon you were talking about earlier, shared accommodation, which is starting to be
quite well known. But could we just go back to how it works? So co-locations are a way for bats
to see. Let's say here we see with our eyes. They see with their ears. But what is special is that
they emit sounds, ultrasounds that we do not hear. It depends on the species, the species for which
it starts at around 16 or 18 kilohertz. And that is more or less the upper limit at which we are
able to hear. And it goes up to 120 kilohertz here. These are sounds that we are no longer able
to hear at all. So they like these sounds that are reflected by obstacles and that allows them
two things. But first to move in an environment that will be complex between the trees at the
exit of caves and so on. But also to locate their prey for species that hunt, for example, flying
insects. So co-location is really that it is sending a signal and then analyzing the echo
that comes back in return. And so the bats, we say they fly, they fly very fast. I think they
reach speeds of up to 60 kilometers per hour. We want much more than that. You've already
experienced it. You're in a car and then suddenly you have a bat flying next to the car. That
happened to me the first time it impressed me. So even the small species that we have around our
house, they're in active flight. They can easily reach speeds of 40, 50, 60. And I don't even
remember the number, but the species that was flashed at the fastest speed. So these are studies
that are done with special GPS sensors. I think it's not far from 200 kilometers per hour. These
are GPS that are placed on the bats. Yeah. So we equip them and then we measure the distance between
two points. That's exactly it. Okay. There you go. Then since we know the time between two points,
we can measure the speed. And so they are very comfortable in the air, but you told us that they
can move in other ways. They know how to walk and climb. So there are bats. So obviously they all
know how to at least hang on somewhere. We have the image of the bat that hangs on its front legs,
which are transformed into it and some species. So all species can move like any mammal on these
four legs. That's funny to see. They can climb arms, go down, move on a wall. And there are
some species. There is a species in particular in New Zealand that has almost completely lost
the ability to fly and only moves on foot. It's that already in New Zealand, the only species
of mammal that existed before the arrival of man were bats. There are very few predators. And so
it is a species that has adapted to the forest environment, which is very crowded and which
ultimately to find its food no longer needs to fly. So it moves on its four legs. Are there any
questions just ahead? I was wondering about the bat. Finally, the species that would have been
recorded as flying at 200 kilometers per hour. Could it be thanks to an air current or would
there be air currents that help them reach these speeds or not? Yeah, I admit I forgot a little bit
the exact speed. On the other hand, what is certain is that it has been measured on high flying species
and on descents, changes in altitude on descent. And it seems to me, yes, that reached almost 200
kilometers. Even it is not faster, because in my memory, I don't know. Do you know the speed record
of the frigate bird? In any case, it was it was the fastest bird between the frigate bird and the
peregrine falcon. Bats go faster there. We can take another question if ever there is one.
Hello. Uh, just to know the adequate hibernation temperature of a bat in Europe.
The adequate temperature? Yes. Uh, not easy to say. Uh, so several elements on that. Bats,
like any species that hibernate, lower the temperature a few degrees above zero when
they're in hibernation. Lower the heart rate, the breathing rate, the temperatures at which
they hibernate. Uh, I don't have a figure to give you like that. What is certain is that we can in
any case put it in relation with the temperatures of emergence and activity of bats. You shouldn't
imagine the temperature as being a problem in itself. It's a problem because there is nothing
left to eat. That's it. And below seven, eight degrees G.R., you have almost no more insects
flying or very few. That's it. So when we are below these temperatures, it is better to hide
and then wait for better days to have something to eat. Afterwards, there are very interesting
phenomena that have been observed on species that hibernate in groups. It is that they are able to
thermoregulate the group so that the temperature remains at a temperature lower than the outside
temperature. That is to say that when the temperature rises, the group will maintain
a lower temperature to avoid waking up at the wrong time. As I was talking about earlier.
This is the perfect transition to approach the life cycle of the bat. Here, we are at the
Normally, they hibernate. There you go. There are effects of global warming.
