The problem with Presidents' Day that few are talking about

PragerU
799 followers
18 Video Views·Dec 2, 2024
Jill Simonian and Richard Lim of PragerU Kids debunk myths about Washington & Lincoln and discuss the effects of burying the true meaning of this once-popular holiday. Need more resources to educate your children about two of our most brilliant presidents? Visit and subscribe to PragerUkids.com
Download a limited-time, FREE copy of children's educational magazines from Washington to Lincoln: https://www.prageru.com/american-presidents-magazines
Tuesday live welcome yes that's right we
are live on Facebook and YouTube I'm Jo
simonian from Prager you kids and today
is Tuesday February 13th and joining me
is Richard Lim our resident historian
Big Nerd I'm so excited we're going to
talk about presidents today you you all
have no idea it's like it's unhealthy my
love for presidents and and the thing is
I love presidents but I also don't want
presidents to have too much power over
me so it's one of those like I love them
but I think we put too much importance
on President it's a fine line it is a
fine line yes because yes Richard is our
resident historian and you're also the
host of your own podcast that is totally
separate from Prager you but it's an
incredible informative historic fun to
listen to this American president right
yes yes I hope it's fun to listen to and
where is it on it's on just go anywhere
your podcast app you can go on uh yeah
just if you Google this American
president and you'll see it uh don't
confuse it with the movie the American
president or This American Life those
are two you know but this American
president we have our own website this
American president.com if you go on your
app or on Apple podcast iTunes
everything else so very good okay well I
wanted to get that out of the way uh
because today we're talking about
something that is very near and dear to
uh Richard's heart and we're coming to
you to discuss this because you know
many of you who watch prer kids who
share Prager kids.com with your young
children or grandchildren or um your
students even for all your teachers out
there we are big Believers in learning
about our history and we have so many
offerings on Prager kids.com that if you
haven't subscribed yet for free go ahead
and do that but today I want to tackle
something that very few people talk
about and I thought it would be great to
address the parents and the teachers
about and the the official title if
you're watching this live on Facebook or
YouTube I believe is the problem with
President's Day that very few people
talk about now I am learning to
sincerely love history in fact so much
that yesterday February 12th was
Lincoln's actual birthday and I had a
wild and crazy slam jammed packed busy
day at work here at Prager you kids and
I got to the end of the day and I this
is how much working here has affected me
I got to the end of the day and I said
oh my goodness I did not do anything on
my Instagram to wish President Lincoln a
happy birthday and Richard's going to be
so mad when I I was outraged I I looked
at your and I threw my phone that no
it's fine I know I know so anyway so
we're going to talk about it here
because Richard I do want to talk with
you about this problem of President's
Day and then we're going to debunk some
fun and silly myths that uh historians
have you know always disputed in the
past but we'll do that later for the
kids for all of you parents and teachers
to watch and share this with your kids
the big problem about President's Day
why is there a problem are we creating a
problem you have told me that there's a
problem so I want to know yeah well
first of all this mindset of year zero
and that uh you know cancel culture and
that any any person that doesn't agree
with you know the current uh morality
that we have uh and that judges past
presidents unfairly looks at all these
guys and says oh they were evil white
supremacists and all this kind of stuff
so you're talking about Lincoln and
Washington yeah Lincoln Washington
Jefferson all these presidents that are
just being trashed now because they uh
they they came from a certain you know
world and perspective and we expect them
to adhere to our own standards which is
completely unfair I mean imagine if
people 400 years from now judged us on
their standards who knows what they're
going to believe by that right so to do
that is completely ahistorical it's
unfair and it really uh doesn't
appreciate the contributions that they
made to this country but I have a
personal beef with President's Day
because President's Day is not an actual
federal holiday there's no federal
holiday called President's Day right
it's legally called Washington's
birthday and when is Washington's
birthday the date so okay all right now
you're up for dispute too yes yes so now
you're getting into complication so
first of all before I I say that I'm
such a nerd I have Washington Socks can
you see his socks you you you oh my gosh
I have I have Reagan socks you but it's
but President's Day is not meant to
honor President Reagan true and then I
have uh this is actually a pin from
Washington's Bicentennial in
1932 so it's I know I know I know I told
you it's unhealthy it's very healthy he
told me look out I have swag on yes yes
