Providing Health Care Directly to the Homeless in Los Angeles | Brett Feldman

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
84 Video Views·Dec 3, 2024
More than a thousand homeless individuals died in Los Angeles County last year, with limited health care access and untreated conditions fueling this crisis. We sit down with Brett Feldman, the director and co-founder of USC Street Medicine, who takes an unconventional approach by providing care directly on the streets to address this urgent issue.
*Views expressed in this video/article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of California Insider.
Living in the streets of Los Angeles can be deadly. More than 2,000 homeless people lost
their lives in the county of Los Angeles last year. That's about six per day. If you're on
the streets, it's very difficult to access health care. It's assumed that a lot of people die from
drug overdoses, but people are challenged with medical conditions on the streets of LA.
Our guest today is Brett Feldman, who's a doctor that has been taking the initiative
to provide health care to the homeless going into the streets of Los Angeles.
In our medical training, we're taught don't get too close to your patients,
no hugging your patients, no crying with your patients. You'll make the wrong diagnosis and
it'll cloud your clinical judgment, and besides, it's unprofessional.
And then you meet somebody scared and suffering.
Today, he'll tell us what is happening in the streets of Los Angeles,
what it takes to help the homeless, and why he needs to go against the grain of the medical
field to help the homeless patients. I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Brett, it's great to have you back on. Welcome back.
Thank you. It's wonderful to be back.
You're doing something amazing for the community. You're going out there,
helping the homeless people with their medical needs.
Can you tell us what's happening now in the streets of LA?
Yeah. In general, on the streets of LA, some things have changed, but in general,
for the singular person on the street, most has stayed the same. They're still
suffering from the same material poverty for want of a home or want of food. And
we know that about a third of people are eating four or less meals a week.
Still the same physical comorbidities, physical illness, substance use disorders,
psychiatric disorders, and still the same spiritual poverty of feeling unwanted or unloved.
And these things, we have to address all of them if we really want to
talk about caring for people and solving homelessness.
You're mentioning one out of three don't have four meals. They have four meals a week,
because we know a lot of nonprofits that are actually handing out food. What's happening?
Yeah. So the vast majority of services, especially food services and shelters,
are concentrated on Skid Row. But when we talk about unsheltered homelessness, so people not
in the shelters, not in transitional housing, it's about 5% in the county are on Skid Row,
but still the vast majority of resources. So outside of Skid Row, it's really, really hard
to get access to your basic needs, including food. And so even if you have a soup kitchen
or a food pantry, the sprawl is so big that it's really hard for people to get there. It's not
nearly enough. So most of them rely on actually buying their own food is the most common way that
they get it, according to our research. And about a third are getting four or less meals a week.
And this has consequences for everything, right? So they have to make these difficult decisions,
the opportunity costs, you know, Economics 101, that if they choose to, so they have to buy their
food, and if they're going to buy it, they have to find money somehow. So maybe they're going to
panhandle for that. And if they choose to not do that that day, because they have to go to the DMV
for an ID, go to the doctor for a doctor's appointment, go for a job interview, they have
make this difficult decision, well, now I won't, now I won't eat today, in order to go do those
things. And that's a decision that you and I don't have to make every day. And in terms of you being
on the streets, you guys go to them because they cannot go to the hospitals. We are hearing that
people go to the emergency rooms is which one is, is true, or both true? It's both. We call it a
diurnal pattern. So there's, there's a majority, actually, who don't access health care at all.
And there's a number of reasons why that is. And then, and then another part that, that are what
we would call super utilizer, they access a lot of health care, mostly in in like emergency room,
hospital type of settings. And the idea is that, is that you don't want to wait until it gets to
this point that they have to use the emergency department and the hospitals. We want it to get,
as they say, the right care at the right time at the right place. And that's part of what street
medicine is, is, is coming up a way to deliver health care in a way that's accessible to them,
acceptable to them, and can flip the power dynamic in their favor where they feel most comfortable.
You mentioned there is the, the spiritual poverty, there's the, the food side, there's the material.