Temperatures vary a lot. But it is like many annual phenomena. It is linked both to temperatures but
also to the unique day-night cycle. So there, normally they are in hibernation. But as I was
saying earlier, bats are in hibernation. It is an advanced torpor. And if the days if you have a
nice week to who will wake up after that will also depend on the species do not all wake up the
same at the same time. Are not all sensitive to temperatures. There are some that will put them
that will hibernate in areas that are not very buffered from the outside temperature.
The arboreal species and the cave species. There are some that will put themselves at the very back
of the caves very far from the entrances and there it will be much less sensitive and therefore there
they can remain in hibernation much longer. And precisely if we dwell a little on their
life cycle, I think that there is one of the feats of bats that we are obliged to address this
evening. I believe that they can more or less control in fact the fertilization to optimize
the chance of survival. Yeah, that is also an element of biology that is very particular.
Also among bats, we are going to talk about the European bats that give a little picture of what
is happening elsewhere. But there are two there are two ways of doing it. There is a species,
the Schreiber's miniopter which does like the roe deer. So if I tell you that,
do you see what it is or not? No, so it's different ov implantation, it's called in technical terms.
The fertilization mating and fertilization take place in the fall. The first developments of the
egg take place and then the egg will remain at the same stage throughout the winter and then
the brionary development will resume in the spring. So that exists in other species but
the other hand what bats do and other mammals don't do what insects do what other species of
animal do is to store sperm. So mating takes place from the end of August all fall. There is even
mating in winter and the females will store sperm in their genital tract for several weeks or even
several months. And suddenly you have a little bit of synchronization of fertilizations just at the
end of hibernation. It will really happen in the first few days after coming out of hibernation.
And that's a mystery to biologists because we know how to store sperm in freezers but not in
women's bodies today. So there is some research being done to understand how these phenomena are
possible. Are there any questions? Question mark. Talk about bat hibernation. You were talking in
particular about the fact that they could cling with their legs and head down. So when they
hibernate, do they always have their heads down? Are they like that all the time? Is that when I
burn? Is that where they put themselves like that only to rest or is that a classic position for
them? In fact it's very species dependent. So we have the image of the bat that clings by its feet
and then its head down. Uh so here we come back to the hypothesis that you mentioned earlier because
we wonder if why do bald people live upside down. So there are two possible explanations.
Uh there is one that is indeed an anti-predation strategy. That is to say that there are no other
creatures that live like that. You put yourself in a cave. If you are on the ceiling there is
much less chance of being caught by a predator. In trees it is a little less true but it is also true.
There are many places where in fact when you are hanging like that you are less subject to
predation. So that is the hypothesis rather put forward for this thing but that does not mean
that they all live like that. It depends on the species and in particular the species that are
hanging from a support. And you have lots of species that are said to be fisherical and
they will go and put themselves in very narrow spaces. Aachen mentioned the common barbastle. It
is a species about 30 years ago. We said to ourselves there are very few. We don't even know
where it lives. No one sees them anywhere other than in these nets when we put nets to catch them.
And then it is Swiss colleagues who started to put small radio transmitters on their backs.
