Box of Lies with Scarlett Johansson

Now Scarlett and I are about to face off in a game called Box of Lies. Here's how it works. Upstage are a bunch of boxes containing objects neither of us have seen before. Taking turns, Scarlett and I are going to select a box, open it on our side of the table, out of view of the other person. You remove the object from the box, show it to the audience, then look at your opponent and tell them what's in the box. You may be lying, you may be telling the truth. Your opponent has to guess either lie or truth. If you guess correctly, you get a point. If you guess wrong, the other person gets a point. First one to two points wins. Here we go. Scarlett, you're our guest. Please pick the first box. Which one should I pick? Four, four, okay. Four. Four, all right. It looks like it's a light box. All right, hint number one. Oh, man. Four, perfect. That's the one I saw in rehearsal. You're lying. That's not the game. No way, dude. Oh, it's so heavy. It is. A hot dog bun shaped like the Hulk. Oh, my gosh. A hot dog bun shaped like the Hulk. Wait, you're laughing. So that means you're trying to fake me out because maybe it really is a hot dog bun shaped like the Hulk, which would be very reverse psychology of you, very actor-y of you, but you are an actor. Scarlett Johansson. What is it? Yeah, you know. It's right in front of you, man. What do you think? It's a hot dog bun in the shape of the Hulk. How is that even possible? You had to get a Hulk mold and bake? I'm not a baker, so I'm going to say it's impossible. I'm going to say you lie. Damn it! Yes! Whoa. It's me and Gumby sitting on a park bench. That's kind of good. You should keep that one. Which number? Gosh, I didn't know that we were allowed to have bricks on our show. Okay. All right. And... This is so stressful. Okay. It's a fun thing. A lot of people can use it and have a great time with it. It's a mannequin head with diamond eyes and a Speedo cover over the eyes so you can go swimming underwater if you have diamond eyes. And it's usable because it's fun. You can put it around your office and it's a good time. I can't tell whether you've taken a lot of pauses because you're trying to psych me out, but I cannot imagine that anybody would think to make a mannequin with diamond eyes and, like, a little Speedo goggle cover thing. You don't think. Sometimes, you know. Wait. Did Wiz Khalifa make it? Okay. I'm gonna say... There's no way. Right? Oh, yeah! Like, what if it just... If there wasn't anybody there and it just, like, came out. Oh, that's frightening! Yeah, that's frightening. Sorry. All right. Let's do one more, because I totally destroyed on this, and I totally won. Two-zip. So I basically won the game. But the bonus, the secret box, if you choose the right number, is worth 1,000 points. So let's do one more round. Okay. Scarlett, you pick. Okay, great. People love this number. I'm not even... Okay. I'm not even looking at the number or the box or how you carried it over. Here, I have to move this out of the way. Oh, my God. Take it. It's so creepy. Please. They took it. It came from my dressing room. Perfect. Mm-mm. Okay. Mm-hmm. Oh. Whoa. All right. Ready for my... Ready for my hint. Oh, sorry. I was just... Yeah? I fell into an eyes. So it has eyes. It is... A potato. Close. Mm. It is a plastic cup. Mm-hmm. It's a plastic cup filled with beans. Baked beans. It's a cup of beans. All right. Wait, wait, wait, wait. Let me just say this right here. So if it's a plastic cup filled with beans, that I can maybe get. If it's a Jelly Belly or some type of thing like that, you can glue it together, and you stick it in a box, and you can carry it out the box. If it's baked beans, that means that's... You could glob around a little bit. Like, you know, fall over the box. Beans everywhere. Total nightmare for my crew to clean up afterwards. Don't see that happening. But maybe you had a very steady hand by handling that box. Plastic cup. It's full of baked beans. Hmm. It's a Starbucks cup. You liar! Speaking of... What are you doing?