What about the drug side? Because we, we are seeing a lot of drugs and is that a component of
people becoming homeless? Yeah, absolutely. The drug side straddles the health poverty
and the spiritual poverty. It's hard to say. Some people came to homelessness because they started
using drugs. I actually think this is a small amount. Most people started using once they got
onto the street because it's, it's horrible on the street. And anything that you can do to just
dull that pain for a minute, in an act of desperation, you want to do that. There's also
a safety component, especially with, for females on the street, where over 90%
are sexually assaulted at some point during their time on the street. And so it's very common for
them to start using methamphetamine in order to stay awake at night so that they can just walk,
walk, walk in a self-protective way and then sleep during the day. So for your viewers,
if you see somebody sleeping during the day, experiencing homelessness, this is not necessarily
because they're lazy. They don't feel like doing anything. They were probably awake all night,
just trying to protect themselves. And so it's very difficult to make the clear connection that
when you use drugs, you wind up homeless. It's much more complicated than that.
Was there a moment you realized that there is a spiritual poverty in the streets?
Some of the questions I would ask myself about that kind of led to the focus on the spiritual
poverty was like, on one hand, the rest of the community, like the rest of the medical community
was saying not to do this, not to go out onto the street, not to get too close,
and that I should practice self-care. And most of the self-care was about retreating
away from the problem. So not get too engaged with the patient. Yeah, don't get too engaged
with the patient. You should be disconnected so that you don't bring it home with you.
And that didn't seem to work. It didn't seem to work for me and it didn't seem to work
for the patients. And then I realized that this can't be just like a job that I go to and leave
on the street. There's real suffering on the street. And that part of what the folks need
is for us to share in that with them. That it can't just be giving out of our excess.
Like most of our programs are something out of excess. It's some grant, some philanthropy,
and we do a little bit. But it's not a firm commitment to the work. And so the people have
been so excluded, so expelled that they need to know that there's a firm commitment from you too.
It can't be done by half. And so the more I would engage in them, the more of myself I gave. We
talk about them building trust, but do I trust them? I want to know all these things about them,
all these things about their history and their trauma and who did what to them in their past,
but do they know anything about me? If this is a relationship, it should go two ways.
And so I would share a little bit about me and they would share a little bit more about them.
And then I realized that we would get to this place of solidarity where, you know, in the
medical community typically we're very like parental. We tell people you should do this,
you should do that. And then we sort of flipped that in street medicine and said, well, it should
be patient led. Like we should follow what they want us to do. And that's better than us telling
them what to do. But the real goal is this solidarity point where I don't really know who's
leading. We're working so closely as a team that we're doing this together. So for example,
very simple, if I'm treating somebody's blood pressure and they're taking their medication,
is this my goal or their goal? Well, of course, like I want them to take it because
that's why I do medicine. I want people to be healthy. And if they want to take it,
they want to be healthy. That's their goal. It's the same goal. That's exactly
where we want to get to. Where it gets confusing to people is when you have the same
organization that's sending them mixed messages. So for example, and I think this is for some of
our governments too, is if you have the same government that they don't know the difference,
like most of us don't know what city, what county, what state, it's just like the government.
The same government that's on one hand pushing them, sweeping them from place to place,
and then also sending out a team to help them. First we sweep you and then now we'll send out
Department of Health or Department of Public Health and help you. This is confusing.
Which government should we trust? And it tends to be the one that most impacts their life.
And so you have to just have an overwhelming amount of help in order to counter the impact
of getting pushed around everywhere. So that consistency is part of it. You can't solve
spiritual poverty without that. The other thing I noticed about it is like
when you're in this state of oppression, which they are because they can't go places that other
people can go to. They can't sit on a bench for too long. They can't go into a restaurant
for too long. And then you start to believe these things about yourself,
that you really are less than human and you really don't deserve these things.
And then you begin to treat other people that are like you the same way.
And so that's why you see so much, maybe they'll steal from each other,
maybe they'll treat each other poorly, because that's also what they have been taught about
themselves. And so the first thing to do is to, we don't give them their humanity that's
inherent in them being human, is to just help them recognize that with acts of love.