yes so okay with all that said uh
basically Washington when he was born it
was February 11th
1732 okay but what happened was that
they changed the calendars so they went
from the classical uh Julian calendar
named after juliia Caesar so we're
talking you know Millennia and uh then
they went to the Gregorian calender Pope
Gregory and so when they did that they
added 22 days to the month right so then
was in Washington's lifetime so they
moved observation or they he considered
his birthday actually the 22nd if you
want to go by like when it actually
corresponded to you know the the year
right but uh some would do it the old
style the 11th and some do the 22nd but
then everything changed so people would
celebrate Washington's birthday but then
in 1968 they passed a law called the
uniform holiday act which then uh
Congress was trying to consolidate the
holidays so that it would create a 3
weekend because they wanted to encourage
families to get together and all that
stuff and so when that happened
basically uh uh Washington's
birthday was then observed uh not on his
actual birthday but on a Monday right
and so when that happened uh there was
actually a lot of debate about okay
should we do this and if we do this it
won't really be Washington's birthday
and then when that happened uh some of
the Illinois people said well cuz
Lincoln's birthday happens to be 10 days
before Fe 12 Washington's observed on
the 22nd so they kind of wanted to
incorporate you know Lincoln into that
and there were even debates at that time
saying if you do this people are going
to forget about George Washington and
then what happened was that okay so when
the date got a little closer to
Lincoln's birthday mattress and car
salesmen looking for you know promotion
started saying what Washington Lincoln
whatever President's Day okay and so
they changed it to President's Day so it
was like unofficially these like
salesmen were thinking of a pitch and
they said president day okay so I just
I'm gonna break it down I'm a mom I have
kids in school so Lincoln's birthday
February 12th yes officially
Washington's birthday February 22nd
officially yes what's the big deal if we
just lump them together why is that a
problem well that's a great that's a
great question now I have a couple
responses the first is that I don't want
to celebrate Joe Biden so you're forcing
me to celebrate all the presidents I'm
not celebrating joee Biden I'm not you
know I want to celebrate the great
president if you're going to celebrate
great presidents okay you know
Washington je Jefferson Lincoln that's
great you know but president day I don't
want to celebrate all of them I'm sorry
I don't but that's the first thing the
second thing to note is that we have
Martin Luther King Day birthday right we
don't have Civil Rights Day right you
know so why do we have you know why do
we have President's Day but not one
person we're celebrating that person so
whatever you think of MLK Day we
celebrate him we but you know and if you
go to other countries if you go to India
there's a day to celebrate the father of
their Nation Gandhi you know if you go
to different countries like uh my birth
country the Philippines the national
hero is Jose Roselle you could celebrate
Rosal day America has like an amazing
Founding Father George Washington we've
abandoned celebrating our Founding
Father Americans like they don't
celebrate it now here's the thing
certain States the states can make their
own holidays too right so some states
have Washington day some states have
Lincoln day um Illinois the Land of
Lincoln they have Lincoln day but as a
nation it's like no one cares you know
it's like oh you know when it's
President Day first of all how many
people really think oh yay presidents
but like you know most people it's day
off but President's Day it's here it's
Washington's birthday you know
Washington the F father of the country
you know as great if not greater than
any founder of father of a country and
we don't celebrate it at all it what you
just said makes perfect sense to me when
you put it in that context because as a
mom I think oh my goodness if my
children don't understand how to honor
and recognize and celebrate the father
of our nation we might not have a nation
going forward is that yeah the principl
no not at all the princip I mean it's
all part and parcel I think of of the
fact that we forgotten a lot of our
history this is just kind of a
reflection of that you know um and and
the fact that in other countri
they care a lot about this stuff you
know they they talk so much about how in
in the Middle East you know they they
there's so much of their history that
they know you know in the Middle East
kids know what the Crusades are and
they're taught to think of the West in
this way right in America you know the
most people know about history is what
they saw on uh National Treasure right
like that's or or uh I like that movie a
lot it's you know I I I watched it a
long time ago and it was at a party so I
wasn't paying attention but everyone
like you should watch it it's history
you know but anyways you'll probably
debunk everything I mean you know
Nicholas Cage you know he's you know
great actor but anyways yes so okay so I
want to get to uh debunking some of
these uh myths about presidents because
