Let's Talk About Some Prospects (Statline Scouting)

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Welcome back to not Out of the Park Baseball 25. This is Statline Scouting. Statline Scouting is a
series I do a couple times a year where I check in on some of the top performers in minor league
baseball and talk about interesting prospects that might be off the radar. If you are looking
for a video where I talk about how Jackson Holliday is doing or how James Wood is doing,
this is not the video for you. This is an exercise to see if I can identify future
major league contributors based only on their stats. And as per usual, the main tool I will
be using to identify these talents is the Fangraphs Minor League Leaderboards with a
little help from MLB Pipeline later on. So we'll start here in AAA and work our way down the minor
league level. Here are the top qualified hitters in AAA this season by WRC Plus, Weighted Runs
where 100 is average. James Wood, who I just mentioned before, leads the way. He's a mega
prospect. We're not going to talk about him. And then you'll see some other names coming up. Oh,
well, here's David Dahl, but he's 30. Here's Jonah Bryde, but he's 28. Here's Daniel Schneeman,
whose last name kind of rhymes with mine. But those guys, they're old for AAA. So one thing
we can do is we can set a filter and we can say, hey, how about guys who are 25 or younger?
And there we start to see prospects. We see Heston Kerstad, who is a big draft pick. Miguel Vargas
has been up and down the big leagues. We see, you know, the Orioles guys, Jackson Holliday and Kobe
Mayo. The guy I want to talk about is Adrian Del Castillo for the Arizona Diamondbacks. He was
selected in the 2021 draft by the Diamondbacks, 67th overall out of the University of Miami.
This is a left-handed hitting catcher, although based on what I've read and some of these Fangraphs
grades, kind of fringy there defensively. Not sure if he would be able to play there at the
big league level. They're hoping he will, of course. And one thing that really stands out to
me looking at his stats so far this year is this is not his first stint in AAA. He made it to AAA
last year after a good stint in AA in the first half of the season. And when he made it to AAA,
he did not do well. He had a 72 WRC+, he hit two homers in 37 games. This year, through 49 games,
he has 10 homers. You know, everything is up. His batting average is up 100 points. His on-base
is up about 55 points. His slug, his ISO are just way up. He's OPSing over 1,000. And he's being
really aggressive. You can see that by the fact that his strikeout rate is way down, but also his
walk rate is way down. He is just trying to make impact, make power. And that has worked for him.
He's hit plenty of home runs already, and he's showing off his power swing in AAA. And that's
exciting to see because he ranks among one of the best hitters, at least younger hitters,
in AAA so far this season. This is the only time I'll use it in this video, but there is stat
cast data for AAA players. They have a nice search on Baseball Savant. This is a fairly new feature.
But I'm just looking at total barrels at the AAA level this year. And Del Castillo is second. He's
had 20 barrels this year. That sandwiches him between Kobe Mayo and Oralvis Martinez. Both
those guys are top 100 prospects. Adrian Del Castillo more under the radar. The Diamondback
system is populated at the top by guys like Jordan Lawler, Tommy Troy, Drew Jones, and stat line
scouting alum Yu-Min Lin. But we'll have to scroll down to number 28 to find Mr. Del Castillo.
On the pitching side of things in AAA, we're going to talk about a player who was recently traded.
More on that later. So here's our AAA leaderboard. And you know, we could sort by all kinds
of stats. But if we sort by ERA, we find ERA is maybe not the most indicative thing of success.
We're talking about like a 30 inning sample like we're using right now. So the best ERA guy is
Michael Mercado. But he's walking 14% of the batters he faces and only striking out 22% of
them. That's probably not going to lead to long term success. So let's sort by FIP instead. That's
going to look at the three true outcomes. And if we're looking for young pitchers who have a good
FIP so far in AAA, the guy that definitely stands out is Joe Rock. Joe Rock has a 3.41 FIP and 3.45
ERA for the Tampa Bay Rays. I believe that's the Durham Bulls, their AAA affiliate across 47
innings at the age of 23. And Joe Rock is interesting because not only was he picked 68th
overall in the 2021 draft, which means he was picked one pick after Adrian Del Castillo. That's
interesting. He was drafted by the Rockies. So he's on the Rays now, but he was drafted by the
Rockies and he was traded this past offseason for Greg Jones. And what was basically sort of a 40
man roster crunch trade for the Rays. They wanted to get Greg Jones off the 40 man roster. They only
had so many 40 man spots. And so they orchestrated this trade with the Rockies. And I think the
lesson here is don't trade prospects with the Rays. I think we've seen that time and time again.