And that's how you solve the spiritual poverty. So the medical community said,
don't get close to your patient. This is best practices. And you did that, kind of broke the
rules. Did you get impacted in a negative way when you broke that rule? So the medical community,
when we started going out onto the street, there was some pushback because we broke some of those
things that were considered professional, but it's not about professionalism at all. It's about
the humanist. People can feel more comfortable just treating numbers. The math problem that
comes with their lab results or with some imaging. So medicine, the only difference between medicine
and biology or biochemistry, any other science, is because of respect for life or respect for
human dignity. If medicine is not different, then it's simply another science applied to a
biped species that we call homo sapien. And I think that we all got into medicine thinking
that it was more than that. But what a lot of medicine has done has degraded this field into
simply another science. And that can be a painful process, rehumanizing into the way that it should
be. So just it's become more like a material. You fix somebody's physical problem. Yeah.
But it needs to be more, essentially. Yeah. And everybody needs that. Every patient
needs that. But in a typical house population, they're not always looking for that from their
doctor or from their healthcare provider because they have families. People rely on their families
for support. For people who are experiencing homelessness, they might have a community on
the street, but it's different from that longstanding deep family support or friends
that others might have. And so they're looking for more from us. And that's okay. There's nothing
wrong with us trying to provide more support in that way. When you are seeing your patients,
can you tell us about the interaction? So you built a relationship with them. Is it hard to
build that relationship? There's this perception that it can take months to build trust, months to
build rapport. That hasn't been my experience. You know, we always say when you go out on the street,
there's two important things. One, the first thing you do is make sure that they know how
much you love them. That's probably what they're missing the most. And then next, just be your
authentic self. You know, we all have different personalities. One of our physician assistants,
who's an amazing street medicine provider, and she's like, you know, I'm a white suburban mom.
When I go out onto the street, that's all I need to be. And people respect everybody as their
authentic selves. But ultimately, it comes down to them knowing that you love them and that you're
willing to be there for them. The trust part is the first part. And that's not just for care,
it's for any sort of service. And I guess the best way I can explain it is imagine that you're in
this like big shipwreck. And everybody you know has died. But you're like holding on to this one
piece of lumber. And it's not like a great lumber, but it has kept you alive when everybody around
you has died. And then somebody comes to you in a boat and says, swim to me, I'll save you.
And you have to decide, will I let go of my lumber and swim to them, that if their trust
is betrayed, I'll drown just like everybody around me? Or do I stick with what I know that's saving
my life? So many of them have let go and have swam and have drowned. And so we need to be
trustworthy enough that they're willing to take that chance on us. So that's the first thing.
The second thing is understanding that there's lots of different priorities in their life. Like
where's my next meal going to come from? Where am I going to sleep tonight? Am I going to be safe
doing those things? And then the trauma around other things like health care. I mean, we know
there have been studies published that the reason why they don't go to the hospital is because of
previous negative experiences in the hospital. And so we know that we have to bring it to them.
And so it's more than just an office visit, even if that office is under the bridge.
So we dispense medications, draw labs, do ultrasound, everything on the street.
Because that's the only way we know for sure that they're going to get it. And so in a lot of ways,
street medicine is really an act of reconciliation to say that we know what you're going through.
We're sorry for maybe we or our colleagues may have done before, but now we're here with you.
If you like California Insider and you'd like to know what's going on in California,
make sure to check out Epoch Times. This is a newspaper that started by a group of Chinese
Americans because of human rights abuses in China and now is starting to grow here. Make sure to go
to the Epoch Times website and check out the California section where you can get a lot of
fresh perspectives on what's going on in California. Now, let's go back to the interview.
And now in terms of people getting access to housing, is it that there is not enough shelters
or do they not want to go into shelters because they had a bad experience or they don't want to get the housing?
Every person has their individual preferences. But what I do know is that there are not open
shelter beds. All the shelter beds are full. They're even like beyond capacity. Whenever we
have a housing unit available, we fill it so fast. You can fill it with your patients?
