The Brilliant Submarine Tactic That Crippled Japan

World of Submarine
9 followers
July 31st, 1945. In the murky depths of Singapore Harbor, the British midget submarine XC-3
carefully nestles beneath the hull of the Japanese heavy cruiser Takao.
Leading seaman James McGuinness enters the cramped vessel's wet and dry chamber,
ready to plant six limpet mines onto Takao's hull.
McGuinness takes a deep breath and pushes the hatch. With Takao's massive hull looming just
inches above, the hatch won't open fully. With desperate ingenuity, McGuinness deflates his
aqualung's air sac, hoping to squeeze through the half-open hatch. McGuinness contorts his body,
finally slipping through the narrow opening. Takao's hull is a forest of barnacles and
marine growth, making it impossible to attach the limpet mines. McGuinness has no choice
but to scrape at the cruiser's bottom until his hands are red and raw. Finally,
he can secure the first mine. But with five more to go,
the risk of detection is growing with each passing second.
In the early months of 1945, despite significant Allied advances in the Pacific Theater,
several key Japanese strongholds remained, including the heavily fortified naval base
at Singapore. Formerly one of the crown jewels of the British Empire and strategically vital
to the entire region, the Allies were desperate to retake the island. However, Singapore's natural
geography and extensive fortifications made it virtually impregnable to naval assault.
At the same time, an attack from the air would be too risky due to the island's anti-aircraft
defenses, recently given a serious boost by the arrival of a new addition, Takao,
a 15,490-ton heavy cruiser of the Imperial Japanese Navy.
Launched in 1930 as the lead ship of its class, Takao had been at the forefront of
Japanese naval operations throughout the war. Her ten 8-inch guns, eight 5-inch guns,
and vast array of anti-aircraft weapons had provided powerful fire support for the invasions
of the Philippines and the Aleutian Islands, and she had wreaked havoc over Allied shipping
in the Dutch East Indies, sinking several merchant vessels and their destroyer escorts.
At the Battle of the Santa Cruz Islands, she participated in the demise of USS Hornet
before pounding USS South Dakota with shells at Guadalcanal.
However, while making her way to fight in the Battle of Leyte Gulf,
Takao was struck by two torpedoes from USS Darter, shattering two shafts, breaking her
fantail, and flooding three boiler rooms. It was serious enough to force her to retreat to Singapore.
After a damage assessment there, it was determined that the only way for her to be repaired
would be to tow her to Japan, impossible at the time.
Nevertheless, the Japanese forces in Singapore found another use for her, protecting the island
as a floating anti-aircraft battery, posing a major threat to any potential Allied air raids.
She was joined by Miyoko, another damaged heavy cruiser being used in the same way.
If the Allies were to stand a chance of reclaiming Singapore,
they would have to find a way to deal with Takao and Miyoko first.
The British Royal Navy believed it had the solution, the brand new XE class of midget
submarines. Known as X-Craft, these 12 tiny underwater vessels, constructed in 1944,
were designed specifically for penetrating harbors. Measuring just 51 feet in length,
they could use their diminutive size to approach enemy ships in a way that larger vessels would
never be able to. Upon reaching their target, the X-Craft would drop their two side charges,
each one loaded with two tons of ammotal explosive, and fix their six 20-pound
limpet mines to the side of the hull, then withdraw to safety before the ordnance detonated.
The XE class's predecessors, the X-Class, had been used this way in 1943 as part of Operation
Source to cause major damage to the German battleship Tirpitz while stationed in northern
Norway. With the war in Europe drawing to a close, the British destined this new class
for a series of missions in the Pacific Theater.
Unable to spend long periods of time underwater, the 12 XE class submarines
were transported to the newly liberated British North Borneo aboard a depot ship,
HMS Bonaventure, arriving in Labuan in July 1945.
XE-4 and XE-5 were assigned to Operation Sabre and Operation Foil, respectively,
two daring missions to cut the telephone cables that Japanese forces in Hong Kong used
to communicate with those in Saigon.
Meanwhile, the attack on Takao at Singapore Harbor would be carried out by XE-3,
commanded by 25-year-old Lieutenant Ian Edward Fraser.