Do not trade prospects in particular with the Rays. They know how to identify talent. Joe Rock,
you know, was pretty good in 2023 with Colorado in their system. He was striking out, you know,
27% of the batters he faced in AA this year, 24% of the batters faced he struck out in AAA and only
a 5% walk rate. That is very good stuff to see from Mr. Joe Rock, a tall lefty. And I've seen
video of him, but he's a tall lefty with a low release point, kind of an interesting, almost
Chris Sale arm action. And here are the top prospects in the Rays system. According to MLB
Pipeline, this is headed by Junior Caminero and Carson Williams. We will have to scroll down a bit
to number 17 for Joe Rock and what is ultimately a pretty deep system usually. And as you can see,
as mentioned in their writeup, the Rays acquired him in March and a straight up swap for 2019
first rounder Greg Jones. So recently traded, but doing well in new organization. The next player
that we're going to be looking at is also a pitcher and also in AAA, but we're really going
to be honing in on his AA stats first. And that is Andrew Walters in the Cleveland Guardians system.
So if we sort by players with at least 20 innings pitched, age 23, younger in AA, one of my favorite
stats to look at is strikeout rate minus walk rate, especially across a smaller sample. It's
very easy to explain. You know, it does what it says on the tin and his strikeout rate minus walk
rate is absolutely dominant compared to every other young pitcher on this list. And there's
a caveat with that because Andrew Walters, as you'll soon find out, is a reliever. This is a
reliever prospect. And when the Guardians selected Andrew Walters towards the end of the second round
of the draft just last summer, I think they knew they were getting a relief prospect who is going
to make an impact in the big leagues sooner rather than later. This was a guy with proximity
to the big leagues right away. He has made his pro debut for them this year. In AAA, one outing,
not good. Walk, two home runs, four runs allowed, not a good outing. But if we hone in on the AA
stats, 46% strikeout rate, 10% walk rate, 1.35 ERA, 1.75 FIP. That is very impressive. And I think
he's very relevant because he could be a high leverage relief option for a team that has been
one of the best in the American League to start the season. Looking at MLB Pipeline's rankings of
the Cleveland Guardians system, you'll find Andrew Walters at number 24. And I don't envy the people
who have to rank, you know, a close to the big leagues relief option versus a, you know, 18 year
old shortstop in A ball. Like how do you even quantify the potential impact of those types of
players and compare them to one another, but they're right up for Walters. The thing that
stands out to me is that it mentions his reliance on the fastball. He used it 84% of the time with
the Miami Hurricanes. So another Miami guy. And so it's, it's tough for him. I think he has a great
fastball and he is working on the secondaries, but a great fastball is a great jumping off point.
Looking at qualified AA hitters. Now we find some interesting names at the top of the WRC
plus leaderboard. Davison De Los Santos was interesting because he was actually rule five
by Cleveland and then returned back to Arizona. People were a little surprised that Arizona left
him uncovered. He has big power, but he's back with Arizona and absolutely tearing it up for
them in AA. Carson Williams is a big race prospect, a former first rounder for them.
Emmanuel Rodriguez has been covered in this series a while back, honestly. So of course,
the guy I want to talk about is Matthew Lugo of the Boston Red Sox. Matthew Lugo was selected in
the second round of the 2019 draft by the Red Sox out of Carlos Beltran Baseball Academy in Puerto
Rico. This is especially relevant because Carlos Beltran is Matthew Lugo's uncle. So baseball
definitely runs in the family. Matthew Lugo is listed as a shortstop and he's been a shortstop
for a lot of his pro career. Keep in mind, this guy was drafted at 19. So he's been a pro for
five years now. Last year, moved over to third base and this year left field. So he's moved down
the defensive spectrum. He could no longer be thought of as a middle infielder, maybe more of
a corner outfielder, at least based on how the Red Sox are using him now. But man, look at the
transformation offensively because this guy has been kind of inconsistent. But last year in AA,
five homers in 83 games. This year in AA, 11 homers in 41 games. He's basically quadrupled
his home run rate. The strikeouts are down. The walks are up from 84 WRC plus a year ago to 193
and he's still fairly young. He's only just turned 23 a few weeks ago. This is an exciting
offensive transformation for Matthew Lugo. And if you hop on the MLB pipeline and look at the
Boston Red Sox top 30 prospects and you scroll and you scroll and you scroll, you'll see many names,
but you will not see Matthew Lugo. He's listed outside of the top 30 for now.