We followed them and we realized it is a species that lives almost exclusively under the detached
courses. So it is on the trees behind the course and so that is a species when you see it in the
houses. It can also be in the lintels in the lintels which are all which are in two parts
and you have a small space species we have the impression that to be good there must be a support
in front and behind. So often head down in these spaces but you have species that are horizontal
which are you see bald ones in all positions especially when we go to look at them in
is there another question precisely speaking of the fact that it often has its head down
how does it work in terms of blood circulation well it's an adapted blood system so that's not
at all my my my specialty but there are two there are two phenomena in fact these are generally
animals that are quite small so there is not too much of a problem with the presence of blood in
the brain but the circulatory system is adapted so that it is possible and there is no problem
link to link to that that is an adaptation that was made little by little as the vertical position
upside down was taken so i say that there was a second explanation that i learned by chance in a
blah blah card i was with a gentleman who came from mali and then we talked we talked all you
talk you know the things bats i'll explain to you why bats have their heads down and it turns out
that their god of the day so i don't remember what his name was i had uh his mother was sick
and he asked a bat to bring him a fruit uh and the bat uh it's it's it's put in his way she went to
get the fruit brought it back it cured the mother of the god of the day and then uttering this
journey it was the mother of the bat who fell ill and suddenly she asked the god of the day said
well there you go the fruit is a shea fruit by the way do you know shea quote he brings back fruit
and then she said well it was my mother who got sick and according to the shamans
the doctors she needed a little son and the god of the day never gave her any son and suddenly
since then bats have their heads down because they don't want to see it anymore neither the day nor
the god of the day in general as you said bats are small animals in general small mammals they
live relatively short lives but they compensate by reproducing more bats are a bit of an exception
to the rule they have adopted the strategies of large mammals that's it yeah that's it if you look
at the relationship between size longevity and then the number of children that many of the
young animals have bats are an exception so they have one little parent some species that have
twins so when we say one little parent it's the maximum it's that you also have females who give
birth to females every year who give birth to zero young eh so it's oh one exceptionally two
for migratory species in particular and these are species that can live a very long time
so it's more of a strategy it actually looks more like an elephant than a mouse that's it
typically and bats they can live so what does that mean a long time the record today is a
you see it's a very small thing like that and an individual that was captured as an
adult and was recaptured 42 years later so it was recaptured it was at least 42 years old
that's for very small creatures indeed it's very particular this is data that can be established
from the baggage or observation systems of bats that's it it's individual by individual in fact
there you go here we need individual data so we need individual marks uh the classic marks that's
what we invented for birds we put rings around their legs we still do that and for bald people
we also invented rings that we can put back on the forearm that look like that are adapted so
as not to hurt them and that actually allow for individual monitoring so today we do it with other
techniques we also do it with pick tags or transponders it's exactly the same thing as what
we put under the skin of cats dogs at the vet which allows for long-term monitoring to have
the life history of individuals and when i talk to you about records here these data are records
when we say 42 years for a brand's bat in the great mouse-eared bat that we study in morbelin
the record is 37 years here we are following five populations finally five colonies since 2010 and
uh so we are at 14 15 years of monitoring and we have very few individuals who are 14 or 15
years old so the individuals who are of an exceptional age remain exceptional the average
lifespan is between 10 and 20 years depending on the species or a little less as you said some
bats migrate what route do they take in fact they go to the warmer countries when it is cold in
winter like birds like the birds in europe it is the natusis pipizelle the common noctual in particular
uh this type of species that are then in winter they are rather in the northeast uh the balkans
poland the north of germany and then they come to france in particular they come to switzerland
come to italy when the bad days arrive and these are in particular species that are arboreal
the noctuals the natusis epithel is in winter when they are in cavities that are arboreal
it is quite poorly protected against frost and for people who work on these species in these regions
is not rare to find entire colonies that have frozen eh so in fact when there is no migration
there is a significant risk of mortality in winter and in terms of distance they can travel
up to how many kilometers here we are at a few hundred and up to 2500 kilometers for it's the
same age earlier i was talking about the natusis pipistrelle it weighs 67 g there you go can do
2000 kilometers to go to its winter quarters following in particular the coast between estonia
