A Revolution in Aviation... or not. The An-72

Military Transport Aircraft
1 follower
Let's face it, modern aviation is pretty boring sometimes. Most of the planes are already
divided into different types, and in each they are practically identical. But among all this
crowd of twins, there will always be one that makes you want to ask, what is that?
Hello aviators, Sky here, and today we're looking at an unusual plane,
with unusual capabilities. I present to you, the An-72.
The history of this aircraft begins in the 1960s, as we like it. Military transport aviation,
like aviation in general, was developing at a furious pace, but in its own special way,
which can be seen just by looking at the model lines. Almost all aircraft were turboprops,
there were a few jets among them, mainly the largest types.
The nuance is that turboprop engines were reliable and economical,
allowed flying quite slowly, supporting short takeoffs and landings, including on unpaved
runways. For military transports, this was very important. Jet engines gave high speeds,
but could not boast of much else. And aviators tried to solve this problem for a long time,
how to make a fast jet aircraft, while maintaining its capabilities for short
takeoffs and landings. And the solution was found in a small aerodynamic trick.
I think everyone is familiar with the situation. You want to pour hot tea,
tilt the teapot over the cup, and the treasured hot drink seems to stick to the body,
flowing down it right on the table. The same phenomena occur not only with tea. A flow
encountering a surface begins to move around it, deviating from the original course,
and at a decent speed, pulling this surface. Meet the Coanda effect, which is actively used
in many different areas. Yes, ladies, your beloved Dyson is also sitting on it.
Aviators have been playing with it for quite a long time. For example, special nozzles blowing
air towards the flaps were integrated into some military aircraft, allowing to increase lift and
reduce flight speeds during takeoffs and landings. But the effect could be used on a larger scale,
for example, to get even more lift by arranging the engines so that the jet stream would blow
over the wing. This idea had been in the air for a long time, but by the end of the 1970s,
aviators from different countries had taken it up seriously.
The AMST, or Advanced Medium STOL Transport Program, was initiated in the United States,
which was supposed to create a short takeoff and landing jet transport.
Two concepts were developed within the program. The first was led by McDonnell Douglas with their
YC-15, basically a classic jet transport with a trapezoid wing and four engines. Such a design
and high thrust-to-weight ratio were supposed to give good indicators. The second was led by Boeing
and their YC-14, and it was more interesting. The concept was based on the Coanda effect,
with the installation of engines on the wing. In the USSR at that time, there were also two
similar concepts, and both were developed within the walls of the Antonov Design Bureau.
At first, the main one was the classic version, the AN-60, with engines suspended under the wing.
But interest in it over time faded in favor of the second version with engines on the wing,
like the YC-14. The Coanda effect and its bonuses were extremely tempting.
Calculations and wind tunnel tests gave promising results. The lift force could be increased by as
much as 20%, and the designers preferred it. Having completed the first stages, Antonov presented
the project officially. The aircraft was supposed to retain the flexibility and low demands of
turboprops, while becoming jet-powered and achieving much higher flight speeds. It was
necessary to explain why the aircraft looked unusual, but the prospects turned out to be very
interesting to the military. An official order followed. Airplane 200, as it was initially named,
was supposed to have a lifting capacity of about 5 tons, be able to perform airborne landing
operations, and of course, be able to work on short unpaved runways. That is, more or less,
to become a replacement for light transports like the An-26, but with a jet power plant and a high
cruising speed. The turboprop flew at 270 knots, and the newcomer promised more than 380 knots.
From that moment on, the work was carried out very quickly. While the first research within the
walls of Antonov began around 1972, by 1977 it began to be realized in metal and acquired its
name. Airplane 200 grew into Izdeliye 72, and then into An-72. Finally, from the concrete of the
Gostomel airfield near Kiev, the first prototype rose into the sky. The An-72 took off on August 31,
1977, exactly 30 years after the An-2. Progress is obvious.
The testing of the aircraft was quite difficult. It had to suffer with the nuances of the Coanda
effect. The jet flow around the wing was unstable and wondered depending on the flight modes.
In addition, nuances arose in flight operations. The engines now not only pulled, but also lifted,
and in the event of a failure of one of them, a sharp imbalance in the lifting forces arose,
and the aircraft could simply tip over. But from the prototype to prototype,
the design and systems were adjusted, so all the problems were not critical.
Especially since the shortcomings were more than compensated for by its excellent flight
performance. With a normal load, it took off with a run of 450 meters, and its landing distance was
only 350 meters. It felt quite confident both on concrete and on the grass. Meanwhile, thanks to
its thrust-to-weight ratio and enormous lifting force, the aircraft turned out to be very maneuverable
and fast-climbing. The An-72 not only replaced the old turboprops, but also significantly
surpassed them. So, it's time to get acquainted with the An-72. The plane is quite compact,
28 meters long, 32 meters wingspan, 8.75 meters high, a little bigger than the An-26.
