Georg Cantor
Georg Ferdinand Ludwig Philip Cantor was a German mathematician, best known as the inventor
of set theory, which has become a fundamental theory in mathematics. Cantor established
the importance of one-to-one correspondence between the members of two sets, defined infinite
and well-ordered sets, and proved that the real numbers are more numerous than the natural
numbers. In fact, Cantor's method of proof of this theorem implies the existence of an
infinity of infinities. He defined the cardinal and ordinal numbers and their arithmetic.
Cantor's work is of great philosophical interest, a fact of which he was well aware. Cantor's
theory of transfinite numbers was originally regarded as so counterintuitive a euro even
shocking a euro that it encountered resistance from mathematical contemporaries such as Leopold
Kronecker and Henri Poincaré copyright and later from Hermann Well and L. E. J. Breuer,
while Ludwig Wittgenstein raised philosophical objections. Some Christian theologians saw
Cantor's work as a challenge to the uniqueness of the absolute infinity and the nature of
God a euro on one occasion equating the theory of transfinite numbers with pantheism a euro
a proposition that Cantor vigorously rejected. The objections to Cantor's work were occasionally
fierce, Poincaré copyright referred to his ideas as a grave disease infecting the discipline
of mathematics, and Kronecker's public opposition and personal attacks included describing Cantor
as a scientific charlatan, a renegade, and a corruptor of youth. Kronecker even objected
to Cantor's proofs that the algebraic numbers are countable, and that the transcendental
numbers are uncountable, results now included in a standard mathematics curriculum. Writing
decades after Cantor's death, Wittgenstein lamented that mathematics is written through
and through with the pernicious idioms of set theory, which he dismissed as utter nonsense
that is laughable, and wrong. Cantor's recurring bouts of depression from 1884 to the end of
his life have been blamed on the hostile attitude of many of his contemporaries, though some
have explained these episodes as probable manifestations of a bipolar disorder. The
harsh criticism has been matched by later accolades. In 1904, the Royal Society awarded
Cantor its Sylvester Medal, the highest honour it can confer for work in mathematics. It
has been suggested that Cantor believed his theory of transfinite numbers had been communicated
to him by God. David Hilbert defended it from its critics by famously declaring,
No one shall expel us from the paradise that Cantor has created.
Life, youth and studies Cantor was born in the Western Merchant Colony
in Saint Petersburg, Russia, and brought up in the city until he was eleven. Georg,
the oldest of six children, was regarded as an outstanding violinist. His grandfather
Franz Barth Paragraf H.M. was a well-known musician and soloist in a Russian imperial
orchestra. Cantor's father had been a member of the Saint Petersburg Stock Exchange. When
he became ill, the family moved to Germany in 1856, first to Wiesbaden then to Frankfurt,
seeking winters milder than those of Saint Petersburg. In 1860, Cantor graduated with
distinction from the Relschule in Darmstadt. His exceptional skills in mathematics, trigonometry
in particular, were noted. In 1862, Cantor entered the University of Saar ¼. After receiving
a substantial inheritance upon his father's death in 1863, Cantor shifted his studies
to the University of Berlin, attending lectures by Leopold Kronecker, Karl Weierstrass and
Ernst Kummer. He spent the summer of 1866 at the University of Gaar § Tingen, then
and later a centre for mathematical research. Teacher and researcher, in 1867, Cantor completed
his dissertation, on number theory, at the University of Berlin. After teaching briefly
in a Berlin girls' school, Cantor took up a position at the University of Halle, where
he spent his entire career. He was awarded the requisite habilitation for his thesis,
also on number theory, which he presented in 1869 upon his appointment at Halle. In
1874, Cantor married Valli Gutmann. They had six children, the last born in 1886. Cantor
was able to support a family despite modest academic pay, thanks to his inheritance from
his father. During his honeymoon in the Hertz Mountains, Cantor spent much time in mathematical
discussions with Richard Dedekind, whom he had met two years earlier while on Swiss holiday.
Cantor was promoted to extraordinary professor in 1872 and made full professor in 1879. To
attain the latter rank at the age of 34 was a notable accomplishment, but Cantor desired
a chair at a more prestigious university, in particular at Berlin, at that time the
leading German university. However, his work encountered too much opposition for that to
be possible. Kronecker, who headed mathematics at Berlin until his death in 1891, became
increasingly uncomfortable with the prospect of having Cantor as a colleague, perceiving
him as a corruptor of youth for teaching his ideas to a younger generation of mathematicians.
