I Used Proton Mail for 6 Months - Is it Good?

The Linux Cast
170 followers
362 Video Views·Dec 11, 2024
[Music]
for the last year or so I have been on
the hunt for a new email provider
because I want to get away from Google
as much as possible now I know I won't
be able to abandon Google completely
because I run a YouTube channel and my
main job does most of their stuff in
Google Docs so I'm always going to have
a Gmail account but I figured I could at
least move most of my personal email and
most of my business email away from
Google onto another server somewhere and
and maybe that made me feel a little bit
better about myself so I have been
trying different providers over the
course of the last year or so and the
one I settled on was proton male and I
had some mixed feelings about it to
begin with because there are some truly
matte-like flaws and if you watched my
channel you guys know that I like to
nitpick over things like UI and
appearance and stuff like that stuff
that usually doesn't really matter and
there's some of that stuff here that
just really bugged me at the beginning
and I'll talk about those things but
before we jump in if you'd leave a
thumbs up on this video it'd be really
appreciative it' really help the channel
so let's first talk about my move so the
actual setup of moving from Gmail to
proton mail wasn't hard at all I do have
my own domain so like I have the Linux
cast.org I was able to move that over
really easily mainly because it wasn't
on Google to begin with so I was just
able to set up the DNS wait for the DNS
to propagate it was really simple now I
will say that in order to use those I do
believe you have to pay I don't think
the free version offers any uh the the
ability to use it your own domain so I
did end up paying because I do have
multiple domains I'm going to have to
use so it's not really expensive I think
I paid like $50 a year or something like
that maybe a little bit more I don't
really remember how much it cost but it
wasn't too astonishingly expensive but
it is the first time really I've paid
that much for email I did in the middle
of this kind of switch used Zoho for a
while but they're like a dollar a month
and I don't even really consider that
paying free mails like really really
super cheap and I think I had like a $10
credit or something like that so I ended
up paying like $2 for an entire
six-month period or a year or whatever
it was so this is the first time I've
truly paid for email and it was you know
whatever I don't mind paying for
something that's good and prop time mail
is good so it's ended up being okay but
if you're used to using Gmail for free
moving to somewhere else that requires
you to pay some money for some features
probably is going to be a little bit
jarring but you also have to remember
that a lot of the features that you get
with Pro time mail are on Gmail as well
but you have to pay for those with
Google apps or workspace or whatever
they're calling it today so overall the
move was very very smooth it ended up
taking probably about 3 hours for
everything to propagate and start
handling over I set up forwarding from
my existing Gmail account so that it all
comes directly to proton that ended up
working pretty well it worked better
sending from Gmail to proton mail than
it ever did from Gmail to Zoho I was
always having problems with Zoho where
about half of my messages would never
get forwarded for some reason that
hasn't been a problem on uh Pro time
mail at all so the overall setup was
very very easy I'm not a web web Guru of
any kind I have dealt with DNS a lot in
the past but I wouldn't consider myself
an expert so I'd say if you have never
done that you still should be able to do
it they their setup for walking you
through how to do it is fairly easy as
long as you have just a smidge knowledge
of how to set up a domain name which you
if you own one you probably have already
you know got that far you should be able
to do it as well no matter your level of
expertise so overall the setup was
really really good and then we just have
to move on to the overall usage of it
because it proton does have quite a few
claims when they try to sell you on
their service and their big one is that
it's Uber privacy focused right that's
their whole ethos right they're they
encrypted email and they're supposed to
provide a lot of security for your email
and I think that overall they do a good
job as far as they can at providing that
service now I say as far as they can
because there's a big big caveat when it
comes to their whole security scheme and
that is that other email providers don't
encrypt their emails so once your emails
let's just say for example you send from
your proton account to someone who uses
Gmail that conversation is not going to
be endend encrypted it's just not going
to happen so it will be encrypted on on
Protime mail servers it will be
encrypted over the transfer via TLS and
SSL and then once it gets to Gmail
servers or Google servers it'll be
decrypted and stored in plain text
unless the person you're sending to uses
pgp or some other encryption technology
which the vast majority of people do not
do that now they do offer the ability to
send them a link and have it password
protected instead probably not the best
thing when you're not supposed to click
links and emails at all ever so I don't
think that that's a very good service
but if you have to use it you have to
use it right so their whole claim of
this being a a privacy thing is Half
Baked at best and it's not their fault
at all it's just the nature of the way
email works right it the vast majority
of email Prov writers don't encrypt
their their servers therefore proton
doesn't work the way way it does or the
way it should do excuse me so I I will
just as as an
aside if Google's listening to this
which they are they listen to everything
that we say uh start encrypting your
emails man like why why not just do that