you know as is you're if you're just
logging on or seeing us in your feed
right now Jill simonan and Richard limb
from prer you kids we're talking about
President's Day how it used to be
Lincoln's birthday and Washington's
birthday now they've lumped it all
together and we've come to the
conclusion now if you're just joining us
that for our children not to understand
the the history and the significance
that George Washington had on this
country as his own person to not
recognize his own birthday in itself um
is potentially detrimental to the future
of our nation because if my kids don't
understand how to honor our founding
father and what he stood for and what
found and what the founders stood for
then we might not have a country left
tell me where you're from in the
comments tell me if your school
celebrates President's Day if they've
you know exnay President's Day I want to
get to um some of these myths that
Richard has incidentally sent to me and
you're going to debunk them so you sent
me this interesting article admittedly
from uh two years ago actually wow three
years ago as we are in 2024 so this
article is from Big ideas for
smallbusiness.com and it says Lincoln's
lessons on failure and I have it pulled
up on my screen now
and it's just sort of a little for lack
of a better word little sticky article
about how many times Lincoln failed and
he his life was full of failures but
look at how successful he was and I'll
read you a couple of them here he was
defeated for Illinois State Legislature
In 1832 he lost his run for Congress in
1843 and again in 1848 he lost his bid
to become a US senator In 1855 he ran
for vice president in the US in 1856 and
lost and so it it details all of these
losses and how Lincoln was essentially a
big failure but hey he became president
and me reading this as a mom I think wow
that's really cool and inspirational to
tell kids but you don't like this
article why I know I know I'm the Grinch
you know why describe I know I know well
so I was told I was uh one of my friends
showed me this list actually sorry not a
friend a teacher showed me this list and
it's it's kind of one of those things
that it's an inspirational thing right
Lincoln failed failed failed failed
failed failed failed and not just failed
but it was like you know not just the
professional failure but then you know
his his his love interest died and you
know his his girlfriend died and then
his you know whatever and then suddenly
out of nowhere he becomes president
right and it's like oh wow that's so
neat and you know I don't know like you
know for all the people out there that
get inspired by the kind of
inspirational posters you know those I
know people like that kind of stuff but
sorry to say a lot of that stuff is just
not true and when I say not true
there might be some truth in it you know
did a guy like Lincoln have uh failures
of course just like any figure right
historical figure but here's the thing
uh a lot of times a politician will run
for an office knowing they're going to
fail at that because it's a little too
high for what they're aiming at but it
gets their name out there and then they
then they they lose their first election
to win their second election and so
that's what happened a lot with with
Lincoln he was a a politician he was
politically ambitious so he ran for
offices you know people mention he ran
in 1856 for the vice presidency and he
lost that but actually what happened was
that his you know there was some
consideration of him as as VP and all
that stuff but it didn't work out didn't
mean he ran and lost you know it's not
like one of those where like oh you're a
loser it's like oh people thought about
it you know it was one of those things
but the person who kind of wanted to
create this inspirational thing and the
thing about our our our leaders like
Washington and Lincoln is is that as as
as great as they were there's a
mythology that starts surrounding them
that starts uh basically obscuring who
they really were you know and we like to
turn them into a tall tale well I think
of and we actually have in our defense
at Prager you kids to engage children to
learn about these prolific figures in
history we do have the um Otto tal story
time and we included the George
Washington and the cherry tree and we
included the other story about on the
folk tales about Honest Abe about him uh
you know keeping the shop and learning
to read and and and all of these folk
tales which might be based in truth but
don't those myths also contribute to
maybe engaging the youngest Learners
absolutely you're right and and I think
that that there's a place for that you
know you know it's it's the same thing
I'm just making sure you no you're
absolutely right I mean here's the thing
uh there are so many movies uh I just
saw this trailer for a movie it's it's
called damsel I'm not trying to promote
it I don't know if it's going to be good
or not good but but that whole idea it's
a modern take on a myth that that we all
know right and people love the story
about the Damsel in Distress and all
that kind of stuff and and so it's a
modern take so that has a place you know
one of my favorite myths is about James
Watt he's it's not an American Myth it's
a British myth but he's the guy that