Oh, yes. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we don't build the homes or control the vouchers.
But you kind of have access to, if you're offered, you have people that they're
willing to go into the shelters. Yes. Yeah. That has not been a problem.
We've been involved with Inside Safe, Mayor Bass's initiative, and I think that has done a great job
of really proving that if there's housing, people want the housing.
And so I think the idea is that, you know, maybe not 100 percent are going to take it,
but a lot, a lot are going to take it. That's why they're working on building more. But the
problem is not that people don't want it, that they want to be homeless. They don't.
But when we hear some people say they want to live like that in the street,
that might be a few, or you think they're kind of rebelling.
I mean, I'm not going to say there's nobody, but that's not causing a homeless crisis.
If there was enough housing, then people would go into it. I mean, there is an element of like
housing that is fit for people to live in. But assuming that the housing is fit for human
habitation, and assuming that a shelter is a safe place to be, and we have to make them a
safe place to be, then people will go in. Have you had complaints that shelters are
not safe for some people? Yeah, we have. People say that they
get their stuff stolen in shelters. You know, sometimes, too, it's not just the safety, but,
you know, understanding that people want their liberty, their freedom, their ability to make
decisions, and be treated like a human being, just like you and I do. And sometimes, when we're
setting up these units, there are certain policies in place that dehumanize people who are coming
into them. So, for example, some units, you can't go in with weapons. And so, whenever you walk in,
they'll take your fork or your nail clippers as a weapon. And to me, these are things that
people typically will have in their home. And so, it's based on an inherent distrust of the people
coming in. And so, how does that make you feel? How would you feel if somebody wouldn't allow you
to have a fork to eat your food with? And so, they don't want to be in places like that,
but I wouldn't either. Last time you were here, I think there was big challenges with
insurance covering what you guys did. Yes. And has that changed? Yes, it has changed
pretty significantly since I was here last. So, before the issue that we were trying,
the problem we were trying to solve was that for street medicine, we couldn't bill
Medi-Cal or Medicare. This was a federal problem. Because when you bill, you bill for what you do
and where you're doing it. What we did, what we do is always billable, but there was no where
of the street. And so, first, Department of Healthcare Services issued what's called an
all-plan letter, which is a communication from the state to the health plans and told them to cover
street medicine, cover care on the street. And then, we talked to the federal government,
CMS, Center for Medicare and Medicaid, and they issued a new place of service code
so that the street could be a billable place. And while it's an important thing for us to be
able to get reimbursed for our care, because that's a fair thing that the cardiologist or
family doctor doesn't worry about getting reimbursed because of where they are,
it also recognizes the people's right to life who rely in as much as healthcare contributes to
people's life, because they rely on us to deliver care in that environment in the street.
So, by recognizing the street, they recognize their right to life. So, that is new. We're all
still working on our contract. We have to have a contract with managed care, all the insurance
companies, in order to bill. And so, most of us are right now talking to the insurance companies,
trying to be able to get reimbursed for the care. And how is the ID situation comes in? It's very
hard for people to have ID in the street because they will steal them, right? Yes, you have to
prove that you are who you say you are in order to get a lot of benefits. And so, yes, people's ID
is frequently a target for theft. You could sell an ID for $250 on the street. So, the same
thing that is their ticket to different services is the same thing that's being targeted for theft.
One of the things that we've done differently, I think, is we try and help people
keep record of their ID. So, there's a system called HMIS, Homeless Management Information System.
And when we get that ID, we stick it right in that system so that it can be easily accessible.
Even if they lose it. Even if they lose it. And it's not as good as the physical things. Not
everybody accepts it, but we're doing our best. So, you're taking care of all of that when you
meet people? Yeah. It's very far outside of the typical scope of healthcare. So, for example,
I was trying to care for somebody who had scabies. Their dog also had scabies. And so,
we had to get rid of the scabies on their dog also. So, we had to buy some veterinary
medicine. So, yeah. And also, they didn't have money to wash their clothes.