it it seems I mean if if proton can do
it it's obviously technologically
possible and that seems like something
that Google would be be like hey all of
our emails are encrypted it's it's great
you know it's a it's a selling feature
you should do that people use your
service like crazy and it feels like
that's something that they should do but
that's neither here nor there so let's
go back to proton so that's the big
thing right the secur the security stuff
that's supposed to be the selling
feature of proton mail and if you use it
that way it's fine because if you have a
lot of people who also use Protime mail
sending back and forth between them is
fully then encrypted or if you you're
send to some somebody who uses something
like Tuda something something like that
those would also be encrypted so it does
work with other email providers that do
encrypt their email servers so that's
nice now let's then move on to the
actual experience of using it outside of
all the technical security stuff right
overall there are two things here that I
just want to point out first off there
are ways and this was a misconception
that I had there are ways for you to use
traditional email clients if you want to
and you can do that with either proton
Bridge there's a way to set up IMAP
though I haven't tried to see how well
it works and I don't know what downsides
that has because I'm assuming that
there's going to that's going to dilute
the encryption if you do use that or
maybe there's some limitations there I
don't know I didn't try it and that's
kind of the point I had no interest and
this was surprising to me I ended up
having no interest in using a
traditional email client if you've
watched my channel in the past you know
that I've I've been big on email clients
I do prefer a native client and I have
for a very long time I I just really
didn't care for having my email on a tab
I wanted to have it in its own
application uh somewhere on my desktop
that's just the way that I always wanted
it but on my switch to Pro time mail I
had that misconception that it was not
easy to use in a client I knew that
bridg existed from what I heard about
Bridge it was hard to set up and wasn't
100% reliable and it would only work on
the desktop you're were going to always
have to use proton mail on your mobile
phone so I decided I was going to isue
using a native client completely which
was a big turnoff for me and just use it
in in a browser t and it worked actually
end up working pretty well I'm going to
be showing some Boll here along the way
of their user interface and overall it
worked really really well I liked the UI
quite a bit on the on the desktop at
least it has key bindings it allows you
to navigate between panels really really
easy there's a lot of customization
there for colors and layout which is
nice easy access to all the settings
that you could possibly want easy access
to creating folders and all that stuff
all the stuff you'd expect from a really
good email web client all of it's there
it's really welld designed and after
using it for a while I had no interest
whatsoever installing Thunderbird or
whatever to use Protime with I just use
this in an email in a in a Vivaldi Tab
and it works really well notifications
come through through Vivaldi just like
you'd expect them to do as long as you
enable them so I can see when an email
comes and over all just was a very good
experience from a UI perspective I had
no problems whatsoever on the desktop on
mobile now I use an
iPhone and you can give me for
using iOS all you want I have just kind
of settled on iPhone for various reasons
but the app on iPhone for proton mail is
not great now it's fairly welld designed
it it does take after the web design a
little bit and there's swipe actions and
it it works
okay and I can use it but it has this
stupid feature where every time you open
the app it has to load your entire email
list so there's always a small delay
that you can't help but notice every
time you launch the app before your
email show up and that happens whether
you just closed the app or not it's
really annoying I hate it it's the
stupidest thing it if I had a way to use
Protime bridge on the on iOS I proba
probably would do that now I don't think
that I would go so far as to use the
IMAP stuff I don't I I don't want to
deal with whatever downsides are there
but the mobile application was bad
really well not even just bad it was
just that that delay in loading of the
emails is really just annoying and it's
something that I've had to learn to put
up with and I haven't done such a great
job because I notice it every single
time even though it's just a couple
seconds you know it still bothers me so
the mobile experience was nearly as good
I do not know if that happens on Android
I don't use Android all that much so I
don't know if the same experience can is
on Android or not so the the user
experience in in terms of the UI and
actual functionality was pretty good uh
sending emails also was fairly easy
right it reminds you a lot of uh Gmail
has the little composed window along the
side or you can make it full screen if
you want it just kind of it's very
reminiscent of your Gmail experience now
it doesn't do the like autop population
of trying to to PR predict what you're
doing you're going to be right be wri
next as far as I know it doesn't do any
of that stuff at least automatically
proton does have some AI features I've
not turned them on I have no interest in
AI in my email at all uh so I don't know
whether or not those things are good if
you are into email or AI you can give
those a try yourself so overall it was
just a good experience in terms of
actually using it and it actually worked
right so one of the problems I had when
I was on Zoho for so long was that I
couldn't first off the forwarding of the
email didn't work all that well from
Gmail to proton for whatever reason
about half the email that I was sending
or getting sent from Gmail to my proton
