Painted Roman Statues

Roman Stoneworks
4 followers
Today we're going to be talking about the white marble of ancient Rome, but of course so much of
that white marble the statuary was painted. Here's a replica of the famous Augustus Prima Porta
that is showing you how much of the statue was originally painted. A lot of the paint
from the ancient world is going to be lost over time when these statues, when these monuments
are buried. But we're going to be talking about that color in the context of the white marbles
of ancient Rome. First of all, what the Romans were using before marble, then in comes marble
with conquest, really not in a grand scale until the 2nd century BC. Then we'll be talking about
what really picks up pace in the end of the 1st century BC and into the imperial period. We'll
be looking at Italian marble, Carrara, and then we'll be looking at other marbles predominantly
coming from the Greek East. All right, so before you have marble, you're going to use the local
volcanic conglomerates, these tufts that we've talked about on many occasions. You have the
original wall circuit made of tuft blocks. First they're quarried extremely locally, really from
the hills of Rome themselves, and then over time they're going to go further afield towards the
Alban hills and they're going to be identifying and extracting better qualities of volcanic stone.
Now we see them principally like this, and you see in the photo, the cornice, the freeze zone,
those are blocks of tuft that are compact enough that they can take detail. You'll even see examples
of statuary, but they're poorly, the archaeological record for them is poorly preserved. We'd have to
go to Montemartini to see some examples of that. But the stuff that we call peperino comes from
the Alban hills or nearby in Gavi, but they're going to be superseded by better materials,
materials that are going to be more compact. So this metamorphic limestone, it's a metamorphic
rock composed of recrystallized carbonate minerals. This is how we define marble today.
Of course, we're going to see other stones that the Romans are going to be employing,
particularly when we talk about colored marbles, we'll be including the granites that are coming
from Egypt. But when we're talking about marble, we're talking about something that has
less tensile strength than bronze. So you're going to have all kinds of supports around
extended appendages. And of course, at the base, this stuff can just snap off if the statue is big
enough on the top. So it's not as strong as bronze. It will need some extra supports.
It is something that is difficult to maneuver, to shift, to work with. It's almost three tons per
cubic meter. We have to always keep that in mind as well. And then ultimately how we're going to
be identifying the various white marbles. There are certain characteristics that you can just
eyeball to have a pretty good sense of it's probably this or it's probably that or it's
definitely not this. But the scientific analysis has enabled us to have a much clearer picture
of the origins of the white marbles. So you're using trace elements, ESR spectroscopy,
thermoluminescence, and stable isotopic ratios. And there are a number of scholars around the
world involved in this. And it means identifying the ancient quarries and getting samples for
which there could be a great variety within a given quarry. And then going and getting permission
to take small samples from the backsides of various reliefs, architectural features,
and statues to then match those signatures. And there's been great progress done in the past 20
years. Here we see an example of two different marbles employed. This is the famous Pontifex
Maximus statue. It's in Palazzo Massimo for which we have done a video for Museo Nazionale Romano.
You can go check out this statue in that video, always on our YouTube channel. Now the body is
made of Carrara or italic marble, which is going to be quarried by Julius Caesar and Augustus,
not much beforehand. But then the specific designation of the stone for the portrait,
which is arguably the most important part of this statue, they choose to use a more appreciated,
more famous, let's say, better quality, less imperfections. It's the Parian marble,
which is known and used and exploited by the Greeks from the 6th century BC.
The Romans are obviously then in this statue making a distinction of two different kinds
of white marbles. Okay, now the first temple in Rome goes back to 146 BCE, not before.
What are they making temples with before? They're using tuff, they're using terracotta plaques,
and there's infrequently the use of marble. But initially, throughout most of the Republic,
they're going to be just small choice pieces that are used for some statuary,
some architectural feature, maybe just the head of a statue, a cult statue. Now that's all going
to change with so much material coming in, this market, this demand for the marble. And in comes
not just the marble, but the sculptor, the designer of that first Greek material statue
and temple, the Jupiter Statua Temple in the Porticus and Metellus in the Circus Flaminius.
We don't have that anymore, although we know the location. What we do have is something literally
one generation away. So at the end of the 2nd century BC, we have this temple, and this is
round temple in the Forum Boarium, the cattle market, and the marble here used is Pentelic
marble, which is the marble made famous by the Athenians. It comes from Pentelechon,
just outside of Athens. So things start off on a small scale when they finally do have marble
arriving. And in fact, one of the famous characteristics of this particular temple
is when we look at the columns, the column capitals were actually made of two separate blocks.