Fraser had already been awarded the Distinguished Service Cross for his role in the sinking of
German U-boat U-301 while serving onboard the S-Class submarine HMS Sahib. The rest of his
crew was made up of Sub-Lieutenant William James Lennon Smith at the controls, Engine Room Artificer
Third Class Charles Alfred Reed as the engineer, and Leading Seaman James Joseph McGinnis as the
diver. McGinnis was no stranger to X-craft, having already taken part in Operation Source
and earning a mention in dispatches for his bravery and devotion to duty.
XE-3's objective was to penetrate Singapore's defenses, navigate the treacherous Johor
Strait, and plant explosive charges on Takao's hull, while XE-1 simultaneously did the same
to Miyoko. The resulting damage, hopefully, would knock the already wounded Japanese vessels
out of action for good and clear the way for the Allies to finally take back possession of the
island. On July 26, 1945, the two X-craft began their perilous journey from Labuan,
towed by two larger submarines, HMS Spark and HMS Stygian, which would bring them to
within range of their target before releasing them for the final approach.
The journey was fraught with danger. The midget submarines were not designed for long-distance
travel, and their crews endured cramped conditions and sweltering heat. The risk
of detection by Japanese forces was constant, necessitating mostly submerged travel and
limiting opportunities for the crew to surface for fresh air. As they neared Singapore, the tension
aboard the two X-craft mounted. The crews knew that the most dangerous part of their mission
lay ahead. They would need to avoid detection by hydrophones, navigate through minefields,
sneak past patrol boats, and slip through anti-submarine nets to reach their target.
On July 30, Spark and Stygian released XE-1 and XE-3, approximately 40 miles from the entrance
to Singapore Harbor. The midget submarines were now on their own. Their mission and their very
survival depended entirely on their skill, courage, and a considerable amount of luck.
As night fell over Singapore, XE-3 began her final approach. Lieutenant Fraser,
perched atop the casemate, guided the tiny submarine through treacherous waters.
Deliberately avoiding the marked channel, he steered into a known minefield,
gambling his and his crew's lives to evade Japanese hydrophone listening posts.
The coast of Johor slipped by in darkness. Just before dawn,
they reached the Singapore Straits. Fraser's eyes strained through his binoculars,
scanning the horizon. Suddenly, he spotted something massive bearing down on them.
It could only be an enemy convoy. In a flash, he dropped through the hatch, ordering an emergency
dive. Yet more dangers lurked below. As XE-3 sank, a terrifying clank echoed through the hull.
The crew exchanged horrified glances. Another clank confirmed their worst fears.
They were sitting atop a mine. Hearts pounding, they listened as the convoy passed overhead.
The thump of the tanker's propellers mixed with the high-pitched whine of escort ships.
Minutes stretched like hours until the sounds faded.
Fraser ordered the tanks blown, and XE-3 rose, miraculously avoiding detonation.
They pressed on, approaching the anti-submarine net guarding the harbor.
At 1030 AM, Fraser spotted the trawler tending the net.
He ordered McGinnis to prepare for the worst, cutting through if necessary.
But luck was with them. The net caped open.
XE-3 slipped past, silent as a ghost. The harbor narrowed, teeming with small boats.
Every man focused intently on his task. Fraser searching for their target,
Smith monitoring depth, Reed steering. Only McGinnis waited, knowing his greatest challenge
lay ahead. Finally, there she was. Takao, the floating behemoth they'd come to destroy.
As a Liberty launch full of sailors pulled away from the cruiser,
Fraser checked his watch. 2 PM. Time to strike.
XE-3 crept towards Takao's imposing hull. Suddenly, a sickening crunch reverberated
through the submarine. They'd hit the cruiser's bilge, wedging themselves between ship and seabed.
For 40 agonizing minutes, Fraser maneuvered back and forth,
searching for enough depth to position them properly.
Finally in place, McGinnis prepared to exit. But as he tried to open the hatch,
his heart sank. Takao's hull loomed so close that the hatch would only open halfway.