Worse yet, Kronecker, a well-established figure within the mathematical community and Cantor's
former professor, disagreed fundamentally with the thrust of Cantor's work. Kronecker,
now seen as one of the founders of the constructive viewpoint in mathematics, disliked much of
Cantor's set theory because it asserted the existence of sets satisfying certain properties,
without giving specific examples of sets whose members did indeed satisfy those properties.
Cantor came to believe that Kronecker's stance would make it impossible for him ever to leave
Hallé. In 1881, Cantor's Hallé colleague Eduard Heiner died, creating a vacant chair.
Hallé accepted Cantor's suggestion that it be offered to Dedekind, Heinrich M. Weber
and Franz Mertens, in that order, but each declined the chair after being offered it.
Friedrich Wangeren was eventually appointed, but he was never close to Cantor. In 1882,
the mathematical correspondence between Cantor and Dedekind came to an end, apparently as
a result of Dedekind's declining the chair at Hallé. Cantor also began another important
correspondence, with Gaar paragraph star Mittagallafala in Sweden, and soon began
to publish in Mittagallafala's journal Acta Mathematica. But in 1885, Mittagallafala was
concerned about the philosophical nature and new terminology in a paper Cantor had submitted
to Acta. He asked Cantor to withdraw the paper from Acta while it was in proof, writing that
Cantor complied, but then curtailed his relationship and correspondence with Mittagallafala, writing
to a third party. Had Mittagallafala had his way, I should have to wait until the year
1984, which to me seemed too great a demand. But of course I never want to know anything
again about Acta Mathematica. Cantor suffered his first known bout of depression in 1884.
Criticism of his work weighed on his mind—every one of the 52 letters he wrote to Mittagallafala
in 1884 mentioned Kronecker. A passage from one of these letters is revealing of the damage
to Cantor's self-confidence. I don't know when I shall return to the continuation of
my scientific work. At the moment I can do absolutely nothing with it, and limit myself
to the most necessary duty of my lectures. How much happier I would be to be scientifically
active, if only I had the necessary mental freshness. This crisis led him to apply to
lecture on philosophy rather than mathematics. He also began an intense study of Elizabethan
literature thinking there might be evidence that Francis Bacon wrote the plays attributed
to Shakespeare. This ultimately resulted in two pamphlets, published in 1896 and 1897.
Cantor recovered soon thereafter, and subsequently made further important contributions, including
his famous Diagonal Argument and Theorem. However, he never again attained the high
level of his remarkable papers of 1874–84. He eventually sought, and achieved, a reconciliation
with Kronecker. Nevertheless, the philosophical disagreements and difficulties dividing them
persisted. In 1890, Cantor was instrumental in founding the Deutsche Mathematik of Erinnerung
and chaired its first meeting in Halle in 1891, where he first introduced his Diagonal
Argument. His reputation was strong enough, despite Kronecker's opposition to his work,
to ensure he was elected as the first president of this society. Setting aside the animosity
Kronecker had displayed towards him, Cantor invited him to address the meeting, but Kronecker
was unable to do so because his wife was dying from injuries sustained in a skiing
accident at the time. Late years, after Cantor's 1884 hospitalization, there is no record that
he was in any sanatorium again until 1899. Soon after that second hospitalization, Cantor's
youngest son Rudolf died suddenly, and this tragedy drained Cantor of much of his passion
for mathematics. Cantor was again hospitalized in 1903. One year later, he was outraged and
agitated by a paper presented by Julius Karparagraf-Nigg at the Third International Congress of Mathematicians.
The paper attempted to prove that the basic tenets of transfinite set theory were false.
Since the paper had been read in front of his daughters and colleagues, Cantor perceived
himself as having been publicly humiliated. Although Ernst Zermelo demonstrated less than
a day later that Karparagraf-Nigg's proof had failed, Cantor remained shaken, and momentarily
questioning God. Cantor suffered from chronic depression for the rest of his life, for which
he was excused from teaching on several occasions and repeatedly confined in various sanatoria.
