Major NASA Updates

TMRO Space News
221 followers
22 Video Views·Dec 7, 2024
hello everyone it's space Mike for
tomorrow and we have some breaking news
this week president-elect Donald Trump
has nominated Jared isaacman to be the
next NASA administrator which is crazy
that we've gotten a nomination for that
so early before even inauguration day so
far this seems to be really well
received by the space community and I'm
not going to lie I'm a little excited
about it myself Jared isaacman may not
have a ton of government experience but
he does at least have a little bit I
mean having to adhere to regulations
with his uh financial transaction
company Shift 4 uh dren International
his kind of private Air Force that would
actually train members of the military
military a aviators in the Air Force and
the Navy and the Marine Corps and doing
actual war games with them they had to
go through the process of securing the
government contract for that he has
since sold that company I think he sold
it a couple of years ago to the black
rock group unfortunately but he's got a
little bit of familiarity even with his
idea of going and doing the Hubble
servicing Mission he was able to get an
unfunded space act agreement with NASA
in order to study that idea for real
NASA in the end determined that they
didn't want to pursue that idea at the
time but since then a couple of the key
pieces have started to materialized it's
not fully there yet to be able to serve
as Hubble with the dragon spacecraft but
some of the things that were the biggest
concerns aren't as much of a concern
anymore thanks to his Polaris program
and Polaris Dawn Mission doing that
initial Eva test with the SpaceX Eva
suits and here's the thing that I like
the most about Mr isaacman is that he is
a True Believer he sees the direction
that the space industry is going he's
got great connections with SpaceX and
others in the industry and I think that
he will genuinely try to do the right
thing genuinely will try to move things
forward and not have a particular bias
to rockets and meatbags like I would and
wants real science to actually occur and
wants cool things to to happen at Nasa
so this could be a really really good
choice however there's still a big if a
couple of big ifs actually the biggest
one is that the Senate would still have
to confirm that nomination Congress
would still have to confirm him as the
next NASA administrator which they may
or may not do that's kind of up in the
air at this point the other big question
is whether or not Jared isman is going
to have to change a few things about his
personal situation in order to accept
that role so that he doesn't have any
conflicts of interest with the Polaris
program
and supposed to be the mission commander
of the next two Polaris missions I don't
think that a current NASA administrator
if he is confirmed in that role would be
able to take the time off to do The
Astronaut training and actually fly the
mission
so what happens now with Polaris there
is a chance that it might just be on
hold and they resume those missions
after his term of NASA administrator
which will probably only be the next
four years again if he's confirmed
there's also another chance that he
might hand off those missions to
somebody else that they already have in
mind to be the next mission Commander of
the next Polaris Mission but I mean if
you're the guy paying for this millions
of dollars out of your own pocket I I
would want to fly the mission too so
probably be okay to put it on hold but
we'll see now the very next day the
current NASA administrator Bill Nelson
held a press conference to give an
Artemis Mission update and give us all a
few answers to the questions that we've
been having about the Orion heat shield
and other issues that the Artemis
program is been having so first let's
just hear from the man himself and what
they have decided to do with the emis
program we've conducted
expansive testing we were able to
recreate the problem here on Earth and
now we know the root
cause and this has allowed us to devise
a path forward which we are going to
share with you today now just this
morning we have concluded the executive
Council and based on the
data we have
decided NASA
unanimously in our decision makers to
move forward with the current emus 2
Orion capsule and heat
shield with a modified entry trajectory
and so we are planning for Artemis 2 to
launch in April of 26 wait what another
delay just to change the flight profile
a little bit well it's a little bit more
than that
but it's not launching in 2025 anymore
guys it's launching in
2026
maybe and we're going to do all in our
power with our commercial
Partners to launch earlier yeah I should
freaking hope so assuming the SpaceX
Lander is ready we plan to launch
Artemus 3 in mid
2027 okay so Artemis 3 in
2027 that will be well ahead of the
Chinese government's announced intention
that they have already publicly stated
is
2030 I mean I guess that's good but
let's get to the meat of this update uh
let's talk about the Orion heat shield
Pam melroy the Deputy Administrator of
NASA has some really good things to
say at its very core NASA is a learning
organization the knowledge we gain
builds uh Mission by Mission allowing us
to stretch further farther and
accomplish more
in the test campaign of
emis this is the exemplification of that
learning so one area that's taken us a
considerable amount of time to learn
from emis 1 is how the heat shield
performed during the mission obviously a
very critical aspect of the mission she
goes on to explain that Orion is doing
the skip entry procedure which is where
they dip into the atmosphere a little
bit to lower their apigy and then