And that's an indication, here's the suggestion, the indication in the scholarship is
that's unusual. You don't normally make a capital out of two separate blocks.
It suggests then that the amount and the size of the blocks that are coming into Rome initially
are not that great. So here's a solution. We'll just take two of the smaller blocks available to
us, pin them together, and then carve the capital. Now keep in mind also, when we talk about the
white marbles, statuary was painted. Now the paint was applied and over time reapplied.
Why are they doing this? You're giving more details. You're informing the viewer more about
that figure, mythological or real. Think about hair color. Think about the color of the eyes.
Think about the color of the skin. You're giving details, character, drama, emotion. Think about
conveying more the maybe hair on the body. If it's a cyclops, you want that hair on the feet
and the chest and the arms to stand out. Maybe it's because you want to convey or show more the
particular kind of clothing that they're wearing, which would then be distinguished from the flesh.
Oftentimes, they use encaustic painting technique. Melted beeswax and paint is then applied
over the surface of the marble, and it has been a sort of translucent quality,
so you'll still be able to see the actual surface of the marble itself.
Where's the color coming from? Red is from cinnabar, which is mercury sulfide. A brownish
color is from an ochre, which is just a clay earth pigment. Black can be obtained in many
different ways, including burning ivory. Murex shells can be used to squash the little sea
snails to get the purple dye. Blue comes from calcium copper silicate. White comes from white
lead. Then you're going to be applying these to the surfaces of the statues. When they're
buried for hundreds and hundreds, if not thousands of years, when you're uncovering them, most of
that paint, biodegradable, is going to be lost. When it's exposed to the air after thousands of
years, it eventually fades. For example, when we go back to that Augustus Prima Porta statue from
the beginning, the reason why we have a pretty good idea of what it looked like was that when
it was unearthed in the 1860s, a lot of the paint was still actually quite visible and it was
documented. So what happens, though, is as we're unearthing these statues over the centuries
through, let's say, in particular the Renaissance times, there is a kind of a development of this
aesthetic of appreciating the statues as they are, which by and large was not too much paint.
When we go forward into the time of Winckelmann, who is considered to be the 18th century father
of art history, he's really pushing this aesthetic. So over time, we're also understanding
that at times the color, if it's still there, is actually forcibly removed by those early
collectors and so forth. Today, how do we understand if there, unless it's visible like
this statue from Ponte Martini, how do we know that there was color on it? We can use
ultraviolet light or we can use microscopic analysis of the traces that are still identifiable
on the surface of the statue. We can use x-ray spectroscopy. And of course, when we look at
mosaics, when we look at paintings like this one from, you know, from Pompeii, when we look at the
mummy portraits using encaustic painting on wood and we're seeing tones, the shades,
the color of the hair and so forth, we're understanding that yes, indeed, color,
that's what the Romans saw in. They weren't looking at their artwork in black and white.
They weren't looking at their statues as white statues, but they were distinguishing them
with all kinds of color highlights. You also painted the letters nine times out of ten for
the inscriptions, again, to better highlight the letter forms because all, as you can see,
the letters are all kind of squashed together. So, you want to heighten the legibility as much
as possible. Now, here's an example of a hall in the Forum of Augustus where you actually have the
traces of painting on the panels of white marble. So, we don't have a ton of examples to refer to
like this, but there are indeed quite a few that exist throughout the Mediterranean.
Here's another famous example from Montemartini. This is attributed to the
garden estates of Caligula and a close-up here shows us that they're using all kinds of paints
to apply to statuary. You can see how the eye has been painted, but you can also see
gold that has been applied to the surface of the skin. Here we have a portrait in the
Museum of Athens, the National Museum of Athens, and we have a lot of the beard still painted and
then that would have been highlighted further by the insertion of probably glass paste for the eyes.
So, when we do go around and we do take a look at architectural features, freezes, when we're
painted and sometimes it's quite obvious. Here we have the dying gall and on the image on the right,
I guess maybe beneath my screen, what you actually see is the mortal wound applied to the surface
of the skin of this man and the drops of blood that are forming on the surface of the skin.
