How to Cut Out a Toxic Person

Finding Your Person
2 followers
And if it hasn't changed, then on what basis are you thinking it's going to change in the future?
What we're about to talk about can relate to anybody that you're with who has consistently
treated you poorly, who has ignored your needs, who has disregarded your happiness,
who has been gaslighting you for a long time, lying to you, breaking promises,
someone who consistently lets you down, disappoints you. I want to talk about how
we come to trap ourselves in these situations and what it really requires for us to break free
of them. Because the nature of what Dr. Ramani and other psychologists call the trauma bond
is that we can become imprisoned by that bond. And it can be extraordinarily difficult
to break free from it and to finally release ourselves from a relationship like that.
And we should say that a relationship like that is tremendously detrimental to our mental health,
our well-being, our self-esteem, our quality of life. It is a situation that is maddening.
It slowly erodes your confidence in yourself, especially if your needs are ignored,
if you are gaslit over things that you would like to happen and told that it's crazy for you to want
those things, or you're high maintenance for wanting those things, or that when someone
tries to convince you that your version of reality is completely false, it can have the effect of you
not knowing which way is up anymore. You stop trusting yourself. And of course, when you're
someone who constantly breaks their promises to you, constantly lies to you, and then if you
catch them in the lie, makes it your fault somehow, it makes us unable to see what the truth is
anymore. It divorces us from ourselves. We start becoming somebody else. We live a life of trying
to manage this person. We live a life of trying to read between the lines of what things this
person is saying are true, and which things are false. So we pay a price for staying with someone
like this. I want to start by just talking about how we find ourselves in these situations,
and how one of the qualities that we like most about ourselves in other contexts
can become our biggest enemy in the context of a relationship like this,
and that is our empathy. We show a level of understanding about this person
that allows them to get away with the same thing over and over again. Let's talk about that for a
while. I was going to say, if you're with someone who, if you're taking care of them and making sure
they're okay, and they're taking care of themselves and making sure they're okay,
who's taking care of you? You know, it's quite a common thing that you hear, but
in order to be there for other people, your own cup has to be full, and your priority in life
should always be to make sure that you're okay. Now, that doesn't mean that you have to put
yourself first in every single situation, and in fact, you shouldn't. It's really important to put
other people first sometimes, and to put those you love before you when they need you more than you
need them in that moment. But ultimately, your empathy towards other people cannot come at the
detriment of actually making sure you're okay. That's when you have to suspect yourself, I think,
as to whether or not, is it really empathy, or are you just caught in a toxic cycle where it's
serving some kind of need for you? Well, I think that that's exactly right, and we,
what happens is, because we're so close to this person, we've heard all of their stories,
and people who are really good at mobilizing your empathy, get very good at telling stories that
make them sympathetic. And by the way, we all have things that we've been through in our lives that
could have made us worse people or better people, right? Everyone has things, but
there are certain people who are really good at taking their past and constructing a narrative
that creates excuses for really bad behavior in the present. And if you're somebody who is truly
empathetic, and you're prone to feeling sad for people or seeing people as sympathetic,
then it can be quite easy for someone who's manipulative to use their past as a way to
mobilize your empathy. And it could also happen in reverse, by the way. If they know that you
pride yourself on being generous, being kind, being empathetic, and then you start calling
them out on their behavior and having more boundaries, they can then attack you for that
and say, oh, and you're supposed to be, you see yourself as this empathetic person. Well, right
now, you've got absolutely no care for what I've been through and the ways that I'm struggling.
And you're always playing this empathetic character, and yet right now, you're just
abandoning me. Now they can weaponize it in the other direction and get you feeling guilty that
you haven't been empathetic enough. And it's so interesting, right? Because it knows no limit.
In terms of if you want to extend a sympathetic or a compassionate or kind of understanding lens
towards a person, you can do that with a serial killer. You can say it's not their fault. They're
born this way. They went through these different things in their childhood. That's why they ended
up being aggressive and killing people. Or even just they're a psychopath. They don't feel empathy.