redip into the atmosphere to actually do
re-entry and the craziest part about
this is that
ironically they had a bit of plasma and
gas that was forming on the heat shield
and in the heat shield that was causing
cracks to happen and pieces of it to
break away that you can see quite a few
pieces in this image that are no longer
there and ironically it was caused
during the lower velocity part of that
skip entry and combined with the lack of
permeability on the number of the avco
blocks uh the heat shield that was
tested at the higher heating rates
performed as expected but at the lower
heating rates started to do this whole
charring and breaking off of pieces
which is just nuts so essentially what
they're going to do is a direct re-entry
instead of doing this skip entry tree to
slowly lower your orbit so that you can
have a safe re-enter at the Target area
that you want to re-enter at they're
just going to do direct re-entry which I
guess is a little bit scarier but if
they've really done a considerable
amount of tests over the past year which
I'm sure they have and the astronauts
seem confident that that plan is going
to work
so okay as we're looking ahead we know
we're going to learn a lot more on art
too and we remain committed to that
learning and to the rigorous process
that we have always adhered to to keep
our crews
safe thank you again for your time and
your continued interest in Artemis in
the space program I'll Echo what Pam was
saying was sometimes in space uh delays
are agonizing and and slowing down is
agonizing and it's not like what not
what we like to do but from the crew
perspective the thing that we most asked
our leadership for after emis one was
root cause
of the oblation of the heat shield and
we took the time this was very very open
process the crew certainly never felt
like there was a door closed to us we
never saw any hidden data it was all
open it was all open discussion we had
an independent review team uh with a lot
of outside experts and internal experts
to look at this so we really appreciate
the willingness to take the risk to
actually slow down and understand root
cause determine the path forward
corrective action for Artemis 2 and emis
three so that when Victor Christina
Jeremy and I launch and land after a
successful Artemis 2 we will look to
Artemis 3 to carry the torch forward and
to put humans back on the moon and that
is really our ultimate objective Amit
chhatria actually had some really good
technical updates that explained a
little bit more about what's going on
with this which unfortunately kind of
sent me down a further rabbit hole
before we we saw variations in the
condition of the heat shield which in
which the Char the charir that protects
oryan um broke off in ways we did not
expect we observed about 100 spots
across the heat shield where that
phenomenon occurred it is normal
behavior for the oader that it's that
it's built on Aion to char the heat
shield is however is not designed to
liberate those pieces of char uh instead
and a Char layer and an ablator is
supposed to recede gradually uh so the
underlying material insulates the
spacecraft from the high heat flux we
experience during entry so this brought
up a question that we've asked before on
this show of why are they using avot
instead of pika
avat is essentially the same type of
heat shields that they used way back in
the day during the Apollo days it has a
slightly different manufacturing process
because some of the materials that it
used to be made out of are quite toxic
and no longer available and NASA
invented the Pika heat shield which has
been used on some of the the Mars
science Landers like the Curiosity and
perseverance Rover and they have a
really cool proprietary technology
that's open SpaceX you know took that
idea took that technology made a couple
of improvements and calls it p x and
they've even made further improvements
on that which they now call Pika 3 and
it's a really great heat shield it's
worked out really well for the Dragon
capsule so my question was why isn't
NASA using a better heat shield
technology that they themselves
invented Well turns out its supply chain
issues and material issues and this one
slide from a study I found in 2019
answered the question a lot of the
materials that they need in order to
manufacture Pika are no longer being
made the companies that made those
materials went out of business maybe
because NASA decided to go with avot
back in 2005 instead of going with Pika
I don't know that's just my theory I'm
sure there's a lot more to it than that
that's not being very fair of me my
apologies however if you're interested
in some of the technical details I put
the p PDF a link to it anyway in the
description so that you can check it out
yourself and see if maybe together we
can come up with some solutions for NASA
so we've decided that in order to
enhance our learning for Artemis 2 as
quickly as we can because there's
nothing like flying in the flight
environment to learn everything that you
need to learn about how these system
will perform that if if we if we we can
either change the material to mitigate
the issue or we can change the
environment to mitigate the issue and
for emus 2 because of the nature of the
mission
which right now the mode we're using is
equatorial free return we can safely and
with high degrees of success control
that entry environment and so that
that's the plan we're going to proceed
along we are also experiencing a handful
of issues um in the uh in the in the
performance and integration of the
vehicle um we have as I mentioned uh to
this community back at the beginning of
the year we have had some issues with
the electrical system on the vehicle oh
man battery issues too specifically when