How much more that would have been highlighted with the application of paint. So, where is the
white marble coming from? So, you have on the one hand in Italy, the famous Carrara marble,
the italic marble. Everything else is coming from, well you can see here what we call Greece today,
that's Mount Pentelecon right by Athens and everything else is coming from the islands
in between Greece and Turkey as well as mainland Turkey. These are all important Greek city-states
with very important cores that are going to be exploited. Some already exist as early as the
6th century BC, other ones are going to be really exploited only under Augustus and subsequent
emperors. But you can see right here in terms of the white marble extraction, it's predominantly
coming from the east, but also predominantly these quarry sites are islands. So, you extract
the stone and pop it on a ship and off you go to Rome. The major difficulty, the major costs,
like for duchymium marble that we'll talk about shortly, is when they're at a land route,
your cost is extraordinarily high because transporting by land is much more expensive,
tedious, and time-consuming than shipping by sea. So, here we have our famous Carara marble,
surely a Truscans are documented as having extracted some but really not so familiar to
the Romans into the 2nd century BCE. And then, of course, as Julius Caesar begins to exploit it for
his building project, particularly his first forum of Caesar, and then on a large scale it comes in
under Augustus. And again, it's that forum of Augustus that's really having quite a substantial
supply, the first big use of Carara marble. And it's coming from a great distance from Rome,
350 kilometers, but hey, most of that route you can do by sea. The difficulty is extracting it
from the top of a mountain and then carefully controlling the path down off the mountain to
the port city, Luni, to then bring it all the way to Rome. So, here we get a little view
past the later forum. We're going to pivot over to the forum of Augustus, and we want to think
about predominantly here for the columns and so forth and the staircase. It's Carara marble,
it's the marble of Italy. What a great statement then for Augustus as he's employing it on a grand
scale as never before seen in Rome at the time. And the white marble is Imperial Rome.
Let's look at Parian marble, already being quarried heavily by the Greeks. It's an island,
and it's known for just this incredible translucent quality. Number one statuary
marble for the Greeks. Pentelic marble has a lot of inclusions, microports, and so forth,
so not as prestigious you can say, but of course used for very many projects,
including the Parthenon on the Acropolis in Athens. Tucumian marble, Aphrodisian marble,
they're both really going to be heavily exploited only from Augustus and onward. And it's Tucumian
that's really, really expensive because it's inland in central Turkey, Phrygia, and there is no
easy way, there's no river connecting to the sea, it's a big expensive land route.
So when you saw Tucumian marble in Rome, you knew it had a big price tag. Aphrodisian marble is
closer to the coast, it's Bottepe, and that is these quarries actually, in recent times,
we really understand how heavily this was being used. In particular, the Sperlonga
statuary coming in, either Augustan or Tiberian in date, fantastic. You can see my video on it on
my YouTube channel, youtube.com slash Darius Aria, and more and more first and second centuries,
this is becoming a predominant statuary type. And with these new studies, more sophisticated
studies on the marbles, it's turning out that a lot of things that, like when I went to school,
we were told was the Carrara marble, is now turning out to be Tucumian marble,
such as the famous Kalmanus statue, Kalmanus as Hercules, in the Capitoline Museums. So we are
getting a more refined understanding and view of the various kinds of marbles, and how they're
picking up and becoming more popular under certain emperors over others. Abassos is an island,
Prokinesis is an island, and so obviously you get a lot of these shipments coming from an island,
on a boat, and then off to Rome. So you can imagine then that's going to keep the cost
down. Prokinesia, in particular, is going to be very popular in the second century and onward.
We can see it for the columns, for example, for the temple of Hadrian, the god, just down the street
from the Pantheon. It has a very distinct kind of regular gray banding that goes through it.
So that's one you can feel pretty confident when you look at when you're trying to eyeball it,
and it's going to be used all the way forward into the 4th and 5th centuries CE. The Pentallic
marble is particularly popular with the Flavians, and here we're taking a look at the magnificent
arch of Titus. The inner arch is what's original. The outer part is made of travertine stone.
That's going to be with a restoration job in the early 19th century, and we also want to keep in
mind that throughout this discussion today, of all these white marbles, the true white stone
of ancient Rome was actually travertine stone, limestone quarried from Tivoli,
ancient Tibur, and it was in use really from about 200 BC and onward, and the sheer amount of volume
of travertine stone that comes into the city of Rome throughout antiquity far outweighs the amount
of marble that came to the city, but you really won't see travertine stone as statuary
building material and rather is for grand public structures like the
Stadium of Domitian and the Colosseum.