lti and then the netherlands the north of germany the netherlands up to france
it's impressive are there any questions are these characteristics that you mentioned therefore
longevity reproduction or distribution which make them good bioindicators or are there other reasons
well it's then it's a question a little uh we'll say i would almost say politico scientific because
indicators these are things that we measure and then that we try to use to adapt in particular
our public policies and so on so it has a very societal and even political side after the more
scientific answer because from this point of view obviously well everyone goes with their indicator
and then their group people who work on certain groups will say that these are good indicators
and in fact in biodiversity there are many indicators that are very relevant ah and it
depends a little bit on the issues behind them bats are also good indicators in particular because
they are species that are at the top of the food chain and there is still recent work that shows
that we have long talked about umbrella species of this type of term uh all the species that are at
the top of the food chain remain very good indicators of the state of ecosystems and from
this point of view bats are very good indicators or what is the closest relative of bats because
there are evolutions that are both close to birds and other close relatives of large mammals so what
is its somewhat historical evolution in your life well if i see i don't know at all no no idea there
you go it's called bats so there are a lot of people who say oh well it looks like mice that
have taken wings the other mammals that fly a little or squirrels and in fact no it is in the
group of it is in a phylogenetic group a branch of the tree of life which includes carnivores
herbivores and bats so there you have it cats dogs cows all that it is what is closest to bats
is there another question thank you i saw in asia buying by the finally the person who hosted me at
the market some fruit bats which are very large it is to eat them i think but i am not sure
and who paid those that i had seen have the width of the deployed aids almost 50 or 60 centimeters
something like that and in europe what are the maximum sizes of the species are the smallest
minimum then in asia the largest it's 1.80 wingspan yeah in europe it goes from so if we
talk about the wingspan it goes from 20 centimeters the same between 50 and 60 centimeters approximately
h how can we explain this bad reputation that bats still have today where does it come from so it
varies greatly over time and space so in our country it's true that shoes have a rather bad
image ah especially because of vampires there you go i think i'll definitely still come across people
who talk to me about vampire bats and then ask me but does it really exist so i was telling you
earlier yes there is a species that really is a vampire and that feeds only on the blood of
mammals and birds so that's one of the reasons and then in fact when we dig a little into human
animal relationships ah depending on the regions in france it varies depending on the regions in
the world it varies depending on the times other are often we cite today that especially in china
and for obviously phonetic reasons happiness and bats are the same they are pronounced in roughly
the same way so ah they are a bit of signs of happiness but that's quite recent in fact
in china ah older they were also seen as demons so in fact the relationships between humans and
bats they vary a lot and i hope when i do this kind of conference that this image changes a
little bit ah in fact there is a way of feeling it too people have a lot of aversion to what they
don't know and bald people are small often it's dark it lives at night and it flies so the chances
of meeting are low then when we send it's a time when we are if we don't like the night too much
we are not necessarily very well and suddenly i think that today the bad image of hunter it is
very much linked to this notion of unknown of night and then sometimes a little bit of am i going to
get bitten they are sometimes also accused of transmitting diseases in science west you told
us something that i find very interesting it tells us less about the fact that it carries diseases
yeah these are fairly recent discoveries so firstly the diversity of diseases transmitted
by a taxon is very much linked to the diversity of the taxon perhaps come back to what a taxon is
a taxon is therefore a set of species it is a branch of life so earlier we were saying that
bats and 20 of mammal species well 50 or so 50 are rodents it's rodents among mammals it's rodents
that transmit the most disease because there is more diversity among rodents than among bats
after that bats come in good place but not more than any other group given the number of species
there are that's the first thing and the second thing is that they are very bad reservoirs so
what is a reservoir they are living beings that can live with pathogens very well and then since
they live with these pathogens they can transmit them but bats have a particularity which is that
they have an immune system that will most often eliminate pathogens so in fact bats are capable
of transmitting some of these diseases only a bit like us when we have a cold if you sneeze in your
neighbor's nose you will transmit the cold bats when they are sick they can transmit but behind
they will not keep they erase so there are many many species of many works which show today that
the species we find traces of many pathogens in fact what we call desalogue testological we do
not find traces of pathogens so in fact they have succeeded in eliminating pathogens and that is an
important avenue of research because there is we try to understand because when we talk to you