invented or he perfected rather the
steam engine right and there's this
awesome myth that when he was a boy he
got the idea of a steam engine when he
saw his mom or grandma or n
making tea boiling tea and he saw that
the the steam was moving something and
then from there this you know he came up
with the idea well if you can move a lid
on a cup maybe you can move a something
you know makes you know the spinning
motion and he Chang the world and we
don't know if it's true it might be true
it might not be true and it's a it's a
wonderful myth to have right but I think
where where it goes wrong is when you
present something as real about that
person you know when you say oh this
happened that Lincoln definitely failed
at this and that you know it's one thing
to say that there are myths about
Lincoln and Washington and you know
honestly I I I don't think it takes
anything away to the myth to say that
it's a myth you know to say that this is
part of our Tall Tales or history and it
it there's something about um this myth
that is true even if the actual story
isn't true it's an illustration and it
it it kind of shows you the it it's it's
a piece of nostalgia in Americana and
I'm all for that now so so George
Washington never chopped down a cherry
tree oh boy so I know the I know the
answer to this and the answer the short
answer is no well we don't know we don't
know we don't know for sure it was
written by a guy named Parson weams
after Washington died and there's no
verification of it I will say I took my
great uncle who uh God Rest the soul but
he was about 80 at the time I took him
to Mount Vernon uh when I was living out
there and he asked me where the cherry
trees on Washington State and I had to
tell him that it wasn't true and you
know I think it was one of those things
where I should have just let the man
just believe it because he had believed
it he told me he was taught that as a
boy in Hong Kong like in British uh Hong
Kong which is pretty amazing they were
teaching that over there but he believed
this his whole life you broke his
shattered you shattered his perception
and well not only that it's even more
guling because it's a story about
honesty right but it's it's but it's
likely not true and so I told him and he
you know hand to the temple jaw drop and
he said that's the world's biggest lie
and it was like you he you know he
probably internalized it and it was part
of his character and then we don't know
if it's true but there's all sorts of
wonderful myths we can get into I want
another myth about George Washington he
did he wear a wig did he not okay so
this is something this is for the kids
this is for the kids teachers did George
Washington wear a wig he did not wear a
wig that was his actual hair that was
his actual hair I know I know it's
interesting cuz and how do you know this
I mean it's it's like in history do well
the thing is is that he was known since
he was a military man for wearing what
was called a queue and that was when you
tied the hair back in qu and so that was
his hairstyle so it was known that he
did that specifically that he had he did
not have a wig that was his actual hair
and it's interesting because he he has a
certain hairstyle you know it poofs out
a little bit and and it's gray and and
there were people who had that look that
did have wigs you know judges would put
on these wigs and all that and so it's
understandable why people think that but
it he didn't wear wig that was so his
hair was gray or his hair was red and
powdered because I've heard that his
hair was red right right well in this is
important stuff I know it is critical
Washington birth he okay so Washington
as a young man had red hair and
Jefferson did too okay so we owe our
freedom to to the gingers thank you
gingers out there Ginger yeah they but
as he got older he did uh it it did you
know get darker and then it did gray and
and he did from what I I know I'm sure
pretty sure he powdered it because
that's what people did back then and
kept things clean and all that stuff but
it was his hair that was his hair not a
wig and and it's interesting because I
think that kind of speaks to our own
perceptions right like there are a lot
of perceptions we have about people and
some of them are based on truth and some
of them are based on on on myth and kind
of uh just a notion that we have without
really thinking it through but yeah that
was his actual hair okay so one more
thing before we sign off and tell
everyone goodbye and have a happy week
George Washington obviously we we've
never disputed that he owns slaves here
of we have outwardly said multiple times
on our kids shows and in our uh regular
content that slavery was and still is an
evil and it was wrong it still is wrong
it was abhorent no one here has ever
endorsed slavery and however two things
can be true at once one George
Washington was a prolific leader the
father of our nation who we owe much to
when it comes to you know the freedoms
that we secured as As Americans but also
he was a slave owner a lot of people say
stop celebrating him because of that
slave owner but something that people
also forget that you consistently bring
to the table when we're discussing
George Washington in our prageru kids
meetings is that let's not forget that
George Washington did teach young black
