Using Psychotherapy in Divided Times with Prof Mick Cooper

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
So welcome to the latest episode of MQ's Open Minds and today we've got Professor Mick Cooper.
Mick's a professor of consciousness psychology at Roehampton and is also an author, a trainer
and a UK CP registered psychotherapist. So welcome to the podcast. Thanks Rory.
Great to have you here and so what we try and do in the podcast, we keep it pretty natural we hope,
but we always start with asking about, tell us about your journey into mental health. You
obviously been involved in mental health for many years. I see you did your, well starting off as
your undergraduate, your psychology, social psychology degree, you completed that in 1998
and then your decline, or defill sorry, in the 90s. So you've been involved in psychology and
then obviously moved into the mental health field thereafter. So can you tell us a bit about your
journey, what interested you in the first place? I think I started, I mean I started off doing a
psychology degree, I was in the sciences before and got interested in psychology because I wanted
to do something as an undergraduate that was more human focused. And I guess as an undergraduate I
started studying the work of Carl Rogers and for the first time read a book that really spoke to
me at a very kind of personal emotional level really, something that was the idea that we all
wear masks and that there's something deep in our experiences that often doesn't get spoken about
and the idea of being able to be true to ourselves I was really taken with. So I wasn't really sure
what I wanted to do after that, after that one of traveling, certainly wasn't thinking at that point
I was going to be a therapist or a practicing psychologist, thought about maybe doing media,
but started, it was kind of really, and then really struggled in my 20s, was really lost, just
just didn't have a sense of where I was going, lots of closed doors, but found an opportunity to do a
PhD around the psychology of, actually of masks, bizarrely. I got asked a few questions around that
I was interested in what happens when people put on masks and the kind of transformation
and thought if I'm going to do a psychology PhD I should probably do something useful at the
same time. So I did a counseling training, started doing counseling training. Alongside the PhD?
Yeah, yeah, it was just a year's kind of certificate and it wasn't really, I mean it was
it was flagged as a counseling training, it was one of those things that at the last moment I thought
I kind of, I saw an advert in the garden and thought I'd go for it. It was one of these
incredible, it was so unstructured that you sat there for the first, probably the first term or so
in a room of about 60-70 people, you didn't even know who the trainers were, you just kind of sat
there trying to work out what was going on which was, you know, that was kind of the training.
But I liked it and, you know, the level of conversation about experiencing and relationships
and what goes on in a group was incredibly powerful really and was something that I kind of,
I guess I felt I wanted to stay involved in and, you know, again after that there was a year and
thought maybe I'll carry on training and then a few years later went and decided to do a kind of
proper deployment training and then went on to complete a UKCP training which was four years
and then about 10 years later qualified as a psychologist, so became a counseling psychologist.
So it wasn't something I kind of set out and said right I'm going to be a therapist or a psychologist,
kind of just found my way into it through different routes, but what I would say is that from a really
early age I was very politically involved, so I was involved in kind of, my parents were very
progressive, I was always very progressive, that as a student I was very involved in student politics
and a kind of social justice issues really mattered to me, so I guess therapy was in some
ways a way of seeing myself as being able to make some kind of social contribution and that was
important, you know, and I think that's why I did it alongside the PhD because I didn't want to just
do something theoretical, I wanted to do something that would make a difference to people's lives as
well. So in terms of the PhD though, so what was the PhD on? So it was on masks, it was on like
what happens when you wear a mask. So the whole PhD was on masks, ah okay, right, right. It was on masks and it was about
actually how masks bring out these different sides of ourselves and if people, maybe you can
pop into a chat or somewhere, my website, because I actually write about doing the PhD, I had a
disastrous experience, I got to the end of it and the examiners basically hated it and I had
to rewrite the whole thing from scratch and spent eight years on it after, I did four years and then
had to rewrite it which was horrible, a learning experience but not one I'd want to repeat. My god,
but so what, hold on, was it interview based then? It was kind of theoretical, it was kind of, I
started off doing it as cultural studies and psychology and what happened was basically
the examiners were psychologists, I'd done it as a kind of cultural studies, let's look at masks
across cultures and in literature, so I was writing about things like Batman and the way that
Batman's mask brings out different sides in the Joker and of course these psychologists looked at
it and thought what the hell, what the hell is this? So I had to go and do four years of empirical research
into it. Wow, that was dedication to the cause, but I dare say it didn't feel like that at the time.