The events of 1904 preceded a series of hospitalizations at intervals of two or three years. He did
not abandon mathematics completely, however, lecturing on the paradoxes of set theory to
a meeting of the Deutsche Mathematikorre Euro-Vereinigung in 1903, and attending the International Congress
of Mathematicians at Heidelberg in 1904. In 1911, Cantor was one of the distinguished
foreign scholars invited to attend the 500th anniversary of the founding of the University
of St. Andrews in Scotland. Cantor attended, hoping to meet Bertrand Russell, whose newly
published Principia Mathematica repeatedly cited Cantor's work, but this did not come
about. The following year, St. Andrews awarded Cantor an honorary doctorate, but illness
precluded his receiving the degree in person. Cantor retired in 1913, living in poverty
and suffering from malnourishment during World War I. The public celebration of his 70th
birthday was cancelled because of the war. He died on 6 January 1918 in the sanatorium
where he had spent the final year of his life. Mathematical work
Cantor's work between 1874 and 1884 is the origin of set theory. Prior to this work,
the concept of a set was a rather elementary one that had been used implicitly since the
beginning of mathematics, dating back to the ideas of Aristotle. No one had realized
that set theory had any non-trivial content. Before Cantor, there were only finite sets
and the infinite. By proving that there are many possible sizes for infinite sets, Cantor
established that set theory was not trivial, and it needed to be studied. Set theory has
come to play the role of a foundational theory in modern mathematics, in the sense that it
interprets propositions about mathematical objects from all the traditional areas of
mathematics in a single theory, and provides a standard set of axioms to prove or disprove
them. The basic concepts of set theory are now used throughout mathematics. In one of
his earliest papers, Cantor proved that the set of real numbers is more numerous than
the set of natural numbers. This showed, for the first time, that there exist infinite
sets of different sizes. He was also the first to appreciate the importance of one-to-one
correspondences in set theory. He used this concept to define finite and infinite sets,
subdividing the latter into denumerable sets and uncountable sets. Cantor developed important
concepts in topology and their relation to cardinality. For example, he showed that the
Cantor set is nowhere dense, but has the same cardinality as the set of all real numbers,
whereas the rationals are everywhere dense, but countable. Cantor introduced fundamental
constructions in set theory, such as the power set of a set A, which is the set of all possible
subsets of A. He later proved that the size of the power set of A is strictly larger than
the size of A, even when A is an infinite set. This result soon became known as Cantor's
theorem. Cantor developed an entire theory and arithmetic of infinite sets, called cardinals
and ordinals, which extended the arithmetic of the natural numbers. His notation for the
cardinal numbers was the Hebrew letter with a natural number subscript. For the ordinals
he employed the Greek letter i per mil. This notation is still in use today. The continuum
hypothesis, introduced by Cantor, was presented by David Hilbert as the first of his twenty-three
open problems in his famous address at the 1900 International Congress of Mathematicians
in Paris. Cantor's work also attracted favorable notice beyond Hilbert's celebrated encomium.
The U.S. philosopher Charles Sanders Park praised Cantor's set theory, and, following
public lectures delivered by Cantor at the First International Congress of Mathematicians,
held in Zurich in 1897, Hurwitz and Hadamard also both expressed their admiration. At that
congress, Cantor renewed his friendship and correspondence with Dedekind. From 1905, Cantor
corresponded with his British admirer and translator Philip Gerdin on the history of
set theory and on Cantor's religious ideas. This was later published, as were several
of his expository works. Number theory, trigonometric series and ordinals
– Cantor's first ten papers were on number theory, his thesis topic. At the suggestion
of Eduard Heiner, the professor at Halle, Cantor turned to analysis. Heiner proposed
that Cantor solve an open problem that had eluded Peter Gustav Lijon Dirichlet, Rudolf
Lipschitz, Bernhard Riemann, and Heiner himself – the uniqueness of the representation of
a function by trigonometric series. Cantor solved this difficult problem in 1869. It
was while working on this problem that he discovered transfinite ordinals, which occurred
as indices n in the nth-derived set Sn of a set S of zeros of a trigonometric series.
Given a trigonometric series F, x, with S as its set of zeros, Cantor had discovered
a procedure that produced another trigonometric series that had S1 as its set of zeros, where
S1 is the set of limit points of S. If Sk plus 1 is the set of limit points of Sk, then
he could construct a trigonometric series whose zeros are Sk plus 1. Because the sets
Sk were closed, they contained their limit points, and the intersection of the infinite
decreasing sequence of sets S, S1, S2, S3... formed a limit set, which we would now call
C per mil, and then he noticed that C per mil would also have to have a set of limit
points C per mil plus 1, and so on. He had examples that went on forever, and so here
was a naturally occurring infinite sequence of infinite numbers I per mil, I per mil plus
1, I per mil plus 2. Between 1870 and 1872, Cantor published more papers on trigonometric
series, and also a paper defining irrational numbers as convergent sequences of rational
numbers. Dedekind, whom Cantor befriended in 1872, cited this paper later that year,
in the paper where he first set out his celebrated definition of real numbers by Dedekind cuts.