Americans who were slaves at the time he
taught them to read please well I might
be I'm going to let you take this yeah
yeah yeah so the thing to always know
about this is that the founding fathers
were creating a new world out of an old
one right and it's impossible it it's
not fair to expect them to have
eradicated all the evils of the old
world and then it became a matter of
wisdom how do you do that right how do
you do that so men like Washington and
Jefferson and Madison and all these
figures were born into a world they
didn't choose to be born in that world
that's the world they were you know born
into and they knew slavery is wrong they
they said it and and you know we have
examples I mean I know Jefferson
proposed to you know end the slave trade
and and you know in uh I think it was um
uh yeah it was like end of the slave
trade and and Washington what he did he
he he knew a lot of abolitionists you
know Hamilton and and so on and so forth
Lafayette and he essentially had a plan
to basically uh have slavery well he he
wanted to rent out basically have his
slaves Works work on different
plantations and and start to earn some
money for it because you had to start
getting this group of people who had
been deprived of education and you know
any any skills that could lead to like a
marketable you know future and so all of
this stuff was very difficult because he
was constantly called to serve the
country But ultimately what Washington
did was that he called for his slaves to
be freed he said in his will to free the
slaves for the elderly slaves on his
estate to be taken care of for the rest
of their lives and for the young to be
educated to be taught how to read and if
you know anything about that system
slave system teaching a teaching slaves
to read strikes at the heart of the
system yeah because once they become
aware of the broader world and they gain
that skill they're it at at that point
you're the SL system is going to
collapse the more that they get educated
right and there are letters that he
shared with people you know family
members that were writing and if you
look at the letters uh one of his family
members wrote to Washington that where
the slaves are in America where black
slaves are that's where white peasants
were in the medieval times you know back
in the day with feudalism right okay so
it's not their it's not inherent to them
it's the condition the environment that
they're in so you know as more whites
learn how to read the more social
Mobility they had and that was the
future Washington wanted to have for
these and he even wrote that he wanted
them to have a better future than the
one they were born into and so teaching
them to read strikes it basically makes
the slave system un unsustainable for a
while and Washington and Jefferson these
guys wanted a gradual emancipation
program sometimes individually
individual slave holders would free them
and he wanted the states to abolish
slavery over time so that it wouldn't
destroy the country Frederick Douglas
later said that the nation it was
important for the nation to bind
together so that the anti-slavery forces
would influence the pro-slavery forces
and ultimately so he he believed that
the fact that the founding fathers
created a union would and and they knew
that at they couldn't destroy slavery at
the time but by creating that Union it
could get rid of it eventually and isn't
that something of such deep value that
all of our kids should be learning in
school I mean I you know I don't know of
one person here that says don't teach
children about that topic we've always
been you know personally speaking I've
always been a proponent of teaching kids
about topics in a very age appropriate
way that teaches them to love America
through the stains through the faults
and through the constant drive to become
a more perfect union and for for you
know for for children to learn that
George Washington did in fact stand for
all of those things you just described
to eventually abolish slavery through
teaching um the children of slaves to
read in his will that is something that
I think is absolutely we need to teach
that in
schools you did a Harriet Tubman we did
yeah we have we've done a Harriet Tubman
story time on utto Tales um yeah so I'm
GNA see if I can look up any of the
comments here if anyone is weighing in
about President Day only good I'm sure
they're only good I can't well you know
what sometimes it's hard for me to read
the comments because I can't keep up
sure let's see oh Tony here on Facebook
should separate them again big mistake
to lump them together I believe he was
probably talking about the Lincoln
birthday and Washington's birthday big
mistake to lump them together we should
separate the birthdays again so that
kids and adults can honor and learn
about and celebrate Lincoln and George
Washington I don't want to celebrate
woodro Wilson you know I'll celebrate
Washington Jefferson Lincoln I'll
celebrate those guys oh and Reagan I
want to see let me see what what did
Jean say I come from a military family
and I have been in many states I think
the problem with President St started
back when Washington's birthday and
Lincoln's birthday were separated into
the one President's Day celebrated only
so there could be a three-day weekend it