Because in order to get rid of the scabies, you have to
wash your clothes. So, we had to pay for her to wash her clothes. So, there's lots of different
things that we do that would be outside of the insurance. Yes, there's lots of things outside
of that. Yeah. And there's lots of things that we pay that insurance should be paying for.
So, for example, 75% of our patients have Medi-Cal. They have insurance. But certain
things that they're entitled to because of their insurance, they can't access because
of their experience in homelessness. For example, they have a transportation benefit,
but no address for the transportation company to pick them up. So, we have to pay for rideshare
for them. They get durable medical equipment, such as all the wound care we do. All the bandages
is all considered durable medical equipment or wheelchairs or walkers. But no place to get those
things delivered to. And when we see a wound, we have to address that now. And so, we pay for it
out of our budget. And so, we're having to raise a lot of money. But these are things the insurance
company should be paying for. Let's say you meet somebody once. What kind of impact does it have?
People have come to us with a long history of maybe tragedy or trauma.
And people might, like I've heard people refer to this as like a vulnerable population.
This is not a vulnerable population. Vulnerability supposes that something bad might happen.
Something bad has already happened. They've been completely expelled from society. And so,
once you've been treated that way, that like, you know, I can't, you and I can sit on any park bench,
go into any restaurant, but they can't do that. Whenever they settle somewhere, we don't want you
here. We don't want you here. And push, push, push, push, push. And so, when we see them,
the first thing is to recognize their humanity and kind of try and reach a level of solidarity
that we can work together. That they don't have to be different from what they are right now.
We'll work towards that. But right now, we're going to do these things together.
That's not always going to happen in one visit. After a lifetime of poverty, we can't have the
arrogance or a lifetime of exclusion. We can't have the arrogance to think we can solve it
in one visit. So, we have to be realistic of what we can and can't do. But we can at least start
down that path. So, in a sense, that first visit is more like a therapy,
in a sense, what you're saying. To kind of connect with them and build a relationship
and then show them that it's okay. What they're experiencing is okay. Like, they've been through
a lot. Yeah, yeah. I mean, that, the first visit and every visit after that is, the first thing is
to bring them an understanding of love. And then the healthcare behind that. I know sometimes
people are like, oh, that love, that's not going to work. Or that's too cheesy for me. But most of
the people that say that, they've not tried it. Or they've tried it, they found that that's actually
the hard part. And then they decide, oh, it's too hard, I'm not going to try anymore. It's also not
something that can be mechanized in a program that we can easily replicate with money over and
over and over again. It takes some risk, it takes a human connection. There's some personal risk,
too. Like, in our training, in our medical training, and I'm sure it's this way in other
fields, too, we're taught, don't get too close to your patients, no hugging your patients,
no crying with your patients. You'll make the wrong diagnosis and it'll cloud your clinical
judgment. And besides, it's unprofessional. And then you meet somebody scared and suffering.
It's not just in the streets, in every hospital, in every room. And you have a choice. Do I engage
with them and share in some of that suffering, maybe exposing myself to it? Or do I retreat in
an act of self-preservation? And if what you've been taught is that the professional thing to
do is retreat, you'll do that every time. But when you do that, you've left them abandoned,
but you've also, and isolated, but you've also isolated yourself with the knowledge of knowing
that you've abandoned the people you've dedicated your life to serving. And so that's why you hear
so much about physician burnout and burnout in the healthcare field. Some of it's burnout,
a lot of it is moral injury, with the knowledge of knowing that you've abandoned the people that
you've dedicated your life to serving. And so it's as much of a mutual healing as anything else.
What you're saying is that with the programs we have created, we created a level of boundary
where we're trying to take emotions out of it, or the connection, the human connection out of it,
create a system to protect our people that are in that field. But in a sense,
through doing that, we have actually not helped the situation, hurt the situation on both sides,
right? Yeah. If you want to, I don't know the solution to solving homelessness, but I can
maybe shed where to start, is we have to be able to separate the person from their housing status,
and to hate homelessness with everything that we have, but to love the person experiencing it
even more. And until we can distinguish those two things, then we confuse what it is that we're
hating. And we end up working in service of homelessness at the expense of the people
experiencing homelessness. And so the first thing is to separate the person from the experience.
