S&P 500 and Nasdaq notch record closes

Financial Freedom
10 followers
1 Video View·Dec 3, 2024
Scott Chronert, Citi head of U.S. equity strategy, and Adam Crisafulli, Vital Knowledge founder, joins 'Closing Bell Overtime' to talk the days record market action.
To today's market action with city head of U.S. equity strategy, Scott Cronert and Vital
Knowledge founder Adam Christofouli. Great to have you both here. Scott, I'm going to start with you
because we did just have record close for the S&P and for the Nasdaq here. Russell 2000 flirting
with a new record close, although we didn't get that here, it looks like. Just in the last couple
of weeks, strategists seem to be getting very bullish about their S&P 500 price target for 2025.
You're not necessarily one of them. When I look at your base case of 5800 with the S&P finishing
right around 6047 as we settle here. Walk me through it. Why is this your expectation looking
to 2025? And what does that mean for some of these different dynamics that could pull on stocks?
Very good question, Morgan. So that target was set midyear and the market obviously has run
through us. Our base case for 25 has been that 5800 level. We've used 6400 as a bull
case for next year. In either event, what you're talking about is limited upside
based on what we know now. And I think the starting point for this is a very extended
valuation setup where you look at whether it's trailing PE for the S&P, for PE for the S&P
or other related metrics. You're looking at, in many cases, the highest percentile valuation
the past 20 years. So the hurdle that's being set now in terms of what that implies for future
growth expectations is quite high. Bottom line, while constructive on U.S. equities,
no change in our underlying view that we think fundamentals are very good shape.
We just have to allow that a lot is being paid for already.
Adam, I want to get your thoughts on the market here, because tech really
carried this first trading day of December today. We have seen this rotation here out of small caps,
out of the Dow, out of cyclicals. Is this a situation where maybe you're just seeing some
shifts by investors as we finish up the year? Or are there really genuinely concerns here in
the market, especially as we are talking about a Trump administration and what some of this
policies could actually bring for 2025, things like, for example, tariffs?
Yeah, so I definitely agree that valuations are very stretched, and that's obviously a big
headwind. And then I think if you look into the opening months of 2025, there does seem to be a
gap between the reality of Trump 2.0 and some of the policies that are going to be passed or not
be passed, tariffs, et cetera, and then the reality of it. So there's a very positive narrative, but
the reality could be a little bit messier. But in the near term, you have a very favorable
macro set up as far as data and the Fed are concerned. Just today, you had a very bullish
manufacturing ISM with healthy growth indications and a big pullback in the inflation piece of it.
And then just less than an hour ago, you had Fed Waller come out and give a very kind of
Goldilocks type of a speech where he acknowledged the healthy growth trends and then also said that
we still have inflation that's moving towards a 2% target. So he's kind of inclined to cut again
in December and then continue easing further into next year. So you have a decent earnings,
growth, inflation, monetary policy set up in the near term, favorable year and seasonality,
but you definitely do have valuations that are very rich. And then you also have, like I said,
I think a disconnect between reality and some of the hope around politics in Q1 of next year.