just became another day off instead of a
celebration of the two presidents thank
you for that Jee you and Richard are
Kindred Spirits here and I'm happy and
I'm happy to be an avid learner of all
of these uh historic details and truths
and and perspectives that I never
previously talk about uh Reagan was a
president Lady of course he was a
president Virginia I wasn't saying that
Reagan was not a president but all I was
saying when Richard showed his Reagan
socks was that she said so and then
she's mad at me oh no Virginia I think I
think you might have misunderstood
Reagan was absolutely an incredible
president I have always acknowledged
that and I believe that right and
Richard sock Reagan on them I was just
saying that Ronald Reagan's birthday was
not the original purpose of president
day that's all also in February also in
February oh it is also February February
yes yes yeah so three three of those
presidents three great presidents all in
February yes yes okay well my birthday
happens and Jefferson is in April when
you you're done with that you can
celebrate Jefferson in April coming up
soon I love it well talking about other
presidents so while while we're talking
about how all the uh
how President's Day was just sort of
lumped into one holiday as much as we
don't want to feed into that Richard we
do have a special offering for parents
and teachers better than nothing at
Prager kids.com we know that we know
that uh Washington's birthday and
Lincoln's birthday are two distinct
things that children should in fact be
learning about and celebrating
separately but we have a special free
offering for all parents and teachers
free on our website if you go to our
website Prager kids.com I'm going to
show you on the screen right now if you
want to follow follow along on the
screen we have a free downloadable
educational magazine of all of the
presidents from Washington George
Washington president number one through
President Lincoln uh number 16 and all
the presidents in between so your kids
can learn about 16 presidents great for
viewing on a tablet you can download it
onto your device this is for unlimited
time through President's Day in honor of
Washington and Lincoln's birthdays I'm
going to show you right now if you go to
cou kids.com you go to the shows Tab and
then you go it's hard for me to see and
then you go to American Presidents right
here and you click on that and then we
scroll down now it says five minute
videos American Presidents which was
such an
unbelievably phenomenal undertaking that
you had a large hand in doing we have
five minute videos on every single one
of our presidents on our website well
we're getting there we're getting but on
many I think about a little over half
that we but yes we've we've covered yeah
anyway and it's perfect for high school
kids to watch and get these five minute
history lessons on every single
president um almost almost to the end
but if you scroll down on this page that
I took you to it says here we go get
your free president ebooks and Kids
magazines so for parents we have a bunch
of offerings here and then also for the
kids I'm going to click on the get Kids
magazines button and it takes us to the
Kids magazine compilation and every US
president from George Washington to a
Abraham Lincoln in this special edition
16 magazine compilation download um you
enter your email address for free there
is zero cost to this and you get this uh
comprehensive free resource with over
150 pages of facts fun about 16 our
first 16 presidents and it's so valuable
and it's it's really it's really
something that should be taught in every
school but it's not and that's where
we're filling the Gap at PR kids and and
we talk about the contribution of presid
that no one knows about and the reason
why we don't know them is because the
left wants you to think that only the
activist presidents were the great ones
but if you look at presidents like
Grover Cleveland and and Calvin kulage
these are guys that did the hard stuff
that no one gets credit for they they
they stewarded the budget they they went
against big government spending and
again you know the average person might
not remember that or you know the left
wants you to think that they were all
idiots and faur but they actually were
really decent like a lot of these guys
were decent men and you know they want
us to think Wilson and FDR were the
great ones but some of the Obscure ones
that just quietly did their job were
some of our best presidents thank you
for that and we have everything on our
website more than you can ever
practically use I would say in raising
and educating your kids and also filling
in the gaps of history that you might
not know yourself I myself have learned
a lot here so with that thank you
Richard for discussing your favorite
President George Washington as well as
Abraham Lincoln thank you for sharing
your swag I know I know he's all decked
out for president day as nerdy as it
gets yes be sure to go to our website
Prager kids.com download that free Kids
magazine detailing the first 16
presidents and subscribe to Prager you
kids for free for all the educational
content you'll need for your children um
kindergarten through 12th grade so with
that we'll say goodbye and happy
President's day bye byebye