It's not their fault. They're not born with that. You can actually have compassion towards anyone
for anything. And the kind of what's really interesting is the duality between this over
compassion you might extend towards somebody who treats you badly. But this total lack of
compassion you extend towards yourself as you put yourself repeatedly in harm's way of that person.
And for some reason, your well-being and the way that you feel isn't being prioritized by you in
the same way that you're prioritizing being understanding towards them.
Yeah, I think Jack Kornfeld said something along the lines of your compassion for people is
incomplete if it doesn't extend to yourself. Yeah, I think that's right. I do think there's
a big difference between giving love to someone and having love for them and sacrificing yourself,
sacrificing your needs. And I think a lot of people just conflate them together like,
if I love this person, I will sacrifice my happiness to just fulfill whatever their thing
is or help them because they're whatever, a narcissist, an addict, a different whatever.
But I think there's a real difference between loving them and completely sacrificing yourself,
your happiness, your well-being. And I think some people get addicted to that role a bit.
The thing that scares me about empathy in the context of a relationship like this is it can
really, if that empathy becomes a proactive kind of forgiveness for that person and a forgiveness
that leads to you constantly letting them back into your life, not a distant forgiveness where
you say, I forgive you, but I can't have you near me. There really is no limit to how far you can
fall in that relationship. As you say, Audrey, if you excuse them on every level, they're like,
well, it's their past. Well, even if it's not their past, it's their genes. They can't help
it. It's just the way they're built. You can always find a justification. And by the way,
those things are true. They're actually true. But the danger of saying that's true, therefore,
I should forgive this person and be involved with them romantically, that's the non sequitur.
And the danger of that is that if you continue to use your empathy as an excuse for forgiving
someone and letting them back in, there is no limit to the level of destruction that someone can
impose on your life. You're letting them into the house where they can wreak havoc.
And you have to at a certain point say, I cannot trust you. I cannot trust you with my heart.
I cannot trust you with my time. I cannot trust you with my energy. I cannot trust you with my
future. And therefore I can't let you in the house because if I let you in my house, so to speak,
you will predictably wreak havoc. So I can have a distant compassion for you,
but I cannot have a kind of proactive close degree empathy where I constantly let you back in
because you will destroy my life. And I think part of what people struggle with
is this hope that this person will change. That yes, they've been terrible. Yes, they are still
wreaking havoc in my life. Yes, they are still making me unhappy. But if this one thing could
change, then we could actually be so happy. I also think it's a duality between the good
and the bad times. Because I think if you've ever been with someone who is either a narcissist or
narcissistically inclined or selfish or toxic or whatever you want to call it, they're not like
that all the time at all. But even in that, I think there is embedded in that idea is a kind
of hope. The hope for the good times to be more. The hope that the bad times will start to be less.
Of course. I suppose what I mean is that people who are like that are very good at being
really, really charming. So the good times feel better both because of the bad times being so bad
that in contrast, they feel better, but also because they are so good at making life even
better than a healthy person can because they're not playing a role. So people get addicted to the
highs for sure because of that. And that's that's then in turn very difficult because you're almost
turning your back on when you think about it rationally, you end up feeling that you're
turning your back on the happiest moments of your life. It's just that they happen to come
in conjunction with the most terrible moments of your life. I mean, when someone makes your
life so miserable, the good times don't even have to be that good to feel like they're incredible.
If you're in the middle of the desert starving and someone puts like a Wendy's cheeseburger in
front of you. Oh, that's that's ruining our chances of sponsorship for Wendy's.
I thought Jameson was going to say, you know, now you're talking because I feel like that's
the kind of Jameson meal. This is okay. Well, this is hurtful. You love Taco Bell.
But I think Matt's point is it could be Del Taco in the desert. It could be something.