So then you moved in, so that all happened in Sussex
and then so where did you go when you left Sussex then? I was at Regents College and I did,
so that's where I did my existential psychotherapy training and that was it really, I was teaching
at University of Brighton and I went up the University of Strathclyde in Glasgow and then
came back to the University of Roehampton, so those are the main institutions that I've been,
but I did my training at Regents College in London as a psychotherapist. And then you were
in Scotland for quite a while, how many years, 10 years? 10 years, it's very wet up in Glasgow.
It is, well as I well know it's wet, but as we speak at this moment though it's not raining,
as I look out my window. It was amazing to get back down south and see the sun literally,
it was like 10 years and I looked, I remember looking up when I moved back down again and
seeing blues kind of thing, what is that? There's all the blues guys today, so I will have to say
that as well. Being unfair. I know obviously Strathclyde was obviously famous for clownsling
and it was a Dave Mearns and his person-centred work. Yeah, there was a massive, it was a real
homeland of persons and still is actually, I mean they still do some fantastic person-centred
training there, so I got very involved in that, but then kind of moved more into counseling
psychology and what we'll maybe talk about later, kind of more pluralistic rather than purely
person-centred approach. Well so do you want to say tell us a bit, because again a lot of our
listenership wouldn't be familiar with the different types of counseling psychology or
the different sort of approaches. Yeah, no it's a really good question. So I mean there's a lot of
different terminology about, but person-centred therapy is an approach that really tries to begin
with the client, sometimes it's called client-centred therapy as well, it really tries to start and not
impose on them any expectations, any biases, any techniques or methods, it really tries to provide
an empathic valuing space where the client can talk about things at their own pace, in their
own way. It's kind of based on the belief that clients have the answers within them and that
rather than the expert, the therapist being the expert who comes in and says you should do this
or you should do this or what about this technique or try this, that actually rather than
doing that they listen very carefully to the person and help them understand more about their
own experiences, their own ways of perceiving the world and kind of learning to trust I guess those
inner forces, those inner needs and wants that allow them then to find the best way for themselves.
So rather than coming in from the outside and saying you should be doing this, it's more about
helping the person from the inside work out for themselves what it is that they want to do, so
that's the kind of person-centred approach. Pluralistic approach, so I was very involved in that and I
guess as I was 75 I came from a social justice background and was very interested in more
progressive politics, so for me that idea that clients were the experts and that the relationship
wasn't a hierarchical one of I'm the professional, I know you're the client, I need to teach you these
but more is more a collaborative one, we're working together, it was really important to me and I
really valued that and I loved the approach and still love the approach and was involved in writing
co-editing handbooks and different texts on it. But one of the things that we found was that
actually when we really listened to clients and said to people what is it that you want in therapy
kind of paradoxically a lot of the time people would say I want guidance and I want techniques
and I want advice and so if you go back to them and you say well you kind of think you want that
but actually what you really want is space and being listened to then there's kind of a bit of a
contradiction there because you're kind of then going back into the expert position and telling
people what they need. So the pluralistic approach that John McLeod who was up at University of
Alberta and myself and colleagues developed and is still being kind of developed and disseminated
and we have regular conferences was very much on a similar idea that we really want to listen to
clients about what it is that they want but rather than kind of assuming that what everybody wants
is a listening open space is recognizing that people want lots of different things and actually
we know from the research that lots and lots of different ways can be helpful for clients and it
doesn't make too much sense to get too locked down into person-centered or there's other approaches
like psychodynamic or existential. The research shows that most of them are pretty effective
there's not a lot of evidence that some are more effective than others and actually also importantly
different approaches are likely to help different people at different points in time. There isn't
one right approach for everyone whether that's person-centered or CBT or psychodynamic so what
we've done in the pluralistic approach is to try and find ways of understanding more about what
clients want for instance we developed a form an inventory of preferences which we can use at the
beginning of therapy to ask clients do you want something that is where the therapy is more
directive or would you like to take more of a lead do you want more of emotional kind of work or do
you do you want something that's a bit more emotionally reserved do you want something
that's more challenging and more supportive so it tries to bring out more of the client's voice
in a way. Is it more than like a framework then and then you can do underpin that framework you
can do either a psychodynamic CBT or whatever it might be? Yeah exactly I mean you know there's 450
different kinds of therapy out there nobody's going to be skilled in every single one yeah
it's not about doing every kind of therapy but it's about valuing and recognizing the value of
different therapies and then within the limits of what we can train in and what we know and
what we want to do being able to have some not even necessarily flexibility just respect
all these other approaches I think it's really important that therapists kind of recognize the
value of the work that other therapists do and the reality is that the therapy field can get pretty
bitchy for want of a better word you know it can it can be pretty dismissive towards other