uh the vehicle is enduring a an abort
scenario in some of those cases is as we
in this particular case for emus 2 the
um the the abort system on the
spacecraft is active it um so we we need
to make sure that the vehicle will have
maximum capacity during that during
those abort scenarios we found an issue
with the batteries in particular um that
they were not able to tolerate the abort
environment it's pretty severe
especially when when you do an abort
induced by the launch abort system so we
had to fix those batteries and we we've
been working on that fix for a while we
able to completely change the way that
they're mounted that they're
mechanically secured um and we we have
been able to um complete that fix
qualify that fix it was excellent work
by the team at Eagle pitcher in Joplin
Missouri that did that for us it was it
was also sort of it was difficult for
them to do it because as as was
mentioned earlier our supply chains in
some of these critical areas are are
extremely fragile and so we had we had
some difficulty finding very high
reliability components and in order to
complete that build but the team there
was excellent and Eagle pitcher has a
long history with us okay good that's
resolved we hope the other thing we've
been working on significantly is the
life support system on on on the
spacecraft oh yeah and all the life
support issues too that definitely has
to get solved otherwise none of this is
happening not on Orion we are conducting
a full set of integrated life support
system tests on the spacecraft we are
learning every day about how that system
performs we have got to make sure that
every part of that is is in the right
configuration before we commit the crew
to to launch uh we you recall at the
early part of the year we discovered an
issue with the control system of the
valves in that and that and in
particular the carbon dioxide removal
system that that anomaly has been
resolved we've also witnessed a couple a
few issues with the deoration of the
seat material on those valves which has
caused overboard leakage that has also
been resolved we've also been doing
performance testing of the sorbin and
that in that system to make sure it's
it's going to be have the capacity uh in
in all the cases that we care about
including multiple failure cases so we
are continuing to characterize and learn
and test that life support system but it
is taking us longer than we thought and
so we need to we need to get that done
and uh we we're making excellent
progress there to the point at which now
we're ready as as we said to commit to
to to to commit to stacking all right so
all of this definitely needs to be taken
with a grain of salt and some would say
this is a little bit of a a nothing
Burger but it's not necessarily this is
at least an update and is giving some
sort of path forward for how they want
to proceed with things everything is
still up in the air and the new
Administration could cancel all of this
it's pretty ridiculous that we're
looking at over $4 billion per launch
and well over $5 billion if we ever get
any of the upgrades like block 1B or
block two which I don't think what we
should I I think that we should just
cancel it including Orion because Orion
is super freaking expensive and yeah
they say that it's the only vehicle
right now that could safely send humans
you know to uh CIS lunar space around
the Moon and back safely but can it can
it actually do it safely because if we
really cared about safety we would tear
that thing apart take off that crappy
heat shield and replace it with
something better contract SpaceX to
build a new heat shield for it come on I
know we' have SpaceX doing everything
now but they could probably whip out a
new one in a matter of weeks but since
lock heed Martins the primary contractor
even if we were to go down that sort of
path it would take them two years just
to study the idea of replacing the heat
shield before any work actually gets
done so whatever I will say though that
I am still really hopeful and I find
some of the comments that they made at
this uh briefing especially about Jared
isaacman and the idea that it all will
be get cancelled and replaced with
Starship you know whatever it takes man
wherever it takes to us to get back
there and to keep moving forward and to
make progress and to not spend so much
money that the pittance of the budget
that NASA gets out of the entire Federal
bud budget for the entire United States
government is actually put to good use
and we can start doing cool things again
I mean NASA does cool stuff all the time
but it's a lot less frequent than it
used to be at least a lot less frequent
than I remember and if they're doing a
lot of cool stuff behind the scenes they
need to be a lot more public about it
because I haven't heard about cool
little projects in quite some
time anyway I would definitely like to
know what you guys think about these
developments what do you think about
Jared isaacman potentially being the
next NASA administrator and what do you
think about all these updates that we've
gotten with Orion and the SLS
and these awful delays will it still
even fly or will the whole thing be
cancelled definitely let us know in the
comments definitely join us this Sunday
where me and the rest of the crew are
going to be talking a little bit more in
depth about these interesting
developments this week and what it might
mean not just for NASA but space flight
in general as a whole uh please join us
we would love to get your guys's input
during that live show as well in the
meantime don't let this news about Orion
and SLS get you down keep moving onwards
and upwards everybody and don't forget
at Astra to the Stars