It could be something atrocious out there. And it still feels like it's better than
let's at least criticize a lesser brand like White Castle or something, something smaller.
Oh, there goes White Castle. No, wait, I think there is something really important what you're
saying, which is actually like you can have just a normal day finally after just a week long fight
with this person has been making your life miserable. And you have one nice day where
it's like, oh, yeah, we went and we had we had dinner together and no one fought and
the waiter wasn't rude. And suddenly I'm in love again.
You're grateful for civility.
Grateful for civility. What a nice way to put it. Yeah.
What keeps people there, whether it's a hope for the next good time or whether it's a hope
for things to just fundamentally change, that hope is the most misguided thing we have.
What I want you to think in terms of is empiricism. Empiricism is basing
what I do or what I believe on what my actual experience of this person is.
Have they ever truly changed in this area? You may have experienced spikes of change after you
had an argument or after you threatened to leave. But if ultimately it just always returned to the
same baseline, then you know that those changes weren't real. They were just a tactic, more of
manipulation. Empirically, you have to ask yourself, has this person ever changed or has
this been a repeatable pattern throughout my relationship with this person? And if I'm still
talking about it now with my friends, with a therapist, if I'm still ruminating about it
constantly, then it's still happening. And the answer is no, it has not changed.
And if it hasn't changed, then on what basis are you thinking it's going to change in the future?
And the truth is, if you really relate to this episode right now, you've probably been through
every kind of emotion with this person there is. You've cried, you've been angry, you've been
depressed, you've been guilty, you've been frantic, you've despaired. You've been through
everything you can go through with this person. You've begged for change. What emotion
have you kept up your sleeve that you're going to bring out next year that's suddenly going to
change this person? I have to know. If you're telling yourself that they're going to change,
what's the reaction that all this time you've been storing to suddenly get a different result?
Because the chances are you've already cycled through all of them
many times. You have to assume that this person is never going to change.
Because the stakes are way too high. What are the stakes? You don't get your time back again.
So staking your life and your happiness on the idea that this person who has never changed
will one day change is just about the worst bet that you can make.
It makes me really emotional just hearing you talk about it because I just think of the
amount of people who are currently stuck, and I think the word really is just stuck,
in the quicksand of that kind of relationship and how much it just destroys people.
Because it destroys their confidence. It destroys their self-worth. It warps reality,
as you said, in a way where they just feel like they don't even know which way is up anymore.
You end up having no bearing on what a proper relationship should feel like and a proper
connection and being treated with respect and having your needs met. You forget. You
lose sight of what that even feels like. Just look how much empathy Audrey has.
See how dangerous it is? It's interesting you say that, Jay,
because do you remember there was that book, I think it was Paul Bloom, who wrote that book
Against Empathy? I was just about to reference that. I was just about to reference Paul Bloom.
He literally wrote a book called Against Empathy because he's trying to call out the fact that it
is actually a baser emotion. The same way anger is just a baser emotional reaction,
he argues for a rational compassion, which is very similar to what you're saying with this
distant compassion, which is you realize, you understand intellectually what happened in that
person's past to explain it, but you don't take that extra step of like, well, just because it
explains it doesn't excuse it and doesn't mean that I have to emotionally invest in this
situation of their past. You can take a step back and understand without needing to go that extra
emotional journey. Just intellectually understand it, rationally have compassion for their situation.
You don't have to make it your situation. Yeah, as you were saying that, I was thinking,
just because it explains it, it doesn't mean you have to choose it.
Yeah, or justify it. Let me know what you think about this in the comments. Don't forget to like,
subscribe and hit the notification bell so you don't miss the next video. I also want to tell
you that from the 11th to the 13th of November, I'm running my virtual retreat. If you're listening
to this video and you're realizing this is the deepest stuff that I need, I hope you come and
join us. The link is mhvirtualretreat.com. Come check it out and spend three days of
coaching with me and my team. I'll see you over there.