about pathogens it is serious stuff he in bats he it is not here it could be what for example well
to talk about the most common to the one that concerns us there is rabies so there i have in
bats there is rabies but what kind of rabies virus do we find in bats it's not the one we have in
dogs or foxes it's a very wide variety of lissa viruses that are the ancestors of the rabies virus
that is now in our domestic animals and in bats we have a lot of animals that we know have
encountered the virus but no longer have any trace of the virus in the living individual
and just before asking a question how do you explain this resistance in bats so it's an
immunity that has evolved so there's something interesting is that longevity flight and
resistance to disease all of that is linked to the ability to protect against damage caused by
so when we fly a lot metabolisms are very fast you have a lot of western species for example we
talk about western stress bats protect themselves very well from that uh it's the ability to repair
its dna bats have abilities to repair their dna that we don't have so they protect themselves
they are species that have very little cancer and all that is linked and the immune system uh we all
experienced covid not long ago and you know that most human deaths were linked to an overheating
of our immune system bats control it completely so they have an immune response that is adapted
that can be very strong that controls things that are really dirty but there is no overreaction
so they have an immune system that from this point of view is currently under the spotlight
there are a lot of labs that are interested in bats from this point of view uh hello so
bats they have eyes it seems to me is it just a vestige of evolution or does it have a real
impact on environmental analysis in addition to ecolocation bats see very well there are no blind
bats and then what about their visual capacity when you have a bat in your hand sometimes you
even say to yourself are there eyes in fact yes there are eyes and it sees very well and there
are species that have lost co-locations so co-locations now we are pretty sure of that
the oldest bats are species of bats that were already capable of co-locations i was going to
say and some species especially the largest ones that are frugivorous have lost co-locations and
these species only use their eyes they are species that live in which are frugivorous and which live
rather which go looking for fruit rather at dawn and then in the evening when before the sun goes
down but suddenly they are all able to see are there any other questions um i was wondering if
bats are certain species were tameable because i know that there are squirrels
you can tame them well there are lots of there are lots of species that so i'm going to start
by saying that you shouldn't do it but to answer later to answer the question very directly yes
very well okay there you go there is in particular a colleague from the burn museum in switzerland
who was known for being a chiropteologist and then he was in a museum so he started to bring
he gave them shelters that allowed them to be in contact he made lots of interesting
discoveries for that in contact he put them in nest boxes on the roof of the museum
there you go so that's that was one way so he fed them because they were no longer able to fly
the one that was able to fly released them obviously but the ones that weren't able to fly
he put them there except for one so it's a story that i know uh and the bat at his house followed
him everywhere like a dog absolutely there you go knew him got on him so it tames very well
we have another question hello i just forgot my question that's great no it wasn't that one
uh i wanted to know i forgot my question so the microphone will come back there you go
good evening are there any traces of bat evolution in contact with man
there you go uh no i don't know of any work uh and i'm looking a little bit no i rather know the
opposite that is to say uh so there it is rather to approach another aspect when we to come back
moreover to the previous question he on the reasons why we discovered some diseases which
were linked to what we called reservoirs of bats it is because we increasingly trample on their
habitats and that contacts are more frequent there you go that's clear and it's true for
bats but for other species too oh good evening i had already heard that bats could descend from
primates it was a hypothesis since their wings in fact five hypertrophied fingers so do we know a
little more about this hypothesis as to how it descends from primates or has that changed yeah
it has changed because primates are not part of the group i was talking about earlier carnivores
herbivores but yes it is a hypothesis that has been explored in particular by morphologists
but the phylogeny of bats has been revolutionized like many phylogenies by molecular approaches and
therefore bats are not neighbors of primate cousins i have a question about wind energy
and therefore the group of a co-opter uh we know that there are impacts today that's for sure but
uh how can we be sure to save these species to live with them even though there are real
environmental problems today so the that's the second reason when i started working on bats
a few years ago in the general public we didn't really talk about it and there are two subjects
that have brought up questions about bats in the general public it's the one we just talked about
diseases and the second is wind turbines and just to give you a figure so i don't even have the
second figure i'm not going to give you one because when i started in the late 90s there was
a 100 percent bat employee in france in an association in the east of france today there
