Why the Freedom Class Ships Are Both the U.S. Navy’s Fastest and Most Controversial!

Vehicles for Warfare at Sea
8 followers
Welcome to Navy Steel, where we dive deep into the fascinating world of modern naval power.
Today we're taking a close look at the Freedom Class Little Combat Ships, a class of vessels
that have faced their fair share of challenges and triumphs. From their unique design and high
speed capabilities to the controversial decisions surrounding their missions and maintenance,
these ships have had quite the journey. But here's the real question, can the Freedom Class
still hold its own in the modern navy, or are they destined for an early retirement?
What if I told you they've had a major redesign to fix many of their initial issues?
Stick around as we explore the highs and lows of these ships, and make sure to let us know,
do you think the Freedom Class deserves a second chance, or should it be sent to the scrapyard?
Are they more than just fast, or are they missing something crucial?
Drop your thoughts in the comments and let's dive in.
In this case I boarded the US Navy's most insane ship, the world's largest jet ski that just so
happens to have a naval gun. If you could see what I saw through this window, you'd probably
come to the same mind-blowing conclusion I did. This ship is by far the most overpowered vessel
in the entire US Navy. I got to explore every part of the USS Marinette that they'd let me,
from the engineering room, which I thought was the most badass area, to the bridge that was
unlike anything I'd ever seen, and don't even get me started on the red light district,
but here's the real kicker. Why is this ship forbidden from hunting submarines,
and why is there no way around it? Why is the doctor in the USS Marinette the same person
that handles the mooring lines when the ship docks? How the hell does this class of ships fire
tomahawk missiles, even though there's no launcher? And why out of all the Freedom Class little combat
ships, is the USS Marinette the only one that actually gets it right? Well, let me tell you,
it's not what you're thinking. On the other side of this window, there's something that once soared
through the skies. This monster of a Rolls-Royce MT-30 gas turbine is the naval version of the
engines found on a Boeing 777. With over 50 million flight hours, you'd think this engine
has proven its worth. But on this ship, it's locked inside a steel explosion-proof box.
So, if this thing blows up for any reason, all the damage is contained. The ship has not one,
but two of these engines, each cranking out an insane 48,000 horsepower. And here's the crazy
part. Unlike most ships, these engines don't drive traditional propellers. Instead, they power
water jets. The USS Marinette has four of them, and together they can pump a mind-blowing 25,000
gallons of water every second. Let me break that down for you. If I tried filling an Olympic-sized
pool using the faucet at my house, it would take me 305 days. These four water jets can fill that
same pool in 25 seconds. But why water jets instead of propellers, right? Well, two of the
water jets on this beast can also serve as rudders. Since they can steer independently,
the ship can maneuver like a jet ski. Normally, ships have a helm to steer, but not this one.
The USS Marinette has a massive, modern bridge with four controls to adjust the power and
direction of the water jets. This thrust vectoring ability gives the ship insane maneuverability,
allowing it to pivot tightly or move purely sideways. Something ships with rudders and
propellers just can't do. And when it comes to stopping, the water jets are so powerful,
they can bring the ship to a full stop in no time. A cover swings over the nozzles,
forcing the water jet to go backward. This is called a crash stop, and it can stop a fast-moving
ship in barely the length of its hull. And did I mention that it's done without any propellers?
This ship can operate in waters as shallow as 15 feet? That's because these ships were made
for shallow littoral waters. This is Freedom Dunright. That's the model of the USS Marinette,
the 13th ship in the Freedom-class littoral combat ships, also known as LCS. It's the only
ship to carry the name of the city where it was built, christened, and commissioned, Marinette,
Wisconsin. And that meant the ship had to travel through the St. Lawrence Seaway to reach its home
port in Mayport, Florida. The Freedom-class isn't the only ship type with gas turbines.
The Arleigh Burke Destroyers use General Electric LM2500 gas turbines. But the Rolls-Royce MT-30
is in a whole different league. That's why ships like the Zumwalt Destroyers and the Royal Navy's
Queen Elizabeth-class aircraft carriers are powered by the same two jet engines found on the USS
Marinette. Pretty insane, right? These massive ships have a displacement that's 19 times bigger
than the 3,500-ton Freedom-class littoral combat ship. But the USS Marinette is completely souped
up. It makes you wonder, why would the U.S. Navy shove all that raw power into such a lightweight
hull? The answer's simple, speed. Freedom-class ships are the fastest in the U.S. Navy fleet,
clocking in at speeds over 40 knots. That insane speed was the reason these ships are lightly
armored and armed, finding a balance between killing power, survivability, and sheer velocity.
