BEST No-Churn Pumpkin Cheesecake Cottage Cheese Ice Cream

Frosty Recipe
434 followers
I'm excited for you to make pumpkin cheesecake as a creamy homemade ice cream without an ice cream
maker. It's naturally sweetened with maple syrup and flavor rich with cream cheese, cottage cheese,
pumpkin, maple, and pumpkin pie spice. You can add extra crunch and texture with my gluten-free
graham cracker bits that taste just like a pie crust. And with half the sugar grams of a
traditional pumpkin cheesecake ice cream, you will feel great even after you eat this. You can make
your ice cream using an upright blender or an immersion blender or a food processor like I am.
We're going to start with one and a half cups of cottage cheese and you can use large curd,
small curd, low fat, non-fat, whatever your preference. And then we'll add fourth cup of
cream cheese and a third a cup of maple syrup, one teaspoon of vanilla extract, one teaspoon of lemon
juice, and then for extra flavor just a couple drops of maple extract. And I just pour a little
bit into the lid and then pour that in. And then I'll put on the lid to my food processor and then
blend this on high until it's smooth and creamy. Well that looks fantastic. The blender has removed
the curdled texture of the cottage cheese and now's a great time to go in for a pinky test.
And this is an excellent time to gauge the sweetness level. If you'd like it to be a little
bit sweeter, go ahead and add another tablespoon of maple syrup. But for me this is perfect. You'll
want to have a shallow dish to pour your ice cream into and it can be made out of glass or metal or
aluminum or plastic, it really doesn't matter. But having a shallow means that your ice cream is going
to freeze quicker. And next we want to scoop out about two-thirds of our ice cream mixture and pour
that into the bottom of our dish. And then just very simply spread it around with your spatula.
And then with the remaining ice cream in our food processor, we want to add three-fourths of a cup
of pumpkin puree, which is different than pumpkin pie filling. And then we'll add an additional
tablespoon of maple syrup just to help sweeten up the pumpkin. And for that classic pumpkin pie
flavor, we want to add half a teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice. And then we'll put our lid back on and
blend this until smooth. That looks perfect. And then we're going to simply pour the pumpkin layer
on top of our cream cheese layer. Now you could mix all of the ingredients together at once and
then you would just have one solid orange color. But I really like the aesthetic of having some of
the white cream mixture as well as the pumpkin mixture separate because then they can swirl
together to make a really cool marbled effect. So I'm just going to very quickly spread out the
pumpkin layer. Now to take the flavor of this ice cream to another level and to make it taste even
more like a pumpkin cheesecake pie, I'm going to add my gluten-free graham cracker bits. And
these are made very simply with oat and almond flour and have a little bit of maple syrup and
molasses in them, which gives them a really delicious graham cracker flavor. But you could
also use pre-packaged graham crackers and use gluten-free if that's your preference. So I'm just
going to go ahead and sprinkle about a half a cup of my graham cracker bits over the ice cream.
And then to get that really beautiful marbling effect between the two different colors,
I'm just going to take a spoon and I'm going to go in and just kind of like flip it over.
And I'm pulling some of the white to the top and pushing some of the orange down below. And this
is also helping to incorporate our graham cracker bits. Already looks so beautiful. And then as
you're eating your ice cream, you get to taste that little bit of contrasting flavor between the
two. And then I'll go through and just kind of smooth it out. This feels more like an art project
than making ice cream, which is never a bad thing. Well, this looks amazing and it smells just like
pumpkin pie. So now it's ready to go into the freezer for anywhere from two to four hours
or until it freezes. Well, I have one here that I made last night that I froze overnight.
Now this cottage cheese ice cream is a little different than traditional ice cream in that it
doesn't stay kind of soft and creamy even when it's fully frozen. So all you have to do is take
it out of the freezer and just let it sit on your counter for about 10 to 15 minutes and just give
it a second to thaw out. And then it's going to be nice and soft and the perfect consistency.
And then we can come in with our ice cream scoop. Oh, look at that beautiful roll of ice cream.
Oh my goodness, that looks amazing. Put this right into our bowl. I love the marbling between
the two different colors of ice cream. Make sure we get a bite with one of the graham cracker bits.
That is delicious. That tastes just like a frozen creamy pumpkin cheesecake.
As soon as I bite in, I get a burst of flavor from the pumpkin and the pumpkin pie spice.
And then I get that tanginess that comes in from the cream cheese and that little bit of lemon.
And then it's all just wrapped up in a really creamy sweetness that comes in from the maple
syrup and the cottage cheese. I love that it's not overpoweringly sweet like a traditional ice
cream that's just made with a ton of sugar. This is just sweet enough to be perfectly satisfying,
but then you get all those other delicious flavors from our natural clean ingredients.
Well, thank you so much for hanging out with me today in my kitchen. And I've included a link to
the full recipe in the video description below. And it's also on my website, gentletummy.com.
And I also invite you to like and subscribe to my channel. And if you know someone else who you
think would love to have a healthier ice cream option, please share this video with them.
And I cannot wait to have you hang out with me again in my kitchen again.