account or my uh Zoho account just never
arrived I had never no problems with
that uh whatsoever on proton it all just
comes right as it was there's no delay
there really as soon as it appears in
Gmail it's coming right to Pro on
there's it doesn't like take an hour or
whatever which is nice especially like
if you're trying to get like like an
activation code or something that that
for two- Factor authentication you don't
want to have to wait for that to come in
and on Zoho sometimes I'd have to
actually go to Gmail to get that email
because it would either take a long time
to get to Zoho or it wouldn't come at
all so I haven't had any of those
problems with proton which is good also
I I will say that even though you are
going to spend most of your time
emailing people who don't use proton I
do feel like more and more I'm saying
people do who use encrypted email show
up in my email list and knowing that I
can have a lock like when you send to
these people there's a lock next to your
email address and a lock next to their
email address and it will that just
gives me a little bit of sense of
security to knowing that that message is
going to be encrypted I wish I could see
it more and I go back to asking Google
toe please encrypt their emails but
overall the more I see that the more
happy I am to to actually see it because
I know that at least in some cases the
stuff that I'm sending is not going to
be unencrypted somewhere out there now
obviously I'm not dealing with State
Secrets or any of that stuff like that
so I don't really care but it's more
just like the principle of the thing and
I don't have to deal with you know
worrying about you know Google reading
that email because it's encrypted right
so well I
I do have to worry about that if I'm
sending to Google but if I'm sending to
someone who uses encryption I at least
can have that security right so that's
good I wish that happened more often now
one of the coolest features about proton
that I don't actually use as much as I
should is their ability to create email
aliases basically these are fake email
addresses that you can give to Services
when you're signing up and then they
don't actually have your true email
address so this will prevent them from
selling your email address or losing it
because they don't know how to protect
their servers that's an awesome feature
because once you sign up for them if you
no longer want to receive their emails
and they won't let you unsubscribe
because they're a bunch of crooks you
can just delete that Alias and they
can't send you email anymore so it's a
truly good it's a it's a really good
service that proton offers that allows
you to protect yourself even if you
can't have endend encryption everywhere
you can set this up so that if you sign
up for say I don't know GrubHub or
something like that you can just give
them this phony email address while
still being able to receive email but
they don't have access to your true
email address which they can then lose
or sell or whatever that's a great
service and I do believe that everyone
should use that as much as possible
there are other services out there that
offer this type of thing I know if
you're on an Apple's ecosystem iCloud
will do that for you I I'm pretty sure
bit Warden will also do that for you I'm
not exactly sure about that I just
vaguely remember seeing something like
that in bit warden so the ability to
create those aliases and then protect
your email address from being sold or or
or stolen away is phenomenal it's really
really good and all of that stuff is
built in to your email clients so if you
use that it's just a simple matter of
generating the email address and then
copying and pasting it into the field
wherever it needs to submitted so it's
really really easy to use and it just
provides that extra layer of security
for your email address itself so I
highly recommend if you're going to use
proton use the Alias service because
it's really really good now uh some of
the other things that come along with
proton mail I haven't used as much so
things like calendar Proton Drive proton
passwords I just have no interest or
need really for using those I'm still
stuck on Google Calendar because of my
job um Google drive or Proton Drive is
something that I just haven't really
looked into all that much I've been
using nextcloud instead and the password
service is not something I'm really
interested in either because I use bit
Wen and I just prefer it so uh maybe in
the future I'll give proton password a
try but I I'm so invested in
self-hosting bit Wen that I don't know
that I want to try something different
so mainly I've just been using the email
and it's actually been really really
good so uh that's a for this one I know
it's not as in depth as it probably
could have been I I will point you guys
towards techlore he he does he has his
own YouTube channel is much bigger and
he has uh several videos on how proton
works and whether or not you should use
them and all the security stuff that
goes in there uh so I will link his
Channel Down Below in the video
description you can check some of those
videos out uh he does a really really
good job so uh that's it for this one if
you have thoughts on any of this stuff
you can leave those in the comment
section below I'm losing my voice as you
can tell I don't know why I feel
perfectly fine but I'm losing my voice
I'm sounding like I'm smoking a pack a
day uh but anyways uh you can uh follow
me on M on Odyssey those links will be
in the video description you can support
me on patreon at patreon.com Linc uh or
uh YouTube or Kofi both of those links
will be in the video description as well
thanks to everybody who does support me
on patreon and YouTube in Kofi you guys
are all absolutely amazing without you
the channel just would not be anywhere
near where it is right now so thank you
so very much for your support I truly do
appreciate it if you too want to support
me again