are several hundred and why for wind turbines because impact studies have been done on all
wind projects whether terrestrial or marine now uh it has been shown that wind turbines have direct
impacts eh you have direct mortality uh shocks barometasmas a bat that gets too close to the
when the blade passes well that makes the bat implode basically so internal hemorrhage these
are direct impacts and then the work of the museum which also shows very well that there are when i
speak of the museum it is the national museum of natural history which also shows that there are
effects on the occupation of the habitat and the person who did this work i think he was even
surprised by his results he measured it up to one kilometer and then he said and in fact there are
effects at least up to one kilometer so in fact when you have wind turbines the hunting habitats
which are around the wind turbines are less frequented by bats than when there are no wind
turbines so there are also impacts on the habitats so today all this is uh it is a work which shows
the impacts where we have fewer balls uh i sometimes get into arguments with colleagues
but uh i don't think there's any good work on that yet it's about the impact on population dynamics
there's american work that's very indirect for me uh so there we're lacking stuff we're lacking
evidence but on the other hand so also the political aspects at one point i was at the crpn
it's a kind of assembly at the regional level that governs a little bit the authorizations to
deviate from the laws of protection against nature and i had asked that we set up an observatory
i wasn't the only one when i talk about gambling it's because i'm there an observatory that allows
us to measure sums it takes money and in general where our impact measurements done done where there
is an impact and when we want to do good science well we have to measure where there is an impact
and then look a little to the side it costs twice as much as if we measure and that has not been done
so there is no proof but there is also perhaps no desire to go looking for proof
so that is the first thing but second element of discussion but i will also leave that for you to
think about uh personally i also think that wind turbines are a very good scapegoat
our roads kill a lot more bats than wind turbines there you go so and that is easy to understand and
therefore there is a lot of impact in fact wind turbines arrived at a time when environmental
awareness had risen a little and they are a very good scapegoat for a lot of environmental issues
and that doesn't mean that we shouldn't take care of it but we shouldn't take care of it by
forgetting the rest and then by taking the problems in their entirety i found my question
again are there structures in the region assaults that offer workshops to take care of bats to
observe them to do prevention that kind of thing preservation so there are associations that there
are some that are there are representatives in the room by the way or over there at the back
there are two associations mainly but others but the two regional associations
it's britannia vivante and then the logical breton group uh for what concerns the care and
the we'll say the management of emergency situations of question there is a network
that has been set up between these associations there is also one of the care centers that can
take care of but when you call this network will you have you are told you are explained where you
are redirected but these are the two main associations and on ren will you have a kiro
every two months for all those who are interested in bats and which is organized by
when we are here in ren it is rather britannia vivante and you have people who come to learn
about these animals understand how we study them how we protect them what species are present in
the territory oh there you go there are very active people in the area if we have some at
home it is it's that's it or it is these associations that we must call yeah that's it
there you go you will have the right contacts by going through these associations there
in particular on r before the question of a little anecdote that i had forgotten precisely
during my previous interventions it is i saw again a few days ago finally a bat to the south of ren
so there are still some maybe not to the north but still to the south in any case the question
was you said that certain species have lost the co-locations in particular the fujivores
does it see it in color or not did i think that there were the great primates who saw in color
to identify the fruits and so on a joker i think so in my memory but to be verified and i am i am
not sure that it sees all the colors on the other hand but they see some h but it seems to me that
yes or not like the finally they do not have a filter like cats or dogs which makes that the
vote that only one color can distribute to be verified okay dot thank you since the 1950s
the destruction of bokeh wetlands the arrival of pesticides this has led to a significant
decline in bat populations in france today where are we uh it's a complicated question
uh it's a complicated question because we didn't have a lot of very good figures
uh there is no reference so though what we can say today is that the species for which we have
a reference uh for example the little rolloff so it's not a reference in abundance but it's
a reference in distribution in fact we know that since finally in the last few decades
its distribution area has contracted significantly it has disappeared from belgium almost all of
germany from holland there you go it's a species that is now being recolonized little by little
but in abundance it's very easy to say there is more recent work by it's what we call the vige