approaches and it can be like you know my approach is better than yours what we might call schoolism
and you know that's not it's not grown up and more importantly it's really not helpful for clients
you know I mean I remember as a young person going to a behavioral therapist and said to me
you know I don't believe in all that counseling you know it's all you know a bit rubbishy
and actually you know that was the counseling I was having as well as a behavioral therapy was
really helpful for me the counselor was also very skeptical about the behavioral therapy
that wasn't about me and my needs that was about them and their egos their professional egos their
needs to feel like what they were doing was of value as opposed to something else so I think
pluralism tries to kind of move away from that and develop a field in which we can really respect
based on the evidence which shows that lots of different things help people at different
points in time you don't have to do everything but I think there is an onus on therapists
in the service of clients to be able to respect what other people are doing and what other
professionals are doing and then and so have you seen is there is there progress in that regard
is there more respect now and comparing now than 10 years ago or 20 years ago if you look in the
states that most of the therapies there something like 90 plus will draw on multiple methods in
their work and I think in the UK yeah I think that there is more respect across the different
therapies if you look back like 20-30 years ago you had not just the person-centered people
sometimes being very critical of CBT and seeing CBT is very kind of lightweight and not really
going in very deeply you also had CBT people in their research studies for instance would often
compare against the kind of straw man person-centered therapy that I mean you know sometimes
they'd have this thing they call person-centered therapy but it would be delivered by CBT nurses
supervised by CBT people clearly wasn't bona fide person-centered therapy and you kind of get less
of that and I think it's partly because the research shows that generally for what we know
the different therapies seem to be as good as each other I think there is more respect across
the field now and people kind of recognize that different therapies can can be a value and I think
that's got to be a healthy thing for clients more than anyone else yeah and I suppose there's also
the growing recognition that in terms of the active ingredients I think often we don't know
what the active ingredients of the different therapies are A and then B but we do know that
the relationship building the therapeutic alliance is so fundamental so I suppose if
whatever helps build that has to be crucial then yeah and I mean most therapies really I mean you
know sometimes people say that CBT is not a relational approach but if you read back if
you read any of the work it's really got the relationship built in as the psychodynamic as
does humanistic approaches person-centered approaches so it is all that but you know even
with a question like the relationship from a pluralistic standpoint we'd say well yeah the
relationship and working collaboratively is really important but then for some clients it might not be
what they need you know they might they might not need a relationship at all they might actually do
better with a workbook or they might do quite well you know watching a film or getting involved in
literature or going to a sports club but actually they're you know different things can help
different people outside of just therapy and outside of the therapeutic relationship so you
can you know when I was in my kind of 30s I was really kind of gung-ho for the therapeutic
relationship and really saw that as the kind of be all and end all of therapy and actually the
research doesn't show that it shows that it there's a really good association between relational
fact the quality of the relationship and outcomes we don't actually know whether that means that
the relationship is driving the outcomes there's kind of emerging evidence that probably some of
that's going on but you know not everybody needs a relationship and you know if it was all about
the relationship then the more relational therapies like person-centered therapies would be doing
better overall the more maybe technique-based therapies like CBT and they don't they they seem
to do equally well generally yeah but I suppose yeah that's that's a fair point but I suppose
I wonder to what extent though if you've got a good therapeutic relationship obviously builds trust
makes it more likely you will engage with that therapy better I mean a whole range of other
behavioral as well as cognitive outcomes yeah I suppose it what you're saying I think is that we
don't know enough about it yet in terms of the evidence yeah we know that I mean certainly quality
of evidence would support that I think that's about as you know that that as much as we do
know that's one of the things that we can be about as certain of as anything else but you're right
there is still a lot more that we need to find out I mean people often say that the most important
determinant of outcomes in therapy is the relationship actually it's not its client
factors it's things like the client's level of motivation whether the client engages with the
therapy factors about the client about whether the client can use therapy you know do they one
of the things we find actually which is a shame in some ways is that there's a kind of
kind of a law that the rich get richer than the poor in therapy meaning that where somebody's
got quite good relational skills and ability to attach securely where they're psychologically
minded generally the evidence suggests that they tend to get more out of psychotherapy
than clients who are maybe poor attachments and find relating more difficult which is a shame
you'd kind of hope it was the other way around in some ways um but it but but yeah but client
factors you know therapy sometimes think that therapy is like uh we make the change happen but
of course it's not it's more like you got a client is the one who's driving the car we're sitting
there more like if anything a driving instructor or a passenger kind of helping them along to get
to where they want to go it's not us driving the car absolutely but i suppose what they
was a disappointing thing what you're saying is the people arguably the people who most need it
we're going to talk about social change and inequalities but it's sadly many cases that