It's interesting in terms of materials. Short and rough landings did not promise comfortable
loads, so the structure was significantly reinforced. This naturally led to over-weighting,
and to combat it, Antonov tried to lighten the elements wherever possible. New aluminum and
titanium alloys, honeycomb panels and composites. The plane did not become light, but it allowed to
win several hundred kilos. The most important issue was the power plant, but Antonov had thought
about it before the An-72 appeared. Even during the An-60 project, an engine was created
specifically for it. The D-36, the same one that was also installed on the Yak-42.
The engine was very decent for its time. Three spool with a titanium fan, a bypass ratio of 5.34
to 1, low fuel consumption and a thrust of up to 63.8 kN. In addition to the general advantages,
it had a bonus that was important to the project. With a high bypass ratio, its jet stream was,
well, not cold, but not as hot as usual, which is important for what I will describe next.
Considering the specifics of the aircraft, we can say that the wing is also part of the
power plant. The engines are placed in the cells integrated into the upper part,
and are pushed forward, so that the nozzles practically lie on the wing from above in front.
Moreover, these nozzles are slightly flattened, which spreads the jet stream over a large area.
This section itself is reinforced and has heat-resistant protection, so as not to burn
during each take-off. Hence my comment on why the cold exhaust of the engines was important.
In addition to the Coanda effect, this design had another bonus. The engines were placed high,
which minimized the risk of foreign objects getting in from the runway. One of the problems
of jet aircraft, especially those operating on unpaved ground.
The high lift devices, considering the requirements, are very advanced. Around the
center section, large slotted flaps are installed, and when released, the jet stream of the engines
begins to flow around them, also increasing the lift. Further, there is another group of
slotted flaps. In front, a pair of sections of large slats. On the wing, there are interceptors,
four sections on each console, a full set, plus ailerons.
The plane of course received a thrust reverser, but given the specific location,
the mechanism is not quite ordinary. One huge bucket is installed in the upper part of the
engine nacelle. The plane received a T-shaped tail, such that the stabilizer does not intersect
with the exhaust. The landing gear was another challenge. Short take-offs, rough landings,
uneven ground. A difficult task, even for the Antonov engineers who were well versed in this
topic. Many options were considered, including an air cushion, but in the end they decided to
return to the classic with modifications. The front leg is a regular two-wheeler. The main
gear, four wheels on powerful shock absorbers, retractable into a fairing in the lower part of
the fuselage. Each wheel is independent, and even if one of them fails, the plane can land on the
remaining three. This was quite enough. The aircraft control system was pretty good for
its time. It combined both direct control and booster support. The cockpit received modern
onboard systems, automation and navigation. Everything was simple and comfortable to
control, and the total number of crew members varied from three to five, depending on the tasks.
The An-72 cargo hold is quite large, 2.2 by 2.1 meters in cross-section, 9 meters in length. The
load capacity is 10 tons, which allows it to carry light equipment, various pallets and containers,
up to 68 soldiers, and up to 57 paratroopers inside. The cargo ramp of the aircraft is
interesting. During parachuting, it rolls under the fuselage, and on the ground it lowers to the
without the need to use additional equipment. And here, an attentive viewer will ask,
what is this 10 tons load capacity? The An-72 was designed for five. The thing is,
that the An-72 that took off in 1977, and the An-72 that we see in front of us, are
basically different planes. Are you ready to jump down the rabbit hole?
The first public demonstration of the An-72 was held in 1979 at the Paris Air Show. There,
the unusual aircraft showed everything it could do, even some elements of aerobatics,
which impressed the people. And in the NATO classification, a new name appeared,
Kohler. Not a great name, but in this case, it just needed to start with the letter C.
And while it was delighting guests in Paris, a big battle for the production site was going on
at home. Initially, it was assumed that the An-72 would be assembled at the Kiev aircraft plant,
where the prototypes were made. But it was already overloaded, and there was simply no
room to make the new model there. The Kharkov aircraft plant was chosen as an alternative site,
but it was not easy there either. Kharkov for a long time specialized in Tupolev aircraft,
which were very different from Antonov ones. It was necessary to change the technical process,
update the equipment, and retrain the personnel, which meant additional costs and time.
And here comes the Ministry of Civil Aviation, which, observing the advantages of the An-72,
wanted to have such an aircraft on cargo and passenger lines. It would seem that additional
demand is always useful, but everything turned out to be not so simple. Initially, the military
transport was multifunctional, undemanding and nimble. But, for a civilian aircraft,
its range and payload were too modest, and these figures had to be almost doubled.
What a surprise. They had to make a cocktail of the air force and airflot requirements.