I love scouting for prospects, but I also like scouting for seats. And the best tool for that
is going to be SeatGeek. Whenever somebody does this ad, they just try to choose the cheapest
team, the cheapest game available. And they say, Hey, I can get you $20 off. But if you
want to go to the angels game to see them play a little league team at 10 in the morning,
look, it's only $1 and my code will get you $20 off. So it's basically free or whatever.
That's not what I'm going to do. Let's talk about the Red Sox. This is a big market team. People
want to go to Fenway and let's say they want to see the Atlanta Braves on a Tuesday night at 710.
This is a game that actual people will probably want to go to. Here's what I would do. I would
sort by deal score, deal score, just base the tickets on their location and their price and
gives them a score from one to 10. This is a 10. Look at this view of Fenway for a $64 each.
You can look around this simulation. I promise you this guy will sit down. I promise you this
woman who will be seated to your left. We'll make some excellent conversation with you about
will your bray you. That is my promise. A seed geek use code foolish at checkout for $20 off
your tickets or don't, I really don't care. I make more money than teachers doing this
and I am not proud of it. We are continuing to move down the minor league ladder. Next up is
high. And in high, we're going to discuss a couple of bats were probably the most relevant
prospects we'll talk about in this video. And chief among those is going to be Carter Jensen
because Carter Jensen is an age 20 catching prospect for the Kansas City Royals. And even
looking at his fan graphs page right here, he was listed in February as a name to know 100 more
relevant prospects. So outside of their top 100 list, but maybe in sort of their de facto top 200
among all prospects in baseball. And the thing that's interesting about Carter Jensen was a
couple of things drafted in the third round, but with a bonus of 1.1 million, which means the
Royals had to pay significantly over slot to lure him away from going to college. And in doing so,
I think they did a good job because this is a young catcher who has hit at every level he has
played in so far in minor league baseball, despite the fact that he's been younger on average than
the competition he's facing off against. And this year so far in high A has been his most
impressive outing. And I'm curious to see if they would consider promoting him to double a
sometime soon, that jump from high A to double A is probably the hardest jump to make in the
minors. It's also really hard to go from, you know, rookie ball to full season, a ball, and
also obviously from triple A to the majors, but that high A to double A seems to give people a
lot of problems. And Carter Jensen is quite young, he's still only 20. But look at what he's done in
high A this year. And even you can compare it to last year. You know, he has five home runs in 48
games. But for me, it's the, you know, look at the strikeout rate just coming down 5%. Look at the
fact that he's struck out almost as many times as he's walked. Look at the fact that he's hitting,
you know, 306 average 430 on base 503 slug for a 162 WRC plus, and this is a legit catching prospect.
So that is very exciting for the Royals and Carter Jensen. Looking at MLB Pipeline's top
prospects in the Royal system, this is not the best system in baseball by any means,
but they do have Carter Jensen at 10th, I would actually argue for him to be in the top five,
I'm pretty convinced he would be in their top five at a minimum. The write up for him on Pipeline
notes a few things, double A likely being his home. So I think hopefully promotion is coming
soon the way he's hitting at high A, that'll really challenge him. And we'll really see,
you know how he can do at a higher level in the minor leagues. But they like his incredible eye
at the plate, having drawn 175 walks in his first two pro seasons could be an on base percentage
king. And next up in that group of high A bats is Henry Bolt, who is also a 20 year old. He's an
outfielder in the Oakland athletic system drafted by them in the second round of the 2022 draft out
of Palo Alto High School. So that must mean he is a Bay Area local. And for a bonus of 2 million,
again, significantly over the slot value for that pick, you pay for those high upside high school
bats in the hopes of convincing them not to go to college. In this case, it looks like a good
decision once again, at least based on his performance in 2024, hadn't exactly killed it
to start his minor league career. But now in high A, he seems to really be getting into his power
and speed potential eight home runs in 47 games at high A as a 20 year old, he is six foot three
195 pounds. So this is a big guy who still has some room to grow maybe into that frame even more.
