Alleged Labor Violations in Starbucks’s and Nestlé’s China Supply Chains

China in Focus - NTD
3.8K followers
123 Video Views·Dec 4, 2024
Undercover researchers are accusing Starbucks and Nestle of labor violations in their supply chains based in China.
A 15-year-old Chinese girl spotted picking coffee beans said to be sold to Nestle.
A human rights group is releasing findings from an investigation on alleged labor violations
focused on Starbucks and Nestle's Chinese supply chains.
Entity's Juliet Song has more details.
Working over 80 hours a week, paid a mere $420 a month.
A New York-based human rights group says these are among the labor
violations that have happened in Starbucks and Nestle's supply chains in China.
The organization is called China Labor Watch.
It sent undercover researchers to a Chinese city called Puerh to investigate.
This region produces over half of China's coffee.
The report says labor violations have been found in smaller farms that supply
certified coffee farms that work with Starbucks and Nestle.
Because these smaller farms are not technically associated with Starbucks and Nestle,
they can essentially get away with more unethical labor standards.
So we see a lot more labor violations occur on these smaller farms.
Researchers also spotted a 15-year-old girl sorting coffee beans which were later sold to Nestle.
With the 15-year-old girl, when we saw her helping her family
sort out the defective beans that were sourced at Nestle,
this was during the summer, so she did not have school during this period.
So it is hard to say whether she was participating in school.
On another occasion, investigators saw a 12-year-old boy
picking coffee cherries at a certified farm tied to Starbucks.
It's unclear if they were helping their families during
school break or working under their own contract.
The report noted that children could be exposed to agrochemicals in the process.
Though when we spoke to teachers in the region,
there's a higher dropout rate for children above 12 years old.
Local teachers said many children drop out of school once they're 12 or older.
Some of them then go on to join their families doing farm labor.
Hughes said for adult workers, excessive hours and low wages are common.
Workers are also paid by the weight of their harvest,
further incentivizing excessive work hours during peak harvest season.
So essentially they're working from sunrise to sunset.
This could be as many as 12 hours per day, which violates both China labor laws,
which stipulates that a working day should only be eight hours.
It also violates Starbucks and Nestle's cap of 48 work hours per week.
They're paid on average one RMB per one kilogram of harvest.
So this roughly translates to around 14 U.S. dollars per day.
But bear in mind, this 14 U.S. dollars per day is only achieved with
excessive working hours and additional help that is largely uncompensated.
So this additional help can sometimes mean
other family help such as their spouse, but also children.
The report said many farmers don't have formal work contracts or health insurance.
Injuries are common.
Some farmers also don't get sick leave or paid vacations.
In a statement to NTD,
Starbucks said it is committed to investigating the allegations in the report,
adding that its agreements with suppliers
ban the informal supply arrangements mentioned in the report.
Nestle did not respond to our request for comment by airtime.
Juliet Song, NTD News.