depending what you're bringing to the therapy can be obviously a barrier to the success
and that could be obviously socially patterned and lead to even greater inequality which is
obviously as sad but i suppose there must be ways in which yeah there's been great examples
over the years of people have been able to overcome that those inequalities so i mean
are there any tips you can think of might put you on the spot here of how we can help people
to maybe tackle that inequality well i mean just go to unpack that a little bit more rory i think
what you're absolutely right so one of the best predictors of how well people can do in therapy
is the levels of social support and people with low levels of social support can struggle more
to make good use i mean it's not that they it doesn't help them but it's just if you've got
good social support you can people tend to use therapy better but i think that you know when
we come on to things like social factors like poverty racism or housing i think it's really
important to recognize that psychotherapy can't solve everything and that there are issues and
there are you know inequalities that psychotherapy isn't developed and isn't appropriate and and it
would be a misuse of therapy and a kind of undermining and a misrecognition of the problems
people are facing to think that therapy is going to i mean it's complex you know potentially therapy
can empower people in a way that can then help them challenge inequalities what you get in the
state is that in the counseling world in the state where they've really developed multicultural and
social justice competencies a lot things like advocacy have become much more part of the
role so that they're you know whereas when i was trained that if a client comes in with something
like a housing form and says can you help me with with my housing form we were kind of trained to
you know be horrified and go you know what is it that you would want me to do that but
states now with advocacy it's like okay yeah no this is something i can maybe help you with and
you know i think there's more of a crossover and a kind of recognition of what can help with what
but i think that you know i'd be reluctant to say well here's examples where
therapy have helped people really get over these social and economic yeah adversities because i
think there's a risk of implying that i don't know that these inequalities are things that
people bring on themselves or that they can choose to overcome or it's all about kind of having
willpower and you can be whoever you want to be um and i think there's probably a small minority
of people in the therapy world who think that but i think most people in the therapy world
would recognize that you know what we do is within a particular context and there's
there's complex relationships and the organization and therapy and social change network is very much
about exploring that interface between therapeutic change and psychological change and that's
particularly the work i've kind of been involved in recently okay we'll move on to the therapy
and social change network in a wee second as you've just mentioned it but just one last one
last question on this sort of sort of pluralistic approach so in terms of implementing that in
practice you're saying what you've got these that you've developed a checklist or some some
approach at the start of the sessions for you to tell us a bit about how that works in practice
yeah so i mean it depends what it depends how therapists are trained and what they're working
so you might have somebody who's mainly say a person-centered therapist or somebody who's
mainly cbt you might have somebody who's integrative and what means integrative is
that they would kind of draw on different approaches into their work and maybe that
they've got a wider number of wider range of practices either of them can be within a pluralistic
approach though so what you do is you'd sit with the client and you talk to them and you'd introduce
yourself and find out about there is what's going on for them maybe what they want to get out of
therapy and then what i would do is i'd say to client you know is it can you tell me a little
bit about maybe what you you think would be helpful here particularly to get to these goals you haven't
have you been in therapy before is there things that have been helpful for you or not helpful for
therapy that maybe we could learn from and then i might introduce this form this inventory and say
you know it might be useful you know if you're okay just to fill that in and you know that will
give us a bit of an indication of how you'd like the therapy to be and then we talk about it and
it might be something like but the form shows that they got a strong preference for um you know
therapist directiveness and then we might talk about what does that mean so it's not that they
fill in a form and then you go right yeah yeah yeah but it's just it just i think a lot of it
we've done research on clients experiences of it and how they find it and a lot of it i think is
just about well we'll go back to what you were saying rory is about building the relationship
really and say this is an opportunity for us to work together to help address the things
you want to address and that's that's very much how i see therapy as a collaborative
enterprise not as some kind of technique i'm not and it's not like i want to be collaborative
because i think that is the best thing for you is is you know if clients come with problems
generally there's not some easy simple solution it's not just that i'm sitting there thinking oh
if only they did this or only they did that when you really listen to somebody and and understand
what somebody's going through problems are you know this phrase wicked problems most problems
people come to therapy with are wicked problems and uh if if i'm sitting there thinking oh there's
an obvious answer it's probably that i'm not listening closely enough sorry what do you mean
wicked problems are kind of really complex entangled problems really difficult problems
that you know you you find a solution to it one way but actually that raises problems from another
angle so it's not that there is an easy answer to it it's not just you do a or you do b but
actually you kind of have to untangle it like a really kind of tight you know like when your
shoelaces are all tied up and you can't undo them it's like that that kind of thing and i think
you know in my experience as a therapist nearly always the issues that clients bring are of that