And in a case of what is nominative determinism, the guy with the last name Bolt does enjoy
bolting around the base paths and stealing bases. 32 steals last year, this year, 20 steals in 47
games already. So this is a nice power speed outfielder with a 163 WRC plus in high A at the
age of 20. The Oakland A's are very much trying to rebuild this minor league system in 2024. It
is headed by their first rounder last year, Jacob Wilson, who is absolutely killing it this year.
He's also been all right for me in OTP Denzel Clark, their number three prospect has been
better for me in OTP. We'll have to go down to number 10 for Henry Bolt. So same ranking as
Carter Jensen. But yeah, the the writeup likes him a lot. Eye popping raw power in the case of Bolt.
I do have a couple high A pitchers I want to look at as well. The first one is Jaden Ham,
a right-handed pitching prospect, 21 years old for the Detroit Tigers. He was drafted last summer
in the draft, a fifth rounder, 143rd overall pick out of middle Tennessee state. What I like about
Jaden Ham, this guy hates allowing runs. This guy absolutely despises allowing runs. He hates
allowing walks. He hates allowing home runs. Take a look at his minor league career. In his minor
league career, Jaden Ham has allowed four runs. He has allowed four runs. He has appeared in 15
games. He's thrown about 50 innings. He has allowed four runs. He has allowed two home runs.
He has allowed six walks and let's get this math right, 63 strikeouts. So pretty outrageous ratios
this year for him in high A, a 35% walk rate and 4% strikeout rate. And they are using him as a
starter. He's going out there. He is making starts. He has 10 of them already. He's averaging,
you know, between three to four innings per start. That's pretty normal for a 21 year old at his
level. You're not going to pitch super deep into games, but that is very exciting to me.
This guy hates allowing runs. This guy hates allowing walks. This guy hates allowing home runs,
but he enjoys a strikeout or 63. Jackson Jobe, Max Clark, and Jace Young are the top prospects
in the Tiger system. According to pipeline, if we go down to 18, we will in fact find Jaden Ham
and his best graded pitch by them is going to be the fastball, which is described as having average
20.3 inches of induced vertical break. That is very impressive. That is a very impressive number.
And what's interesting is that the writeup says Ham showed spotty or commanding college.
And given his walk rate as a professional so far, that's clearly something that he has sought
to improve. The last high eight player I'm going to talk about is also a pitcher, but I'm first
going to focus on his stats in a, so this picture has earned a promotion. Let's talk about what he
did in a, and one thing that I really like is who can miss bats and who can get ground balls,
who's going to get the swing and miss. And when they don't get the swing and miss, who is going
to get a ground out? Those are the pictures I like a lot. That's kind of, you know, like a
Brandon Woodruff or a Logan Webb type pitcher. Those guys are really good at that.
So I sorted by the top ground ball rate among pitchers in a ball. And I was also keeping an
eye over here on this column, which is their swinging strike rate. And relative to age,
one guy that really impressed me was Luis de Leon, a pitching prospect for the Baltimore Orioles,
who in a ball this year had a 63% ground ball rate and a 16% swinging strike rate.
That is very impressive because another way to describe what Luis de Leon did this year
at a ball is to say two thirds of his batter versus pitcher matchups ended with him either
inducing a ground ball or a strikeout. So over two thirds of the time that happened,
those are great outcomes for a pitcher generally. And as you can see, running a high ground ball
rate is nothing new for him at every stop he has made in the minor league. So far,
he has run a ground ball rate over 60%. That is very impressive. Look at some of the run
prevention metrics. Look at the XFIP across the board. This guy has been a minor league performer.
And because of that, he has earned a promotion to high A, which we also really like. I like
promotions. I like when a guy has already gotten a promotion. They were impressed with what he did
at a ball and in high A the numbers not as good, but look, he's only 21 years old. And this is,
a 6-3 left-handed pitching prospect. So that's very exciting. I'm excited about Luis de Leon
for the Baltimore Orioles. Let's learn just a little bit more about him.
The Baltimore Orioles farm system is stacked. You look at these names and you know,
they are absolutely stacked, particularly in terms of position players in the upper minors.
And the fact that Luis de Leon ranks at 17th is honestly quite impressive given how stacked
the system is. But the thing that stands out to me within this write-up is that it's an example
of the Baltimore Orioles process and how they've been able to build up their farm system because
it's not always, you know, making a great, awesome number one overall draft pick like,
you know, Jackson Holliday or Adley Rutschman before him. Look at Luis de Leon. They signed
him out of the Dominican Republic for only $30,000. So he was certainly not one of the premier
international amateur free agents at the time, but through good process, they were able to identify
his talent. And now just a few years later, he is a very relevant pitching prospect for them.