So you come to love these patients, you know, you just have an interaction.
Do they believe you, that you're genuine? Well, we want them to, as I mentioned before in the
shipwreck scenario, we have to get them to trust us enough. We have to earn that,
to let go of their little piece of wood and swim to us. And so sometimes it takes time,
but it's something you have to earn. It's not just time. It's following through on
things that you're saying you're going to do, not promising things that you can't promise,
but promising that you'll try. And if it doesn't go the way that you planned, at least
they know you tried, and I found that they appreciate that.
We are honored to be sponsored by Shen Yun. Shen Yun Performing Arts is reviving 5,000 years of
lost Chinese traditional culture. It takes you back in time to the magical world of ancient
China with a unique blend of brilliant dancing, beautiful costumes, and legends coming to life.
The show choreography and production values are top-notch. However, it isn't just a technical
ability of the dancers. It's the inner beauty and the devotion of the artist that will stir your
soul to move you to tears. Make sure to go see it this year. Go to ShenYun.com and book your tickets
It was spectacular. So beautiful. I thought I was going to heaven. It was electric. I'm getting
chills talking about it. It gets a 10 from me, that's for sure. It was that good. Absolutely
marvelous. Hands down the best show I've ever seen. Now, is that piece of wood sometimes drugs
and that community they are in, or is it bigger things? Oh, that's a great question.
I think it's different for every person. For example, some of the communities, they share
a lot of things. Maybe somebody gets general relief, they get a little bit of money a month,
and they'll share it to help everybody get food. And so they know, maybe I know I'll get at least
a few meals a week if everybody shares their GR together in this little community. Or they know
that they have some protection within that little community, or even just some fellowship,
you know, some friends that make them feel like they're not as terrible as everybody else might
make them feel. Now, you're dealing with a lot of people that are in a tough situation. Do you
ever feel somewhat hopeless or that this is beyond what you can do? The secret, I think,
is not to try and solve big things. We're not trying to solve homelessness for 50,000 people,
or provide health care for 50,000 people today. The secret is one. So I take care of
the person in front of me, one person, and then one more person, and one more person.
And the hope is that over time, this adds up to something. You put your career on helping people
on the streets. You don't have a fancy office. Now, is it worth it? Yeah, of course. I mean,
I get too much praise from the people on the street, much more than I deserve.
Sometimes because of their experience and because their self-esteem might be so low that we can be
successful in doing something, you know, helping them reach their goals physically, helping them
get into housing, and they think I did it. But they did it. Like, they had to do a lot.
They had to take the big risks. It wasn't me that had to take the big risks.
And so I think I get too much credit for it. And also defining success, I think, is an important
thing. You know, sometimes people think the only successful thing is when they get a job,
and they get housing, and all of their medical stuff is solved. It's gone. But sometimes success
is them just knowing that somebody loved them when they died. We have patients that we do
palliative care for on the street that die. It's not just drug overdose. People like to talk about
that. But the number two cause of death is heart disease. Number three is cancer. You know, we're
caring for people with serious chronic illnesses on the street that are also dying. One of the
patients I met the other day, she has esophageal cancer and leukemia, two forms of cancer.
She was diagnosed four years ago and has not had follow-up care since.
So I know when she met us, and I hope we can make good on this, but she saw maybe she could get
treatment, that she'd been so worried about this on the street, didn't know where to go, where to start,
and that maybe she'd be okay. And so now we have to work with a very, very difficult,
very complex health care system to try and make good on what she's hoping from us.
Can you tell us some of the stories of the people that you've met and tell us the
impact of what you guys have been doing on the streets? I mean, there's been a number of
stories that have really changed the way that I thought about health care and the way I thought
about what we were doing, even more so than demonstrated success necessarily.