While extending the notion of number by means of his revolutionary concept of infinite cardinality,
Cantor was paradoxically opposed to theories of infinitesimals of his contemporaries Otto
Stolz and Paul Dubois Raymond, describing them as both an abomination, and a cholera
bacillus of mathematics. Cantor also published an erroneous proof of the inconsistency of
infinitesimals. Set theory
The beginning of set theory as a branch of mathematics is often marked by the publication
of Cantor's 1874 article, Allerberenigenschaft des Inbegriffes aller realen Algebrationszahlen.
This article was the first to provide a rigorous proof that there was more than one kind of
infinity. Previously, all infinite collections had been implicitly assumed to be equinumerous.
Cantor proved that the collection of real numbers and the collection of positive integers
are not equinumerous. In other words, the real numbers are not countable. His proof
is more complex than the more elegant diagonal argument that he gave in 1891. Cantor's article
also contains a new method of constructing transcendental numbers. Transcendental numbers
were first constructed by Joseph Liouville in 1844. Cantor established these results
using two constructions. His first construction shows how to write the real algebraic numbers
as a sequence a1, a2, a3, a. In other words, the real algebraic numbers are countable.
Cantor starts his second construction with any sequence of real numbers. Using this sequence,
he constructs nested intervals whose intersection contains a real number not in the sequence.
Since every sequence of real numbers can be used to construct a real not in the sequence,
the real numbers cannot be written as a sequence a0 that is, the real numbers are not countable.
By applying his construction to the sequence of real algebraic numbers, Cantor produces
a transcendental number. Cantor points out that his constructions prove more a0 namely,
they provide a new proof of Liouville's theorem, every interval contains infinitely many transcendental
numbers. Cantor's next article contains a construction that proves the set of transcendental
numbers has the same power as the set of real numbers. Between 1879 and 1884, Cantor published
a series of six articles in Mathematicianalin that together formed an introduction to his
set theory. At the same time, there was growing opposition to Cantor's ideas, led by Kronecker,
who admitted mathematical concepts only if they could be constructed in a finite number
of steps from the natural numbers, which he took as intuitively given. For Kronecker,
Cantor's hierarchy of infinities was inadmissible, since accepting the concept of actual infinity
would open the door to paradoxes which would challenge the validity of mathematics as a
whole. Cantor also introduced the Cantor set during this period. The fifth paper in the
series, Grundlageniner Allgemeinen Manifalde Keats-Lew, published in 1883, was the most
important of the six and was also published as a separate monograph. It contained Cantor's
reply to his critics and showed how the transfinite numbers were a systematic extension of the
natural numbers. It begins by defining well-ordered sets. Ordinal numbers are then introduced
as the order types of well-ordered sets. Cantor then defines the addition and multiplication
of the cardinal and ordinal numbers. In 1885, Cantor extended his theory of order types
so that the ordinal numbers simply became a special case of order types. In 1891, he
published a paper containing his elegant diagonal argument for the existence of an uncountable
set. He applied the same idea to prove Cantor's theorem—the cardinality of the power set
of a set A is strictly larger than the cardinality of A. This established the richness of the
hierarchy of infinite sets, and of the cardinal and ordinal arithmetic that Cantor had defined.
His argument is fundamental in the solution of the halting problem and the proof of Gaard
paragraph del's first incompleteness theorem. Cantor wrote on the Goldbach conjecture in
1894. In 1895 and 1897, Cantor published a two-part paper in Mathematiciennelen under
Felix Klein's editorship. These were his last significant papers on set theory. The first
paper begins by defining set, subset, etc., in ways that would be largely acceptable
now. The cardinal and ordinal arithmetic are reviewed. Cantor wanted the second paper to
include a proof of the continuum hypothesis, but had to settle for expositing his theory
of well-ordered sets and ordinal numbers. Cantor attempts to prove that if A and B are
sets with A equivalent to a subset of B and B equivalent to a subset of A, then A and
theorem a bit earlier, but his proof, as well as Cantor's, was flawed. Felix Bernstein supplied
a correct proof in his 1898 Ph.D. thesis. Hence the name Cantor–Auro Bernstein–Auro
Schröder theorem. One-to-one correspondence. Cantor's 1874 Krell paper was the first to
invoke the notion of a one-to-one correspondence, though he did not use that phrase. He then
began looking for a one-to-one correspondence between the points of the unit square and
the points of a unit line segment. In an 1877 letter to Dedekind, Cantor proved a far stronger
result – for any positive integer n, there exists a one-to-one correspondence between
the points on the unit line segment and all of the points in an n-dimensional space. About
this discovery Cantor famously wrote to Dedekind, « Je le vois, mais je n'y le crois pas ». The
result that he found so astonishing has implications for geometry and the notion of dimension.