The updated An has grown in size, the payload has reached the target of 10 tons, and the range
varies from 2700 km with a normal load to 4700 in ferry flight. And these achievements had a
price. The aircraft had become considerably heavier, 34 and a half tons of maximum takeoff
weight. The aerodynamic quality and thrust to weight ratio have decreased. In addition,
larger weight and a larger wing have reduced the role of the Coanda effect to a minimum.
If earlier it was 15 to 20%, now it is 5 to 7%.
Flight speed is now about 380 knots maximum and 300 knots cruise, and the minimum has increased.
The takeoff run is 870 meters, the landing distance is 650 meters.
The new An 72 has become more interesting for commercial use, and remains tolerable for military
use. But from the point of view of aviators and engineers, I think, alas, a truly unique aircraft
has turned into just a good exotic transport. This surprise did not please the manufacturers
either. The Kharkov plant, which was already having a hard time switching to the new type,
almost stopped when it turned out that the new type had also changed significantly.
All this required even more expenses and time. As a result, the aircraft actually went into
production only in 1985, 8 years after the first flight. Back then this was very long.
Nevertheless, the first serial aircraft showed themselves very well.
Soon, due to its unusual appearance, especially when viewed from the front, it was given a new
nickname, Cheburashka, because it looked very much like the famous Soviet cartoon character.
But not everything was perfect. The design of the updated aircraft was not as reinforced as
the original. It was possible to work on unpaved runways, but without extreme conditions, as it
was originally planned. Plus, the aircraft was reliable, but demanding in maintenance,
and it was more difficult to work with high-mounted engines than if they were simply suspended under
the wing. Plus, tests showed the aircraft's weakness in parachuting. It was too small for
landing equipment, and the Coanda effect created wake currents in the tail, which did not make life
easier for paratroopers. Demand from the military died down a little, and the airborne forces
abandoned it altogether, preferring the An-12 and Il-76. Nevertheless, the aircraft surprised
with its versatility. As it turned out, it remained quite maneuverable and undemanding,
and felt great in different climatic conditions, from deserts to glaciers, and from the sea to
the mountains. This fact became the starting point for the emergence of specialized modifications.
The first of them was to be sent to the polar glaciers, where polar explorers still flew on
the ancient Il-14. The modification, called An-72A, received many changes in the configuration
and onboard systems, for work on ice, patrols, and delivery of personnel and cargo. At the stage
of entering serial production, it was renamed, thus was born the An-74, one of the favorite birds
of the Arctic and Antarctic. Subsequently, other civilian versions were released under the An-74
index, and the military retained the index An-72. Then came several other modifications, passenger,
executive, cargo, search and rescue. The patrol An-72P was even armed with the Gesha-23L cannon,
unguided missiles, and aerial bombs. It was more of an anti-piracy tool than a Cold War weapon,
but it worked well. For more serious matters, the An-72R was created, an electronic intelligence
aircraft, and the An-71, the AWACS aircraft. Even more exotic than the original, the radar
dish was placed on top of the reverse swept tail fin, instead of the stabilizer, which in turn,
was moved down. Even naval versions for aircraft carriers were proposed, but they were not
implemented. Heavy machines are not very friendly with sky jumps, and catapults were not used on
Soviet ships. The serial production was developing quite quickly, exceeding the mark of a hundred
machines. But just when everyone was expecting the mark of 200 to be crossed, the Soviet Union
collapsed. Demand within the country, or rather countries, fell sharply. Funding for the once
rich industry collapsed, and established production collaboration fell apart.
While in the late 1980s, early 1990s, 20 to 25 of them were made per year,
at the beginning of the 21st century, they were making at most a couple.
Attempts to enter the commercial market were faced with the specificity of the aircraft.
The plane was well suited for a number of special tasks, but on the commercial market,
it was inferior to purely cargo and passenger aircraft. Antonov engineers continued to fight
for their plane, creating many modifications, including radical ones with the transfer of the
engines under the wing. But the matter did not move forward much, and the priority shifted
from attempts to remake the An-74 to the project of a new aircraft, the An-148.
The finale was delivery of 2014. After the breakdown of production relations between Ukraine
and Russia, it became practically impossible to work further. In total, at that time, 195
machines were produced. There are a lot of what-ifs in the history of the An-72.
What would have happened if Antonov had continued to work with the An-60 project,
and made an aircraft comparable to the An-178 or C-390? They relied on the Coanda effect,
which in practice turned out to be not so effective. I'll note that the Boeing YC-14
also didn't make it, and no one really widely used this concept later.
How good was the original An-72, and what would have happened if it had gone into production?
What would have been the fate of the project if the production had begun as planned,
several years earlier? What if, what if, what if?
We have what we have, and that's about a hundred flying machines,
flying well and pleasing their small fanbase. Well, the project is over, but life goes on.
We'll see what happens next. Fast flights on interesting planes, and soft landings to you.