Back to our minor league leaderboard, we have another pitcher in A-ball I wanted to talk about,
and we're really using the age filter the best we can here. Ages 20 or younger. So these guys
are quite, quite young, particularly for the level they are pitching at. These are qualified
pitchers based on innings pitched. And if we sort by ex-FIP, number one is Santiago Suarez,
who we have highlighted in this before. Jacob Steinmetz stands out to me as a name. This is
someone who made a name for himself in the world baseball classic. If you'll recall,
the guy I want to talk about is a Pittsburgh Pirates arm named Michael Kennedy, who is doing
it at age 19. Michael Kennedy is also a left-handed pitching prospect, a fourth rounder for the
Pirates back in 2022. And the thing that stands out to me is this guy has been a pretty good
performer across the board relative to his age group. In 2023, which represented his pro debut,
a pretty good showing at the complex league level because this is Pittsburgh. I guess that would
have been the Florida complex league. There's also an Arizona complex league, more on that later.
But yeah, even at that level, he was striking out 32% of the batters he faced and had an ERA
hovering around two. And he has made that jump into full season eight ball. They actually gave
him a little bit of a run there in 2023 as an 18 year old. This year as a 19 year old,
eight games started in 40 innings pitch. So that's impressive from a workload perspective
to be averaging five innings per start, he must be being efficient. And that's hopeful for him in
terms of being, you know, a starter at the big league level someday, you got to have that
efficiency. Of course, a long way to go. He's only 19. He's only an eight ball, but still a 29%
strikeout rate and a minuscule 3% walk rate. That is very impressive. So a 3.83 ERA, but a 2.88 XFIP,
which is just one of the most impressive totals we've seen for a teenage pitcher
in full season eight ball this year. That is very exciting for the Pirates and Michael Kennedy.
The Pirate system is headlined, of course, by Paul Skeens, who is still a prospect until he
exhausts his rookie eligibility, as well as Tamar Johnson, who I love. I love me some Tamar Johnson
at 14th on this list, according to MLB Pipeline, is where you will find Michael Kennedy. And
speaking of the complex league, there is one player currently playing in Arizona who I do
want to talk about. And that is a Rockies outfield prospect by the name of Robert. And I don't know
how to say this last name. I would say it's either Kalaz or Kalaz. I'm not really sure where
to put that emphasis. So my apologies on the pronunciation. Couldn't quite find a good way
to do it. But Robert will say Kalaz, an outfield prospect, 6'2", 202 pounds. And as you can imagine
with that frame, big, big, big power. So just a quick word on sort of rookie ball in general.
There's the Dominican Summer League, and that doesn't start until later. That is not a full
season. That will in fact start on June 3rd. So it hasn't quite started, but it will soon.
And we will hit on some players at that level in the next episode of Statline Scouting. But
there's also the complex league, and that is played in the United States, some of it in Arizona,
some of it in Florida. And that represents a slightly higher level of competition. The players
on average are a bit older, but it's still not quite the level of full season A ball. So you
may play complex league before you make that jump to full season A ball eventually. So even at age
18, Robert Kalaz or Kalaz is younger than the competition he is facing on average in Arizona
for the Colorado Rockies complex league team. And look at what he's done so far. It's only 18 games.
This is a very small sample, but four homers and three stolen bases. That is exciting. A 26%
strikeout rate and a 9% walk rate for someone with the big power and the big frame that he has.
That's not too bad either. I know it's a 477 Babbitt, but just, you know, at its core,
four homers, three home runs in 18 games for an 18 year old facing guys who are on average a couple
of years older than him. That is very impressive, especially considering he had a very impressive
showing the previous year in his pro debut in that Dominican summer league when he had seven homers
and six steals in 43 games, a 155 WRC plus at that level, 186 at this level in 2024 so far.
And we are looking at the Rockies top prospects. According to MLB pipeline, Robert Kalaz is ranked
at number 11. And unlike Luis de Leon, who is sort of a diamond in the rough international free
amateur signing for the Orioles, Kalaz is someone who the Rockies did in fact have to pony up for
1.7 million to sign him at the start of the 2023 signing period. To put that into perspective,
that is a similar signing bonus to one that you would find for a second rounder in the draft,
for example, but he has done very well for them. But he has a lot of room to grow,
until he could be a candidate for the big leagues.