In 1878, Cantor submitted another paper to Krell's journal, in which he defined precisely
the concept of a one-to-one correspondence, and introduced the notion of power, or equivalence
of sets – two sets are equivalent if there exists a one-to-one correspondence between
them. Cantor defined countable sets as sets which can be put into a one-to-one correspondence
with the natural numbers, and proved that the rational numbers are denumerable. He also
proved that n-dimensional Euclidean space Rn has the same power as the real numbers
R, as does a countably infinite product of copies of R. While he made free use of countability
as a concept, he did not write the word countable until 1883. Cantor also discussed his thinking
about dimension, stressing that his mapping between the unit interval and the unit square
was not a continuous one. This paper displeased Kronecker, and Cantor wanted to withdraw it.
However, Dedekind persuaded him not to do so and Weierstrass supported its publication.
Nevertheless, Cantor never again submitted anything to Krell.
Continuum hypothesis Cantor was the first to formulate what later
came to be known as the continuum hypothesis or CH, there exists no set whose power is
greater than that of the naturals and less than that of the reals. Cantor believed the
continuum hypothesis to be true and tried for many years to prove it, in vain. His inability
to prove the continuum hypothesis caused him considerable anxiety. The difficulty
Cantor had in proving the continuum hypothesis has been underscored by later developments
in the field of mathematics, a 1940 result by Garth Paragraphdel and a 1963 one by Paul
Cohen together imply that the continuum hypothesis can neither be proved nor disproved using
standards or Miller–Weier–Fraenkel set theory plus the axiom of choice. Paradoxes
of set theory Discussions of set-theoretic paradoxes began
to appear around the end of the 19th century. Some of these implied fundamental problems
with Cantor's set theory program. In an 1897 paper on an unrelated topic, Sir Biroli Forti
set out the first such paradox, the Biroli–Forti paradox, the ordinal number of the set of
all ordinals must be inordinal and this leads to a contradiction. Cantor discovered this
paradox in 1895, and described it in an 1896 letter to Hilbert. Criticism mounted to the
point where Cantor launched counter-arguments in 1903, intended to defend the basic tenets
of his set theory. In 1899, Cantor discovered his eponymous paradox, what is the cardinal
number of the set of all sets? Clearly it must be the greatest possible cardinal. Yet
for any set A, the cardinal number of the power set of A is strictly larger than the
cardinal number of A. This paradox, together with Biroli–Forti's, led Cantor to formulate
a concept called limitation of size, according to which the collection of all ordinals, or
of all sets, was an inconsistent multiplicity that was too large to be a set. Such collections
later became known as proper classes. One common view among mathematicians is that these
paradoxes, together with Russell's paradox, demonstrate that it is not possible to take
a naive, or non-axiomatic, approach to set theory without risking contradiction, and
it is certain that they were among the motivations for Zermelo and others to produce axiomatizations
of set theory. Others note, however, that the paradoxes do not obtain in an informal
view motivated by the iterative hierarchy, which can be seen as explaining the idea of
limitation of size. Some also question whether the Fijian formulation of naive set theory
is really a faithful interpretation of the Cantorian conception. Philosophy, religion,
and Cantor's mathematics, the concept of the existence of an actual infinity was an important
shared concern within the realms of mathematics, philosophy and religion. Preserving the orthodoxy
of the relationship between God and mathematics, although not in the same form as held by his
critics, was long the concern of Cantor's. He directly addressed this intersection between
these disciplines in the introduction to his Grundlageniner Allgemeine und Manifalte Kürzleu,
where he stressed the connection between his view of the infinite and the philosophical
one. To Cantor, his mathematical views were intrinsically linked to their philosophical
and theological implications.: Auro he identified the absolute infinite with God, and he considered
his work on transfinite numbers to have been directly communicated to him by God, who had
chosen Cantor to reveal them to the world. Debate among mathematicians grew out of opposing
views in the philosophy of mathematics regarding the nature of actual infinity. Some held to
the view that infinity was an abstraction which was not mathematically legitimate, and
denied its existence. Mathematicians from three major schools of thought opposed Cantor's
theories in this matter. For constructivists such as Kronecker, this rejection of actual
infinity stems from fundamental disagreement with the idea that non-constructive proofs
such as Cantor's diagonal argument are sufficient proof that something exists, holding instead
that constructive proofs are required. Intuitionism also rejects the idea that actual infinity
is an expression of any sort of reality, but arrive at the decision via a different route