Thinking quickly, McGinnis deflated his aqualung, contorting his body to squeeze
through the tiny opening. Outside, a new horror awaited. Takao's hull was a forest of barnacles
and marine growth. For 30 grueling minutes, McGinnis scraped and clawed till his hands bled.
Each movement risked detection, every sound amplified in the underwater silence.
Inside XE-3, Fraser and the crew waited in suffocating tension, every second feeling
like an eternity. At last, McGinnis returned. Having battled with a leaking breathing apparatus,
he arrived exhausted and panting heavily. Yet triumph gleamed in his eyes. Six limpet
mines now clung to Takao's hull, spread over 45 feet, each one a promise of destruction.
As McGinnis drained the escape compartment, Fraser ordered the release of both the starboard
charge and the empty container. With their mission seemingly complete, XE-3 attempted
to back away from Takao. But fate had other plans. The midget submarine wouldn't budge,
wedged firmly between the cruiser and the seabed.
For nearly an hour, the crew fought against their predicament. They flooded tanks and blew
them empty, alternated between full ahead and full astern, even rocking the craft in desperate
attempts to break free. All the while, the specter of their own explosives ticking away
haunted their efforts.
Suddenly, without warning, XE-3 shot backward. The submarine careened out of control,
its stern breaching the surface in a heart-stopping moment. By some miracle,
the Japanese failed to notice the commotion. Quickly, the crew flooded all tanks,
sinking back to the relative safety of the seabed.
As they struggled to regain trim, a chilling realization dawned. The port container,
now empty of its cargo, remained stubbornly attached to XE-3's hull.
Fraser's heart sank. The crew exchanged grim looks, knowing what had to be done.
Before Fraser could even ask, McGinnis stepped forward. Despite his obvious fatigue,
he volunteered to venture out once more. With a wry smile, he quipped,
"...I'll be alright as soon as I've got my wind, sir."
For seven heart-stopping minutes, the crew held their collective breath.
Outside, McGinnis grappled with the stuck container. As his sore hands worked the
heavy spanner, each clang of metal seemed to echo through the water.
Finally, he returned once more. XE-3 was free.
At last, Fraser could begin guiding XE-3 away from Takao. The crew nervously retraced their
path through the harbor, past the nets, and back into open water. Every unusual sound or movement
brought fears of detection and retaliation.
Finally making it back to the pre-arranged location, XE-3 rendezvoused with HMS Stygian.
The crew, exhausted but elated, were taken aboard the larger submarine.
Meanwhile, XE-1's mission had taken an unexpected turn,
as Japanese patrol craft forced delays, eating away precious time.
Realizing Myoko lay frustratingly out of reach, two miles deeper into enemy waters,
her captain made a bold decision. With XE-3's mines already primed beneath Takao,
XE-1's commander chose to double down on the closer target.
In a daring pivot, they maneuvered alongside Takao, swiftly deploying their own trudges
to amplify the impending destruction.
Mission altered but accomplished, XE-1 slipped away through treacherous waters,
eventually reuniting with HMS Spark, her towing companion.
Soon, a series of explosions rocked Singapore Harbor.
The limpet mines had detonated, causing severe damage to Takao.
While the cruiser didn't sink, she was effectively crippled,
rendered incapable of further military action.
Once a symbol of Imperial Japan's maritime strength, she was reduced to a barely floating hulk.
Along with other Allied operations taking place at the same time,
the attack on Takao was a lethal blow to the Japanese Empire,
as the war would essentially come to an end just over two weeks later.
The badly damaged Takao was surrendered to the British,
who used her as a target ship, eventually sinking her in October 1946.
The bravery displayed by Fraser, McGinnis, and their crew did not go unrecognized.
Both McGinnis and Fraser were awarded the Victoria Cross, Britain's highest military honor,
for their actions during Operation Struggle.
Smith received the Distinguished Service Order,
while Reid was awarded the Conspicuous Gallantry Medal.
Operation Struggle demonstrated the effectiveness of Special Forces
in striking at the heart of enemy defenses,
foreshadowing the increasing importance of such tactics in modern warfare.