systems set up by the national museum of natural history which is a lot of participatory science
and so it was set up since the beginning of the 2010s and so now we have a 15-year perspective and
on a lot of species there are still very marked declines others that have stabilized and then
bread which is rising but slowly and so i always say we have to be careful we have we also have
counts in brittany that have allowed us to show that on certain species that are truly endangered
species that there is a demographic recovery but when for example on the greater mouse-eared bat
you start from i don't have a population of 10 to 20 000 individuals that's as if in britney there
was still an average town so it's ridiculous it's not because it's growing we have to be careful
and it depends on the species there are some who love housing estates and so they do well
others who cannot stand the thermal renovations of old houses for example yeah so the reasons why
in any case if we talk about britney the reasons why uh it has decreased and it has continued to
uh well it has decreased agriculture everywhere and pesticides and then land consolidation a
deforestation or reforestation but on plantations anyway that's what more or less looks like
forests and then after us suddenly that affects both the lodgings and then what they eat
and one of the problems today is indeed especially uh it has also become a lot on the egy mice uh
breton are almost all either arboreal but we still don't have the most wooded region or they are
deviant cave dwellers call it that there are species like the one i spoke about several times
about the greater mouse-eared bat the greater rhinolophus the lesser rhinolophus are species
that are species of the karst environment so in france normally we only find them south of the
loire there you have limestone massifs and so if they arrived north of the loire it is because man
he built dwellings in which they feel good but these dwellings they are rather habitat let's say
old castles churches old houses and today all that has been renovated uh we close the openings
we prevent then often it is the footsteps the bats is the pigeons or something else that we
but in fact we put things that prevent everyone from entering and even when we renovate a house
we will end up with dwellings that are no longer suitable for these species besides that you also
have two or three species that love housing estates so for them everything is fine because
we build housing estates so the common pipistrelle the serotonin they like all that to what extent
could we have observed mental behavior strategies put in place by bats to avoid being linked to
acoustic or light disturbances due to human activities what we see is that they adapted
there are species that we call light repellent others that are light repellent but that's not
really what they like or they don't like light it's where are they going to find food and so
then there are both questions of behavioral ecology linked to optimizing finding food and
then there are also anti-predator strategies for work on light the species that like light in
general are the ones that will find something to eat there the others in fact and in general avoid
and that's why we created the black frames that we create more and more black frames and which
are used for heating for other species he which are spaces in which there is little or no light
but here it is rather for questions of not being seen and suddenly we will say adaptation reflexes
with regard to a potential risk of predation oh good evening i had a question it was to know
to what extent baby bats are autonomous in terms of flight feeding all that so they are not they
are not autonomous right away there is one thing on which they are autonomous very quickly it is
there you go baby bat when it goes right away to find its mother's breasts to cling to them
but very quickly uh the mothers need to go hunting these are species that have a very fast metabolism
and so they have it's quite funny to see moreover they have particular behaviors signals that they
send and which indicate to the young well now you leave me alone you're going to hang on i'll leave
you for 20 minutes i'm going to eat a little and i'll come back so they are autonomous from that
point of view on the other hand well before a bat can fly it takes five to six weeks well in
any case for the spaces that have under the attitude five six seven weeks and during this
whole period they are completely dependent on the sea and for some species also on the other females
in the group because you are species that form a little bit of creches in which some adults will
look after the young while the others go to feed themselves and we're going to take one last
sorry it was to follow up on the previous question but as for noise pollution could it
modify the frequency of their vocalization to compensate for these noise disturbances or not
have you read recent literature no yes no well i haven't read that but i'm going to ask yes yes
in fact they adapt a little like birds but it has been shown that they are capable of adapting
but then to a certain extent it is much less flexible it depends on the species eh you have
species that have cries of colocations that sweep large frequency ranges and for which it is not too
complicated to adapt others that have frequencies that are much more precise and in which adaptation
is not really possible well thank you all for all your questions thank you eric for the fascinating
answers we will meet again on january 8th still with science west to talk this time about the
mental health of adolescents well until then i can only invite you to discover or rediscover
the magazine and have a good evening thank you