than constructivism. Firstly, Cantor's argument rests on logic to prove the existence of transfinite
numbers as an actual mathematical entity, whereas intuitionists hold that mathematical
entities cannot be reduced to logical propositions, originating instead in the intuitions of the
mind. Secondly, the notion of infinity as an expression of reality is itself disallowed
in intuitionism, since the human mind cannot intuitively construct an infinite set. Mathematicians
such as Brahe and especially Poincaré copyright adopted an intuitionist stance against Cantor's
work. Citing the paradoxes of set theory as an example of its fundamentally flawed nature,
Poincaré copyright held that most of the ideas of Cantorian set theory should be banished
from mathematics once and for all. Finally, Wittgenstein's attacks were finitist—he believed
that Cantor's diagonal argument conflated the intention of a set of cardinal or real
numbers with its extension, thus conflating the concept of rules for generating a set
with an actual set. Some Christian theologians saw Cantor's work as a challenge to the uniqueness
of the absolute infinity and the nature of God. In particular, Neo-Thomas Thinkers saw
the existence of an actual infinity that consisted of something other than God as jeopardizing
God's exclusive claim to supreme infinity. Cantor strongly believed that this view was
a misinterpretation of infinity, and was convinced that set theory could help correct this mistake.
The transfinite species are just as much at the disposal of the intentions of the Creator
and his absolute boundless will as are the finite numbers. Cantor also believed that
his theory of transfinite numbers ran counter to both materialism and determinism a euro,
and was shocked when he realized that he was the only faculty member at Hallé who did
not hold to deterministic philosophical beliefs. In 1888, Cantor published his correspondence
with several philosophers on the philosophical implications of his set theory. In an extensive
attempt to persuade other Christian thinkers and authorities to adopt his views, Cantor
had corresponded with Christian philosophers such as Tilman Peche and Joseph Von Theim,
as well as theologians such as Cardinal Johannes Framslin, who once replied by equating the
theory of transfinite numbers with pantheism. Cantor even sent one letter directly to Pope
Leo XIII himself, and addressed several pamphlets to him. Cantor's philosophy on the nature
of numbers led him to affirm a belief in the freedom of mathematics to posit and prove
concepts apart from the realm of physical phenomena, as expressions within an internal
reality. The only restrictions on this metaphysical system are that all mathematical concepts
must be devoid of internal contradiction, and that they follow from existing definitions,
axioms, and theorems. This belief is summarized in his famous assertion that the essence of
mathematics is its freedom. These ideas parallel those of Edmund Husserl, whom Cantor had met
in Hallé. Meanwhile, Cantor himself was fiercely opposed to infinitesimals, describing
them as both an abomination, and the cholera bacillus of mathematics. Cantor's 1883 paper
reveals that he was well aware of the opposition his ideas were encountering. I realize that
in this undertaking I place myself in a certain opposition to views widely held concerning
the mathematical infinite and to opinions frequently defended on the nature of numbers.
Hence he devotes much space to justifying his earlier work, asserting that mathematical
concepts may be freely introduced as long as they are free of contradiction and defined
in terms of previously accepted concepts. He also cites Aristotle, Descartes, Berkeley,
Leibniz, and Bolzano on infinity. Cantor's Ancestry
Cantor's paternal grandparents were from Copenhagen, and fled to Russia from the disruption of
the Napoleonic Wars. There is very little direct information on his grandparents. Cantor
was sometimes called Jewish in his lifetime, but has also variously been called Russian,
German, and Danish as well. Jacob Cantor, Cantor's grandfather, gave his children Christian
saints' names. Further, several of his grandmother's relatives were in the tsarist civil service,
which would not welcome Jews, unless they converted to Christianity. Cantor's father,
Georg Waldmer Cantor, was educated in the Lutheran mission in St. Petersburg, and his
correspondence with his son shows both of them as devout Lutherans. Very little is known
for sure about Georg Waldmer's origin or education. His mother, Maria Anna Bar-Paragraf H.M.,
was an Austro-Hungarian born in St. Petersburg and baptized Roman Catholic. She converted
to Protestantism upon marriage. However, there is a letter from Cantor's brother Louis to
their mother, stating,
Ma Paragraf Genwazinor von Judenabstammen und ich im Prinzip noch so sofar ¼ Gleichberechtigung
der Hebräkurrenze ersehen, im Sozium Lebens in mir Christenliebe. Even if we were descended
from Jews ten times over, and even though I may be, in principle, completely in favor
of equal rights for Hebrews, in social life I prefer Christians. Which could be read to
imply that she was of Jewish ancestry. There were documented statements, during the 1930s,
that called this Jewish ancestry into question. More often, that is, than the ancestry of
the mother the question has been discussed of whether Georg Cantor was of Jewish origin.