type that we kind of untangle it little bit by little bit and hopefully you know and it's very
rare actually as a therapist in my experience that you get from you get to the point where
something is completely untangled that most clients or a lot of clients have been through
different episodes of therapy and have different change processes and you kind of work with them
along and do a little bit of untangling and then maybe see somebody else and they untangle things
a little bit more and you know people people people yeah people always have kind of tangles
in their lives so so moving on then so like so go on you mentioned there a therapy and social
change network you can tell us a bit about that because i'm going to move on i'm really keen to
talk about your most recent book psychology at the heart of social change yeah i mean they're
very related so the therapy and social change network is a very kind of loose group of people
mainly therapists although we're hoping it will be a wider group and it's very much open to
everybody where we're exploring how internal change and psychological change relates to a
wider political and social change and there's there's a number of different areas of that so
partly that's about how therapy can be informed by a social justice perspective like taking into
account factors like people's cultural backgrounds uh looking at issues like sexism racism in the
therapy room looking at issues of power and privilege and marginalization and what that
means for therapy using kind of ideas that and also in training i mean training is another
important area also research i mean there's loads of really good research from the states coming out
for instance around microaggressions and um how clients you know black clients say working with
white therapists can experience microaggressions go and tell people what microaggressions are just
in case they don't know yeah microaggressions are i mean it's not an area of my expertise but
as i understand it they're kind of like not explicitly racist statements but it might be
something like mispronouncing say you say i'm working with an indian client and i might just
kind of keep saying say something like oh that's really hard to say your name can i just use a
nickname or something it's not kind of explicitly i don't like indian people but it is there's a
racism there in that it's not putting the effort in to actually understand a different culture
so that so the you know unfortunately that does happen in therapy there's interesting questions
about how as a therapist you know so if you're a black therapist or a white therapist you deal
with racism or anti-semitism and so there's all those issues about how social justice comes into
therapy also around like training like at the moment in therapy world still it is very very
white and how do we bring people from more marginalized backgrounds into therapy training
so it can be more representative but then the other side of it and i guess where my book's
particularly interested in is then also how can therapy contribute towards a more socially just
landscape and does therapy have any role and or rather what role does it have in helping to create
a world that is fairer more peaceful more thriving so yeah so the network is about kind of we have
seminars we have podcasts we have conferences we have whatsapp groups facebook groups you know
but it's where you're going to lose network of people just on the kind of left of the spectrum
you know it's not trying to represent the whole political spectrum it's from people who are
interested in social justice perspectives thinking about how that feeds into therapy
and if people wanted to find out more about the network how do they do that how do they find out
therapy and social change dot net or just look up therapy and social change network and you know
people are very welcome to be come involved in it you know it's just one i mean there's lots of
different groups there's the black and asian therapist network that's going there's group
of psychotherapies and counselors for social responsibility you know we're not trying to kind
of colonize a marketplace so that we should be ironic there's there's lots of different groups
and i think we try and just be one of one of several groups that are trying to explore this
okay well that sounds fascinating really important work obviously especially i think
what do you think in the uk context of looking at just going through cost of living crisis and
we know it's just leading to greater inequalities and i mean these large massive top level structural
factors are really if we're looking at the key drivers to mental health i mean they're so so
important and indeed we did at mq last year we published this often mentioned it in the podcast
project which we brought together experts from around the world and we're looking at what the
key factors were which lead to the premature mortality associated with mental illness and
mental distress so primarily from suicide or from sort of comorbidities associated with mental
illness and probably number one time and time again is inequalities inequalities inequalities
disadvantage stigmatization racism discrimination gender-based violence i mean and it's if we really
are serious about tackling these inequalities that's where that level of intervention is required
but i suppose that sets up quite nicely and sorry mike for to talk about your latest book
obviously you've written quite a few books how many books have you written about 10 10 or 10
but too many and that was my last one that way oh well i haven't even said it so is it definitely
your last one no as i say the last as in the most recent i suppose no as in the last one i ever want
i'm just working on another one okay we can tell us about that in a second but so this one came out
i think last year and it's called the full title is psychology at the heart of social change
developing a progressive vision for society so no pretty grand title there
so i haven't i haven't had a chance to read it so tell us what it's about and do you live up
do you live up to that grand do i live up to that i mean yeah i want to answer that i just want to
go back to what you're saying more about inequalities inequalities in it i mean absolutely
absolutely that's what the evidence shows and it just it really worries me as a therapist that
so much of the therapy world is not ignorant but just is it is not taking that into account
and it's not joined up you know so much of therapy focuses on individual suffering and we bring