These ships are capable of reaching such high speeds that they need some seriously
heavy-duty wipers to clear the bridge windows from the constant water splash.
The ship's top speed is classified, but we can make an educated guess by looking at the world's
passenger ferry in operation, the HCS Francisco. This ferry uses two water jets powered by the
less-powerful LM2500 gas turbines, which are also found on the Arlebar Destroyers.
The HCS Francisco tops out at 58 knots. Now USS Marinette is a relatively small vessel,
small enough that they had to run an exhaust pipe straight through the wardroom,
where the officers dine. When you cram two massive jet engines into such a compact hull,
you get a lot of vibrations. The faster the ship goes, the more intense the vibrations become.
According to Admiral Gilday, former chief of naval operations, this made freedom-class ships
as noisy as aircraft carriers. This explains the abundance of springs and shock absorbers
scattered throughout the ship. These are there to reduce the vibrations and noise.
But what's the big deal about a little vibration? You can throw tennis balls under the chair legs
to stop the vibrations from scratching the floors or use carabiners to secure the chairs to the
floor during rapid acceleration and rough seas. The real issue with the vibrations wasn't about
the ship itself, it was what was underneath. The freedom-class littoral combat ships were
designed to be modular, adaptable for three main missions. Surface warfare,
mine countermeasures, and anti-submarine warfare. That's why there are two large,
reconfigurable spaces at the aft of the ship, called Recon 1 and Recon 2. These areas could
be swapped with whatever warfare package was needed, through a hatch in the ceiling that
leads to the flight deck. The Recon areas also double as a gym or storage space.
For those of you familiar with the LCS saga, you'll know that the US Navy eventually scrapped
the modular concept and assigned a fixed mission to each ship. In 2022, the Navy even decided to
cancel the anti-submarine mission package for the freedom-class ships, mainly due to the vibrations.
Sonars detect small vibrations underwater to track submarines. However, the vibrations
caused by the jet engines of the freedom-class ships were so intense that they drowned out the
sonar, making it impossible to detect the small vibrations from submarines lurking nearby.
With the anti-submarine mission no longer in play, the Navy ended up with more LCS hulls than it
needed. As a result, some of the freedom-class ships were retired early, despite being just a
couple of years old. But it wasn't just the vibrations causing trouble, there were other
issues contributing to the premature retirement of these ships. The two jet engines aren't the
only source of power on the USS Marinette. The ship also has two cold-peel stick diesel engines
on board, each about the size of a school bus. Together, they generate 19,000 horsepower,
enough for the ship to hit a max speed of 12 knots. To reach speeds over 40 knots,
the gas turbines and diesel engines need to be combined, assisted by a gearbox. Unfortunately,
the gearbox kept breaking down. Without the gearbox engaged, the ship could only reach
around 10 knots, powered by the diesel engines. In 2021, it was revealed that this was a class-wide
defect across the freedom-class ships. The Navy and Lockheed Martin, the ship's manufacturer,
agreed to split the cost of repairing the combining gear around 8 to 10 million dollars,
50 to 50. Since then, at least seven freedom-class ships, including hull number 25,
USS Marinette, have had the gearbox issue fixed, meaning they now have no speed limitations.
USS Marinette, in particular, is equipped with the Surface Warfare Package. In this role,
the ship provides fleet protection against small boats and other asymmetrical threats.
The ship is equipped with 24 Hellfire Precision Strike Missiles, specifically for surface
warfare. There's also the impressive Mark 110 57mm Naval Gun. This was my first time getting
up close to this weapon system, and I have to say, the gun is way bigger in person than it
looks in videos. I asked Adam, who was giving us the tour, if the gun could hit a target on the
other side where those buildings were. He chuckled a bit. Later, I found out the gun actually has a
range of 10 miles. It's fully automatic and can fire 220 rounds per minute. That makes the ship
more than capable of conducting interdiction missions against pirates and other threats.