About this it is reported in a notice of the Danish Genealogical Institute in Copenhagen
from the year 1937 concerning his father, it is hereby testified that Georg Waldmann
Cantor, born 1809 or 1814, is not present in the registers of the Jewish community,
and that he completely without doubt was not a Jewer. It is also later said in the same
document. Also efforts for a long time by the librarian Josef Fischer, one of the best
experts on Jewish genealogy in Denmark, charged with identifying Jewish professors, that
Georg Cantor was of Jewish descent, finished without result. Something seems to be wrong
with this sentence, but the meaning seems clear enough. In Cantor's published works
and also in his knackers there are no statements by himself which relate to a Jewish origin
of his ancestors. There is to be sure in the knackers a copy of a letter of his brother
Ludwig from November 18, 1869 to their mother with some unpleasant anti-Semitic statements,
in which it is said among other things, a. The rest of the quote is finished by the very
first quote above. In Men of Mathematics, Eric Temple Bell described Cantor as being
of pure Jewish descent on both sides, although both parents were baptized. In a 1971 article
entitled Towards a Biography of Georg Cantor, the British historian of mathematics Ivor
Gretan Guinness mentions that he was unable to find evidence of Jewish ancestry, in a
letter written by Georg Cantor to Paul Tannery in 1896, Cantor states that his paternal grandparents
were members of the Sephardic Jewish community of Copenhagen. Specifically, Cantor states
in describing his father, Aristobo in Copenhagen-Gebran, von Israelitischen Eltern, die der deutischen
Portugiesischen Judengemeinde. Parents from the local Portuguese Jewish community. In
addition, Cantor's maternal great-uncle, a Hungarian violinist Josef Bar Paragraf H.M.,
has been described as Jewish, which may imply that Cantor's mother was at least partly descended
from the Hungarian Jewish community. In a letter to Bertrand Russell, Cantor described
his ancestry and self-perception as follows. Neither my father nor my mother were of German
blood, the first being a Dane, born in Copenhagen, my mother of Austrian-Hungar descention. You
must know, sir, that I am not a regular just Germain, for I am born March 3, 1845 at Saint-Peterborough,
capital of Russia, but I went with my father and mother and brothers and sister, eleven
years old in the year 1856, into Germany. Historiography
Until the 1970s, the chief academic publications on Cantor were two short monographs by Shaparograf
Nflies Auro largely the correspondence with Mitaglifler Auro, and Frankel. Both were at
second and third hand. Neither had much on his personal life. The gap was largely filled
by Eric Temple Bell's Men of Mathematics, which one of Cantor's modern biographers describes
as perhaps the most widely read modern book on the history of mathematics. And as one
of the worst. Bell presents Cantor's relationship with his father as Oedipal, Cantor's differences
with Kronecker as a quarrel between two Jews, and Cantor's madness as romantic despair over
his failure to win acceptance for his mathematics, and fills the picture with stereotypes. Gretton
Guinness found that none of these claims were true, but they may be found in many books
of the intervening period, owing to the absence of any other narrative. There are other legends,
independent of Bell Auro including one that labels Cantor's father a foundling, shipped
to St. Petersburg by unknown parents. A critique of Bell's book is contained in Joseph Dauben's
biography. See also Cantor algebra
Cantor cube Cantor function
in honour of Georg Cantor Cantor set
Cantor space Cantor's back-and-forth method
Controversy over Cantor's theory Heine–Euro–Cantor theorem
Infinity List of German inventors and discoverers
Pairing function Notes
References Dauben, Joseph W., Georg Cantor and Pope
Leo XIII, Mathematics, Theology, and the Infinite, Journal of the History of Ideas
38, 85a Euro 108, JSTOR A2708842a. Dauben, Joseph W., Georg Cantor, His Mathematics
and Philosophy of the Infinite, Boston, Harvard University Press, ISBN A978-0-691-02447-9a.
Dauben, Joseph, Georg Cantor and the Battle for Transfinite Set Theory, Proceedings of
the Ninth ACMS Conference, pp. A1–EU 22a. Internet version published in Journal of the
William B., ed., From Immanuel Cantor to David Hilbert, A Source Book in the Foundations
of Mathematics, New York, Oxford University Press, ISBN A978-0-19-853271-2a.
a biography of Georg Cantor, Annals of Science 27, 345a Euro 391, doi, 10.1080//00033797100203837a.