clients in we work with clients we work on internal psychological issues self-esteem
really important work but as you say there are these massive big structural factors that are
causing psychological distress and in some way these things need to be joined up and the site
the counseling world the psychotherapy world we need to be the psychology world we need to be
joined up with a kind of amazing research you're doing that sounds fantastic rory but anyway yeah
i mean the book is so the book is looking at i guess from the other angle the other way around
and it is saying what can therapy and the world of therapy and ideas from therapy contribute
to a fairer world and i think the way that the book goes into that is to say that actually as
therapy we absolutely don't have all the art i mean it's not in any way saying you know it's
about developing contributing maybe making some you know if we're going to have a real
subtitle it's only like trying to make the best contribution we can make even if it might be a
kind of recognizing the limit but i think the book is particularly aimed i guess progressive
parties and and the left and saying that there are things that we've learned in the therapy
world that are really valuable i do mean that actually i do think that is that means really
valuable and i think that's particularly targeted you know sometimes on the left sometimes with
progressive positions they can get very black and white themselves they can get very demonizing of
other positions they can be you know you just need to watch pmqs about kind of i'm right you're
wrong we're good we're in a good position you're you're you're in a bad position rather than kind
of recognizing the basic humanity of others and engaging with people's basic humanity i'm really
trying to understand that and i think that that becomes so easily missed and when we when we when
we miss that even if it's with our political enemies even if it's the people we disagree with
then it betrays the fundamental principles of a progressive approach if we think about a kind of
progressive stance social justice stance is one about equality and one about valuing equality
then we need to recognize the equality and the intelligence and the thoughtfulness of those people
even though we may not like them and that's not always easy and that's certainly not always to
say that we have to agree with them or we kind of have to kind of comply with what they're saying i
i think that that stance of understanding can run alongside and something i argue in the book very
much is that it can really run alongside a very radical challenge to more hierarchical more
authoritarian uh views it's certainly not saying you know we should just go along with it but it
is saying that we need to start from a position of understanding people and to the extent that
social justice perspectives progressives perspective whether they're green or labor
or liberal democrat you know to the extent that they are demonizing and rubbishing the other
perspectives i don't think they're helping us move forward i think what helps us move forward
politically and create and tackle those kind of injustices that uh you're talking about is a kind
of politics that is about understanding people is about is about dialogue is about having real
conversations with people and really trying to understand where people are coming from and i
think that's the heart of a progressive as a heart of an egalitarian outlook is about understanding
others rather than getting into blaming and rubbishing and demonizing others so you know
that's that and i guess that comes from my own history of coming from a progressive background
but also feeling that that was kind of limited in some ways and feeling that there were the way i
mean my parents are actually members of the communist party so i was brought up with a lot of
you know russia's great and america's bad and china's you know that you know that's wonderful
and you know that politics the reality is that politics are very divisive politics was not a
good one you know i remember my kids telling me about you know what mount sitting you know what
happened in china and you know being absolutely horrified because you know for my dad he was a
hero um yeah yeah i mean it was it was awful uh you know as we know and i think we all understand
but but the question is rory i think if we're thinking about developing a progressive politics
what is that going to look like what kind of progressive politics is that what form is that
going to take and i guess the book argues for a humanistic progressive politics so that so then i
mean in terms of the reality of that then so the question then becomes i think to what extent then
can we harness what we know from psychotherapy to making a better world yeah so so how do we do it
how do you do it that's a pretty simple question that michael basically yeah number one i think it
has to be uh social emotional learning so i mean we have schools that teach kids about geography
and about history but what they don't teach kids is about themselves and about their emotions and
about how to relate to people um you know it might be a little bit on the people is it pcr
yeah curriculum um phsr but in terms of what we could be doing in schools to educate kids about
things like you know and there are programs there's really good evidence-based programs
that we know can help develop kids empathy for others by teaching them just things like you know
here's a picture of a little girl you know what is she feeling let's spend a bit of time thinking
about what she might be feeling so that's one thing i would love to see and i would really hope
and my guess is that labor green i mean their policies are very uh aware i think of mental
health issues i i i would like to think there's a kind of open door there and that's something
we're certainly trying to do in task is to begin those dialogues with people and say look let's
have more of that emotional education so that kids can come out of schools doing the things that we
know can make a real difference to people as well but i mean i'm sure in your research rory as well
i'm sure interpersonal relationships come up as a major factor in psychological health and
you know mortality i think interpersonal relationships is one of the best predictors
of mortality and a lot of people just don't learn how to have a relationship so i think
there's something there loneliness loneliness is loneliness exactly exactly the equivalent of
smoking 15 cigarettes a day yeah no exactly right and you know they're saying social factors again