I remember one of the first patients that we saw was Joe. He was in his 70s, a
naval veteran, had a master's degree from Lehigh, a PhD from Cal, and he was a clinical psychologist
in one of the state hospitals before it closed. And coming back from the war, he had been kind
of like a functional alcoholic, where he would drink most of the weekend, sober up to work during
the week. And then when the hospital closed, he was less functional because he didn't have a job
to go to every day. And he had a small pension. When I met him, he was most of the time living
outside in a tent with one of his patients, one of his old patients that was suffering from
schizophrenia, who he continued to take care of, even after the hospital closed. But between the
probably a week or two, they would stay in a hotel together, and then they'd be
on the street together. And I remember he had fallen and broken his ankle.
And we were in the hospital, and they had cleared him to discharge, to go home.
But the hospital, we didn't recognize what his home situation was like. He had walked with
a walker with his broken leg in the flat surface, 50 yards, home with home PT.
But he lived in this riverbed. And in order to just get food, he had to climb out of the
riverbed, hop a fence, and walk multiple blocks, which at 75 was a problem before the broken leg,
but now was really going to be difficult. So I remember going to see him out there,
and he had tried to hop that fence again, but fell. And when I got there, I saw his patient.
He walked up to me, and there was blood on his pants. And he had told me that Joe had fallen.
And so I saw Joe, and there was blood coming from his head. And thankfully, it was not a major
injury, and he survived. But it made me think about the failure of recognizing the reality
that people live in when we're making decisions and different policies, that their lives are so
much different from ours. But I knew the people in the hospital, and I knew that they really cared.
They didn't knowingly make a bad decision. But it made me realize that lack of empathy is really a
lack of the imagination, that we need to go to the people and see what their life is like,
and then report back when we're making any sort of decisions.
Do you think people like that are uncomfortable to tell their situation? Did he tell the hospital
his situation? Yeah, I think part of it is that part of it is there's a shame element to it.
My experience is that if you are experiencing homelessness, that trumps everything else.
For example, we have people with intellectual disabilities, who are part of the regional
center, who are supposed to take care of them for life. But once they become homeless,
they don't do homeless services. Or people who are elderly, who should be in a nursing home.
And if they were in a house, the nursing home would accept them, but they don't do
homeless placement. So this experience trumps all other things. That's why we call it not a
vulnerable population, but an expelled population. The other thing is people don't always know
what's relevant for the medical field to know. For example, I think about another patient,
also elderly, who was blind, with end-stage heart disease, end-stage kidney disease,
and he had atrial fibrillation, which is an irregular heartbeat, which can cause a stroke.
And you take a blood thinner for those things. And in order to get to him, there was this bridge,
that sort of a bridge that his friends made to get over this river. This is in LA. This is not
Pennsylvania. And then you had to, like, trex into the woods. But the problem was at night,
because he was blind, he only saw shadows. And so he didn't know if what he was seeing was a
solid object or just a shadow. So he would get scared and then sleep wherever he was. He would
just lay down where that was. And so if you were to see him, like, when he would go into the
hospital for his heart or for his kidneys, they would just discharge him just like they would
anybody else, not realizing that, like, his biggest risk of death was falling in the ravine
on the blood thinners, not his heart. Or, like, you know, they would have him,
he was on water pills, diuretics, because of his heart failure. But he also didn't have good access
to water, and was, like, forced to walk around all day, walk around to get anything, you know,
in and out of his encampment, and was wearing multiple layers of clothing, even in the summer,
not because he was psychotic and didn't know what temperature it was, but because he had no dresser.
And so all this caused increased water loss. The hospital didn't know
this and would give him too high of a dose of the diuretics, which would cause kidney failure.
But he wouldn't know to, like, tell them these things. So it's our responsibility to flush out
what the reality is of their life and make a reality-based treatment plan.
And do you think there is a connection here between what you're saying about the disconnect
with the spiritual poverty, where it seems like the programs that are created are more around
the material, you know, and it's missing the spiritual side?