Gratom Guinness, Ivor, The Search for Mathematical Roots, 1870a Euro 1940, Princeton University
Press, ISBN A978-0-691-05858-0a. Hallett, Michael, Cantorian Set Theory and
Limitation of Size, New York, Oxford University Press, ISBN A0-19-853283-0a.
Packert, Walter. Illgoods, Hans Joachim, Georg Cantor, 1845a Euro 1918, Berker Currency
User, ISBN A0-8176-1770-1a. Suppes, Patrick, Axiomatic Set Theory, New
York, Dover, ISBN A0-486-61630-4a. Although the presentation is axiomatic rather
than naive, Suppes proves and discusses many of Cantor's results, which demonstrates Cantor's
continued importance for the edifice of foundational mathematics. Bibliography, older sources on
Cantor's life should be treated with caution. See Historiography section above.
Primary literature in English, Cantor, Georg, 1915, Philip Gerdin, ed., Contributions to
the Founding of the Theory of Transfinite Numbers, New York, Dover, ISBN A978-0-486-60045-1a.
Primary literature in German, Cantor, Georg, Weber-Aniagenschaft des Inbegriffes oder Reihen
und Angewandte Mathematik 77, 258a Euro 262a. Cantor, Georg. Grundlagen einer Erlebnis
in mannigfaltigkeitslühe. Mathematische Anaheim 21, 545a Euro 586a. Cantor, Georg. Beiträge
zur Begründung der Transfinitenmengenluhe. Mathematische Anaheim 46, 481a Euro 512a.
Cantor, Georg. Beiträge zur Begründung der Transfinitenmengenluhe. Mathematische Anaheim
49, 207a Euro 246a. Cantor, Georg, und Zermelo, ed., Gesamte Abendlungen mathematischen und
philosophischen Inhalts, Berlin, Springer. Almost Everything That Cantor Wrote. Includes
excerpts of his correspondence with Dedekind and Frenkel's Cantor biography in the appendix.
Secondary literature, Atchel, Amir D., The Mystery of the Aleph, Mathematics, The Kabbalah,
and the Search for Infinity, New York, Four Walls Eight Windows Publishinger. ISBN 0-7607-7778-0.
A Popular Treatment of Infinity, in which Cantor is frequently mentioned.
Dauben, Joseph W., Georg Cantor and the Origins of Transfinite Set Theory, Scientific American
248, 122a Euro 131a, Ferreira Cubedesse, Josa Copyright, Labyrinth of Thought, A History
of Set Theory and Its Role in Mathematical Thought, Basel, Switzerland, Berker Currency
Userer. ISBN 3-7643-8349-6 Contains a detailed treatment of both Cantor's and Dedekind's
contributions to set theory. Halmose, Paul, Naïve Set Theory, New York and Berlin, Springerer.
ISBN 3-540-90092-6, Hilbert, David. Arabidassun English. Mathematische Annalen 95, 161a Euro
190. doi, 10.1007/.bf01206605a, Hill, C.O. Rossado Haddock, G.E., Hussle or Friege? Meaning,
Objectivity, and Mathematics, Chicago, Open Quarter. ISBN 0-8126-9538-03 Chapters and
Herbert, Georg Cantor, Leben, Werke und Verkunft, Weitberg, Brandschweiger, Penrose, Roger,
The Road to Reality, Alfred A. Knopper. ISBN 0-679-77631-1 Chapter 16 illustrates how Cantorian
thinking intrigues a leading contemporary theoretical physicist. Rucker, Rudy, Infinity
and the Mind, Princeton University Presser. ISBN 0-553-25531-2 deals with similar topics
to Atchell, but in more depth. Rodditch, Victor, Wittgenstein's Philosophy
of Mathematics, in Edward N. Zalta, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophical. External links
O'Connor, John J. Robertson, Edmund F., Georg Cantor, Maxeter History of Mathematics Archive,
University of St. Andrews. O'Connor, John J. Robertson, Edmund F., A History of Set
Theory, Maxeter History of Mathematics Archive, University of St. Andrews. Mainly devoted
to Cantor's accomplishment. Georg Cantor at the Mathematics Genealogy Project, Stanford
Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Set Theory by Thomas J. H. Grammar School
Georg Cantor Hallé, Georg Cantor Gymnasium Hallé, Poem about Georg Cantor