there but i think teaching people how to develop relationships how to empathize how to form
connections with others we can do that so that'd be one i think there's something about positive
parenting as well even before that is about you know again like i just think of a martian came
and saw what we were teaching people like one of our most important roles is as a parent and we
just don't get any education about that zero i remember being born when i first became a parent
it's like what do you do here i mean i remember learning stuff about in the uh you know the
and but in terms of emotionally bringing up a healthy child the importance of things like
attachment the importance of security so that kids can grow up feeling positive about themselves
and you know feeling more able then to contribute to society if somebody grows up in a way that
means that they're scared and they're vulnerable and they're feeling that they're going to be
attacked all the time because they've experienced abuse and adverse childhood experiences then
they're less likely i think to be able to contribute and share with others so i think
positive parenting i think looking as i said before looking at our emotional systems and
there's great organizations like compassion in politics where what they do is they actually work
with politicians to help them think about how they talk to each other help them develop their
self-care help develop political systems that are more compassionate things like learning
just really basic stuff like normal i don't know if you know non-violent communication which is
about ways of talking to each other which is just about rather than blaming and saying you know
you've done this i hate you rory you're this and you're that is actually saying rory when you do
this i feel angry and it would be a lot better for me if you could do that really again simple
kind of things where there is leverage to help create a society that is more caring compassionate
understand and i think that is so aligned you know the book is about how this is so aligned
with a progressive politic that i would really hope that over the you know coming years of the
labour government and hopefully you know i would hope for more years that these things will become
embedded in their politics so that we can work towards a more cooperative society a more
collaborative society from all these different angles rather than just that you know that that
economic level is so important and the social and the health that is so important but there's also
that kind of emotional psychological which i think is missing and to say it's missing isn't
say it's the most important bit but it's to say i think there's things that could be filled in there
yeah but but no i i agree entirely like i think if we can have more compassion in politics
it makes all the difference but the stark reality is the most powerful country in the world
has just elected somebody who clearly doesn't embrace those policies
is that a question but i suppose the sad reality is it's what you described is
is a way which well certainly i would totally embrace yeah but but what works in other
countries is that when we work when we live in in a populist society that doesn't hold
in pop for populism because populism is about division about right-wing populism yeah
yeah i don't so i don't know if there's any we can
wait so like a message is anything in psychotherapy can help donald trump with really
i i mean i think like a lot of people are you know are really disheartened and gutted you know
wake up on whenever it was thursday morning and wednesday morning and you know see that
and and of course that's around the world that more and more we see authoritarian
leaders taking hold and it scares me you know it scares me about the the the the the
marginalization and the oppression that people are going to experience you know things like women in
in the states it's really terrifying what what what they may be facing war and of course the
climate and ecological destruction and what that's going to mean for the next four five years and of
you know going back to what you were saying marie what that will then mean for people's
mental health and well-being right down on the ground and that really scares me but i think
i think what we can learn from therapy i think what therapy can help us do is to try i guess
and understand where that comes from and however tempting it is to demonize it and demonize people
like trump is to understand i was over in the states last summer and we talked to a lot of
people and we were really shocked about how pro-trump people were but it was interesting to
to you know we talked to people and trying to understand where they're coming from their fears
and you know it's too easy to say that people who vote for trump are kind of idiots and don't know
and just do whatever they're told yeah i don't think that i mean i think there is obviously
misinformation but but also people are scared and i think if you approach them or interact
with them on the basis that we're right and they're wrong that's not going to change people
no people aren't changed by being told they're idiots or being treated like idiots at the end
of the day if we're going to address things like kind of authoritarian we need to be able to engage
with it in a way that respect not respects the ideas necessarily but respects the people
and tries to understand where people are coming from in a way that people feel valued and people
feel i guess listened to a lot of it was people really didn't feel listened to i mean a lot of it
was you know the people you spoke to they just felt that they weren't listened to they felt they
were at the margins and that's maybe a starting point to try and address that no absolutely and
i couldn't agree more i think it's it's whole communities been left behind or feeling that
they've been left behind and just someone this person saying exactly what you want to hear i
will do with x y and z irrespective of whether it's possible or ethical of course you're going
you're going to vote for it so yeah i agree we have to embrace and understand and i think the
democrats in america really have a lot of thinking to do to see what i mean because i know a lot of
democrat friends who said that that's their view was it's in a way that the democratic party have
left the working class behind and and in a way it's trying to understand that better so you can
re-engage i mean it doesn't matter which side you're on right or left republican or democrat