Yes. It's much easier to fix the material poverty. You give them some bread, and now maybe they're
not hungry for a minute. You can put them in four walls that we call housing and think that it's
solved. But if they're still spiritually homeless, we haven't solved anything. And so this is the
biggest challenge facing us right now, is that we put people in the boxes that we call housing,
but their community is still on the street. And so they are so lonely in those boxes.
And that's what drives and pushes them back outside, not because they love being homeless,
but because that's where their friends are. And so our challenge is to create that same community
indoors, a new community in these housing units or in the community. And that means it's up to us
as a house community to now accept them and make space for them in a loving way.
Now, do you have any advice for professionals in this field?
Yeah, the best advice I would have is to get to know the people, that they're beautiful people
and wonderful people. And if you get to know them, then you'll learn to love them. And once
you love them, that will guide all the other policy decisions, all the other decisions that
you make. Otherwise, you're just making decisions on where to sort different widgets and housing or
parts of programs. Now, you started a lot of programs. Apparently, you've trained a lot of
people to get involved. How many are there now in L.A.?
So in L.A., there's at least 15 street medicine programs now in the state. So when I moved here
in 2018, there were six programs in the state of California. Now, there's at least 65 that we know.
And before, it was mostly concentrated in the urban areas. Now, it's in 34 counties.
It's not nearly enough. When we think about coverage, for example, it's not geographic only,
it's population-based. And in L.A., even though there's 15 programs, we're still seeing less
than 10% of the people. Wow. And do you get any pushback
from other providers or the community on what you're doing?
Less than we used to. When I started, street medicine was this kind of radical fringe movement
that wasn't really accepted by the mainstream. So by the medical community?
Yeah, this was irresponsible. How can you possibly deliver the same care on the street
that you can in a clinic? They would say it's dirty or risky.
Yes. It was irresponsibly medically and risky to us personally to go out onto the street.
There's much less of that now, partially because now we've had decades of experience
and we know it works. We know this is a best practice now. So there's less pushback than it
used to be. Most of the pushback we get now is around the cost of it. But it's more about equity,
where the idea of equity is that people who need more get more and people who need less get less.
And so it's not expensive, it's just equitable.
Now, Brett, do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
I guess just recognizing that we're not alone in this work, USC street medicine and everything.
Right now where we are in the state with street medicine is we've taken what was this radical
fringe, you know, street medicine, crazy street medicine idea, and now it's accepted
by mainstream health care. And so where we are now is trying to figure out how, the question is not
how do we bend and mold street medicine to fit into mainstream health care? We know that street
medicine works. The question is how do we bend and mold mainstream health care to fit street
medicine? How do we build a system from the street backwards? And if we do this, you know,
while keeping the values and philosophy that make street medicine work intact. And so that's our
current challenge. And, you know, there are many different kind of forks we can choose that if we
make certain decisions, it'll cause a retreat from the street and regression back into an oppressive
system that expelled them in the first place. Or we can take the other way to be in solidarity with
the streets and actually like enhance the work that's already being done. And so people all
around the world, but, you know, certainly in our country and our state are working towards that.
Like they know that this is the goal. And so the state has made changes to allow street medicine
values and philosophy to stay intact. Even like some managed care plans are trying to figure
this out. It's still new. It's iterative, but it's an exciting time. Do you think you can bring
the spiritual component of what you guys are doing, which is like building a very deep relationship
with your patient to the rest of the medical community? I hope so. And there are things that
are happening that I think point to that being the case. So for example, whenever we talk about
in the past year, we've trained over a thousand people about street medicine. Our first lecture
is always about the values and philosophy of street medicine. And we talk about this kind of
radical humility that it takes to do this work. And the more we talk about it, the more people
want to join the movement and the family practice association for the country, the residents,
they get to choose what they want to learn the most about. Of all of the topics in the whole
country, they want to learn about street medicine. So I think it's resonating with people. And it's
not that we need everybody on the street, but it's the values and philosophy that people are like,
yeah, that's the way I want. That's what I signed up for when I got into medicine.
Brett Feldman with USC Street Medicine. It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you very much.