For those curious, the black cap on the gun prevents things like water from getting inside
and damaging the system. Normally, the cap is removed before use, but I was told they could
fire right through it if necessary. There's also a cram on board, which is the primary air defense
system designed to intercept incoming anti-ship missiles. At the ship's stern is what I like to
call the Red Light District, though its actual name is the Waterboard Mission Zone. This is where boats
can be launched and recovered. Typically, two 11-meter rigid inflatable boats ribs are stored
here when needed. The stern doors open to launch a R.I.B. with a law enforcement team aboard.
This is different from a well deck, where the ship's stern dips into the water. Instead, this
cradle can be lowered into the water and raised back out, which is how the ribs are launched and
recovered. The Freedom Class ships also have a Mine Countermeasure Mission Package. This was
designed to keep personnel out of dangerous minefields. The ship can launch an Unmanned
Surface Vessel, or USV, from the Red Light District. The USV travels to the designated area,
launches sonar equipment, and scans the area for mines. The operators can then access real-time
data from the safety of the ship. Additionally, Freedom ships can house MH-60 Seahawk helicopters
and Fire Scout drones. The helicopters can launch mine countermeasure systems,
while the Fire Scouts are equipped with sensors that help the ship get a better picture of the
horizon, essentially serving as remote sensors. Before I wrap up with my final thoughts on the
future of the Freedom Class, there's something important to highlight about the crew of USS
Marinette. There are 80 sailors aboard the ship, 13 of whom are female, including the commanding
officer. It's worth noting that a crew of 80 is considered small for a ship this size. For example,
a destroyer or cruiser would typically require around 80 people just to operate the bridge. On
the Marinette, however, it can be run with just two people, the officer of the deck and the junior
officer of the deck. This means the two of them take on more duties, like making announcements,
handling radar, and performing navigation tasks, which aren't usually the junior officer's
responsibility. I also had the chance to visit the ship's small hospital and chat with one of the
corpsmen. Besides his regular hospital duties, he also helps with line duties when the ship is docked.
Even small tasks like rinsing your own dishes after eating highlight how everyone aboard needs
to pitch in and take on multiple roles. But let's be real for a moment. The Freedom Class
has earned a bad reputation. It's easy to forget that with any new design, especially one as
ambitious as this, there are bound to be problems. In the case of the Freedom Class, the gearbox
issues have been resolved. The ships are now equipped with the Surface Warfare Package,
and maintenance costs are coming under control as the crew takes on more and more of the maintenance
responsibilities. However, there is still one lingering issue. The ships are lightly armored.
We already discussed the armament, and if you remember, these ships don't have built-in VLS,
or Vertical Launch System, cells like destroyers and cruisers. But here's the twist. The flight
deck on the Freedom Class is actually larger than that of the Arleigh Burke destroyers and
Ticonderoga cruisers, and this is important for a couple of reasons. This 40-foot long
container you see here is the Mark 7E payload delivery system, which houses four Mark 41 VLS
cells. These cells are capable of launching long-range anti-ship missiles, anti-air weapons
like the SM-6, and even Tomahawk land-attack missiles. According to Lockheed Martin, up to
three of these containers can be placed on the flight deck of Freedom Class ships, and the process
to set them up takes about 7 hours. In fact, in October 2023, an SM-6 missile was successfully
test-launched from one of these containers off the flight deck of USS Savannah. This means that
the Navy could potentially use the Freedom Class for lower-intensity situations, which would free
up destroyers for high-intensity missions. As for the future of the Freedom Class,
two more ships are still under construction, but it's unclear how many will actually be retired.
Back in 2022, it was suggested that the Navy would keep six Freedom Class hulls for surface
warfare and retire the rest. Some members of the U.S. Congress have proposed selling them to Allied
countries, while others argue we should just accept these ships for what they are. After visiting USS
Marinette in person, talking to the crew, and gaining more perspective on what caused the
issues and how they've been addressed, I'm starting to lean towards the latter group.
And there you have it, folks. The Freedom Class Little Combat Ships. Fast, flexible,
and full of surprises. They might not be perfect, but they sure know how to make a splash,
and sometimes a whole lot of noise. From their impressive armament to their quirky maintenance
challenges, these ships definitely keep things interesting. So what do you think? Are they the
future of modern naval warfare, or just a speedboat in a battleship's disguise? Let us know
in the comments below. If you enjoyed this deep dive into naval technology, don't forget to hit
that like button and subscribe to Navy Steel. We've got more naval adventures coming your way
faster than a jet-powered hull.