it's just you live in a world which is more hopefully and compassionate and takes it
seriously the challenges of our age including as you say the climate change issue and attempted
to pass away okay we're coming to almost the end of our time together like a couple of things to
sort of bring it to a close with first of all i'm often this is a research podcast i'm always
keen to get some idea of if you had all the money in the world type thing and in your field of
endeavor where where should we be investing the research funding where are what's our big
questions if i had all the money and i couldn't just give all the money and share it out across
all the people in the world it's for research sorry i would like to do that i would like to
do that but no so the research cancer you've got to give this money research you can't
share it out i don't have a very interesting answer that question i think you know there's
a number of really major psychological distress depression anxiety finding the most effective ways
of tackling that i think continues to be would have to be top of the agenda i think probably
ways in which personalize and ways in which maybe rather than looking you know is it this treatment
or that treatment there's some really interesting research for instance going on james delgadillo
at the university of sheffield which is more and more about kind of how you personalize and how you
can find develop an understanding and a particular qualities that mean particular people will benefit
most in the therapy and i think that kind of personalization that could help us understand
more i think that's a real priority for research that's where psychotherapy research is going now
is much more towards that personalization i think rather than the big kind of x therapy x versus
therapy y is who's going to do best in therapy x and that i think that's a really good way to
spend money and help address some of these kind of mental health issues but it would be amazing
to overcome that wouldn't that well as much as possible yeah no well that would be amazing i
mean because obviously the whole field of over all doesn't matter what you say what brand of
therapy it is it's kind of a more tailored approach genuinely having a person personalized
approach where where we have best chances of success and helping those who are most vulnerable
so one last question um make just but before i do just as a sort of shout out anyone wants to hear
mick talking about this and more about social change stuff and makes going to be speaking at
the uk council for psychotherapy annual conference next saturday well sorry saturday the 23rd of
saturday the 23rd of november that's in london i think you can find all the details i assume if you
google that if you just want to want to attend that so just thought just shout that out before
i ask the final final question so make the final question we're trying to do is unrelated and i
haven't given you no warning that this question is all about my cat is it no it's not with your
cat but it's i'll ask you an easy one it's give them a sort of i'm sort of we start off being a
bit of a bit reflective yeah and suppose that question is if you're thinking back to what
advice you would give your younger self so say yeah 16 or 16 or 18 year old what advice would
you give and why about mental health well any aspect of your life any aspect it's a really it's
a really difficult i know it's a really yeah what would i what would i what would i want to know
what would be useful to know yeah but yeah what why what would you wish that you're sorry
what would you say to that i will answer that but you told me what you'd say first
hold on i'm asking the question here i know i i would say i would say um for me to be less to
be less self-critical and that actually the world is the thing obviously i wish i hadn't known was
as an adolescent how super sensitive you were to you are to criticism and stuff going on in your
life so i wish i'd learned that well but but i suppose at that stage we didn't know when i was
16 we didn't know the brain was still developing and the training was still going on and the
mismatch between emotion processing and capacity to cognitively do things that would be my answer
that's a good answer that's a really good answer you know what i say roy and it's something we
haven't talked about at all but actually you know like myself personally i've struggled with
mental health issues over kind of coming and going over the time certainly around anxiety
i think what i wish i'd known genuinely wish i'd known when i was 15 or 16 was
more about having more confidence to follow down routes to to address that like i think
the kind of anxieties i had when i was 15 16 got so embedded that i never by the time i kind of
in my 20s 30s 40s kind of addressed them probably didn't get right down into the roots that maybe
i could have done when i was younger i really when i was 15 i went off to the tabby stalk and
went had this psychoanalytic therapy that was very kind of talking about my parents thing and
just wasn't the right therapy and you know i think if i'd known to pursue particular you know like
for instance cognitive behavioral pathways which which can be really good for anxiety
uh i wish i'd known that i wish i'd known that that was that can be really helpful and i wish
i'd kind of really pursued that i didn't try that in my 20s and it was helpful but i think just in
terms of my own mental health that would have been uh you know a good thing and i'm sure that's
kind of informed my journey and kind of my desire to kind of work with other people around that and
to kind of disseminate knowledge in a public way rob because i think probably i felt that that
knowledge or some of that knowledge was was kind of guarded in in that professional sphere rather
than being disseminated out and and like the wonderful work that mq is doing about kind of
making knowledge about mental health and many other organizations widely available i think it's
so important i wish wish there'd been more of that when i was a kid yeah that's a great answer for
for you thinking it wasn't gonna be that great an answer it turned into a really good one i think
and a really important message as well so on that note my huge thanks for um for taking the time to
spend with us today and again just to show it for of you for mix latest books so it's a psychology
at the heart of social change developing a progressive vision for society okay so thanks
and all the very best thanks thanks really good to talk to you bye thanks
